Quality of life assessment in haemophilia

What have we learned about the patient's experience of von Willebrand disease? A focus on women

Von Willebrand disease (VWD), the most common inherited bleeding disorder (IBD), disproportionately affects females, given the hemostatic challenges they may encounter throughout their lifetimes. Despite this, research about VWD remains grossly underrepresented, particularly compared to hemophilia, which is historically diagnosed in males. Structural sexism, stigmatization of menstrual bleeding, delayed diagnosis, and a lack of timely access to care result in an increased frequency of bleeding events, iron deficiency, iron deficiency anemia, and a decreased quality of life. However, we are only beginning to recognize and acknowledge the magnitude of the burden of this disease. With an increasing number of studies documenting the experiences of women with IBDs and recent international guidelines suggesting changes to optimal management, a paradigm shift in recognition and treatment is taking place. Here, we present a fictional patient case to illustrate one woman's history of bleeding. We review the evidence describing the impact of VWD on quality of life, normalization of vaginal bleeding, diagnostic delays, and the importance of access to multidisciplinary care. Furthermore, we discuss considerations around reproductive decision-making and the intergenerational nature of bleeding, which often renders patients as caregivers. Through incorporating the patient perspective, we argue for an equitable and compassionate path to overcome decades of silence, misrecognition, and dismissal. This path moves toward destigmatization, open dialogue, and timely access to specialized care.

Outcomes for studies assessing the efficacy of hemostatic therapies in persons with congenital bleeding disorders

INTRODUCTION

Management strategies and hemostatic treatments to achieve control of bleeding are relevant across many disease areas. Identification of primary outcomes for studies assessing hemostatic intervention was the objective of a National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute (NHLBI) sponsored multidisciplinary initiative. The aim of this report is to summarize the evidence reviewed, and the outcomes identified by the subgroup tasked to assess outcomes for inherited bleeding disorders.

METHODS

The subgroup decided to focus on haemophilia, the prototypal congenital bleeding disorder and the one with the largest available body of evidence. MEDLINE, EMBASE and PsycINFO, The Cochrane Review, CINAHL, and Web of Science were searched for systematic and narrative reviews on outcomes used in haemophilia clinical trials. Three different clinical goals were identified as typical objectives of future research.

RESULTS

Out of 1322 unique citations, 24 reviews published in the period 2002-2019 were included. We identified 113 outcome measures, categorized in 6 domains: health-related quality of life (HRQoL), comorbidities and mortality, overall physical functioning and participation, bleeding and hemostasis, joint health, and costs and resource use. Three different clinical goals were identified as typical objectives of future research: Episodic 'on demand' replacement therapy, prevention of bleeding (Prophylaxis), and long-term and overall impact of bleeding. For each of these scenarios, specific outcomes were recommended.

CONCLUSIONS

Primary outcomes for clinical trials assessing the efficacy of hemostatic treatment in achieving control, prevention and limiting long-term consequences of bleeding in inherited bleeding disorders are suggested, and their strength and limitations discussed.

A systematic review on quality of life assessment in adults with cerebral palsy: Challenging issues and a call for research

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Little is known about the quality of life (QoL) of adults with cerebral palsy (CP). This systematic review aimed to examine the extent to which methodological best practices have been applied to achieve valid and informative QoL assessments for this population.

METHODS AND PROCEDURES

Systematic search identified 1097 non-duplicated, quantitative articles assessing self- and/or proxy-reported QoL in samples of adults with CP. Eighteen studies were included and data extraction was conducted for sampling characteristics, selection of informants (self- and proxy-reports), adequacy of administered measures, and examination of age-related specificities.

OUTCOMES AND RESULTS

The results revealed discrepancies between conceptual definitions of QoL and their measurement approaches in CP. Most papers relied on self-reports. Most studies were cross-sectional and often based on relatively small samples; the variable of age was considered inconsistently in statistical analyses.

CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS

Future strategies to improve the validity and applicability of QoL assessments of adults with CP would include: using a clear definition of QoL aligned with the measurement employed; considering proxy-reports whenever appropriate, to encompass larger samples and a wider range of ability; and using age-stratified analyses, in order to deepen understanding of potentially modifiable variables and paths linked to QoL outcomes.

[Inhibitory and mild forms of hemophilia: diagnostic difficulties, surgical complications]

AIM

To identify patients with hemophilia who have a high risk of postoperative hemorrhagic complications.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Prospective trial included 69 patients aged 18-71 years (median 29) with congenital hemophilia A and B. They underwent elective and emergency treatment for abdominal and thoracic pathology at the National Medical Research Center for Hematology in 2011-2016. Patients with mild and inhibitory forms of hemophilia were compared with those with severe and moderate forms of hemophilia. There were 50 (73%) patients with severe and moderate forms of hemophilia, 8 (11%) with inhibitory and 11 (16%) patients with mild form. Emergency operations were performed in 18 cases, elective - in 51.

RESULTS

Inhibitory form of hemophilia is associated with 1.5 times higher (95% CI, 1.1-3.0) risk of hemorrhagic postoperative complications and death and 3,5 times higher (95% CI 1.7-5.9) risk of redo surgery compared with severe and moderate forms (p<0.05). Risk of hemorrhagic postoperative complications is also higher in patients with mild form of hemophilia compared with severe and moderate forms (1/6 vs. 1/50; p=0.05).

CONCLUSION

The risk of postoperative hemorrhagic complications is significantly higher in inhibitory and mild hemophilia compared with severe and moderate forms and associated with hemostatic therapy defects and inadequate assessment of hemostatic disorders. Long-standing haemorrhagic syndrome should be followed by blood clotting system analysis including evaluation of procoagulant activity, presence of inhibitor, and thromboelastography. Decreased levels of albumin (by 2.9-8.6% in our trial) and cholesterol (by 6.5-54.8%) reflects impaired liver function and is sign of unfavorable prognosis. This finding should be considered for surgery and therapy of hemorrhagic manifestations.

Optimization of home treatment in haemophilia: effects of transmural support by a haemophilia nurse on adherence and quality of life

BACKGROUND

Transmural support by a haemophilia nurse may improve treatment and may empower parents and patients.

AIM

To measure the effect of structured home visits by a haemophilia nurse in (parents of) patient on aspects of prophylactic home treatment.

METHODS

A multicentre intervention study in two paediatric haemophilia treatment centres was performed. Primary outcome measures were: adherence to prescribed treatment, health-related quality of life and behavioural scores. Secondary outcome measures were: total clotting factor consumption, self-efficacy and number of joint bleeds.

RESULTS

Over a period of 22 months (median, IQR 21-23), four to seven home visits in 46 patients (mean age 9.4 ± 4.2 years) were made. No difference in adherence to prescribed treatment was seen after the home visits when compared to baseline measurements. Both the Child Health Questionnaire (CHQ) scales on 'Role functioning - Emotional/Behavioural' (P = 0.02, d = 0.53) and 'Parental Time Impact' (P = 0.04, d = 0.33) were reduced after intervention. The disease-specific Haemo-QoL questionnaire showed improvement in domains: 'Family' (P = 0.04, d = -0.14), 'Friends' (P = 0.03, d = -0.29) and 'Perceived support' (P = 0.03, d = -0.37). Significant improvement was observed with regard to domain 'Communication' of the VERITAS-Pro scale (P = 0.03, d = -0.28).

CONCLUSIONS

After a period of transmural care by a haemophilia nurse, significant but small positive effects were demonstrated with regard to communication and increase of perceived support between parents and haemophilia treatment centre. No improvement was observed in other outcome measures.

Severe and moderate haemophilia A and B in US females

Haemophilia A and B are rare X-lined hemorrhagic disorders that typically affect men. Women are usually asymptomatic carriers, but may be symptomatic and, rarely, also express severe (factor VIII (FVIII) or factor IX (FIX) <0.01 U mL(-1)) or moderately severe (FVIII/FIX 0.01-0.05 U mL(-1)) phenotypes. However, data on clinical manifestations, genotype and the psychosocial ramifications of illness in severely affected females remain anecdotal. A national multi-centre retrospective study was conducted to collect a comprehensive data set on affected US girls and women, and to compare clinical observations to previously published information on haemophilic males of comparable severity and mildly affected haemophilic females. Twenty-two severe/moderate haemophilia A/B subjects were characterized with respect to clinical manifestations and disease complications; genetic determinants of phenotypic severity; and health-related quality of life (HR-QoL). Clinical data were compared as previously indicated. Female patients were older than male patients at diagnosis, but similarly experienced joint haemorrhage, disease- and treatment-related complications and access to treatment. Gynaecological and obstetrical bleeding was unexpectedly infrequent. F8 or F9 mutations, accompanied by extremely skewed X-chromosome inactivation pattern (XIP), were primary determinants of severity. HR-QoL was diminished by arthropathy and viral infection. Using systematic case verification of participants in a national surveillance registry, this study elucidated the genetics, clinical phenotype and quality of life issues in female patients with severe/moderate haemophilia. An ongoing international case-controlled study will further evaluate these observations. Novel mechanistic questions are raised about the relationship between XIP and both age and tissue-specific FVIII and FIX expression.

Health-related quality of life in Egyptian children and adolescents with hemophilia A

Quality of life (QoL) in hemophilia is an important area in hemophilia outcome assessment. The Haemo-QoL instrument is a set of questionnaires to measure QoL in those children. The objectives of this study was to assess health-related quality of life (HRQoL) in Egyptian hemophilic children and adolescents using an Arabic version of the Haemo-QoL questionnaire. Sixty patients with severe hemophilia A were recruited from 2 hemophilia treating centers in Egypt. Assessment of quality of life was done using the Haemo-QoL questionnaire. The scores of HRQoL were found to be for all dimensions widely above 50. It was highly significant in the 3 dimensions (physical health-family-treatment) in different age groups, but it was impaired in the dimension of "physical health" for 2 groups, and in the dimension of "family" for the oldest group, whereas the youngest group had highly impaired scores concerning the "treatment." The HRQoL in this study was not affected by the presence of factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors. The QoL in hemophilic patients in Egypt needs strenuous efforts from hemophilia care-integrated teams of pediatric hematologists and psychiatrists in order to properly assess and improve QoL.

Need for Prophylactic Treatment in Adult Haemophilia A Patients

BACKGROUND AND METHODS: A single centre study including 52 German patients aged ≥16 years with severe haemophilia A was performed to compare the amount of clotting factor and outcome between on-demand therapy (26 patients) and continuous prophylaxis (26 patients) over 1 year. RESULTS: Prophylaxis reduced the number of bleeds significantly. Compared to on-demand treatment (20.5 ± 3.0 bleeds/year/patient), under prophylaxis 7.8 ± 1.3 bleeds/year/patient were observed. Joint bleeds were reduced from 12.2 ± 1.5 to 4.7 ± 1.0/year/ patient. In the on-demand group 38% of the patients suffered from more than 2 bleeds/month, whereas in the prophylaxis group no patient was found with more than 2 bleeds/month. Mean annual factor VIII (FVIII) consumption increased from 767 ± 110 IU/kg body weight under on-demand treatment to 2,841 ± 341 IU/kg body weight under continuous prophylaxis, displaying a nearly fourfold increase in FVIII consumption. Furthermore, prophylaxis implies a more than four-fold increase in treatment days which escalated from a mean weekly injection rate of 0.56 ± 0.08 FVIII injections/week when bleeds were treated on demand to 2.52 ± 0.30 FVIII injections/week during prophylaxis. CONCLUSION: Even though the results reflect a benefit also for prophylactically treated patients regarding their bleeding frequency, one has to take into account a substantial increase of the costs for coagulation concentrates when all patients with severe haemophilia A switch to continuous prophylaxis.

Challenges of patient-reported outcome assessment in hemophilia care—a state of the art review

INTRODUCTION

One of the recent advances in assessing outcomes of medical care is the inclusion of the patient perspective. The term patient-reported outcome (PRO) is used to reflect the patient perceptions of disease and its consequences as well as of treatment and health-care provision. The development of PRO measures has advanced rapidly, and implementation in clinical research and practice is now underway. From an evaluation perspective, recommendations for the choice of PRO measures and an appraisal of the potential benefits of PRO data collection within specific health conditions are needed.

METHODS

Hemophilia is a rare and clinically well-defined health condition with established and cost-intensive treatment strategies, in which PRO assessment is increasingly recognized as important. For this reason, measurement of PROs in hemophilia focusing on health-related quality of life (HRQoL) and patient preferences were reviewed to identify appropriate measures, to make recommendations for their choice, and to critically examine their impact in international hemophilia research and practice.

RESULTS

Using literature searches and expert discussion strategies, generic and targeted measures for HRQoL and patient preferences in adults and children with hemophilia were screened, and 20 were reviewed on the basis of their psychometric properties and international availability. Only a few of the 20 measures have been used in clinical settings or research related to persons with hemophilia.

CONCLUSION

Consequently, an increased use of these measures is recommended to understand patient views on disease and treatment and to judge the impact of PROs for improvements in health care.

An attempt to improve the clinical scale for assessment of haemophilic arthropathy in children

Of the methods used to evaluate haemophilic arthropathy, clinical joint score can only detect advanced and not minor changes, which usually occur in younger patients. In addition, the currently used clinical scores are poorly correlated with the MRI and X-rays scales. In an attempt to address these shortcomings, a modification of Stockholm clinical scale was designed in which elements of clinical information were included. This new scale was applied in 165 joints of 40 patients with haemophilia A and B and the results were statistically analyzed for its capacity to detect early joints alterations. Furthermore, the adjusted score was compared with Pettersson's radiological score and Denver's MRI score, which can detect early signs of arthropathy. The adjusted scale (a) revealed the earliest abnormalities of haemophilic arthropathy and its correlation with the Pettersson and Denver scores is better than those of Stockholm's scale, (b) provided prediction of the Denver score and (c) was simple and safe to be performed and it could easily be repeated.

Comparing two measures of quality of life for children with haemophilia: the CHO-KLAT and the Haemo-QoL

Disease-specific measures of quality of life (QoL) for children with haemophilia are now available for use in clinical studies [Haemophilia, 10, 2004, 9-16]. One of these measures, the Canadian Haemophilia Outcomes - Kids' Life Assessment Tool (CHO-KLAT), was developed in Canada with emphasis on the perspectives of children [Pediatr Blood Cancer, 47, 2006, 305-11; Haemophilia, 10, 2004, 34-43]. Another, the Haemo-QoL, was developed in Europe, with emphasis on the perspectives of clinicians [Haemophilia, 8, 2002, 47-54; Haemophilia, 10, 2004, 17-25]. While these two measures are unique and independent, researchers from both studies were collaboratively linked throughout development and testing. This study presents the results of a joint assessment of the two measures with respect to their strengths, limitations and unique contributions. The primary questions addressed were: 1 What is the relationship between the CHO-KLAT and the Haemo-QoL in terms of summary scores and item content? 2 What are the methodological strengths, limitations and unique contributions of each measure? We conducted a retrospective analysis of data from field testing of both measures. The analysis included a comparative assessment of the basic validity, reliability and items used in each measure. Overall, the CHO-KLAT and the Haemo-QoL are promising and valuable measures of QoL for children with haemophilia. Our analyses confirmed the basic psychometric properties of both tools, but identified some discrepancies between them. Additional data will allow for greater understanding of these discrepancies and lend clarity to how the tools should be used in clinical studies (separately or merged). The present recommendation is that the measures be run independently, but preferably concurrently in studies of children with haemophilia.

Health-related quality of life in chronic coagulation disorders

Measurement of health-related quality of life (HR-QoL) is used in patients with haemophilia as a way of assessing the effectiveness of health care, especially as cure is not possible. We report the first such study on patients with chronic coagulation disorders in Australia, using The RAND 36-item Health Survey 1.0 (SF-36), a standardized validated questionnaire combined with a semistructured interview. The mean scores for the eight domains of the SF-36 ranged from 52.5 +/- 42.1 for physical role to 80.0 +/- 20.0 for social functioning. Comparison with normative data obtained from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) demonstrated a reduction in all domains in this population with statistically significant reductions in general health, physical role limitation and vitality. Comparison with other studies indicates that the HR-QoL of patients with haemophilia and von Willebrand's disorder in Australia is comparable with other Western countries, reflecting the overall similar quality of care available to these patients. This study also provides a good cross-sectional view of the psychosocial factors of life in patients in Australia and recognizes the positive family support available to this population, while raising relevant shortcomings in schools and at the workplace that need to be studied further in a controlled manner.

The Haemo-QoL Index: developing a short measure for health-related quality of life assessment in children and adolescents with haemophilia

As quality of life (QoL) research is increasingly focusing on children and adolescents with haemophilia, the need for both age-appropriate and disease-specific assessment tools becomes apparent. Therefore, a set of questionnaires measuring QoL in children and adolescents with haemophilia was simultaneously developed in six languages within the European Haemo-QoL project (Haemophilia, 8, 2002, 47; Haemophilia, 10, 2004, 17). For implementation in larger studies and for use in daily clinical routine, a both short and psychometrically robust version of the questionnaire is needed. Using from the Haemo-QoL field study complete data sets of 306 children and adolescents (4-16 years) and their parents, a multivariate approach of item selection was applied to construct an eight-item instrument, the Haemo-QoL Index. The instrument is applicable to different age groups and represents the core content as well as the multidimensional structure of the original long versions. According to preliminary analyses, the index's psychometric performance concerning reliability and convergent validity is good. Further validation of the instrument's performance on a new and independent sample is needed.

Optimal haemophilia care versus the reality

Haemophilia A and B are inherited bleeding disorders whose diagnosis and management is generally well established and best provided by specialists in a comprehensive care setting. Patients may be put at unnecessary risk if appropriate expertise is not sought for the management of accidents and surgery. The delivery of a high quality comprehensive service to patients with bleeding disorders depends upon defined standards and a network of haemophilia centres in the UK with similar models in other countries. In developing countries, despite a shortage or absence of treatment products, development of local expertise results in an improved outlook and reduction in mortality. Optimal care for severe haemophilia includes accurate diagnosis, early and adequate factor replacement for bleeding episodes and the provision of prophylaxis from an early age to prevent joint bleeding and the consequent arthropathy. Haemophilia treatment is expensive resulting in considerable inequity in provision of care across the world. Despite decades of experience, optimal treatment levels are not robustly defined. Transfusion-transmitted infections continue to have a significant impact on patient management. The development of inhibitory antibodies seriously complicates the management both in morbidity and cost. While gene therapy has not yet produced the hoped-for cure, new technologies will produce improved products.

American Acupuncture and Efficacy: Meanings and Their Points of Insertion

By its very definition, efficacy's meanings remain fluid, their particularities contingent on context. The change seen as significant may occur on a symbolic level or through the removal of physical symptoms. It may address conditions of a social body. Some discussions differentiate between "healing" and "curing." Many of these meanings surface when examining what efficacy means in the practice of acupuncture in the United States. This complex phenomenon is possible largely because acupuncture draws on the qi paradigm on the one hand, allowing for the most ephemeral dimensions of experience to be included in considerations of efficacy. On the other hand, in the most material sense, acupuncture is also susceptible to being conceptualized as a device, independent of that same paradigm, allowing for the insertion of biomedical models and criteria. Pluralism within acupuncture itself intersects with, and even embodies, the medical pluralism of U.S. culture.

Disease-specific quality-of-life measurement tools for haemophilia patients

The purpose of this paper is to summarize the state of the art in measuring quality of life in haemophila populations. The paper reviews the measures recently included in haemophila trials in the published literature. It also summarizes the development of four new disease-specific measures of health-related quality of life. Two of these were developed for children (the Haemo-QoL and the CHO-KLAT), and two for adults (the Hemofilia-QoL and the Hemolatin-QoL). These new measures show promise for use in clinical trials. Further research is in progress to complete the psychometric testing and cross-cultural validation.