Can HLA-DR expression help in the routine diagnosis of malignant melanomas?

HLA-DR expression in melanoma: from misleading therapeutic target to potential immunotherapy biomarker

Since the advent of anti-PD1 immune checkpoint inhibitor (ICI) immunotherapy, cutaneous melanoma has undergone a true revolution with prolonged survival, as available 5-year updates for progression-free survival and overall survival demonstrate a durable clinical benefit for melanoma patients receiving ICI. However, almost half of patients fail to respond to treatment, or relapse sooner or later after the initial response to therapy. Little is known about the reasons for these failures. The identification of biomarkers seems necessary to better understand this resistance. Among these biomarkers, HLA-DR, a component of MHC II and abnormally expressed in certain tumor types including melanoma for unknown reasons, seems to be an interesting marker. The aim of this review, prepared by an interdisciplinary group of experts, is to take stock of the current literature on the potential interest of HLA-DR expression in melanoma as a predictive biomarker of ICI outcome.

Gamma-interferon-inducible lysosomal thiol reductase is upregulated in human melanoma

T-cell-mediated immunity has the ability to produce durable antimelanoma responses, resulting in improved survival of patients with advanced melanoma. Antigen presentation is a key determinant of T-cell responses. Gamma-interferon-inducible lysosomal thiol reductase (GILT) is critical for MHC class II-restricted presentation of multiple melanoma antigens to CD4+ T cells. However, GILT expression in melanoma has not been defined. We evaluated GILT and MHC class II expression in human primary and metastatic melanomas and nevi using immunohistochemical analysis. GILT staining in melanocytes was observed in 70% of primary and 58% of metastatic melanomas versus 0% of nevi. When present, the GILT staining intensity in melanocytes was typically faint. Both GILT and MHC class II expression were increased in melanocytes of primary and metastatic melanomas compared with nevi. GILT staining in antigen-presenting cells (APCs) was detected in 100% of primary and metastatic melanomas versus 31% of nevi, and it was typically intense. GILT expression was increased in APCs of primary and metastatic melanomas compared with nevi, whereas MHC class II had equivalent high expression in APCs of all melanocytic lesions. GILT staining in keratinocytes was detected in 67% of primary melanomas versus 14% of nevi and 6% of metastatic melanomas. GILT, but not MHC class II, expression was increased in keratinocytes of primary melanomas compared with nevi and metastases. GILT expression is anticipated to result in improved presentation of melanoma antigens and more effective antimelanoma T-cell responses. GILT expression may be a biomarker of immune recognition of melanoma.

Class II transactivator (CIITA) isoform expression and activity in melanoma

In contrast with melanocytes, melanomas display constitutive expression of HLA-DR (HLA-DR+). This abnormal expression has been associated with tumour progression and metastatic dissemination. We have previously reported that this deregulation of HLA-D genes is due to the abnormal constitutive expression of the lymphocyte-specific isoform of class II transactivator (B-CIITA), in addition to its fibroblast form (F-CIITA), which is usually expressed in major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II-negative interferon-gamma-induced cell types, such as melanocytes. In this study, we investigated the abnormal expression of B-CIITA in a panel of melanoma cell lines displaying differential HLA-DR expression profiles, and analysed whether such a molecular event can participate in tumour progression. Our results showed that the abnormal expression of B-CIITA did not have any particular effect, in comparison with F-CIITA, on the classical activity of CIITA HLA-D gene regulation. As CIITA has also been shown to regulate genes other than HLA-D, we evaluated the modulation of those encoding cyclin D1, YARS (tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase) and TRIP1 (transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta receptor-interacting protein), proteins involved in cell cycle/apoptosis balance, angiogenesis and resistance to TGF-beta, respectively. In contrast with other cell types, neither B-CIITA nor F-CIITA was able to modulate these genes in melanoma cell lines. Thus, the activity of CIITA, whether lymphocyte-specific or fibroblast-specific, is restricted to HLA-D gene expression in these tumours. Accordingly, our data suggest that CIITA is not involved per se in tumour progression; rather, it is the MHC class II molecules themselves, through tumour antigen presentation and the induction of tumour antigen-specific CD4 lymphocyte anergy, that may participate in immune escape and melanoma progression.

Immunohistologic responses within dermal metastatic melanoma lesions of patients treated with a synthetic peptide vaccine

Three patients with dermal metastatic melanoma lesions responding to a synthetic peptide vaccine (g209-2M) derived from the sequence of gp100 melanoma-associated antigen, along with either IL-2 or granulocyte-monocyte colony-stimulating factor were studied to characterize the immunologic response occurring within and around the lesions during therapy. Standard immunocytochemical techniques were used to study the T-cell response (CD3, CD4, and CD8), the B-cell response (CD20), and the expression of class II major histocompatibility complex (HLA-DR) antigens. Between 40 and 65 days after the initiation of vaccine therapy (more than 3 weeks after the second dose of vaccine), the gross tumor size decreased and the tumors from all three patients showed substantial histologic regression associated with increased numbers of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes and melanophages. The increased lesional tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes consisted of CD3+ T cells and very few CD20+ B cells. In two of the three patients, the T-cell infiltrate occurring during the initial tumor regression consisted predominantly of CD8+ cells. The number of perivascular T cells surrounding small vessels adjacent to melanoma lesions also increased during the time of peak histologic tumor regression. Also during the course of vaccine therapy, the expression of HLA-DR by vascular endothelial cells of the small vessels adjacent to lesions increased in all three patients, and elevated endothelial expression of HLA-DR was maintained in two of the three patients. These results show that patients with metastatic melanoma, who responded to melanoma vaccine therapy, had a predominantly CD8+ T-cell infiltrate associated with a loss of tumor cells. As the tumor cells diminished, they were replaced by heavily pigmented melanophages.

A clinicopathological and immunohistochemical analysis of primary oral mucosal melanoma

Nine cases of primary oral mucosal melanoma in Caucasian patients were reviewed and the tumours analysed for expression of S100, HMB45, NKI/C3, HLA-DR, PCNA, cytokeratin and von Willebrand factor. The clinical, histopathological and immunohistochemical features were quite distinctive and our findings support previous suggestions that oral melanoma should be classified as a separate entity rather than as a sub-type of cutaneous melanoma.

Is poor prognosis really related to HLA-DR expression by malignant melanoma cells?

HLA-DR expression was examined in 50 consecutive primary cutaneous malignant melanomas with a Breslow depth greater than 2 mm using two well-characterized monoclonal antibodies which detect fixation-resistant epitopes. In 31 of these cases (62%) a subpopulation of tumour cells was reactive, although there was considerable heterogeneity. Positive labelling did not correlate with depth but was associated with a reduced likelihood of developing early metastatic disease and a tendency for better overall survival, particularly in male patients. These findings contrast with earlier studies using cryostat sections and one study on paraffin-embedded tissue in which HLA-DR expression was shown to be a poor prognostic factor, but are consistent with the findings in other malignant tumours studied. The significance of HLA-DR expression as a marker of prognosis may depend on the type of tissue preparation, the sensitivity of the immunocytochemical techniques used and the method of assessment.