The effect of recovery conditions on the apparent heat resistance of Bacillus cereus spores

Groundwater promotes emergence of asporogenic mutants of emetic Bacillus cereus

Bacillus cereus is a ubiquitous endospore-forming bacterium, which mainly affects humans as a food-borne pathogen. Bacillus cereus can contaminate groundwater used to irrigate food crops. Here, we examined the ability of the emetic strain B. cereus F4810/72 to survive abiotic conditions encountered in groundwater. Our results showed that vegetative B. cereus cells rapidly evolved in a mixed population composed of endospores and asporogenic variants bearing spo0A mutations. One asporogenic variant, VAR-F48, was isolated and characterized. VAR-F48 can survive in sterilized groundwater over a long period in a vegetative form and has a competitive advantage compared to its parental strain. Proteomics analysis allowed us to quantify changes to cellular and exoproteins after 24 and 72 h incubation in groundwater, for VAR-F48 compared to its parental strain. The results revealed a significant re-routing of the metabolism in the absence of Spo0A. We concluded that VAR-F48 maximizes its energy use to deal with oligotrophy, and the emergence of spo0A-mutated variants may contribute to the persistence of emetic B. cereus in natural oligotrophic environments.

The effect of phosphate on the heat resistance of spores of dairy isolates of Geobacillus stearothermophilus

In this study, we show that phosphate decreases the spore heat resistance by accelerating the rate of loss of cations from spores. Heat resistance of spores of Geobacillus stearothermophilus A1, D1, P3 and ATCC 12980 were determined in distilled water containing varying concentrations (0.1, 1 and 2% w/v) of di‑sodium phosphate. The average decimal reduction times (D value) for strains A1, D1, P3 and ATCC 12980 in distilled water were 5.8, 6.8, 5.7 and 9 min at 110 °C respectively. On the addition of 0.1, 1 and 2% w/v of di‑sodium phosphate, the average D₁₁₀ values of all the strains in distilled water were lowered by 50, 61 and 70% respectively. Addition of 0.05% w/v of Na-EDTA to distilled water resulted in lowering of the average D₁₁₀ value of all the strains by 55%. Heat resistance of spores of A1, D1, P3 and ATCC 12980 was found to be associated with the Dipicolinic Acid (DPA) content whose concentrations were 0.25, 0.30, 0.27 and 1.6 pg per spore respectively. Analysis by atomic absorption spectroscopy revealed that the phosphate present in the heating medium causes excess release of calcium from spores with 2% w/v phosphate being highly effective, thus confirming the chelating effect of phosphate. This study provides insight into the heat resistance and the increased heat sensitivity of spores of G. stearothermophilus A1, D1 and P3 in the presence of phosphate, which can be used in the design of Cleaning in Place (CIP) systems involving phosphate based cleaning agents to combat biofilms and spores in the dairy industry.

Influence of food matrix on outgrowth heterogeneity of heat damaged Bacillus cereus spores

Spoilage of heat treated foods can be caused by the presence of surviving spore-formers. It is virtually impossible to prevent contamination at the primary production level as spores are ubiquitous present in the environment and can contaminate raw products. As a result spore inactivation treatments are widely used by food producing industries to reduce the microbial spore loads. However consumers prefer mildly processed products that have less impact on its quality and this trend steers industry towards milder preservation treatments. Such treatments may result in damaged instead of inactivated spores, and these spores may germinate, repair, and grow out, possibly leading to quality and safety issues. The ability to repair and grow out is influenced by the properties of the food matrix. In the current communication we studied the outgrowth from heat damaged Bacillus cereus ATCC 14579 spores on Anopore membrane, which allowed following outgrowth heterogeneity of individual spores on broccoli and rice-based media as well as standard and mildly acidified (pH 5.5) meat-based BHI. Rice, broccoli and BHI pH 5.5 media resulted in delayed outgrowth from untreated spores, and increased heterogeneity compared to BHI pH 7.4, with the most pronounced effect in rice media. Exposure to wet heat for 1 min at 95 °C caused 2 log inactivation and approximately 95% of the spores in the surviving fraction were damaged resulting in substantial delay in outgrowth based on the time required to reach a maximum microcolony size of 256 cells. The delay was most pronounced for heat-treated spores on broccoli medium followed by spores on rice media (both untreated and treated). Interestingly, the increase in outgrowth heterogeneity of heat treated spores on BHI pH 7.4 was more pronounced than on rice, broccoli and BHI pH 5.5 conceivably reflecting that conditions in BHI pH 7.4 better support spore damage repair. This study compares the effects of three main factors, namely heat treatment, pH of BHI and the effect of food matrix highlighting the impact of different (model) food recovery media on outgrowth efficiency and heterogeneity of non-heat-treated and heat-damaged B. cereus spores.

Modeling the recovery of heat-treated Bacillus licheniformis Ad978 and Bacillus weihenstephanensis KBAB4 spores at suboptimal temperature and pH using growth limits

The apparent heat resistance of spores of Bacillus weihenstephanensis and Bacillus licheniformis was measured and expressed as the time to first decimal reduction (δ value) at a given recovery temperature and pH. Spores of B. weihenstephanensis were produced at 30°C and 12°C, and spores of B. licheniformis were produced at 45°C and 20°C. B. weihenstephanensis spores were then heat treated at 85°C, 90°C, and 95°C, and B. licheniformis spores were heat treated at 95°C, 100°C, and 105°C. Heat-treated spores were grown on nutrient agar at a range of temperatures (4°C to 40°C for B. weihenstephanensis and 15°C to 60°C for B. licheniformis) or a range of pHs (between pH 4.5 and pH 9.5 for both strains). The recovery temperature had a slight effect on the apparent heat resistance, except very near recovery boundaries. In contrast, a decrease in the recovery pH had a progressive impact on apparent heat resistance. A model describing the heat resistance and the ability to recover according to the sporulation temperature, temperature of treatment, and recovery temperature and pH was proposed. This model derived from secondary mathematical models for growth prediction. Previously published cardinal temperature and pH values were used as input parameters. The fitting of the model with apparent heat resistance data obtained for a wide range of spore treatment and recovery conditions was highly satisfactory.

Kinetics of Bacillus cereus spore inactivation in cooked rice by combined pressure-heat treatment

The efficacy of pressure-heat treatment was evaluated for the inactivation of Bacillus cereus spores in cooked rice. The spores of B. cereus ATCC 9818 were inoculated (1.1 × 10(8) CFU/g) in a parboiled rice product (pH 6.0, water activity of 0.95) and inactivated to an undetectable level (<10 CFU/g) by treatment of 600 MPa and process temperatures of 60 to 85 °C or 0.1 MPa and 85 °C. Kinetic inactivation parameters were estimated with linear and nonlinear models. The potential recovery of injured bacteria was also evaluated during storage of the treated product for 4 weeks at 4 and 25 °C. Depending on the process temperature, a 600-MPa treatment inactivated spores by 2.2 to 3.4 log during the 30-s pressure come-up time, and to below the detection limit after 4- to 8-min pressure-holding times. In contrast, a 180-min treatment time was required to inactivate the spores to an undetectable level at 0.1 MPa and 85 °C. The decimal reduction time of spores inactivated by combined pressure-heat treatment ranged from 1.08 to 2.36 min, while it was 34.6 min at 85 °C under atmospheric conditions. The nonlinear Weibull model scale factor increased, and was inversely related to the decimal reduction time, and the shape factor decreased with increasing pressure or temperature. The recovery of injured spores was influenced by the extent of pressure-holding time and process temperature. This study suggests that combined pressure-heat treatment could be used as a viable alternative to inactivate B. cereus spores in cooked rice and extend the shelf life of the product.

Modelling the influence of the incubation temperature upon the estimated heat resistance of heated bacillus spores

AIMS

In this study, the influence of the incubation temperature on the D-values was described according to a simple Bigelow-like model.

METHODS

Model parameters were estimated from different sets of data from the literature and from our own data. For different Bacillus species and heat-treatment conditions, the influence of the recovery temperature was quantified and the optimal recovery temperature was determined.

RESULTS

The impacts of species, bacterial strains belonging to the same species, heat-treatment temperature and composition of recovery media on the model parameters were analysed. The optimum recovery temperatures differ greatly from one species to another; however, no difference appears clearly between strains belonging to the same species. D values were significantly affected by recovery temperature. This influence of recovery temperature was dependent on the species, and affected by the composition of recovery media but not by the heating temperature.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

The developed model could be useful for determining the optimal incubation temperature and quantifying the weight of the recovery temperature influence for safe security control in the canning industry.

A probabilistic modeling approach in thermal inactivation: estimation of postprocess Bacillus cereus spore prevalence and concentration

The survival of spore-forming bacteria is linked to the safety and stability of refrigerated processed foods of extended durability (REPFEDs). A probabilistic modeling approach was used to assess the prevalence and concentration of Bacillus cereus spores surviving heat treatment for a semiliquid chilled food product. This product received heat treatment to inactivate nonproteolytic Clostridium botulinum during manufacture and was designed to be kept at refrigerator temperature postmanufacture. As key inputs for the modeling, the assessment took into consideration the following factors: (i) contamination frequency (prevalence) and level (concentration) of both psychrotrophic and mesophilic strains of B. cereus, (ii) heat resistance of both types (expressed as decimal reduction times at 90 degrees C), and (iii) intrapouch variability of thermal kinetics during heat processing (expressed as the time spent at 90 degrees C). These three inputs were established as statistical distributions using expert opinion, literature data, and specific modeling, respectively. They were analyzed in a probabilistic model in which the outputs, expressed as distributions as well, were the proportion of the contaminated pouches (the likely prevalence) and the number of spores in the contaminated pouches (the likely concentration). The prevalence after thermal processing was estimated to be 11 and 49% for psychrotrophic and mesophilic strains, respectively. In the positive pouches, the bacterial concentration (considering psychrotrophic and mesophilic strains combined) was estimated to be 30 CFU/g (95th percentile). Such a probabilistic approach seems promising to help in (i) optimizing heat processes, (ii) identifying which key factor(s) to control, and (iii) providing information for subsequent assessment of B. cereus resuscitation and growth.

Variation of the spore population of a natural source strain of Bacillus cereus in the presence of inosine

The heat resistance of a wild strain of Bacillus cereus spores isolated from liquid egg was characterized, and the effect of the nutritional germinant inosine on the spore population was then studied, considering different factors such as germination temperature, inosine concentration, and age of spore culture. The heat resistance clearly indicates that these spores can survive mild heat treatments such as those used for cooked refrigerated food of extended durability or liquid egg, posing safety problems for these foods with temperature abuse. The germination study indicates that temperature, spore age, and the interaction between the two were the factors affecting the level of spores remaining after the germination process. No significant differences were found for the three inosine concentrations used in the study (1, 5, and 10 mM). The highest reduction in the spore concentration was reached at 30 degrees C after 120 min, although the reduction in the spore counts at germination temperatures of 4 and 8 degrees C was also considerable.

Improved model based on the Weibull distribution to describe the combined effect of pH and temperature on the heat resistance of Bacillus cereus in carrot juice

The effect of pH and temperature on the thermal inactivation of different strains of Bacillus cereus was modeled. Inactivation tests were carried out in carrot broth, following a full factorial design at four levels for temperature (from 90 to 105 degrees C, depending on the strain) and pH (6.2, 5.8, 5.2, and 4.7). Individual inactivation curves were analyzed by applying the Weibull model function (with percent discrepancy close to 20% for most cases), and the effects of pH and temperature on the scale parameter (designated D(beta)) and the shape parameter (beta) were also studied. Temperature and pH did not have a significant effect on the shape parameter (beta). The effect of temperature on the scale parameter was modeled by the zeta concept. The scale parameter decreased with pH, although the behavior of the strains was not homogeneous. Two global models with a small number of parameters were developed, providing a satisfactory description of the thermal inactivation of B. cereus, with percent discrepancy ranging from 18 to 25%.

Altered ability of Bacillus cereus spores to grow under unfavorable conditions (presence of nisin, low temperature, acidic pH, presence of NaCl) following heat treatment during sporulation

The effect of thermal treatment on the heat resistance of Bacillus cereus spores and their ability to germinate and grow under more or less adverse conditions during sporulation was investigated. Spores produced by sporulating cells subjected to a mild heat treatment (at a temperature 15 degrees C higher than the growth temperature) were more resistant to heat than were spores produced by untreated cells. Spore germination and growth (the lag time, the maximal growth rate, and the occurrence of a decrease in population) may be greatly affected by adverse environmental conditions brought about by the addition of nisin, low temperatures, acidic pHs, and, to a lesser extent, the addition of NaCl. Furthermore, heat treatments applied to sporulating cells or to mature spores induced a modification of the lag time (interaction of both treatments). Therefore, mild heat treatments applied during sporulation may affect the heat resistance of spores and the ability of these spores to germinate under adverse conditions and may thus increase the risk associated with the presence of spores in lightly processed foods.

Empirical model building based on Weibull distribution to describe the joint effect of pH and temperature on the thermal resistance of Bacillus cereus in vegetable substrate

A mathematical model based on Weibull parameters was built to describe the joint effect of temperature and pH on thermal inactivation of Bacillus cereus spores (strain INRA TZ415). The effect of these factors on Weibull model parameters (beta, 1/alpha) was also studied. Heat inactivation tests were carried out in acidified carrot broth as vegetable substrate, following a full factorial design at four levels for temperature (80, 85, 90 and 95 degrees C) and pH (6.2, 5.8, 5.2 and 4.7). The Weibull distribution model provided good individual fits for the different combinations of temperature-pH tested, with discrepancy factors, Df, coming close to 25% for most cases. The temperature and pH did not have a significant effect on the shape parameter (beta), which yielded a mean value of 0.88. The scale parameter (alpha) decreased with pH, and its inverse (1/alpha) followed an Arrhenius-type relationship with temperature. A global model was built, including the dependence of the alpha parameter on temperature and pH, and the model parameters were estimated by using a one-step nonlinear least-squares regression to improve the precision of the estimates. Results indicated that the global model provides a satisfactory description of the thermal inactivation of B. cereus spores, with R2 equal to 0.983.

Nature of the Inactivation Curves of Bacillus Pumilus Spores Heated Using Non‐isothermal and Isothermal Treatments

ABSTRACT: Isothermal and non‐isothermal heat resistance studies were carried out on Bacillus pumilus spores. The non‐isothermal study revealed a non‐linear behavior of the survivor curve, which was revealed as a tail after an isothermal study. Results indicated that the spores obtained by isolating cells from colonies of the tail section were more heat resistant than the original ones (D104°c= 0.15 and 1.9 min for spores from the original population and from the tail, respectively). Application of the Weibull distribution model to analyze the tail produced good results at the 3 temperatures studied. Nevertheless, when the model was applied to curves having both concave downward and concave upward sections a poor result was obtained, with an accuracy factor greater than 1.

Effect of heat activation and inactivation conditions on germination and thermal resistance parameters of Bacillus cereus spores

The effect of isothermal and non-isothermal heat activation on germination and thermoresistance of two strains of Bacillus cereus spores was studied. Results indicated that the germination after isothermal activation was lower than after non-isothermal heating. The activation rate affected the z value, which increased with faster heating rates. For each temperature and inactivation rate, the non-isothermal activation at rate of 2 degrees C/min resulted in larger D values (D90 = 4.70 min) than isothermal activation (D90 = 4.04 min). The two mathematical equations used to analyse non-isothermal data produced similar predicted D and z values, nevertheless the Hayakawa equation modified in this work for non-linear regression analysis, requires less computational effort.