The utility of genomic testing in the ophthalmology clinic: A review

The Role of the Ophthalmic Genetics Multidisciplinary Team in the Management of Inherited Retinal Degenerations-A Case-Based Review

(1) Background: Inherited retinal degenertions are rare conditions which may have a dramatic impact on the daily life of those affected and how they interact with their environment. Coordination of clinical services via an ophthalmic genetics multidisciplinary team (OG-MDT) allows better efficiency of time and resources to reach diagnoses and facilitate patient needs. (2) Methods: This clinical case series was conducted by a retrospective review of patient records for patients enrolled in the Target 5000 programme and managed by the OG-MDT, at the Mater Hospital Dublin, Ireland (n = 865) (3) Results: Herein we describe clinical cases and how the use of the OG-MDT optimizes care for isolated and syndromic IRD pedigrees. (4) Conclusions: this paper demonstrates the benefits of an OG-MDT to patients with IRDs resulting in the holistic resolution of complex and syndromic cases. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this format can be adopted/developed by similar centres around the world, bringing with it the myriad benefits.

Commercial Gene Panels for Congenital Anterior Segment Anomalies: Are They All the Same?

PURPOSE

We compared next generation sequencing multigene panels (NGS-MGP) from 5 commercial laboratories to inform ophthalmologists' decision making in diagnostic genetic testing for congenital anterior segment anomalies (CASAs).

DESIGN

Comparison of commercial genetic testing panels.

METHODS

This observational study gathered publicly available information on NGS-MGP from 5 commercial laboratories for the following: cataracts, glaucoma, anterior segment dysgenesis (ASD), microphthalmia-anophthalmia-coloboma (MAC), corneal dystrophies, and Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome (ARS). We compared gene panel composition, consensus rate (genes covered by all the panels per condition, "concurrent"), dissensus rate (genes covered by only 1 panel per condition, "standalone"), and intronic variant coverage. For individual genes, we compared publication history and association with systemic conditions.

RESULTS

Altogether, cataract, glaucoma, corneal dystrophies, MAC, ASD, and ARS panels tested 239, 60, 36, 292, and 10 discrete genes, respectively. The consensus rate varied between 16% and 50%, and the dissensus rate varied between 14% and 74%. After pooling concurrent genes from all conditions, 20% of these genes were concurrent in 2 or more conditions. For both cataract and glaucoma, concurrent genes had significantly stronger correlation with the condition than standalone genes.

CONCLUSIONS

The genetic testing of CASAs using NGS-MGPs is complicated, owing to their number, variety, and phenotypic and genetic overlap. Although the inclusion of additional genes, such as the standalone ones, might increase diagnostic yield, these genes are also less well studied, indicating uncertainty over their role in CASA pathogenesis. Rigorous prospective diagnostic yield studies of NGS-MGPs will aid in making decisions of panel selection for the diagnosis of CASAs.

Diagnostic yield of next generation sequencing gene panel assays for early-onset glaucoma in an ethnically diverse population

BACKGROUND

Early-onset glaucoma is a potentially sight-threatening condition with high heritability. Next generation sequencing is a cost-effective alternative to individual gene screening that could expedite its diagnosis. However, the diagnostic yield of multigene panel assays for early-onset glaucoma varies according to the tested population. The purpose of this study was to ascertain the diagnostic yield of next generation sequencing panels in our cohort and to identify population characteristics that increase such yield.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective review of the medical records of consecutive patients from November 2016 to August 2021 who were evaluated at our clinics for early-onset glaucoma and had undergone next generation sequencing panels for molecular diagnosis.

RESULTS

A total of 118 patients were included, in 22 of whom (19%) a causative variant was identified. Diagnostic yield varied by age of onset: of 60 patients with onset at <3 years of age, 19 (32%) had such variants identified. In contrast, of 58 patients with later-onset glaucoma, 3 (5%) had said variants identified (P = 0.0003). Other metrics that increased diagnostic yield were presence of additional ocular anomalies (P = 0.0092) and identifying ethnicity as White (compared with non-White, P = 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

In childhood glaucoma, earlier age of onset is correlated with higher likelihood of pathogenic variant identification. The large proportion of unsolved cases indicates a robust opportunity for gene discovery and genetic therapy targets in early-onset glaucoma patients.

Multifaceted and Age-Dependent Phenotypes Associated With Biallelic PNPLA6 Gene Variants: Eight Novel Cases and Review of the Literature

A wide spectrum of neurodegenerative diseases has been associated with pathogenic variants in the PNPLA6 (patatin-like phospholipase domain-containing protein 6) gene, including spastic paraplegia type 39, Gordon-Holmes, Boucher-Neuhauser, Oliver-Mc Farlane, and Laurence-Moon syndromes. These syndromes present variable and overlapping clinical symptoms, encompassing cerebellar ataxia, hypogonadotropic hypogonadism, chorioretinal dystrophy, spastic paraplegia, muscle wasting, peripheral neuropathy, and cognitive impairment. In the present study, we performed a wide genetic screening in 292 patients presenting with ataxia or spastic paraplegia using a probe-based customized gene panel, covering >200 genes associated with spinocerebellar diseases. We identified six novel and four recurrent PNPLA6 gene variants in eight patients (2.7%). Six patients presented an infantile or juvenile onset (age <18), and two patients had an adult onset. Cerebellar ataxia was observed in seven patients and spastic paraplegia in one patient. Progression of cerebellar symptoms was slow in all patients, who retained ambulation even after a mean disease duration of 15 years. Brain MRI showed cerebellar atrophy in 6/8 patients, more pronounced in superior and dorsal vermis lobules (I to VII). Additional clinical features included hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (5/8), growth hormone deficiency (2/8), peripheral axonal neuropathy (4/8), cognitive impairment (3/8), chorioretinal dystrophy (2/8), and bilateral vestibular areflexia with a reduced visual vestibule-ocular reflex (1/8). In accordance with previous studies, chorioretinal dystrophy was the most frequent presenting symptom in early onset patients, hypogonadotropic hypogonadism in juvenile onset cases, and cerebellar ataxia in adult patients. One patient had an initial clinical presentation compatible with Cerebellar Ataxia with Neuropathy and Vestibular Areflexia Syndrome (CANVAS), but no pathological expansions in the RFC1 gene. In conclusion, patients with PNPLA6 variants present a variable age of onset spanning from infancy to adulthood, and each clinical symptom has an age-dependent manifestation thus requiring a multi-systemic diagnostic approach. The description of patients presenting very late-onset cerebellar ataxia suggests that PNPLA6 genetic screening should also be considered in the diagnostic workout of adult cerebellar ataxia.