Stimulatory serum factors in aplastic anaemia. II. Prognostic significance for patients treated with high dose immunosuppression

Thrombopoietin serum levels in patients with aplastic anaemia: correlation with platelet count and persistent elevation in remission

In an attempt to evaluate the role of thrombopoietin (TPO) in the pathobiology of aplastic anaemia (AA), we have examined TPO levels in sera from 54 AA patients and 119 healthy controls. A total of 92 samples were collected from AA patients: 43 samples were harvested at diagnosis, 23 samples in the cytopenic period after treatment, and 26 samples when patients were in partial (n=10) or complete remission (n=16) following immunosuppressive treatment. TPO serum levels were assessed by a sandwich-antibody ELISA that utilized a polyclonal rabbit antiserum for both capture and signal. Serum samples from normal donors revealed a mean TPO level of 95.3 +/- 54.0 pg/ml (standard deviation). Mean TPO levels in AA sera collected at diagnosis and before onset of treatment were 2728 +/- 1074 pg/ml (P<0.001 compared to normal controls: mean platelet count at that time: 27x10(9)/l). TPO serum levels of AA patients in partial or complete remission after immunosuppressive treatment were significantly lower than TPO levels at diagnosis (P<0.001). However, despite normal platelet counts (mean 167x10(9)/l), TPO levels remained significantly elevated in complete remission (mean TPO 1009 +/- 590 pg/ml, P<0.001 compared to normal controls). There was a significant inverse correlation between serum TPO levels and platelet counts in AA patients who were not transfused for at least 2 weeks prior to sample collection (coefficient of correlation (r) = -0.70, P<0.0001). In summary, TPO levels were highly elevated in sera of patients with AA. Thus there is no evidence to suggest an impaired TPO response contributing to thrombocytopenia in AA. Thrombopoietin did not return to normal levels in remission, indicating a persisting haemopoietic defect in remission of AA. We hypothesize that elevated levels of TPO may be required to maintain normal or near normal platelet counts in remission of AA.

Antithymocyte immunoglobulin in severe aplastic anemia and bone marrow transplantation

OBJECTIVE

To review antithymocyte immunoglobulin (ATG) and its current role in the treatment of severe aplastic anemia (SAA), focusing on ATG in immunosuppressive therapy compared with bone marrow transplantation (BMT).

DATA SOURCES

A MEDLINE search (1966 to 1996) of English-language literature and human subjects pertaining to ATG and BMT therapy in SAA was performed. Additional literature was obtained from reference lists of pertinent articles identified through the search.

STUDY SELECTION AND DATA EXTRACTION

All articles were considered for possible inclusion in the review. Pertinent information, as judged by the authors, was selected for discussion.

DATA SYNTHESIS

The hallmark of SAA is pancytopenia and bone marrow hypoplasia. Although the etiology in a majority of cases remains unknown, current data implicate an immune-mediated destruction of stem cells. ATG is a potent immunosuppressive agent and has emerged as an important therapy for patients with SAA. The exact mechanism of immunosuppressive action is not fully understood, although ATG appears to disrupt cell-mediated immune responses resulting in inhibition or altered T-cell function. Numerous trials have evaluated the use of ATG both as monotherapy and in combination with other immunosuppressive agents. Treatment with ATG in SAA has demonstrated a 40-70% response rate. Data suggest that intensive immunosuppressive therapy with ATG in combination with cyclosporine may provide the optimal immunosuppressive treatment. Questions still remain concerning complications and long-term survival of the patients. Although more than a 2-year follow-up shows a decline in mortality, a plateau in the survival curve was not achieved. BMT is a potential treatment for SAA. Although there is a high initial mortality due to treatment-related toxicities, successful marrow engraftment provides a cure for SAA. Many patients (75-90%) experience long-term survival after allogenic BMT. Age, donor availability, and severity of disease limit the number of eligible patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Due to excellent results with BMT, it has become the therapy of choice for selected patients with SAA. For patients who are not eligible for BMT, intensive immunosuppressive therapy with ATG and cyclosporine is recommended. Further study to better understand the pathogenesis of SAA and prevent treatment-related complications is essential to provide the best care to all patients.

Spontaneous cytokine overproduction by peripheral blood mononuclear cells from patients with myelodysplastic syndromes and aplastic anemia

We studied spontaneous cytokine production by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) obtained from 14 patients with aplastic anemia (AA) and 28 various myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS). The levels of interleukin-6, interleukin-1 beta, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha in cultured PBMC were measured by ELISA. The average levels of these cytokines were higher in AA or in refractory anemia (RA) than in RA with excess of blasts (RAEB) or in RAEB in transformation (RAEB-T). Marked cytokine overproduction was observed in RA as well as in AA. High cytokine levels were observed in hypocellularity and low blast cell counts in the bone marrow. These results may suggest that the increase of cytokines may be a reactive response in hypocellular bone marrow.

Serum erythropoietin and serum transferrin receptor levels in aplastic anaemia

Serum erythropoietin (EPO) and soluble transferrin receptor levels were serially measured in 74 patients with aplastic anaemia (AA). As control groups we investigated healthy controls (n = 24) and patients with iron-deficiency (n = 23) or haemolytic anaemia (n = 16). There was a significant negative correlation of log EPO on haematocrit both in AA patients and in the anaemic control group. However, for the same degree of anaemia, log EPO levels in AA were significantly higher than in iron-deficiency or haemolytic anaemia. EPO levels at diagnosis did not correlate with severity of aplastic anaemia, nor did they predict outcome after immunosuppression. During immunosuppressive treatment of AA with anti-thymocyte globulin and cyclosporine A, EPO levels were significantly lower compared with pre-treatment values without a corresponding change in haematocrit. This impaired EPO response to anaemia during immunosuppression might affect recovery of erythropoiesis. In AA patients, EPO levels declined with haemopoietic recovery. However, compared with normal controls, EPO levels in remission patients were still higher with respect to their haematocrit. Results of this study argue against the model of a simple feedback regulation of EPO via hypoxic anaemia. Our data support the hypothesis that cytokines and the erythropoietic progenitor pool are involved in the regulation of EPO production. The results illustrate that serial measurements of EPO along with therapeutic interventions are necessary to identify patients who might benefit from treatment with exogenous recombinant human EPO.

The changes of BPA level in 31 cases of children with aplastic anaemia and its clinical significance

Burst-promoting activity (BPA) was measured in the sera from 31 children with aplastic anaemia (AA). BPA levels were elevated in most of the children with AA (65.2%), the mean value (137.7 +/- 18.4%) being significantly higher than that in normal children (69.6 +/- 9.4%), in children in the recovery period and in children with non-aplastic anaemia. There was a negative relationship between the BPA level in children with AA and the peripheral haemoglobin concentration. The BPA level was higher in those whose duration of illness was shorter than 1 year. In three cases of AA caused by chloramphenicol and benzene hexachloride and one case of congenital pure red cell AA, the BPA level was not elevated. Eleven patients received fetal liver cell suspensions intravenously (FLI). After FLI the BPA level in their sera was significantly reduced. According to these results, it appears that the elevation of BPA level is a special phenomenon of AA. The measurement of BPA in serum is helpful for differentiation between AA and other kinds of anaemia. The elevation of the BPA level in serum is a biological compensation for the haematopoietic disorder, and the measurement of BPA in the serum of patients with AA may be helpful in evaluating the haematopoietic condition.

Effect of antilymphocyte globulin (ALG) on bone marrow T/non-T cells from aplastic anaemia patients and normal controls

The aim of this study was twofold: (a) to test the effect of antilymphocyte globulin (ALG) on bone marrow (BM) T/non-T cells, and (b) to look for a possible differential response of cells from severe aplastic anaemia (SAA) patients and controls. For this purpose bone marrow T/non-T cells from normal individuals (n = 7) or aplastic patients (SAA, n = 13) were kept in liquid culture with or without ALG. Supernatants were then tested for enhancement/suppression on colony forming unit, granulocyte-macrophage (CFU-GM) growth (in the presence of exogenous recombinant granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor (rGM-CSF)), or for their ability to support CFU-GM growth (in the absence of exogenous rGM-CSF). Supernatants from SAA T cells suppressed CFU-GM growth of normal bone marrow cells in 5/12 patients (mean expected growth (EG) 71 +/- 16%), but not after incubation with ALG (mean 110 +/- 29% EG, P = 0.03). No inhibition could be obtained with the supernatants from untreated normal T cells. Significant enhancement was seen with ALG treated versus untreated SAA T cells (142 +/- 28% EG v. 105 +/- 61% EG, P = 0.01) and with ALG treated versus untreated SAA non-T cells (165 +/- 26% EG v. 105 +/- 23% EG, P = 0.01), but not in controls. Supernatants from SAA and control T/non-T cells were capable of promoting colony formation in the absence of rGM-CSF (colony-stimulating activity (CSA) production): 16 +/- 14% for SAA-T cells and 19 +/- 18% EG for non-T cells (100% = 30 ng rGM-CSF/ml). The addition of ALG increased CSA production in T cells to 37 +/- 23% EG (P = 0.04) and in non-T cells to 40 +/- 13% EG (P = 0.04). Similar results could be obtained in controls.

IN CONCLUSION

(a) ALG interacts in vitro with bone marrow T and non-T cells from SAA patients, down-regulating the production of negative lymphokines and enhancing the release of haemopoietins; (b) the latter, but not the former effect, can be shown also with cells from normal controls. The two effects are not mutually exclusive, and are likely to provide maximal benefit in vivo.

Bone marrow histopathology of patients with severe aplastic anaemia before treatment and at follow-up

Pretreatment bone marrow biopsies of 63 patients with severe aplastic anaemia (SAA) who were not transplanted and of whom 55 received ATG, were evaluated according to the amount and character of residual haematopoiesis ('genuine' aplasia/intermediate/hypoplastic myelodysplasia (MD], inflammatory infiltrate (Te Velde & Haak, 1977, grade I/II/III), and number of mast cells (normal or slightly increased/increased). Of 61 evaluable biopsies, 47 were 'genuine' aplastic, 11 intermediate and three hypoplastic MD. Inflammatory infiltrates were graded as III in 36/60 evaluable biopsies, as II in 21 and I in three. A moderate to marked increase of mast cells was seen in 19/61. Of grade III patients, 86% had a less than 90 d interval between diagnosis and administration of ATG, versus 50% of grade I/II patients (P less than 0.01). No other correlations with pretreatment characteristics were found. No significant prognostic value for survival or response to ATG of any of these three criteria has been identified. More patients with grade III inflammation tended to show adequate recovery at 4 and 6 months after ATG. Stem cell damage, not identifiable morphologically, and/or impairment of accessory cells might play a major role in eventual outcome of SAA patients. Thirty-five patients are currently alive, median 3.8 years (up to 12.4) after ATG. Follow-up bone marrow aspirates and biopsies of 32 patients were evaluable and none showed normal haematopoiesis. One patient revealed persistent aplasia. Of the remaining 31, haematopoiesis was decreased in 14 and increased in eight. All had dyserythropoiesis, 28 dysplastic myelopoiesis and in 16/29 with evaluable megakaryocytes, dysmegakaryopoiesis was found. Sixteen patients had normo- to hypercellular bone marrows with two dysplastic cell lines (consistent with myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS) according to the FAB-group). The prognostic impact of the dysplastic abnormalities found in these patients needs longer follow-up. Close observation is indicated in view of the previously recognized, albeit uncommon, evolution of SAA to MDS/acute non-lymphocytic leukaemia.

Haematopoietic and immunologic abnormalities in severe aplastic anaemia patients treated with anti-thymocyte globulin

Thirty-five patients with severe aplastic anaemia (SAA) were extensively evaluated 0.3-12.4 years (median 3.8) after anti-thymocyte globulin (ATG) treatment. All but one were transfusion independent. Most patients revealed a normal Hb level and a granulocyte count over 1.5 x 10(9)/l but were still thrombocytopenic due to decreased platelet production. Lymphocytopenia and/or monocytopenia was found in about 30%. Two patients had a monocytosis. Although there was a great range in degree of recovery at various time intervals after ATG, patients tested more than 4 years after ATG tended to have higher cell counts. Lymphocyte counts correlated with the interval between ATG and evaluation, and with haematopoietic recovery. Qualitative abnormalities were found in all cell lines. Most patients showed a homogeneous macrocytic RBC population, and almost 50% a positive sucrose lysis test; only three patients showed evidence of haemolysis and only two of these showed a positive Ham test. Mean platelet volumes were reduced out of proportion to their number. Platelet function, determined by bleeding time and aggregometry, was impaired in over 30%. The granulocytic series showed a shift to the left in about 30%. Hypersegmentation and pseudo Pelger-Huet anomaly were seen in some patients. Lymphocyte subset distribution in blood and bone marrow was within the normal range but absolute blood levels of CD4 cells in particular were slightly decreased, and tended to increase gradually with time after ATG. IgG and IgA levels were significantly decreased. In only one patient cytogenetic analysis of unstimulated bone marrow cells revealed an abnormal karyotype, but in eight of eight patients an increased sensitivity of lymphocytes to X-rays was found. These data suggest impairment at the level of the very early haematopoietic progenitor cell in all patients up to 10 years after ATG. Since similar findings have been reported in clonal (pre-)malignant disease, SAA, improved after ATG treatment, might be prone to clonal (malignant) evolution.

Pathophysiology of aplastic anaemia

No single pathophysiological phenomenon--neither the intrinsic defect of haemopoiesis nor any of the described immune effects--explains aplastic anaemia. Since the intrinsic defect is compatible with near normal haemopoietic function, as seen in autologous bone marrow reconstitution, it cannot be the cause of severe pancytopenia. On the other hand, immune mechanisms cannot be the primary cause of the disease, otherwise haemopoietic function would recover to complete normality after immunosuppressive therapy. From these observations we deduce that the intrinsic defect, a premalignant haemopoietic disorder, can either be clinically quiescent by virtue of repair mechanisms, or induce auto-reactivity of the immune system against the abnormal haemopoietic tissue, drugs, chemicals and viruses acting as non-specific triggers or amplifiers. In this sense, aplastic anaemia could be interpreted as an attempt to 'self-cure' from a variant type of preleukaemia. This means that the original concept of aplastic anaemia being a hypoplastic variant of leukaemia may be true. The fact that aplastic anaemia can present either as acute severe bone marrow failure, as chronic mild pancytopenia or as a myelodysplasia-like syndrome does not imply that the underlying pathophysiological mechanisms are basically different. Variations of the clinical course and the response to immunosuppressive treatment could be explained by variations in the balance between the primary defect and the secondary immune reaction; the co-involvement of accessory cells in the primary disease; the relative time course of the two components and the efficiency of repair mechanisms. From repeated in vitro studies in a large group of aplastic anaemia patients at various stages of disease this concept can be applied to the majority of cases, including chloramphenicol- and virus-induced aplastic anaemia. In a small proportion of patients with pancytopenia occurring after exposure to certain drugs other than chloramphenicol, aplastic anaemia is rapidly and completely reversible after withdrawal of the drug. These patients probably have truly benign aplastic anaemia and thus differ from the majority of patients who are left with a permanently fragile bone marrow once they have acquired aplastic anaemia.

Immunostimulatory effects of different antilymphocyte globulin preparations: a possible clue to their clinical effect

Antilymphocyte globulin (ALG) and antithymocyte globulin (ATG) have an established role in the treatment of severe aplastic anaemia. The response rate ranges from 40% to 80%. Its mode of action is believed to be complement dependent lysis of immunocompetent cells which inhibit haemopoietic maturation. This might not be the sole mechanism. We have tested four different preparations of ALG/ATG for their mitogenic effect on normal peripheral blood cells and on enriched T-cells in vitro by 3H-thymidine incorporation. We found marked differences between the four preparations. One was strongly mitogenic and able to induce profound release of haemopoietic growth factors. This mitogenic effect could be detected in the serum of patients during ALG treatment. Clinical response rates of this preparation are about 80%. Three other preparations were of lower or no stimulatory effect. Clinical response rates with these preparations vary between 40% and 60%. From our results, we postulate that the beneficial effect of ALG could be partially due to its ability to stimulate release of haemopoietic growth factors. The mitogenicity of different ALG/ATG preparations should be tested as an in vitro parameter of clinical efficacy.

The release of interleukin-2 (IL-2) and colony stimulating activity (CSA) in aplastic anemia patients: opposite behaviour with improvement of bone marrow function

Peripheral blood cells from patients with aplastic anemia were tested for their ability to release interleukin-2 (IL-2) and colony stimulating activity (CSA) before treatment. IL-2 release--as measured in the mouse thymocyte assay--was abnormally high in 18/34, and abnormally low in 10/34 patients. "Low" release was due to simultaneous release of thymocyte inhibitors. In 18 patients who achieved self-sustaining hemopoiesis after high dose immunosuppressive therapy, excess IL-2 release decreased to low levels (p less than 0.001), and the release of inhibitors disappeared. In contrast, the release of CSA by patient cells--which did not correlate with peripheral blood monocyte counts--either remained high or increased to excessively high values in 24/24 patients tested before and after successful immunosuppressive treatment. Patients with stable hemopoietic grafts after bone marrow transplantation for aplastic anemia, did not release excess CSA. It is concluded that IL-2 and CSA play opposite roles in aplastic anemia. High IL-2 release seems associated with disease activity, whereas high CSA-release appears to reflect a repair mechanism.