Clinical and genetic spectrum of 104 Indian families with central nervous system white matter abnormalities

Spectrum of Leukodystrophy and Genetic Leukoencephalopathy in Indian Population Diagnosed by Clinical Exome Sequencing and Clinical Utility

Background and Objectives

Next-generation sequencing (NGS) has expedited the diagnostic process and unearthed many rare disorders in leukodystrophy (LD) and genetic leukoencephalopathy (gLE). Despite the progress in genomics, there is a paucity of data on the distribution of genetic white matter disorders (WMDs) and the diagnostic utility of NGS-based assays in a clinical setting. This study was initiated to explore the clinical, radiologic, and genetic spectrum of LD and gLE in the Indian population and also to estimate the diagnostic yield of clinical exome sequencing (CES).

Methods

This is a retrospective descriptive analysis of patients with a diagnosis of genetic WMDs from a single tertiary referral center who had CES performed as part of the diagnostic evaluation between January 2016 and December 2021. The demographic, clinical, radiologic, and genetic data were collected. The variants were classified using the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics criteria. Pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants were included in the calculation of the diagnostic yield.

Results

In the study period, 138 patients were clinically diagnosed with either LD or gLE, of which 86 patients underwent CES. Pathogenic variants, likely pathogenic variants, and variants of uncertain significance with phenotype match were seen in 40 (41.8%), 13 (29.1%), and 15 (15.2%) patients, respectively. The mean age at onset in these 68 patients was 6.35 years (range 1 month-39 years), and 38 (55.9%) were male. LDs and gLE were diagnosed in 31 and 37 patients, respectively. 56 patients (71.8%) had autosomal recessive inheritance. The common clinical presentations were developmental delay (23.5%), psychomotor regression (20.6%), progressive myoclonic epilepsy syndrome (19.1%), and spastic ataxia (14.7%). Myelin disorders (48.5%) and leuko-axonopathies (41.2%) were the commonest type of disorders. The most frequently identified genes were ARSA, CLN5, ABCD1, CLN6, TPP1, HEXA, and L2HGDH. The diagnostic yield of the study was 61.6% (53/86), which increased to 79.1% when VUS with phenotype match were included.

Discussion

This study demonstrated a high diagnostic yield from proband-only CES in the evaluation of genetic WMDs and should be considered as a first-line investigation for genetic diagnosis.

Classification of Evidence

This study provides Class IV evidence that proband-only clinical exome sequencing is a useful "first-line investigation" for patients with genetic white matter disorders.

Etiologic Spectrum of Pediatric-Onset Leukodystrophies and Genetic Leukoencephalopathies: The Five-Year Experience of a Tertiary Care Center in Southern India

BACKGROUND

White matter (WM) disorders with a genetic etiology are classified as leukodystrophies (LDs) and genetic leukoencephalopathies (GLEs). There are very few studies pertaining to the etiologic spectrum of these disorders in the Asian Indian population.

METHODS

This study was conducted over a period of five years from January 2016 to December 2020, in the medical genetics department of a tertiary care hospital in southern India. A total of 107 patients up to age 18 years, with a diagnosis of a genetic WM disorder confirmed by molecular genetic testing and/or metabolic testing, were included in the study and categorized into LD or GLE group as per the classification suggested by the Global Leukodystrophy Initiative consortium in 2015.

RESULTS

Forty-one patients were diagnosed to have LDs, and 66 patients had GLEs. The two most common LDs were metachromatic LD (16 patients) and X-linked adrenoleukodystrophy (seven patients). In the GLE group, lysosomal storage disorders were the most common (40 patients) followed by mitochondrial disorders (nine patients), with other metabolic disorders and miscellaneous conditions making up the rest. The clinical presentations, neuroimaging findings, and mutation spectrum of the patients in our cohort are discussed.

CONCLUSIONS

This is one of the largest cohorts of genetic WM disorders reported till date from the Asian Indian population. The etiologies and clinical presentations identified in our study cohort are similar to those found in other Indian studies as well as in studies based on other populations from different parts of the world.

PRKACA-related, atrial defects-polydactyly-multiple congenital malformation syndrome in an Indian patient

PRKACA-related, atrial defects-polydactyly-multiple congenital malformation syndrome is a recently described skeletal ciliopathy, which is caused by disease-causing variants in PRKACA. The primary phenotypic description includes atrial septal defects, and limb anomalies including polydactyly and short limbs. To date, only four molecularly proven patients have been reported in the literature with a recurrent variant, c.409G>A p.Gly137Arg in PRKACA. In this study, we report the fifth affected individual with the same variant and review the clinical features and radiographic findings of this rare syndrome.

De novo variants underlying monogenic syndromes with intellectual disability in a neurodevelopmental cohort from India

The contribution of de novo variants as a cause of intellectual disability (ID) is well established in several cohorts reported from the developed world. However, the genetic landscape as well as the appropriate testing strategies for identification of de novo variants of these disorders remain largely unknown in low-and middle-income countries like India. In this study, we delineate the clinical and genotypic spectrum of 54 families (55 individuals) with syndromic ID harboring rare de novo variants. We also emphasize on the effectiveness of singleton exome sequencing as a valuable tool for diagnosing these disorders in resource limited settings. Overall, 46 distinct disorders were identified encompassing 46 genes with 51 single-nucleotide variants and/or indels and two copy-number variants. Pathogenic variants were identified in CREBBP, TSC2, KMT2D, MECP2, IDS, NIPBL, NSD1, RIT1, SOX10, BRWD3, FOXG1, BCL11A, KDM6B, KDM5C, SETD5, QRICH1, DCX, SMARCD1, ASXL1, ASXL3, AKT3, FBN2, TCF12, WASF1, BRAF, SMARCA4, SMARCA2, TUBG1, KMT2A, CTNNB1, DLG4, MEIS2, GATAD2B, FBXW7, ANKRD11, ARID1B, DYNC1H1, HIVEP2, NEXMIF, ZBTB18, SETD1B, DYRK1A, SRCAP, CASK, L1CAM, and KRAS. Twenty-four of these monogenic disorders have not been previously reported in the Indian population. Notably, 39 out of 53 (74%) disease-causing variants are novel. These variants were identified in the genes mainly encoding transcriptional and chromatin regulators, serine threonine kinases, lysosomal enzymes, molecular motors, synaptic proteins, neuronal migration machinery, adhesion molecules, structural proteins and signaling molecules.

Exome Sequencing in Monogenic Forms of Rickets

OBJECTIVE

To understand the phenotypic and genotypic spectrum of genetic forms of rickets in 10 families.

METHODS

Detailed clinical, radiographic, and biochemical evaluation of 10 families with phenotypes suggestive of a genetic cause of rickets was performed. Molecular testing using exome sequencing aided in the diagnosis of six different forms of known genetic causes.

RESULTS

Eleven disease-causing variants including five previously reported variants (CYP27B1:c.1319_1325dup, p.(Phe443Profs*24), VDR:c.1171C>T, p.(Arg391Cys), PHEX: c.1586_1586+1del, PHEX: c.1482+5G>C, PHEX: c.58C>T, p.(Arg20*)) and six novel variants (CYP27B1:c.974C>T, p.(Thr325Met), CYP27B1: c.1376G>A, p.(Arg459His), CYP2R1: c.595C>T, p.(Arg199*), CYP2R1:c.1330G>C, p.(Gly444Arg),SLC34A3:c.1336-11_1336-1del, SLC2A2: c.589G>C, p.(Val197Leu)) in the genes known to cause monogenic rickets were identified.

CONCLUSION

The authors hereby report a case series of individuals from India with a molecular diagnosis of rickets and provide the literature review which would help in enhancing the clinical and molecular profile for rapid and differential diagnosis of rickets.

Clinical, genetic and structural delineation of RPL13-related spondyloepimetaphyseal dysplasia suggest extra-ribosomal functions of eL13

Spondyloepimetaphyseal dysplasia with severe short stature, RPL13-related (SEMD-RPL13), MIM#618728), is a rare autosomal dominant disorder characterized by short stature and skeletal changes such as mild spondylar and epimetaphyseal dysplasia affecting primarily the lower limbs. The genetic cause was first reported in 2019 by Le Caignec et al., and six disease-causing variants in the gene coding for a ribosomal protein, RPL13 (NM_000977.3) have been identified to date. This study presents clinical and radiographic data from 12 affected individuals aged 2-64 years from seven unrelated families, showing highly variable manifestations. The affected individuals showed a range from mild to severe short stature, retaining the same radiographic pattern of spondylar- and epi-metaphyseal dysplasia, but with varying severity of the hip and knee deformities. Two new missense variants, c.548 G>A, p.(Arg183His) and c.569 G>T, p.(Arg190Leu), and a previously known splice variant c.477+1G>A were identified, confirming mutational clustering in a highly specific RNA binding motif. Structural analysis and interpretation of the variants' impact on the protein suggests that disruption of extra-ribosomal functions of the protein through binding of mRNA may play a role in the skeletal phenotype of SEMD-RPL13. In addition, we present gonadal and somatic mosaicism for the condition.

Challenges in the Definitive Diagnosis of Niemann-Pick Type C-Leaky Variants and Alternative Transcripts

Niemann-Pick type C (NPC, ORPHA: 646) is a neuro-visceral, psychiatric disease caused predominantly by pathogenic variants in the NPC1 gene or seldom in NPC2. The rarity of the disease, and its wide range of clinical phenotypes and ages of onset, turn the diagnosis into a significant challenge. Other than the detailed clinical history, the typical diagnostic work-up for NPC includes the quantification of pathognomonic metabolites. However, the molecular basis diagnosis is still of utmost importance to fully characterize the disorder. Here, the authors provide an overview of splicing variants in the NPC1 and NPC2 genes and propose a new workflow for NPC diagnosis. Splicing variants cover a significant part of the disease-causing variants in NPC. The authors used cDNA analysis to study the impact of such variants, including the collection of data to classify them as leaky or non-leaky pathogenic variants. However, the presence of naturally occurring spliced transcripts can misdiagnose or mask a pathogenic variant and make the analysis even more difficult. Analysis of the NPC1 cDNA in NPC patients in parallel with controls is vital to assess and detect alternatively spliced forms. Moreover, nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) analysis plays an essential role in evaluating the naturally occurring transcripts during cDNA analysis and distinguishing them from other pathogenic variants' associated transcripts.

Case report: Heterozygous mutation in HTRA1 causing typical cerebral autosomal recessive arteriopathy with subcortical infarcts and leukoencephalopathy

Background: Cerebral autosomal recessive arteriopathy with subcortical infarcts and leukoencephalopathy (CARASIL) is an autosomal recessive disorder characterized by baldness, recurrent ischemic stroke, lumbago, headache, and dementia which is closely related to homozygous mutations of the high-temperature requirement serine peptidase A1 (HTRA1) gene. Heterozygous mutations of HTRA1 are usually considered to be non-pathogenic. Although it has been revealed that only a few patients with heterozygous mutations could present some manifestations, their clinical symptoms were atypical, milder, and always with a lower frequency of extra-neurological features. Here, a rare patient with heterozygous mutation of HTRA1 who had all typical features of CARASIL as well as severe clinical symptoms and rapid progression was initially reported in our study. Case presentation: A 43-year-old female patient presented with a gradual onset of headache and cognitive decline. As time progressed, her headache intensified and symptoms of dementia began to manifest gradually. During her early years, she had thinning hair and subsequently experienced two occurrences of ischemic strokes in her thirties. Furthermore, she also had a history of lumbago and urinary retention before visiting our hospital. The patient's magnetic resonance imaging revealed the presence of widespread white matter lesions, infarctions, and microbleeds, in addition to lumbar disc herniation and degenerative lesions. The observed clinical characteristics had a strong correlation with CARASIL, and the patient was diagnosed with a heterozygous missense mutation of 905G>A (Arg302Gln) in the HTRA1 gene. The patient has been under continuous follow-up for a duration exceeding 3 years subsequent to her release from the hospital. She underwent cystostomy, and symptoms of bulbar paralysis developed in a progressive way. Currently, there has been a notable decrease in motor function and activities of daily living, resulting in the individual being confined to bed for a duration exceeding 1 year. Conclusion: This case suggests that patients carrying a heterozygous mutation in G905A may also have typical clinical features of CARASIL, which allows us to have a more comprehensive understanding of CARASIL.

Solving inherited white matter disorder etiologies in the neurology clinic: Challenges and lessons learned using next-generation sequencing

Introduction

Rare neurodevelopmental disorders, including inherited white matter disorders or leukodystrophies, often present a diagnostic challenge on a genetic level given the large number of causal genes associated with a range of disease subtypes. This study aims to demonstrate the challenges and lessons learned in the genetic investigations of leukodystrophies through presentation of a series of cases solved using exome or genome sequencing.

Methods

Each of the six patients had a leukodystrophy associated with hypomyelination or delayed myelination on MRI, and inconclusive clinical diagnostic genetic testing results. We performed next generation sequencing (case-based exome or genome sequencing) to further investigate the genetic cause of disease.

Results

Following different lines of investigation, molecular diagnoses were obtained for each case, with patients harboring pathogenic variants in a range of genes including TMEM106B, GJA1, AGA, POLR3A, and TUBB4A. We describe the lessons learned in reaching the genetic diagnosis, including the importance of (a) utilizing proper multi-gene panels in clinical testing, (b) assessing the reliability of biochemical assays in supporting diagnoses, and (c) understanding the limitations of exome sequencing methods in regard to CNV detection and region coverage in GC-rich areas.

Discussion

This study illustrates the importance of applying a collaborative diagnostic approach by combining detailed phenotyping data and metabolic results from the clinical environment with advanced next generation sequencing analysis techniques from the research environment to increase the diagnostic yield in patients with genetically unresolved leukodystrophies.

Biallelic loss-of-function variants in EXOC6B are associated with impaired primary ciliogenesis and cause spondylo-epi-metaphyseal dysplasia with joint laxity type 3

Spondylo-epi-metaphyseal dysplasias with joint laxity, type 3 (SEMDJL3) is a genetic skeletal disorder characterized by multiple joint dislocations, caused by biallelic pathogenic variants in the EXOC6B gene. Only four individuals from two families have been reported to have this condition to date. The molecular pathogenesis related to primary ciliogenesis has not been enumerated in subjects with SEMDJL3. In this study, we report two additional affected individuals from unrelated families with biallelic pathogenic variants, c.2122+15447_2197-59588del and c.401T>G in EXOC6B identified by exome sequencing. One of the affected individuals had an intellectual disability and central nervous system anomalies, including hydrocephalus, hypoplastic mesencephalon, and thin corpus callosum. Using the fibroblast cell lines, we demonstrate the primary evidence for the abrogation of exocytosis in an individual with SEMDLJ3 leading to impaired primary ciliogenesis. Osteogenesis differentiation and pathways related to the extracellular matrix were also found to be reduced. Additionally, we provide a review of the clinical and molecular profile of all the mutation-proven patients reported hitherto, thereby further characterizing SEMDJL3. SEMDJL3 with biallelic pathogenic variants in EXOC6B might represent yet another ciliopathy with central nervous system involvement and joint dislocations.

Pseudoachondroplasia: Phenotype and genotype in 11 Indian patients

Pseudoachondroplasia (PSACH) is an autosomal dominant disorder characterized by rhizomelic short-limbed skeletal dysplasia. The primary clinical and radiographic features include disproportionate dwarfism, joint laxity and hyperextensibility, exaggerated lumbar lordosis, and late ossification of the epiphyses. Identification of disease-causing variants in heterozygous state in COMP establishes the molecular diagnosis of PSACH. We examined 11 families with clinical features suggestive of PSACH. In nine families, we used Sanger sequencing of exons 8-19 of COMP (NM_000095.2) and in two families exome sequencing was used for confirming the diagnosis. We identified 10 de novo variants, including five known variants (c.925G>A, c.976G>A, c.1201G>T, c.1417_1419del, and c.1511G>A) and five variants (c.874T>C, c.1201G>C, c.1309G>A, c.1416_1421delCGACAA, and c.1445A>T) which are not reported outside Indian ethnicity. We hereby report the largest series of individuals with molecular diagnosis of PSACH from India and reiterate the well-known genotype-phenotype corelation in PSACH.