Deep sequencing analysis of serum hepatitis B virus-RNA during nucleot(s)ide analogue therapy

Switching from combination therapy with entecavir hydrate plus tenofovir alafenamide fumarate to tenofovir alafenamide fumarate monotherapy in patients with chronic hepatitis B based on nucleotide sequences of hepatitis B virus pregenome RNA

AIM

Patients with chronic hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection experiencing viral breakthrough (BTH) or partial response (PR) during lamivudine (LAM) or entecavir hydrate (ETV) administration often took ETV plus tenofovir alafenamide fumarate (TAF) due to the emergence of a drug-resistance mutation. However, in patients lacking drug-resistance mutation against TAF, sufficient antiviral effects may be achievable with TAF monotherapy. We assessed the drug-resistance profile through nucleotide sequences of HBV pregenome RNA, and subsequently changed to TAF monotherapy from ETV plus TAF.

METHODS

This prospective study included 25 patients with serum HBV-DNA below 20 IU/mL under ETV plus TAF administration. Pregenome RNA nucleotide sequences of HBV in the sera were analyzed using direct sequencing and deep sequencing. ETV was discontinued in patients without rtA194T and rtS106C + rtH126Y + rtD134E + rtL269I quadruple mutations in direct sequencing.

RESULTS

LAM-PR, LAM-BTH, ETV-PR, and ETV-BTH were observed in 1, 16, 7, and 1 patient(s), respectively. Pregenome RNA nucleotide sequences were analyzable in 20 patients. Among the 12 patients classified as LAM-BTH, six patients showed rtL180M + rtM204V/I in direct sequencing, and one patient showed minor clones containing rtL180M + rtM204V + A194T in deep sequencing at a frequency of 0.3%. In the six patients classified as ETV-PR, one patient harbored rtM204I. No clones showing rtS106C + rtH126Y + rtD134E + rtL269I quadruple mutation were detected in deep sequencing. Subsequently, ETV was discontinued, and serum HBV-DNA remained undetectable up to 48 weeks in all patients.

CONCLUSION

Patients receiving ETV plus TAF due to partial response or BTH during initial LAM or ETV administration were able to safely transition to TAF monotherapy based on nucleotide sequences of HBV pregenome RNA in the sera.

Hepatitis B virus serum RNA transcript isoform composition and proportion in chronic hepatitis B patients by nanopore long-read sequencing

Introduction

Serum hepatitis B virus (HBV) RNA is a promising new biomarker to manage and predict clinical outcomes of chronic hepatitis B (CHB) infection. However, the HBV serum transcriptome within encapsidated particles, which is the biomarker analyte measured in serum, remains poorly characterized. This study aimed to evaluate serum HBV RNA transcript composition and proportionality by PCR-cDNA nanopore sequencing of samples from CHB patients having varied HBV genotype (gt, A to F) and HBeAg status.

Methods

Longitudinal specimens from 3 individuals during and following pregnancy (approximately 7 months between time points) were also investigated. HBV RNA extracted from 16 serum samples obtained from 13 patients (73.3% female, 84.6% Asian) was sequenced and serum HBV RNA isoform detection and quantification were performed using three bioinformatic workflows; FLAIR, RATTLE, and a GraphMap-based workflow within the Galaxy application. A spike-in RNA variant (SIRV) control mix was used to assess run quality and coverage. The proportionality of transcript isoforms was based on total HBV reads determined by each workflow.

Results

All chosen isoform detection workflows showed high agreement in transcript proportionality and composition for most samples. HBV pregenomic RNA (pgRNA) was the most frequently observed transcript isoform (93.8% of patient samples), while other detected transcripts included pgRNA spliced variants, 3' truncated variants and HBx mRNA, depending on the isoform detection method. Spliced variants of pgRNA were primarily observed in HBV gtB, C, E, or F-infected patients, with the Sp1 spliced variant detected most frequently. Twelve other pgRNA spliced variant transcripts were identified, including 3 previously unidentified transcripts, although spliced isoform identification was very dependent on the workflow used to analyze sequence data. Longitudinal sampling among pregnant and post-partum antiviral-treated individuals showed increasing proportions of 3' truncated pgRNA variants over time.

Conclusions

This study demonstrated long-read sequencing as a promising tool for the characterization of the serum HBV transcriptome. However, further studies are needed to better understand how serum HBV RNA isoform type and proportion are linked to CHB disease progression and antiviral treatment response.

A critique and systematic review of the clinical utility of hepatitis B core-related antigen

BACKGROUND & AIMS

Hepatitis B core-related antigen (HBcrAg) is a new biomarker for chronic hepatitis B (CHB) whose performance has not been critically or systematically appraised. Herein, we performed a systematic review to determine its clinical utility.

METHODS

We evaluated the biological pathway of HBcrAg and performed a systematic review of PubMed for clinical trials, cohort studies, and case-control studies that evaluated the clinical utility of HBcrAg. The effectiveness of HBcrAg in predicting HBV-specific clinical events (e.g. HBeAg seroconversion, phases of CHB, HBsAg loss, treatment response, and relapse after stopping therapy) was examined using receiver-operating characteristic curves. The correlation coefficients of HBcrAg with HBV DNA, quantitative HBsAg (qHBsAg), HBV RNA, and cccDNA were summarised from published studies. Median values were used as estimates.

RESULTS

HBcrAg consists of three precore/core protein products: HBcAg, HBeAg, and a 22 kDa precore protein. HBcrAg assays have been associated with false-positive rates of 9.3% and false-negative rates of between 12-35% for CHB. The new iTACT-HBcrAg is more sensitive but does not reduce the false-positive rate. A PubMed search found 248 papers on HBcrAg, of which 59 were suitable for analysis. The clinical performance of HBcrAg was evaluated using AUROC analyses, with median AUROCs of 0.860 for HBeAg seroconversion, 0.867 for predicting HBeAg(-) hepatitis, 0.645 for HBsAg loss, 0.757 for treatment response, and 0.688 for relapse after stopping therapy. The median correlation coefficient (r) was 0.630 with HBV DNA, 0.414 with qHBsAg, 0.619 with HBV RNA and 0.550 with cccDNA. Correlation decreased during antiviral therapy, but combined biomarkers improved performance.

CONCLUSIONS

HBcrAg has a mixed performance and has a poor correlation with HBsAg loss and antiviral therapy, hence HBcrAg results should be interpreted with caution.

IMPACT AND IMPLICATIONS

Hepatitis B core-related antigen (HBcrAg) has been used to assess management of patients with chronic hepatitis B (CHB) without a systematic and critical Sreview of its performance. Our finding that HBcrAg had a false-positive rate of 9% and a false-negative rate of 12-35% raises concerns, although larger studies are needed for validation. A systematic review showed that the performance of HBcrAg was variable depending on the CHB endpoint; it was excellent at predicting HBeAg seroconversion and HBeAg-negative chronic hepatitis (vs. chronic infection), which should be its main use, but it was poor for relapse after stopping antiviral therapy and for HBsAg loss. HBcrAg results should be interpreted with considerable caution, particularly by physicians, researchers, guideline committees and agencies that approve diagnostic tests.