Variation in the microleakage produced by four different techniques in root fillings in a simulated root canal model

Influence of reduced air pressure methods on dye penetration in standardized voids

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to evaluate the influence of the moment when reduced pressure is applied on dye penetration patterns.

STUDY DESIGN

Nine hundred and sixty glass capillary tubes of different inner diameter (0.3 mm and 0.8 mm), divided into 48 groups, were submerged into dye in 3 different positions (horizontally, opening upwards, and opening downwards) under different vacuum conditions (passive, 5 kPa, 35 kPa, 70 kPa reduced pressure). When reduced pressure was applied half of the groups were submerged into dye before and half of the groups after the application of reduced pressure. Linear dye penetration was measured. Univariate analysis was performed with Mann-Whitney U test and Kruskal-Wallis test to select variables to be included in the regression model. A multiple logistic regression analysis with backward elimination was performed to assess the influence of different covariates on linear dye penetration.

RESULTS

The multivariate linear regression showed that the moment of vacuuming had the greatest positive effect on linear dye penetration value (beta = 10.6, P < .0001). Also the level of pressure reduction had a positive effect on the outcome variable (beta = 0.2, P < .0001) while the vertical positioning of the tubes has negatively affected the outcome variable both for the open end upside (beta = -1.01, P = .024) and the open end downside (beta = -1.05, P = .019). Diameter of the tubes (P = .442) and immersion time (P = .727) had no effect on the outcome of linear dye penetration.

CONCLUSIONS

Even minimum air pressure reduction applied before immersion of the specimens allowed the dye to extensively penetrate the voids.

A comparison of four different microleakage tests for assessment of leakage of root canal fillings

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to compare four different microleakage tests (dye leakage, electrochemical test, bacterial test and fluid filtration) for evaluation of the coronal seal of teeth obturated using Thermafil or lateral condensation techniques.

STUDY DESIGN

One hundred forty-four extracted single-rooted teeth were selected and prepared. The specimens were divided into 8 experimental groups. In 4 groups the root canals were filled with Thermafil obturators and in the other 4 groups by the lateral condensation technique. Coronal microleakage was assessed after exposing one group of specimens (n = 15 teeth) from each of the obturation techniques to each of the four microleakage tests.

RESULTS

In the fluid filtration test, lateral condensation showed statistically less leakage than the Thermafil technique (P < .05). Electrochemical and dye leakage test results showed no difference between the two obturation techniques (P < .05). However, in the bacterial leakage test, Thermafil showed less leakage than lateral condensation (P < .05).

CONCLUSION

There is poor correlation between various methods to evaluate hydraulic leakage. The clinical significance of leakage tests in vitro is questionable.

Decoloration of 1% methylene blue solution in contact with dental filling materials

OBJECTIVES

Leakage studies have been performed frequently, since a tight seal provided by various dental fillings has been considered clinically important. The dye penetration experiment using a methylene blue solution as a tracer is one of the most common methods applied in these types of studies. The stability of the colour of methylene blue in contact with six dental filling materials was observed.

METHODS

Silicon rubber tubes and human tooth roots of 10 mm in length and 1.5 mm inner diameter were filled with amalgam, calcium hydroxide, Cavit, Fuji II, mineral trioxide aggregate, or zinc oxide eugenol, 10 tubes or roots for each material. Groups of five tubes or roots filled with the same material were immersed in 0.8 ml 1% methylene blue dye solution. The optical density of the methylene blue solution before immersion and after 24, 48 and 72 h of immersion was measured in a spectrophotometer at 596 nm.

RESULTS

The methylene blue solution was found to be decoloured over time by all the test materials (P < 0.01) except for Fuji II, in both silicone tubes and roots. At 24 h, the optical density value of methylene blue decreased by 73% for the Ca(OH)2/silicone group and 84% for the mineral trioxide aggregate/silicone group.

CONCLUSION

Methylene blue is decoloured by some dental filling materials, which may result in unreliable results for these materials in dye leakage studies.

Microleakage along apical root fillings and cemented posts

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Coronal leakage of endodontically treated teeth has been found to result in a high failure rate.

PURPOSE

This study tested leakage along apical root fillings remaining after post space preparation and cemented posts in root canals.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 120 human roots were used in the study and divided into six groups, 20 roots for each group. By using a modified fluid transport model, leakage (in microL/hr) along ParaPost dowels that were cemented in the coronal 7 mm of root canals with Fuji Duet, Ketac Cem, Panavia EX, or zinc phosphate cements was compared with that along the coronal 7 mm of conventional root canal fillings. Leakage along the apical 4 mm of root filling remaining after post space preparation was compared with that along the 11 mm root filling before post space preparation.

RESULTS

More leakage was recorded along the apical 4 mm of root filling than along the 11 mm of original root filling (p = 0.0325). ParaPost dowels cemented with any test cement did not produce more leakage than the 7 mm coronal root filling (p = 0.2145).

CONCLUSIONS

The apical 4 mm of root canal filling remaining after post space preparation leaks statistically significantly more than the original full-length root canal filling. The leakage created by removal of the coronal part of root canal filling during post space preparation may be compensated by the cemented posts.

The sealing ability of Thermafil obturators assessed by four different microleakage techniques

An in vitro investigation was performed to assess the extent of apical dye leakage in relation to root fillings made by Thermafil obturators and the lateral condensation of gutta-percha in extracted human teeth under conditions of passive dye penetration, centrifugation, a vacuum technique and an increased air pressure technique. One hundred and twenty-eight extracted teeth were selected and prepared. The specimens were allocated into eight closely matched experimental groups. Four groups were obturated with Thermafil obturators and four with the lateral condensation technique. Microleakage was assessed after exposing one group of specimens from each of the obturation techniques to each of the four dye penetration systems using India ink as the leakage detector. The teeth were demineralized and cleared prior to examination and the maximum dye penetration for each specimen was recorded. The statistical analysis on transformed data revealed no significant differences between the four microleakage techniques and no differences between the two obturation techniques.