Malignant transformation of tailgut cysts is significantly higher than previously reported: systematic review of cases in the literature

The management of retrorectal tumors - a single-center analysis of 21 cases and overview of the literature

AIM

Retrorectal tumors are rare and heterogeneous. They are often asymptomatic or present with nonspecific symptoms, making management challenging. This study examines the diagnosis and treatment of retrorectal tumors.

METHODS

Between 2002 and 2022, 21 patients with retrorectal tumors were treated in our department. We analyzed patient characteristics, diagnosis and treatment modalities retrospectively. Additionally, a literature review (2002-2023, "retrorectal tumors" and "presacral tumors", 20 or more cases included) was performed.

RESULTS

Of the 21 patients (median age 54 years, 62% female), 17 patients (81%) suffered from benign lesions and 4 (19%) from malignant lesions. Symptoms were mostly nonspecific, with pain being the most common (11/21 (52%)). Diagnosis was incidental in eight cases. Magnetic resonance imaging was performed in 20 (95%) and biopsy was obtained in 10 (48%). Twenty patients underwent surgery, mostly via a posterior approach (14/20 (70%)). At a mean follow-up of 42 months (median 10 months, range 1-166 months), the local recurrence rate was 19%. There was no mortality. Our Pubmed search identified 39 publications.

CONCLUSION

Our data confirms the significant heterogeneity of retrorectal tumors, which poses a challenge to management, especially considering the often nonspecific symptoms. Regarding diagnosis and treatment, our data highlights the importance of MRI and surgical resection. In particular a malignancy rate of almost 20% warrants a surgical resection in case of the findings of a retrorectal tumour. A local recurrence rate of 19% supports the need for follow up.

Tailgut Cyst in a Child: A Case Report and Review of Literature

ABSTRACT

Tailgut cysts are rare congenital abnormalities that develop due to failure of embryologic tailgut to involute. This generally manifests as a presacral, retrorectal and multicystic mass. It has a high propensity in female patients including paediatric age group. The clinical presentation varies depending on the age of patient, location and size of the cyst. The symptoms are mostly due to mass effects and rarely complications such as malignancy. Being a rare entity, it is generally misdiagnosed. Differential diagnosis mostly includes rectal duplication cyst, sacrococcygeal teratoma and anterior meningocele. Radiological imaging such as computed tomography scan and magnetic resonance imaging is useful in the diagnosis. The treatment of choice is complete excision to prevent recurrence, infection and malignant degeneration. We have reviewed previous literature and given our valuable information regarding the same.

Analysis of the clinicopathological features of tailgut cyst with emphasis on the development of neoplastic lesions

Tailgut cyst is a rare congenital cyst occurring in the retrorectal space and development of neoplastic lesions in tailgut cyst has been reported. Due to the rarity of the tumor, the histogenesis of neoplastic lesions in tailgut cyst has remained elusive. In the present study, the clinicopathological features of tailgut cyst were analyzed with a particular focus on the development of neoplastic lesions. The clinicopathological features of four patients with tailgut cyst (one female and three males) were retrospectively reviewed. No symptoms were present in two patients. Perineal discomfort, and constipation and urinary retention, were described in the other two patients, respectively. Magnetic resonance imaging showed that the cystic lesions were hypointense on T1- and hyperintense on T2-weigted images in all patients. Histopathological analysis revealed that all lesions were multilocular, and cystic walls were covered by squamous and ciliated epithelia without nuclear atypia. The development of neoplastic lesions was noted in two patients. Dysplastic change composed of piling-up proliferation of glandular cells with mild to moderate nuclear atypia was present in one patient, and invasive adenocarcinoma with a dysplasia component was observed in another patient. Dysplasia of the glandular cells, as seen in two patients in the present series, may be a precursor lesion of invasive adenocarcinoma; therefore, adenocarcinoma arsing in tailgut cyst may show a dysplasia-carcinoma sequence. While the reported incidence of neoplastic lesions in tailgut cysts is ~9% or less, their frequency remains to be accurately determined. Therefore, complete surgical resection is important for the management of patients with tailgut cyst. Additional clinicopathological and molecular studies with large cohorts may be required to clarify the histogenesis of neoplastic lesion in tailgut cyst.

Presacral Tailgut Cyst

A tailgut cyst is a rare benign polycystic congenital lesion in presacral or retrorectal space, when there is failure of involution of tailgut. Clinical presentation may be with or without symptoms of different types related to obstruction, infection, or rarely malignancy. Symptoms may be misleading and atypical, so understanding of characteristics of tailgut cysts is important for precise and early diagnosis to be made for proper treatment and to avoid complications and malignant transformation. Magnetic resonance imaging pelvis was used as diagnostic imaging investigation, but the final confirmation was only done by histopathology. Definitive treatment is surgery, though various surgical approaches are described, surgery is tailored which will suit the individual patient's anatomy and suspected diagnosis of mass. This case review used PubMed and Web of Science databases to search for the studies. We found around 176 articles and selected 77 articles in our survey, with 8 reviews, 31 case reports, and 31 case reports and reviews.

Surgical treatment of retrorectal tumors: a plea for a laparoscopic approach

INTRODUCTION

Retrorectal tumors (RRTs) are rare and often surgically excised due to the risk of malignant degeneration and compressive or obstructive symptoms. The approach for excision has traditionally been based on tumor location and performed using either a transabdominal or perineal approach depending on the position of the tumor. The advent of minimally invasive surgery, however, has challenged this paradigm. Here, we determined the applicability and potential advantages of a laparoscopic transabdominal approach in a series of 23 patients with RRTs.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We included 23 patients presenting with RRTs treated at the Surgical Gastrointestinal Unit at Hospital de Sant Pau that were registered prospectively since 1998. The preoperative evaluation consisted of colonoscopy, CT scan and/or MRI, mechanical bowel lavage, and antibiotic therapy. Signed consent was obtained from all patients for a laparoscopic transabdominal approach unless the tumor was easily accessible via a perineal approach. In case of recurrence, a transanal endoscopic microsurgery (TEM) approach was considered. Surgical details, immediate morbidity, and short- and long-term outcomes were recorded.

RESULTS

Of the 23 RRT cases evaluated, 16 patients underwent a laparoscopic transabdominal approach and 6 underwent a perineal approach. No patients required conversion to open surgery. In the laparoscopic transabdominal group, the mean operating time was 158 min, the average postoperative hospital stay was 5 days, and postoperative morbidity was 18%. Three patients had recurrent RRTs, two of the three underwent surgical reintervention. The third patient was radiologically stable and close follow-up was decided.

CONCLUSION

Our results show that laparoscopic transabdominal excision of RRT is a safe and effective technique, offering the potential advantages of less invasive access and reduced morbidity. This approach challenges the traditional paradigm of excision of these infrequent tumors based solely on tumor location and offers a viable alternative for the treatment of these infrequent tumors.

Malignant transformation of tailgut cyst to squamous cell carcinoma, a rare case with poor outcome

Tailgut cyst, a type of retro-rectal cyst, is a rare condition requiring evaluation for malignant transformation. We report a case of squamous cell carcinoma arising in the retro-rectal cyst, in a 51-year-old female who underwent incomplete resection of the cyst and chemo-radiotherapy, subsequently became locally recurred and metastatic.

Cystic lesions of the retrorectal space

Cysts of the retrorectal space comprise a heterogeneous group of rare lesions. Most develop from embryological remnants and include tailgut cysts, dermoid cysts, rectal duplication cysts, anal canal duplication cysts, sacrococcygeal teratomas and anterior meningocoele. Tailgut cyst is the most common cyst of developmental origin, usually presenting as a multilocular cystic mass with mucoid content and lined by multiple epithelial types. Compared with tailgut cysts, rectal duplication cysts display all layers of the large bowel wall including a well-defined muscularis propria. Retrorectal cysts of non-developmental origin are far less common and represent lesions that either infrequently involve the retrorectal space or undergo extensive cystic change. This review provides an overview of the various histological types of cystic lesions of the retrorectal space, divided into cysts of developmental origin and those of non-developmental origin. A practical pathological and multidisciplinary approach to diagnosing these lesions is presented.

A Rare Case of Ruptured Tailgut Cyst Leading to Carcinomatosis

Tailgut cysts are congenital cysts arising in the retrorectal space. They are thought to be benign with variable malignancy risks. We report a case with previous surgical intervention decades prior that had undergone a tailgut cyst excision with surgical complications leading to carcinomatosis. An elderly female (70s) presented with tailbone/pelvic pain. She underwent cyst excision that was complicated by an intraoperative rupture. The cyst was pathologically proven to be a tailgut cyst with adenocarcinoma. She presented 13 months postoperatively to the emergency department with worsening abdominal pain. Imaging was concerning for diffuse omental nodules and narrowing of the proximal sigmoid colon. She was not deemed to be a surgical candidate and was transitioned to hospice care, where she passed away shortly afterward. This case report highlights the utility of complete excision of tailgut cysts and possible complications.

[Neuroendocrine tumor associated with an intestinal cyst: a case report]

Intestinal (tailgut) cysts or retrorectal cystic hamartomas are rare benign lesions that are included in the category of developmental cystic lesions. Their origin is still uncertain, although several hypotheses have been proposed to explain their development. They are located mainly in the presacral (retrorectal) space and predominately affect middle-aged women (40-60 years). Taking into account location and histological characteristics, the main differential diagnoses include epidermoid cysts, duplication cysts and teratomas. Malignant transformation of these lesions is rare and preferentially into adenocarcinoma and neuroendocrine tumors. We present a case of an intestinal cyst associated with a well-differentiated neuroendocrine tumor (G1) in a 63-year-old woman.

Primary malignant tumours and malignant transformation of cysts in the retrorectal space: MRI diagnosis and treatment outcomes

Background

There are no clear guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of malignant retrorectal tumours. The purpose of this study was to increase preoperative diagnostic knowledge and to describe the outcomes of treatment for these patients.

Methods

This retrospective study was conducted on patients who underwent complete retrorectal tumour resection between May 2006 and July 2018, and had confirmed post-operative pathology reports. Demographic and clinical data (including imaging, perioperative, pathological, and prognostic data) were collected and analysed.

Results

Malignant lesions were identified in 15 (9 [60%], female) patients. The median age of the patients was 59 years (range, 34–72 years). Primary malignant tumours were identified in seven patients with solid tumours, in which gastrointestinal stromal tumours accounted for 71.4% (five of seven) and the remainder were chordoma or mucinous adenocarcinoma. Malignant transformation of cysts occurred in another eight patients with heterogeneous tumours, while histopathological features were present in 75% (six of eight) of patients with mucinous adenocarcinoma, and the remainder were squamous-cell carcinoma or neuroendocrine tumour (Grade 2). The malignant characteristics of the solid portions observed using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) were as follows: the cyst wall of the tumour was irregularly thickened; the surface was convex or lobed; the solid tumour had no capsule, or the capsule was destroyed; and the surface had a gyrus-like morphology. At a median follow-up time of 52 months (range, 13–100 months), the overall recurrence-free survival rate was 40.0% and the survival rate was 46.7%.

Conclusion

Some MRI features can be used to distinguish malignant retrorectal tumours from benign retrorectal tumours. The survival rate of patients with malignant retrorectal tumours is poor.

Perianal Tailgut Cyst: An Unusual Presentation

A tailgut cyst (TGC) is a rare congenital lesion that occurs due to failure of involution of the distal hindgut, leading to the development of a mucus-secreting cyst. The clinical presentation is nonspecific, and often the diagnosis can be missed. We present the case of a 20-year-old female with a TGC in the perianal region. Surgical excision of the cyst was performed, followed by an uneventful recovery. The young age of our patient and the anatomical location of the TGC make our case a rare entity, highlighting the need for practicing surgeons to keep TGC as a differential in mind while examining masses in the perianal region.

Risk of malignancy and outcomes of surgically resected presacral tailgut cysts: A current review of the Mayo Clinic experience

AIM

The aim of this study was to describe the surgical management, outcomes and risk of malignancy of presacral tailgut cysts.

METHOD

A retrospective analysis of all patients who underwent resection of tailgut cyst at Mayo Clinic in Arizona, Florida and Minnesota between 2008 and 2020 was performed. Demographics, presentation, evaluation, surgical approach, postoperative complications, pathology and recurrence rates were reviewed.

RESULTS

Seventy-three patients were identified (81% female) with a mean age of 45 years. Thirty-nine patients (53%) were symptomatic, most commonly with pelvic pain (26 patients). Digital rectal examination identified a palpable mass in 68%. Mean tumour size was 6 cm. Resection was primarily performed through a posterior approach (77%, n = 56), followed by a transabdominal approach (18%, n = 13) and a combined approach (5%, n = 4). Six patients underwent a minimally invasive resection (laparoscopic/robotic). Coccygectomy or distal sacrectomy was performed in 41 patients (56%). Complete resection was achieved in 94% of patients. Thirty-day morbidity occurred in 18% and was most commonly wound related; there was no mortality. Malignancy was identified in six patients (8%). For the 30 patients with follow-up greater than 1 year, the median follow-up was 39 months (range 1.0-11.1 years). Local recurrence was identified in three patients and distant metastatic disease in one patient.

CONCLUSION

The rate of malignancy in presacral tailgut cysts based on this current review was 8%. Overall recurrence was 5% at a median of 24 months.

A Case Report of Large Tailgut Cyst Located from the Perirenal to the Perivesical Spaces

Tailgut cysts are known to originate from the remnants of the embryonic hindgut. They occur exclusively in the retrorectal and presacral spaces. There have been limited reports of tailgut cysts occurring in the left perirenal space. The present case features a huge tailgut cyst extending from the right perirenal to the perivesical space. We believe that this case report will help to further elucidate the characteristics of perirenal and perivesical tailgut cysts.

Epidemiology, diagnostic approach and therapeutic management of tailgut cysts: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Tailgut cysts (TGCs) are benign congenital abnormalities that usually present with non-specific symptoms, constituting a diagnostic dilemma for physicians. The aim of this study was to systematically review the literature concerning clinical manifestations, diagnostic modalities and histologic findings of TGCs and highlight current knowledge on therapeutic management of this rare entity.

METHODS

PubMed and Embase databases were systematically searched by two independent investigators (last search 18 February 2021) for studies concerning TGCs published in the past two decades.

RESULTS

Totally, 144 articles, including 135 case reports and 9 case series, met our inclusion criteria. One hundred eighty-four patients were included (3:1/female:male) with an age of 42.3 ± 18.7 years (mean, SD), while 5 cases concerned new-born infants. Pain was the prevailing clinical manifestation (41.8%), whereas 16.8% were asymptomatic. MRI and CT were utilized for diagnosis in 58.7% and 54.7% of cases, respectively. The majority of cysts were multilocular, while ciliated columnar epithelium and smooth muscles of the cyst wall were the prevailed histological findings. Malignant degeneration of TGCs was reported in 32.1% of cases, while carcinoid tumours were the most frequent malignancies. Surgical resection was performed in 155 cases, while laparoscopic and robotic approach was preferred in 18 and 2 cases, respectively. A posterior approach was implemented in 80.9%, anterior technique in 9% and combined technique in 6.7% of cases. Postoperative complications and recurrence of the cystic lesion were reported in 17.4% and 7.6% of cases, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

TGCs constitute a dilemma for the physicians. Surgical resection comprises the ultimate treatment to avoid complications or malignant transformation of the cyst. Concrete follow-up strategies and optimal therapeutic options should be outlined through consensus guidelines and at the time being, such decisions can be made only on the basis of extrapolation and on a case-by-case approach.

Evolution of the management of retrorectal masses: A retrospective cohort study

AIM

Retrorectal masses are abnormalities located anatomically in the retrorectal space. A significant proportion are asymptomatic with no malignant potential while others cause symptoms due to mechanical pressure or malignant infiltration. We reviewed and categorised the retrorectal masses encountered over a 30-year time period in a specialist colorectal hospital and describe our management algorithm for consideration by other multidisciplinary teams (MDT).

METHODS

This was a retrospective analysis of consecutive patients referred between 1984-2019. A detailed review of clinical presentation, imaging features, postoperative histology and impact on morbidity and anorectal function is reported.

RESULTS

A total of 143 patients with median age of 46 years and female preponderance (74%) were reviewed. The commonest presenting symptom was pain (46%) and all malignant cases had symptoms (n = 17). Over the last decade, more asymptomatic patients have presented with a retrorectal mass (33%, p = 0.04) and more patients are opting for surveillance rather than resection (33%, p = 0.013). Increasing age and lesion size were associated with malignancy (p < 0.05). Radiological features associated with malignancy included: solid/heterogeneous component, lobulated borders or locally invasive. Following surgery, complications included chronic pain (40%), poor wound healing (23%) and bowel dysfunction (10%).

CONCLUSIONS

The management of retrorectal masses remains complex. There are features, both clinical and radiological, that can help determine the best management strategy. Management should be in a high-volume tertiary centre and preferably through a complex rectal cancer MDT. Long-term sequelae such as chronic pain must be highlighted to patients. We advocate the establishment of an international registry to further record and characterise these rare, potentially troublesome lesions.

"The Innate Tail": An Unusual Cause of Rectal Bleeding in an Adult Male

Retrorectal cystic hamartomas or tailgut cysts are infrequent congenital lesions presenting as presacral masses originating from the embryonic hindgut. They are commonly diagnosed in middle-aged women. Physicians must have a high index of suspicion to diagnose this rare tumor. We report a case of retrorectal hamartoma in a 70-year-old male presenting as rectal bleeding instead of the usual compressive symptoms. The utility of imaging modalities and the paramount importance of histopathology has been described. The treatment modality is surgical excision to prevent the potential malignant transformation.

[Incidental finding of an intestinally differentiated adenocarcinoma in a tailgut cyst after robotic-assisted resection]

Due to pelvic symptoms, a diagnostic sectional imaging was initiated in a 52-year-old female patient. This revealed a cystic, retrorectal mass, suspected to be a tailgut cyst. Due to the symptoms and the unclear dignity after several frustrating endosonographic punctures, a robotic-assisted resection of the cystic Tumor was performed after careful interdisciplinary consultation.The histological examination confirmed the diagnosis of a tailgut cyst but also revealed parts of an intestinally differentiated adenocarcinoma.Due to the unclear metastatic behaviour, robotic-assisted low anterior resection with total mesorectal excision was performed as oncological resection, similar to rectal carcinomas. No residuals or lymph node metastases were detectable in the histological examination, so that follow- up monitoring was recommended.Retrorectal tumours are an extremely rare entity, worldwide only 28 cases of an intestinally differentiated carcinoma in a tailgut cyst have been described so far. Since there are no clear recommendations in the literature regarding the diagnostic or therapeutic procedure, we would like to discuss a possible algorithm in case of a proven retrorectal mass in our case study.

Retrorectal Mucinous Adenocarcinoma Arising from a Tailgut Cyst: A Case Report

We report the case of a 57-year-old woman who presented with local invasion of the anal canal by mucinous adenocarcinoma, the malignant transformation of a long-term preexisting retrorectal tailgut cyst. This progression is infrequent and justifies preemptive surgical treatment of retrorectal cysts.

Multimodality imaging review of complex pelvic lesions in female pelvis

Complex pelvic lesions can originate from various anatomical structures in the pelvis and pose a diagnostic dilemma due to a wide range of possible diagnoses. Accurate characterisation of these lesions would often require an algorithmic approach, which incorporates clinical findings, sequential use of multiple imaging modalities and a multiparametric approach. This approach usually aims at identifying key imaging features, which aid in anatomical localisation, morphology and tissue characterisation. There have been various attempts to standardise the lexicon used for describing adnexal masses in female patients; stratify their risk of cancer and suggest appropriate next steps in the management pathway. Through this review, we extend this approach to complex pelvic masses in female pelvis in general and will focus on optimal use of different imaging modalities to arrive at definitive diagnosis or meaningful differential diagnosis. We will also discuss potential pitfalls of imaging diagnosis and common mimics.

Retrorectal tumors: Case report and review of literature

BACKGROUND

Retrorectal tumors are rare diseases and they can be challenging to diagnose and to manage. Usually they have a slow growth and they are asymptomatic. When present, symptoms depends on the dimensions of the tumor and their position. Inside the retrorectal space may develope a wide variety of benign and malignant masses.

CASE REPORT

A 70-years-old, obese, female patient was admitted to our hospital referring pelvic and lower-back pain for six months. The retrorectal mass was incidentally detected on imaging, and treated with a modified Kraske procedure.
Pathological examination revealed a rare retrorectal epidermoid cyst. We also reviewed the informations present in the scientific literature about the incidence, diagnosis and treatment options of retrorectal tumors.

CONCLUSIONS

Even though the rarity and heterogeneity of these tumors, we agree with literature that their surgical management is mandatory in order to achieve a definitive diagnosis and to avoid complications including malignant transformation. The surgical approach should be tailored for each patient and according to tumor's features.

Robotic approach to large tailgut cyst with malignant transformation: A case report

Introduction

Tailgut cysts (TGC) are rare congenital retrorectal lesions deriving from vestiges of the hindgut. The risk of malignant transformation is relatively high. Thus early diagnosis and a complete removal of the mass are of paramount importance. We present a case of successful robotic exeresis of a large TGC adenocarcinoma.

Presentation of case

A healthy 35-year-old woman was found to have a retrorectal TGC with suspected malignant transformation. The patient underwent complete robotic resection of the mass and pathology confirmed a TGC adenocarcinoma. The patient’s post-operative course was unremarkable. At 24 months, the patient has not experienced any recurrence nor complained functional disorders.

Discussion

The current case highlights the importance of TGC as a differential diagnosis of presacral masses, underscoring that malignant transformation can occur and may result in mortality and morbidity if radical surgery is not performed.

Diagnosing TGC adenocarcinoma can be challenging because of its relatively low incidence. Biopsy is not recommended while magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is indispensable in the evaluation of this lesion as the presence of intracystic vegetations could indicate a malignant transformation.

Surgery is the mainstay of treatment and minimally invasive techniques have the potential to minimize morbidity and enhance recovery. Amongst these, the robotic approach can make the dissection of large lesions easier, reducing their manipulation and preventing nerve injuries.

Conclusion

Robot-assisted resection of a TGC adenocarcinoma is safe and feasible. This approach can be particularly useful in the pelvis providing acceptable functional and oncological outcomes.

Tailgut cyst with adenocarcinoma transition: A rare case report

RATIONALE

Tailgut cyst (TGC) is a rare congenital disease that originates from residues of the tail intestine during the embryonic period. Most TGCs are benign lesions and the malignant transition is very rare.

PATIENT CONCERNS

A 50-year-old woman attended our department complaining of defecation difficulty for more than 2 months. She reported irregular defecation with a small amount of liquid stool, 3 to 4 times per day.

DIAGNOSIS

Biochemical analysis showed high levels of carcinoembryonic antigen (79.89 ng/mL; normal, 0-3 ng/mL) and carbohydrate antigen 199 (57.60 U/mL; normal, 0-35 U/mL). Abdominal computer tomography and magnetic resonance imaging showed a large cystic mass with enhanced signals. Post-surgical histopathology indicated that the mass was a TGC with adenocarcinoma transition.

INTERVENTIONS

The cyst was completely resected. Symptomatic treatment was further performed, and the patient recovered well.

LESSONS

We reported a rare case of a large TGC with adenocarcinoma transition. CT, MRI, and histopathology are important to diagnose TGC. Complete surgical resection is the first choice to treat TGC.