Thyroid cytology in Pakistan: An institutional audit of the atypia of undetermined significance/follicular lesion of undetermined significance category

The Incidence of Thyroid Cancer in Bethesda III Thyroid Nodules: A Retrospective Analysis at a Single Endocrine Surgery Center

BACKGROUND

Fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is widely used to diagnose and monitor thyroid nodules. The Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology (TBSRTC) is the standard for interpreting FNAC specimens. The risk of malignancy in Bethesda III nodules, also known as Atypia of Undetermined Significance (AUS), varies significantly throughout several studies published worldwide. This retrospective study examines the risk of cancer in thyroid FNAC categorized as Bethesda III as identified in the final histopathology of thyroidectomy specimens at a single endocrine surgery center.

METHODS

This retrospective cohort analysis included 1038 consecutive patients who underwent elective thyroid surgery with complete follow-up data between January 2020 and March 2024. Preoperative data on clinical and pathological characteristics have been collected. The final histopathology report from the thyroidectomy specimen was compared to the results of the preoperative FNAC on nodules that were judged to be Bethesda category III. Statistical methods were performed using SPSS version 29.

RESULTS

A total of 670 ultrasound-guided FNACs (64.5%) performed during the study period were included in the final analysis. The study population was predominantly female, represented by 79.6% of patients with a mean age of 42.5 (SD 12.1), while 20.4% were male and significantly older with mean age of 45.13 years (p = 0.02). The FNAC inadequacy rate was 5.1%, which was associated with a high risk of malignancy (6 out of 34; 17.6%). Out of the total sample size of 170 patients classified as group III, 57 were found to have malignancies in final surgical histopathology, representing 33.5% of the cases within this category. The secondary gender-related outcome analysis showed that female patients classified under the Bethesda II category had a significantly higher risk of malignancy, with a rate of 21.2%, compared to males who had a malignancy rate of 3.4% in the same Bethesda category (p = 0.001, chi-square test). However, the female patients exhibited prognostically superior non-invasive tumors compared to male individuals (p = 0.02, chi-square test).

CONCLUSION

This study's results indicate that Bethesda categories II and III are associated with a higher risk of malignancy in comparison to the reports of the first and third editions of the TBSRTC, particularly for female patients classified under category II.

Thyroid fine-needle aspiration cytology: malignancy rate in the category of indeterminate significant atypia/indeterminate significant follicular lesion

BACKGROUND

Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is a standard preoperative diagnostic modality for thyroid nodules. The Bethesda Thyroid Cytopathology Reporting System (TBSRTC) defines the FNAC atypia group as atypia of undetermined significance/follicular lesion of undetermined significance (AUS/FLUS).

OBJECTIVES

Determine the risk of malignancy after surgical resection in patients with AUS/FLUS.

DESIGN

Retrospective.

SETTING

Pathology department of a tertiary care center.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

All thyroid FNACs between 2015 and 2023 that were diagnosed as AUS/FLUS in Turkey. Patient demographics, preoperative ultrasonographic features, and follow-up data were collected.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Relationship between AUS/FLUS diagnosis and final histopathological diagnosis.

SAMPLE SIZE

562.

RESULTS

In total, 562 thyroid nodules were diagnosed as AUS/FLUS, and 267 (47.5%) were surgically excised. A malignant histopathological diagnosis was given in 28 cases (10.4%). Malignancy risk sensitivity of AUS/FLUS diagnosis was 75.68% (95% CI=58.80-88.23%), specificity was 55.24% (95% CI=50.91-59.52%), positive predictive value was 10.49% (95% CI=8.71-12.58%), and negative predictive value was 97.04% (95% CI=94.86-98.31%). In the ultrasonographic data, having symptomatic nodules, nodule calcification, and irregular nodule borders were all statistically significant signs of cancer in a one-variable analysis (P<.01). The presence of a family history emerged as a statistically significant prognostic marker for malignancy (P=.012). Although not statistically significant, the malignancy rate for nodules with nuclear atypia was 11.9%, significantly higher than the rate of 8.3% for nodules with architectural atypia only (P=0.32).

CONCLUSIONS

The diagnosis of AUS/FLUS has a high rate of predicting the risk of malignancy and should continue to be offered. In addition to cytopathological features, ultrasound data and family history should be taken into consideration when evaluating the case.

LIMITATIONS

Retrospective design and no molecular studies.

Malignancy outcomes and the impact of repeat fine needle aspiration of thyroid nodules with Bethesda category III cytology: A multicenter experience

BACKGROUND

The clinical management of Bethesda III category thyroid nodules has some undefined points and differs among centers and conflicting malignancy rates are present in the literature. The aim of this study was to investigate the Bethesda category III thyroid nodule outcomes in our centers, to determine malignancy rates and also to evaluate clinical and sonographic features which may help to predict malignancy.

METHODS

This retrospective study included 333 patients with thyroid nodules who had Bethesda category III on fine needle aspiration (FNA) in three tertiary medical centers of Turkey.

RESULTS

Among 333 patients, 302 had appropriate follow up. Eighteen patients received thyroidectomy after the first FNA, with a malignancy rate of 38.89% (7/18) and 284 patients received a second FNA. After the second FNA, thyroidectomy was performed in 80 patients and 41 patients needed the third FNA. Thirteen thyroidectomies were performed after the third FNA. Totally 111 patients received thyroidectomy with a malignancy rate of 48.65% (54/111) among patients with surgery and the lower bound was detected as 17.88% (54/302). Of these patients the malignancy rates of patients receiving thyroidectomy with two and three FNAs were 47.50% (38/80) and 69.23% (9/13), respectively. Hypoechogenicity, microcalcification, and irregular margin were found as good predictors for malignancy.

CONCLUSION

We demonstrated that the malignancy rate was 48.65% in patients receiving thyroidectomy. We showed a higher malignancy rate than the traditionally rate of 5%-15%. This study showed that repeat FNAs decrease the rate of unnecessary surgery performed for benign lesions by increasing the rate of malignancy detection.