Using the mouse to model asthma: the cup is half full and then some

Airway Hyperresponsiveness and Inflammation: Causation, Correlation, or No Relation?

Asthma represents a growing problem in the developing world, affecting millions of children and adults. Features of the disease are reversible airflow obstruction, airway hyperresponsiveness and airway inflammation leading to tissue damage and remodeling. Many studies have attempted to address whether inflammation and airway hyperresponsiveness are mechanistically linked. In this study, data are presented from several mouse models that illustrate that a clear link between these features of asthma remains elusive. The impact of altering inflammatory signaling (NF-κB or JNK1) on inflammation and airway hyperresponsiveness was examined. In addition, the effect of antigen sensitization and the route of antigen delivery were investigated. The data herein show that in many cases, inflammation and airway hyperresponsiveness do not directly correlate. In conclusion, the need for mechanistic studies in mouse models is highlighted to address the interplay between these components thought to be critical to asthma pathogenesis.

Animal models of asthma

Studies in animal models form the basis for much of our current understanding of the pathophysiology of asthma, and are central to the preclinical development of drug therapies. No animal model completely recapitulates all features of the human disease, however. Research has focused primarily on ways to generate allergic inflammation by sensitizing and challenging animals with a variety of foreign proteins, leading to an increased understanding of the immunological factors that mediate the inflammatory response and its physiological expression in the form of airways hyperresponsiveness. Animal models of exaggerated airway narrowing are also lending support to the notion that asthma may represent an abnormality of the airway smooth muscle. The mouse is now the species of choice for asthma research involving animals. This presents practical challenges for physiological study because the mouse is so small, but modern imaging methodologies, coupled with the forced oscillation technique for measuring lung mechanics, have allowed the asthma phenotype in mice to be precisely characterized.

Intranasal challenge with increasing ovalbumin doses differently affects airway hyperresponsiveness and inflammatory cell accumulation in mouse model of asthma

OBJECTIVE

To investigate whether challenge with increasing allergen doses could differently affect allergen-induced airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR) and inflammatory cell accumulation in mouse model of asthma, providing an experimental model to investigate their relationship.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

AHR and accumulation of inflammatory cells in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) and into the lungs were compared in ovalbumin-sensitized mice that were challenged intranasally with 2.5, 10, 25 or 100 microg of ovalbumin/mouse.

RESULTS

Both AHR and inflammatory cell accumulation were proportional to the ovalbumin dose used for challenge. However, in group challenged with 10 microg of ovalbumin airway inflammation was present, although allergen-induced AHR was not detected. Additional analysis indicated that neither mucous hyperproduction nor eosinophil degranulation could be correlated to presence of AHR in this model, whereas concentration of interleukin (IL)-13 in BALF was increased only in those groups in which AHR was present.

CONCLUSIONS

Altogether, intranasal challenge of mice with increasing allergen doses could serve as a suitable experimental system for investigation of mechanisms by which airway inflammation leads to allergen-induced AHR. Our initial findings are in line with previous reports that dissociate AHR from amount of eosinophil accumulation and imply the role of IL-13 in this process.