Evaluation of guidelines for diagnosis and treatment of Helicobacter pylori infection

Quality appraisal of clinical guidelines for Helicobacter pylori infection and systematic analysis of the level of evidence for recommendations

OBJECTIVES

To systematically assess the quality of clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) for Helicobacter pylori (HP) infection and identify gaps that limit their development.

STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING

CPGs for HP infection were systematically collected from PubMed, Embase, the Cochrane Library, the Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, and six online guideline repositories. Three researchers independently used the AGREE Ⅱ tool to evaluate the methodological quality of the eligible CPGs. In addition, the reporting and recommendation qualities were appraised by using the RIGHT and AGREE-REX tools, respectively. The distribution of the level of evidence and strength of recommendation among evidence-based CPGs was determined.

RESULTS

A total of 7,019 records were identified, and 24 CPGs met the eligibility criteria. Of the eligible CPGs, 19 were evidence-based and 5 were consensus-based. The mean overall rating score of AGREE II was 50.7% (SD = 17.2%). Among six domains, the highest mean score was for scope and purpose (74.4%, SD = 17.7%) and the lowest mean score was for applicability (24.3%, SD = 8.9). Only three of 24 CPGs were high-quality. The mean overall score of recommendation quality was 35.5% (SD = 12.2%), and the mean scores in each domain of AGREE-REX and RIGHT were all ≤ 60%, with values and preferences scoring the lowest (16.6%, SD = 11.9%). A total of 505 recommendations were identified. Strong recommendations accounted for 64.1%, and only 34.3% of strong recommendations were based on high-quality evidence.

CONCLUSION

The overall quality of CPGs for HP infection is poor, and CPG developers tend to neglect some domains, resulting in a wide variability in the quality of the CPGs. Additionally, CPGs for HP infection lack sufficient high-quality evidence, and the grading of recommendation strength should be based on the quality of evidence. The CPGs for HP infection have much room for improvement and further researches are required to minimize the evidence gap.

Testing for Helicobacter pylori in an era of antimicrobial resistance

Antimicrobial resistance in Helicobacter pylori has reached alarming levels and is compromising traditional empiric treatment of H. pylori. Antimicrobial susceptibility testing is routinely performed for infectious diseases when there is a risk of resistance and is now recommended to guide therapy for H. pylori. This mini-review overviews the current diagnostics for H. pylori with a focus on tests that enable susceptibility-guided treatment, including molecular tests performed directly on stool and endoscopically collected specimens.

Profile of Helicobacter pylori infections among children in the South Island of New Zealand (2010-2021)

BACKGROUND

Helicobacter pylori is a gram-negative gut bacterium most often acquired during childhood. International guidelines state that children with suspected H. pylori infection should be referred to a gastroenterologist for investigation via gastroscopy and biopsy. Eradication therapy should be prescribed for children with peptic ulcer disease or following a treatment risk/benefit discussion for those with an incidental gastroscopy finding. Guidelines state that for children a "test-and-treat" approach is not warranted, contrasting recommendations for adults. The aim of this study was to profile pediatric H. pylori infections in the South Island of New Zealand (NZ) to determine diagnostic and management strategies, and adherence to international guidelines.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Retrospective data for positive H. pylori tests between 2010 and 2021 were retrieved from hospitals and regional testing laboratories throughout the South Island (NZ) for children ≤18 years. Outcome data were retrieved from tertiary care hospital records; sociodemographic, testing methods, eradication therapy, and symptoms.

RESULTS

Two-hundred and forty children were identified: 105 (44%) male, mean age 13.2 years (SD 4.3). Participants of Pasifika, Asian, and Middle Eastern/Latin American/African heritage were overrepresented compared to the NZ census data. Overall, 138 (58%) children were diagnosed via stool antigen tests, 78 (32%) serum, and only 24 (10%) adhered to international guidelines in being confirmed via gastroscopy. Only 59 (25%) had a record of eradication therapy, and 39/59 (66%) were retested to determine eradication success, with 32 (82%) negative tests and seven (18%) remaining positive. Of the 181 (75%) that had eradication status unknown, 66 (28%) had a retest result available with 48 (73%) testing negative and 18 (27%) positive, suggesting a substantial proportion had received eradication therapy without adhering to international guidelines.

CONCLUSIONS

International guidelines were not adhered to for most children in the study cohort. Implications of this include cost, unnecessary venipuncture, and unjustified antibiotic exposure.

Helicobacter pylori infection in Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region: Prevalence and analysis of related factors

BACKGROUND

14C urea breath test (14C UBT) and immunohistochemical staining (IHC) are widely used for detection Helicobacter pylori (H. pylori) infection with different sensitivity, and there is a difference in H. pylori infection rate in Uyghur and Han ethnic groups. Both need large cohort studies to evaluate the differences more accurately.

AIM

To analyze the difference between 14C UBT and IHC for H. pylori detection in Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region and the difference between Uyghur and Han populations.

METHODS

There were 3944 cases of H. pylori infection detected by both IHC and 14C UBT at the same time (interval < 1 wk, with sampling site including gastric antrum, selected from 5747 patients). We compared the sensitivity of 14C UBT and IHC. We also compared 555 pairs of Han/Uyghur cases (completely matched for gender and age) for their H. pylori infection rates. The overall H. pylori infection rate of all 5747 cases and the correlation with other clinicopathological data were also further analyzed. SPSS V23.0 software was used for statistical analysis.

RESULTS

The sensitivity was 94.9% for 14C UBT and 65.1% for IHC, which was a significant difference (n = 3944, P < 0.001). However, among those cases negative for H. pylori by 14C UBT (detection value ≤ 100), 4.8% were positive by IHC. Combining both methods, the overall H. pylori infection rate was 48.6% (n = 5747), and differences in gender, age group, ethnicity and region of residence significantly affected the H. pylori positive rates. According to age group (Han/Uyghur), the positive rates were ≤ 30 years (62.2%/100.0%), 31-40 years (45.2%/85.7%), 41-50 years (47.2%/79.2%), 51-60 years (44.6%/76.1%), 61-70 years (40.9%/68.2%), 71-80 years (41.7%/54.1%) and ≥ 81 years (42.9%/NA). The H. pylori infection rates of Han/Uyghur paired cases were 41.4% and 73.3%, which was a significant difference (P < 0.001) (555 pairs). H. pylori positivity was significantly related to moderate-severe grade 2-3 chronic/active gastritis and intestinal metaplasia (all P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The sensitivity of 14C UBT was significantly higher, but combined application can still increase the accuracy. The prevention H. pylori should be emphasized for Uygur and young people.

YouTube as a source of information on Helicobacter pylori: Content and quality analysis

BACKGROUND

Helicobacter pylori infection is the most common cause of infectious diseases worldwide, and management is a current and vital problem for physicians and patients. One of the online platforms that people use most to access health information is YouTube. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the quality and reliability of H. pylori information videos on YouTube.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The "Helicobacter pylori" keyword was searched with default filters on YouTube. Two hundred videos were evaluated. The source of videos was categorized as academic institutions, professional organizations, physicians, healthcare professionals other than physicians, health information websites, and independent users. The target audience of the videos was classified as patients and healthcare professionals. The Global Quality Scale (GQS), JAMA, and modified DISCERN video scores were obtained by taking the average of the scores given by the two authors.

RESULTS

Seventy-four videos were analyzed, and the median duration was 9.25 (range: 1.14-121) min. The target audience of 43 (58.1%) videos was healthcare professionals, and 31 (41.9%) videos were for patients. There was no correlation between likes, dislikes, views, and the quality-usefulness of the videos. Video characteristics such as duration, likes, number of views, and time since video upload day were not associated with the source. The JAMA and DISCERN scores were significantly higher in academic institutions than in other sources. Health information websites had a significantly higher GQS score than other video sources (p = .01). In comparison, there was no significant difference between the target audience (patients and healthcare professionals) in terms of JAMA, modified DISCERN, and GQS scores.

CONCLUSIONS

YouTube has numerous videos for healthcare information nowadays. Although the quality and reliability of YouTube videos on H. pylori are average according to common scoring systems, we recommend videos produced by academic institutions and health information websites to inform patients.