Reappraisal of hMLH1 promoter methylation and protein expression status in the serrated neoplasia pathway

Loss of expression of MLH1 in non-dysplastic crypts is a harbinger of neoplastic progression in sessile serrated adenomas/polyps

AIMS

Dysplasia in colonic sessile serrated adenomas (SSAs)/sessile serrated polyps often shows loss of MLH1 expression as determined with immunohistochemistry, but the significance of loss of MLH1 expression in non-dysplastic crypts in these polyps is less well studied. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the prevalence of loss of MLH1 expression in non-dysplastic crypts in SSAs, and to evaluate its significance with regard to progression of these polyps.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Four hundred SSAs, including 158 SSAs without dysplasia, 219 SSAs with dysplasia (SSAD), and 23 SSAs with invasive adenocarcinoma (SSAC), were evaluated immunohistochemically for loss of MLH1 expression in both non-dysplastic and dysplastic portions of the polyps. Seventy-one of 400 (18%) SSAs showed loss of MLH1 expression in non-dysplastic crypts. The prevalence of MLH1-deficient non-dysplastic crypts was higher in polyps with dysplasia or carcinoma (7%, 22%, and 52% in SSAs, SSADs, and SSACs, respectively; P < 0.0001). When SSAs with MLH1-deficient dysplasia and those with MLH-1-proficient dysplasia were compared, those with MLH1-deficient dysplasia were more likely to have MLH1-deficient non-dysplastic crypts (66% versus 8.1%, P < 0.0001) and a greater number of discrete foci (3.6 foci versus 1.1 foci, P = 0.008). Also, non-dysplastic crypts with loss of MLH1 expression were more likely to be contiguous with the dysplasia when the dysplasia also showed loss of MLH1 expression (26% versus 0%, P = 0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that loss of MLH1 expression in non-dysplastic crypts in SSAs precedes the development of MLH1-deficient dysplasia and adenocarcinoma, and may be a biomarker of an advanced serrated polyp even in the absence of dysplasia.

DNA methylation changes that precede onset of dysplasia in advanced sessile serrated adenomas

Background

Sessile serrated adenomas (SSAs) are common polyps which give rise to 20–30% of colorectal cancer (CRC). SSAs display clinicopathologic features which present challenges in surveillance, including overrepresentation in young patients, proclivity for the proximal colon and rarity of histologic dysplasia (referred to then as SSAs with dysplasia, SSADs). Once dysplasia develops, there is rapid progression to CRC, even at a small size. There is therefore a clinical need to separate the “advanced” SSAs at high risk of progression to SSAD and cancer from ordinary SSAs. Since SSAs are known to accumulate methylation over time prior to the development of dysplasia, SSAD backgrounds (the remnant SSA present within an SSAD) likely harbour additional methylation events compared with ordinary SSAs. We therefore performed MethyLight and comprehensive methylation array (Illumina MethylationEPIC) on 40 SSAD backgrounds and 40 matched ordinary SSAs, and compared the methylation results with CRC methylation, CRC expression and immunohistochemical data.

Results

SSAD backgrounds demonstrated significant hypermethylation of CpG islands compared with ordinary SSAs, and the proportion of hypermethylated probes decreased progressively in the shore, shelf and open sea regions. Hypomethylation occurred in concert with hypermethylation, which showed a reverse pattern, increasing progressively away from the island regions. These methylation changes were also identified in BRAF-mutant hypermethylated CRCs. When compared with CRC expression data, SV2B, MLH1/EPM2AIP1, C16orf62, RCOR3, BAIAP3, OGDHL, HDHD3 and ATP1B2 demonstrated both promoter hypermethylation and decreased expression. Although SSAD backgrounds were histologically indistinguishable from ordinary SSAs, MLH1 methylation was detectable via MethyLight in 62.9% of SSAD backgrounds, and focal immunohistochemical MLH1 loss was seen in 52.5% of SSAD backgrounds.

Conclusions

Significant hyper- and hypomethylation events occur during SSA progression well before the development of histologically identifiable changes. Methylation is a heterogeneous process within individual SSAs, as typified by MLH1, where both MLH1 methylation and focal immunohistochemical MLH1 loss can be seen in the absence of dysplasia. This heterogeneity is likely a generalised phenomenon and should be taken into account in future methylation-based studies and the development of clinical methylation panels.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s13148-019-0691-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Solitary rectal ulcer syndrome complicating sessile serrated adenoma/polyps: A case report and review of literature

Solitary rectal ulcer syndrome (SRUS) is a rare benign condition, which can mimic many other diseases because of their similarities in clinical, endoscopic and histological features. Sessile serrated adenoma/polyp (SSA/p) is a premalignant lesion in the colon and rectum. The misdiagnosis of SSA/p in SRUS patients has been noted, but the case of SRUS arising secondarily to SSA/p has been rarely reported. We herein report the case of a 59-year-old man who presented with an ulcerative nodular lesion in the rectum, accompanied by the symptoms of blood and mucus in the feces, diarrhea and constipation. Magnetic resonance imagining revealed thickening of the rectal mucosa-submucosa. Histologically, the lesion was characterized by the hyperplastic lamina propria and diffusely serrated crypts. Further immunohistochemical staining showed the loss of HES1 and MLH1 expression in the epithelial cells in the serrated area. The patient with SRUS had histological changes of SSA/p, suggesting a potential of tumor transformation in certain cases. SRUS uncommonly accompanied by serrated lesions should at least be considered by pathologists and clinicians.

WNT Pathway Gene Mutations Are Associated With the Presence of Dysplasia in Colorectal Sessile Serrated Adenoma/Polyps

Sessile serrated adenoma/polyps (SSA/Ps) are believed to be the major precursor of serrated pathway-derived colorectal carcinomas. To better characterize the process of progression from SSA/Ps to carcinomas, we analyzed 46 SSA/Ps with dysplasia and 45 SSA/Ps without dysplasia using targeted next-generation sequencing and immunohistochemistry. Among the WNT pathway genes analyzed, protein-truncating mutations of RNF43, APC, and ZNRF3 were identified in 23 (50%), 4 (9%), and 3 (7%) SSA/Ps with dysplasia, respectively. In contrast, SSA/Ps without dysplasia rarely had WNT pathway gene mutations, except for 3 lesions with RNF43 mutations (7%). None of the SSA/Ps had CTNNB1 mutations or RSPO fusions. Thus, WNT pathway gene mutations were more common in SSA/Ps with dysplasia than in SSA/Ps without dysplasia (P=3.0×10). Consistently, nuclear β-catenin accumulation and MYC overexpression, indicative of active WNT signaling, were present in most of the SSA/Ps with dysplasia, but were rare in those without dysplasia. BRAF (86%) or KRAS mutations (7%) were identified in the majority of SSA/Ps, regardless of the presence or absence of dysplasia. MLH1 expression was lost in 14 SSA/Ps with dysplasia (30%). The majority of MLH1-deficient SSA/Ps with dysplasia had RNF43 mutations (86%), most of which were frameshift mutations involving mononucleotide repeats. In contrast, MLH1-retained lesions had less frequent RNF43 mutations with no hot spots (34%), and 4 had APC mutations (13%). These results suggest that WNT pathway gene mutations are involved in the development of dysplasia in SSA/Ps and that MLH1-deficient and MLH1-retained SSA/Ps with dysplasia exhibit distinct mutation profiles of WNT pathway genes.

Molecular characteristics of colorectal serrated polyps and hyperplastic polyps: A STROBE compliant article

The serrated neoplasia pathway of colorectal carcinogenesis is characterized by BRAF mutation and aberrant DNA methylation, which have not been reported on Korean patients. The aim of this study was to investigate BRAF mutation and DNA methylation in colorectal serrated polyps and the right colon.Between 2005 and 2013, 146 colon polyps (47 tubular adenomas [TAs], 53 traditional serrated adenomas [TSAs], 17 sessile serrated adenomas/polyps [SSAs], and 29 hyperplastic polyps in the proximal colon [PHPs]) were collected from patients. Paraffin-embedded colon polyp tissue was used for DNA extraction. BRAF V600E mutation was identified through polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and pyrosequencing assay. The methylation status of the long interspersed nucleotide element-1, insulin-like growth factor binding protein 7 (IGFBP7), mutL homolog 1 (hMLH1), and CD133 genes were evaluated through disulfite conversion, PCR, and pyrosequencing assay.BRAF V600E mutation was found in 2.1% of TAs, 47.2% of TSAs, 41.2% of SSAs, and 20.7% of PHPs. TSA and SSA had higher BRAF mutation rates than did TA (P < 0.0001). TSA had higher BRAF mutation rates than did PHP (P = 0.018). IGFBP7 hypermethylation was found in 17% of TAs, 37.7% of TSAs, 88.2% of SSAs, and 37.5% of PHPs. TSA and SSA had higher hypermethylation of IGFBP7 than did TA (P = 0.021 and P < 0.0001, respectively). SSA had higher hypermethylation of IGFBP7 than did PHP (P = 0.002). hMLH1 hypermethylation was found in 2.1% of TAs, 5.7% of TSAs, 0% of SSAs, and 0% of PHPs. CD133 hypermethylation was found in 21.3% of TAs, 9.4% of TSAs, 35.3% of SSAs, and 17.4% of PHPs.BRAF mutation and methylation in TSA and SSA are different from those in PHP in Koreans. These findings suggested that PHP may have different molecular characteristics compared with other serrated polyps.

Comprehensive DNA Methylation and Mutation Analyses Reveal a Methylation Signature in Colorectal Sessile Serrated Adenomas

Colorectal sessile serrated adenomas (SSA) are hypothesized to be precursor lesions of an alternative, serrated pathway of colorectal cancer, abundant in genes with aberrant promoter DNA hypermethylation. In our present pilot study, we explored DNA methylation profiles and examined selected gene mutations in SSA. Biopsy samples from patients undergoing screening colonoscopy were obtained during endoscopic examination. After DNA isolation and quality analysis, SSAs (n = 4) and healthy controls (n = 5) were chosen for further analysis. DNA methylation status of 96 candidate genes was screened by q(RT)PCR using Methyl-Profiler PCR array system. Amplicons for 12 gene mutations were sequenced by GS Junior Instrument using ligated and barcoded adaptors. Analysis of DNA methylation revealed 9 hypermethylated genes in both normal and SSA samples. 12 genes (CALCA, DKK2, GALR2, OPCML, PCDH10, SFRP1, SFRP2, SLIT3, SST, TAC1, VIM, WIF1) were hypermethylated in all SSAs and 2 additional genes (BNC1 and PDLIM4) were hypermethylated in 3 out of 4 SSAs, but in none of the normal samples. 2 SSAs exhibited BRAF mutation and synchronous MLH1 hypermethylation and were microsatellite instable by immunohistochemical analysis. Our combined mutation and DNA methylation analysis revealed that there is a common DNA methylation signature present in pre-neoplastic SSAs. This study advocates for the use of DNA methylation as a potential biomarker for the detection of SSA; however, further investigation is needed to better characterize the molecular background of these newly recognized colorectal lesions.