Excising or preserving perforation margins in endoscopic transtympanic cartilage myringoplasty does not affect surgical success

Effects of no perforation margin trimming and EAC packing in cartilage underlay myringoplasty for chronic large perforations in children

OBJECTIVE

Trimming of perforation margins and external auditory canal (EAC) packing are basic procedures in underlay myringoplasty for repairing chronic perforations. The objective of this study was to compare the operation time, graft outcome, hearing improvement, and complications of endoscopic cartilage underlay myringoplasty with and without trimming of perforation margins and EAC packing in children.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective, randomized study.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Pediatric patients older than 12 years with chronic perforations were randomly divided into two groups: myringoplasty with trimming of perforation margin and EAC packing (TPME) group or no trimming of perforation margin and EAC packing (NTPME) group. The operation time, graft success rate, hearing improvement, and complications were compared between the two groups.

RESULTS

Fifty-two patients were ultimately included in the study. The mean operation time was 31.4 ± 4.2 min in the TPME group and 23.6 ± 1.7 min in the NTPME group; the difference was significant (P < 0.01). The rate of aural fullness significantly differed between the TPME and NTPME groups (P = 0.000). All participants were followed up for 12 months; the graft success rate did not significantly differ between the groups (88.5% vs. 96.2%; P = 0.603). No patients developed adhesive otitis media. Between the preoperative and postoperative measurements, the mean air-bone gap improved by 10.2 ± 2.8 dB in the TPME group and 11.6 ± 0.7 dB in the NTPME group; this was significant (P < 0.001) in both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic cartilage underlay myringoplasty NTPME shorted the operation time and avoided aural fullness and EAC discomfort compared with the TPME technique; however, graft success and hearing improvement were comparable between the two techniques for repairing large perforations in children.

Additional cartilage reinforcement of the annulus in myringoplasty for subtotal perforation

OBJECTIVE

In this study, graft success, hearing outcome, and complications were compared following the repair of subtotal perforation using a cartilage reinforcement underlay technique (CRUT) versus the traditional cartilage underlay technique (TCUT).

STUDY DESIGN

Randomized controlled trial.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seventy-six patients with subtotal perforations were prospectively randomized to the CRUT (n = 38) or TCUT (n = 38) group. The graft success rate, hearing outcome, and complications were compared at 12 months.

RESULTS

The mean operation time was 32.9 ± 4.2 (range: 26-47) min in the CRUT group and 51.8 ± 6.3 (range: 48-73) min in the TCUT group (P < 0.001). At 12 months postoperatively, no residual perforation was seen in either group. The graft success rate was 94.7 % (36/38) in the CRUT group and 92.1 % (35/38) in the TCUT group; the difference was not significant (P = 0.643). The postoperative air bone gap (ABG) was significantly improved compared to the preoperative value in both groups, without significant between-group differences in either the preoperative (P = 0.741) or postoperative (P = 0.865) ABG or the mean ABG gain (P = 0.812). Additionally, there were no significant between-group differences in the preoperative (P = 0.887) or postoperative (P = 0.753) mean bone-conduction pure tone average. In the TCUT group, seven (18.4 %) patients developed temporary hypogeusia and two (5.3 %) had external auditory canal scarring. Graft cholesteatoma was not observed in either group.

CONCLUSION

In the treatment of subtotal perforations, lateral reinforcement of the annulus with additional cartilage is simpler than traditional cartilage underlay for achieving graft and hearing success. The technique also does not involve raising the tympanomeatal flap or removing perforation margins.

Graft Healing Process Following Cartilage Myringoplasty Without Trimming of the Perforation Margin

Objective: The objective of this study was to endoscopically evaluate the graft healing process and graft success rate following cartilage myringoplasty, without trimming of the perforation margin or external ear canal (EAC) packing. Material and Methods: Patients with chronic tympanic membrane (TM) perforation underwent endoscope cartilage underlay myringoplasty, without trimming perforation margin or EAC packing. The healing process of the cartilage graft and the graft success rate were evaluated at 6 months postoperatively. Results: Fifty-eight ears were included in this study. At 1 week postoperatively, clinical inosculation and neovascularization of the graft were observed in small- and medium-sized perforations, but not in large or subtotal perforations. At 2 weeks postoperatively, graft clinical inosculation and neovascularization were completed in the small- and medium-sized perforations; however, neovascularization of the graft had only just begun in the large perforations. At 3 weeks postoperatively, completion of the graft clinical inosculation was achieved in 57 of the 58 ears. At 4 weeks postoperatively, complete neovascularization was achieved in all perforations. Of the 58 ears, postoperative infection resulted in residual perforation in 1 ear, and an insufficient graft resulted in residual perforation in a large perforation without infection. Overall, the graft success rate was 96.6% (56/58). There was no correlation between the graft success rate and graft neovascularization score. Conclusions: The graft healing process experienced the dilation of the blood vessels of the remnant TM, graft clinical inosculation, and neovascularization following cartilage myringoplasty without trimming of the perforation margin and EAC packing; however, the graft success rate was not related to the endoscopic graft neovascularization scores.

Comparison of two endoscopic perichondrium-cartilage graft underlay myringoplasty for large perforations: a randomized controlled trial

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to compare the graft outcomes and complications of two endoscopic perichondrium-cartilage graft techniques for repairing large perforations.

STUDY DESIGN

Single center blinded randomized controlled trial.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

61 large perforations more than 50% of TM area were prospectively randomized to undergo the free perichondrium and free cartilage graft group (FPFC, n = 31) or perichondrium partial attachment the cartilage graft group (PPAC, n = 30). The primary outcome measures were the operation time; secondary outcome measures were the graft success rate and hearing gain at 12 months postoperatively and postoperative complications.

RESULTS

All patients completed follow-up of 12 months. The mean operation time was 38.2 ± 2.3 min in the FPFC group and 37.4 ± 5.6 min in the PPAC group (P = 0.658). At postoperative 3 months, the graft success rates were 96.7% in the FPFC group and 93.3% in the PPAC group (P = 0.976). At postoperative 12 months, the graft success rates were 96.7% in the FPFC group and 83.3% in the PPAC group (P = 0.182). However, the residual and re-perforation rate with no infection was 0.0% (0/31) in the FPFC group and 16.7% (5/30) in the PPAC group (P = 0.056). No significant between-group differences were observed pre- (P = 0.842) or post- (P = 0.759) operative air bone gap (ABG) values or mean ABG gain (P = 0.886). However, granular myringitis has been noted in 6.5% in the FPFC group and in 3.3% in the PPAC group.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggested that 12-month graft success and hearing gain were comparable between the perichondrium free and partial attachment the cartilage graft techniques, nevertheless, partial attachment technique could increase residual and re-perforations.

Endoscopic Perichondrium-Cartilage Myringoplasty With Preserving of Anterior Margins and Tuck Grafts for Repairing Anterior Perforation With 3 year Followup

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to evaluate the graft outcomes of endoscopic perichondrium-cartilage myringoplasty with preserving of anterior margins for repairing anterior perforation with 3 year followup.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective case series.

SETTING

Tertiary university hospital.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We performed a prospective study in 47 patients with anterior perforation who underwent perichondrium-cartilage myringoplasty with preserving of anterior margins and tuck grafts. The operation time, graft success rate, hearing outcome, and complications were evaluated at 6 months and 3 years after surgery.

RESULTS

A total of 47 ears with anterior marginal perforation were included in the study. The perforation size was subtotal in 2 (4.3%) eras, large in 11 (23.4%) ears, medium in 27 (57.4%) ears, and small in 7 (14.9%). The mean operation time was 41.2 ± 5.4 minutes. All patients completed 6 months of follow-up. Residual perforation was observed in 2 patients with medium perforations, the graft success rate was 95.7% (45/47). The mean preoperative and postoperative AC PTAs were 38.1 ± 7.3 dB and 25.4 ± 4.6 dB (P < .05), while the mean preoperative and postoperative BC PTAs were 9.0 ± 4.6 dB and 9.6 ± 1.9 dB (P = .672). The functional success was 91.5% (43/47). None of the patients reported sensorineural hearing loss, altered taste, facial nerve palsy, vertigo, or tinnitus during the follow-up period. In addition, 34 (72.3%) patients completed 3 years followup and performed temporal bone CT examination, the mean followup time was 39.1 ± 2.7 months, CT revealed the well pneumatization of mastoids and middle ear.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic perichondrium-cartilage myringoplasty with preserving of anterior margins and tuck grafts is a safe, suitable, and reliable method for repair of anterior perforation with few risk of anterior blunting and lateralization.

Comparison of perichondrium-cartilage double and single underlay myringoplasty for subtotal perforations: a randomized controlled trial

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to compare graft outcome, operation time and surgical complications of the double and single perichondrium-cartilage underlay techniques for repairing subtotal tympanic membrane (TM) perforations.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Patients with unilateral subtotal perforations undergoing myringoplasty were prospectively randomized to undergo DPCN or SPCN. The operation time, graft success rate, audiometric outcomes, and complications were compared between these groups.

RESULTS

In total, 53 patients with unilateral subtotal perforations were included (DPCN group, 27; SPCN group, 26).All patients completed 6 months of follow-up. The mean operation time was 41.2 ± 1.8 min in the DPCN group and 37.2 ± 5.4 min in the SPCN group, the difference was not significant (p = 0.613).The graft success rates were 96.3% (26/27) in the DPCN group and 73.1% (19/26) in the SPCN group, the difference was significant (p = 0.048). During the period of follow-up, residual perforation was found at postoperative in one (3.7%) in the DPCN group, while cartilage graft slipped (graft lateralization) in 2 (7.7%) and residual perforation in 5 (19.2%) were found in the SPCN group, the difference of residual perforation was not significant among two group (p = 0.177).In addition, no significant between-group differences were observed pre- (p = 0.741) or post- (p = 0.687) operative ABG values or mean ABG gain (p = 0.659) (Table 2).The functional success rates (postoperative ABG ≤ 20 dB) were 85.2% (23/27) in the DPCN group and 73.1% (19/26) in the SPCN group (p = 0.454).

CONCLUSION

Although similar functional result and operation time can be obtained with double perichondrium-cartilage underlay technique compared to the single perichondrium-cartilage underlay technique for endoscopic closure of subtotal perforations, double unerlay technique offers better anatomical result with minimum complications.

Effect of Packing Versus No Packing in Transperforation Myringoplasty for Chronic Tympanic Membrane Perforations

OBJECTIVE

To compare the operation times, graft survival and success rates, audiometric outcomes, and complications of patients who underwent transperforation myringoplasty with and without packing but without perforation rimming.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective, randomized controlled trial.

SETTING

A university-affiliated teaching hospital.

METHODS

We conducted a randomized controlled trial that enrolled patients who underwent underlay myringoplasty. No patient underwent perforation rimming. Patients underwent myringoplasty with or without graft lateral packing. The operation times, graft survival and success rates, audiometric outcomes, and complications were compared between the 2 groups.

RESULTS

Sixty patients with unilateral perforations were included. The mean neovascularization score at postoperative week 2 was significantly higher in the no-packing group than in the packing group (p < .01) but did not differ significantly at postoperative weeks 3 and 4, or postoperative month 3. Neither the graft healing rate (p = .313) nor the perforation closure rate (p = .640) significantly differed between the 2 groups. The mean air-bone gap improved by 8.91 ± 5.45 dB in the packing group and 8.17 ± 1.19 dB in the no-packing group (p = .758).

CONCLUSION

The long-term graft success and hearing improvements in transperforation myringoplasty with no rimming of the perforation and no-graft lateral packing were comparable to those in the graft lateral packing group with no rimming of the perforation, with a low incidence of complications. These results may change the traditional practice of packing the external auditory canal and rimming the perforation in underlay myringoplasty, even for all myringoplasty surgery.

Comparison of Endoscopic Modified and Typical Myringoplasty: A Randomized Controlled Trial

OBJECTIVE

Here, we aimed to compare the operation time, postoperative pain score, graft healing, graft success rate, cholesteatoma incidence, audiometric outcomes, and complications between endoscopic modified myringoplasty (EMM) and endoscopic typical myringoplasty (ETM).

METHODS

Patients with unilateral chronic tympanic membrane (TM) perforations undergoing myringoplasty were prospectively randomized to undergo EMM (n = 44) or ETM (n = 45). The operation time, postoperative pain score, graft healing, graft success rate, cholesteatoma incidence, audiometric outcomes, and complications were compared between these groups.

RESULTS

In total, 89 patients with unilateral chronic perforations were included (EMM group, 44; ETM group, 45). There were significant differences between the EMM and ETM groups in mean pain scores on the day after surgery (1.32 ± 0.56 vs. 2.58 ± 1.16, p < 0.001) and in the mean operation time (18.18 ± 2.43 vs. 51.53 ± 8.28 min, p < 0.001). There were no significant differences in graft success rates (93.18% vs. 88.89%, p = 0.735), pre- or postoperative air conduction pure-tone averages or air bone gaps (ABGs), or changes in ABGs between the groups. However, the difference in graft healing was significant at postoperative week 2 (33/44 vs. 24/45, p = 0.033) but was nonsignificant at postoperative week 4 and month 6. Computed tomography revealed the middle ear and mastoid to be well pneumatized at 12 months in all patients.

CONCLUSION

While 12-month graft and audiometric outcomes were comparable between EMM and ETM techniques, patients who underwent EMM had less postoperative pain, shorter operative times, faster healing, and a lower incidence of complications.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

1 Laryngoscope, 133:2779-2785, 2023.

Local Anesthesia-Based Modified Cartilage "Inlay" Graft Myringoplasty for Repairing Large Perforation

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to evaluate the graft success rate and hearing outcome of modified cartilage inlay graft technique for repairing large perforations under local anesthesia.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective case series.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We performed a prospective study in 31 patients with large perforations who underwent endoscopic local anesthesia-based modified cartilage inlay graft technique with no raising of the squamous epithelium and no rimming of the perforation margins. The graft outcomes and complications were evaluated at 6 and 24 months postoperatively.

RESULTS

Thirty-one patients (31 ears) were included in this study. The mean operation time was 42.3 ± 2.6 (ranged 36-51) minutes. The visual analog scale pain scores at intraoperative and 2 and 48 hours postoperatively were, respectively, 2.6 ± 0.6, 1.4 ± 0.2, and 0.6 ± 0.1. The graft success rate was 100.0% (31/31) at 6 months after surgery. However, only 25 (80.6%, 25/31) patients completed a 2-year follow-up and performed a temporal bone CT examination; re-perforation was seen in 2 patients, the graft success rate was 92.0% (23/25). CT revealed the well-developed pneumatization of the mastoids and middle ear in all the patients. Nevertheless, 1 (1/25, 8.0%) patient developed a graft epithelial inclusion cyst, which was removed by endoscope in the outpatient setting. The mean preoperative air bone gap (ABG) was 23.1 ± 4.3 dB, while the mean postoperative ABG after 6 months was 14.9 ± 2.6 dB; the difference between these values was significant (P < .05; Wilcoxon's signed-rank test), and the functional success rate was 93.5% (29/31).

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic modified cartilage "inlay" graft technique with no raising the squamous epithelium and no rimming the perforation is a minimally invasive technique with a short operative time and satisfying success rate for closure of large perforations under local anesthesia.

Perichondrium-Cartilage Inlay Butterfly Myringoplasty: An Office-Based Procedure for Closing Small- to Medium-Sized Tympanic Membrane Perforations

Objective: The objective of this study was to assess the graft and functional outcomes of inlay butterfly cartilage-perichondrium graft myringoplasty in an office setting. Material and Methods: Adult patients with chronic perforations underwent inlay butterfly cartilage-perichondrium graft myringoplasty under local and topical anesthesia. The graft and functional outcomes, intraoperative pain score, and complications were evaluated at 6 months postoperatively. Results: A total of 39 patients (39 ears) were included in this study. All patients completed 6 months of follow-up. The mean operation time was 26.5 ± 3.2 (ranged from 21 to 32) minutes. The intraoperative mean pain score was 0.61 ± 0.28. The graft success rate was 97.4% (38/39) at 6 months postoperatively. The mean preoperative air-bone gap (ABG) was 19.18 ± 4.01 dB, while the mean postoperative ABG at 6 months was 10.56 ± 2.27 dB (P < .05; Paired-Samples T Test). The functional success rate was 100.0% (38/38). Endoscopic examination showed that the transplanted perichondrium graft gradually atrophied, flattened, and became indistinguishable from the surrounding tympanic membrane 2 to 3 months following surgery, the superficial layer of perichondrium graft formed the crust and migrated into the external auditory canal at 3 to 6 months postoperatively. Conclusions: Perichondrium-cartilage inlay butterfly myringoplasty is a highly successful and minimally invasive procedure well tolerated by adults for closure of small- and medium-sized perforations in an office setting.