Microspectrophotometric studies of Romanowsky stained blood cells. II. Comparison of the performance of two standardized stains

Improving biological dyes and stains: quality testing versus standardization

This paper discusses the impact of both standardization and quality testing of dyes and stains in biology and medicine. After the brief review of why standardized dyes and strains are not presently available commercially, two types of testing and ways of improving dye quality are described. National or international organizations could be established to define standardization of dyes and stains. Standardization would be specifically defined as a list of physico-chemical parameters such as elaborated in this paper. Commercial batches of comparable quality may be labeled by the supplier as "standard dye," a procedure currently performed by the European Council for Clinical and Laboratory Standardization (ECCLS). Also recommended to improve dye quality is commercial dye testing by independent laboratories with subsequent certification for use. This sort of quality control is currently carried out in the United States by the Biological Stain Commission (BSC). The advantages and disadvantages of both techniques and the use of image analysis for the definition of standards are discussed. A combination of both the BSC testing protocols and the ECCLS standards should be established for extended quality control of biological dyes and stains.

Standardization of biological dyes and stains: pitfalls and possibilities

The present paper gives a review of the actual state of standardization of biological dyes and stains. In a first part general information is given on practical problems encountered by the routine user of dyes with special emphasis on dye contamination. Some theoretical aspects of standardization are discussed. The second part of the paper gives more detailed information on commercial batches of hematoxylin-eosin-, Giemsa- and Papanicolaou-stains and on their standardization. Special problems arising with the application of image analysis techniques are briefly mentioned. User-oriented specifications for the standardization of dyes, stains and staining procedures are given. Fluorescent dyes and dyes used in chromogenic reagents such as the Feulgen-Schiff reaction are not included in this review.

The standard Romanowsky-Giemsa stain in histology

A new and technically simple Romanowsky-Giemsa (RG) stain is proposed as a standardized technique for use in histology. An RG stock solution (pure azure B 7.5 g/l, eosin Y as eosinic acid 1.2 g/l in dimethylsulfoxide) is diluted to form the working solution with HEPES-buffer, pH 6. Staining time is 30-90 min after formol-calcium solution (or 2-4 hr after formaldehyde-organic acid mixtures). The resulting overstained sections are to be differentiated. A tannic acid-acetic acid combination in an isopropanol-water mixture was found to give optimum results within 100 sec. Subsequent dehydration is in isopropanol only. The staining pattern obtained is polychrome. The distribution of colors in detail is influenced by the modes of pre- and posttreatment. Of practical interest is the development of green and greenish blue colors on collagen fibrils which contrast strongly against the pink of sarcoplasm. For this and other reasons, this RG stain version seems suitable to replace the trichrome Gomori-type trichrome stains under appropriate processing conditions.

Standard specimens for stain calibration: application to Romanowsky-Giemsa staining

Standardized specimens with reproducible staining properties were fabricated from extracts of biological objects (bovine liver, nucleoprotamine and defatted muscle). The standard specimens were stained with two formulations of the Romanowsky-Giemsa stain (RG), using the same azure B and eosin Y. One formulation used methanol and Sorensen's buffer and the other DMSO and Hepes buffer as solvents. The standard specimens were stained either in the composite stain or in the individual dyes dissolved in the same solvents and at the same concentration as the composite stain. Solution spectroscopy demonstrated different spectra for the two formulations with some wavelength regions varying by more than an order of magnitude. The RG spectra were also very different from those of the individual dyes dissolved at the RG concentration in the respective solvents. The stained standard specimens were analyzed by microspectrophotometry and were found to have spectra similar to those of cell smears. Furthermore, the standard specimens were shown to be a repeatable substrate for stain uptake. The transmitted light intensity from random fields of the same standardized specimen varied +/- 5%. When specimens were stained at the same time, the specimen-to-specimen variation depended on preparation conditions and the measurement wavelength, but was as good as +/- 5% for some conditions. The quantitative stain performance of both formulations was studied and compared. The standardized specimens provide a tool for the quantitative study of staining processes and specimen preparation procedures and for stain calibration.

Romanowsky dyes and Romanowsky-Giemsa effect. 5. Structural investigations of the purple DNA-AB-EY dye complexes of Romanowsky-Giemsa staining

A reproducible Romanowsky-Giemsa staining (RGS) can be carried out with standardized staining solutions containing the two dyes azure B (AB) and eosin Y (EY). After staining, cell nuclei have a purple coloration generated by DNA-AB-EY complexes. The microspectra of cell nuclei have a sharp and intense absorption band at 18,100 cm-1 (552 nm), the so called Romanowsky band (RB), which is due to the EY chromophore of the dye complexes. Other absorption bands can be assigned to the DNA-bound AB cations. Artificial DNA-AB-EY complexes can be prepared outside the cell by subsequent staining of DNA with AB and EY. In the first step of our staining experiments we prepared thin films of blue DNA-AB complexes on microslides with 1:1 composition: each anionic phosphodiester residue of the nucleic acid was occupied by one AB cation. Microspectrophotometric investigations of the dye preparations demonstrated that, besides monomers and dimers, mainly higher AB aggregates are bound to DNA by electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions. These DNA-AB complexes are insoluble in water. Therefore it was possible to stain the DNA-AB films with aqueous EY solutions and also to prepare insoluble DNA-AB-EY films in the second step of the staining experiments. After the reaction with EY, thin sites within the dye preparations were purple. The microspectra of the purple spots show a strong Romanowsky band at 18,100 cm-1. Using a special technique it was possible to estimate the composition of the purple dye complexes. The ratio of the two dyes was approximately EY:AB approximately 1:3. The EY anions are mainly bound by hydrophobic interaction to the AB framework of the electrical neutral DNA-AB complexes. The EY absorption is red shifted by the interaction of EY with the AB framework of DNA-AB-EY. We suppose that this red shift is caused by a dielectric polarization of the bound EY dianions. The DNA chains in the DNA-AB complexes can mechanically be aligned in a preferred direction k. Highly oriented dye complexes prepared on microslides were birefringent and dichroic. The orientation is maintained during subsequent staining with aqueous EY solutions. In this way we also prepared highly orientated purple DNA-AB-EY complexes on microslides. The light absorption of both types of dye complexes was studied by means of a microspectrophotometer equipped with a polarizer and an analyser. The sites of best orientation within the dye preparations were selected under crossed nicols according to the quality of birefringence.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

[Model investigations on the structure of the purple dye complex of Giemsa staining]

Nuclei of Giemsa stained cells show a purple coloration, which is generated by a complex of DNA, azure B (AB) and eosin Y (EY). The structure of this complex is unknown. Its absorption spectrum shows a sharp and strong band at 18,100 cm-1 (552 nm), the so called Romanowsky band (RB). It is possible to produce the complex outside of the cell, but it is cubersome to handle. Easier to handle is a purple complex composed of chondroitin sulfate (CHS), AB and EY, which also shows a sharp and strong RB at 18,100 cm-1 in the absorption spectrum. This CHS-AB-EY complex is a model for the DNA-AB-EY complex of Giemsa stained cell nuclei. We tried to investigate its structure. In the first step of the staining procedure CHS binds AB cations forming a stable CHS-AB complex. In the case of saturation each anionic SO4- and COO- -binding site of CHS is occupied by one dye cation and the complex has 1:1 composition. It has a strong and broad absorption band with its maximum at ca. 18,000 cm-1 (556 nm). In the second step the CHS-AB complex additionally binds EY dianions forming the purple CHS-AB-EY complex with its RB at 18,100 cm-1. This band can be clearly distinguished from the broad absorption of the bound AB cations. RB is generated by the EY chromophore, whose absorption is shifted to longer wavelength by the interaction with the CHS-AB framework.

Colorimetry for the stain technologist. IV. Analysis of the components of color difference

Total color differences have been calculated for various pairs of stained microscopic substrates. The latter include azure B/eosin stained blood cells and Papanicolaou stained cells from the uterine cervix. Both the CIE L*u*v* and L*a*b* color spaces have been used. Total color differences have been analyzed in terms of lightness, hue and chroma components. Various discrepancies have been noted among these components, especially the chroma difference, for the two spaces. It is concluded that current color-difference formulae are less than perfect, although they can provide much useful information.

A versatile and simple method for staining nervous tissue using Giemsa dye

A method for staining nervous tissue with Giemsa dye is described. The procedure is easy to perform and works well on paraffin, celloidin and frozen sections. The results combine the properties of the Nissl stains with the polychromatism of the Romanowsky dyes. The method also provides good results for counterstaining autoradiographies, or when applied after horseradish or peroxidase-antiperoxidase techniques. In the latter case, Giemsa dye darkens the immunoreactive product in the same manner as osmium tetroxide but avoids the well-known risks of handling this toxic agent.

On the nature of Romanowsky-Giemsa staining and the Romanowsky-Giemsa effect. I. Model experiments on the specificity of azure B-eosin Y stain as compared with other thiazine dye-eosin Y combinations

After incorporation into a polyacrylamide matrix, the biopolymers DNA, RNA, heparin, hyaluronic acid, collagen and the synthetic polymers poly(U) and poly(A, U) were stained with the pure thiazine dyes, Methylene Blue, the Azures and Thionin alone and combined with Eosin Y. Satisfactory spectrophotometric agreement was obtained between the staining reactions of the biopolymers in the artificial matrix and those in their natural surroundings. This was especially true with respect to the specificity of the Azure B-Eosin Y dye-pair, which is based on the generation, on suitable substrates, of a purple colour, the Romanowsky-Giemsa effect (RGE), with an absorbance maximum near 550 nm. In the model experiments, DNA, heparin, hyaluronic acid and collagen were found to be RGE-positive and poly(U), poly(A, U) and RNA RGE-negative. A theory of RGE is proposed which complies with the new and earlier observations: after saturation of available anionic binding sites and aggregate formation by Azure B, electron donor acceptor complexes are formed between Eosin Y and Azure B via hydrogen-bridge formation of the aminosubstituent proton of Azure B and between Eosin Y and the biopolymer surface. Charge-transfer complex formation may also account for the qualitative identity of Azure B-Eosin Y and Azure A-Eosin Y spectra of substrates, which are coloured purple. Quantitatively, Azure A-Eosin Y is less efficient in giving RGE. The generation of RGE is time-dependent. Equilibrium staining is attained after about 120 h. The implications of the results for the biological application of Romanowsky-Giemsa staining are discussed briefly.

Colorimetry for the stain technologist. III. The specification of color difference

This paper illustrates the calculation of color differences, involving luminance as well as chromaticity components. Color differences have been calculated for a large number of stained histological objects. Four different color difference formulae have been used, namely, those associated with the FMC 2, U*V*W*, L*u*v* and L*a*b* systems. Comparison has first been made between various hematological substrates after staining with two different azure B-eosin Y stains. Next, comparison is made for the same substrates after staining with one of the azure B stains and a methylene blue-eosin Y stain. Pairwise comparison is also made of various substrates from the epithelium of the uterine cervix after Papanicolaou staining. Finally, pairwise comparison documents color differences accompanying maturation for the erythroid and myeloid cell lines in azure B-eosin Y stained bone marrow. The limitations of current color difference formulae are discussed.

Colorimetry for the stain technologist. II. The specification of chromaticity difference

This paper describes the calculation of chromaticity difference. The text has been written specifically for the stain technologist and is largely self-contained. The concept of a uniform chromaticity scale (UCS) is described. A UCS is a diagram in which equal perceived differences in chromaticity are represented by equal distances anywhere on the diagram. UCSs are developed by transformations of the CIE 1931 chromaticity diagram, and may be linear (projective) or nonlinear. The effectiveness of the various transformations has been assessed using published data on discrimination of chromaticity. The usefulness of chromaticity difference calculations is illustrated by histological examples, including Romanowsky stained blood cells and Papanicolaou stained cells from the uterine cervix. Six UCSs are used in these examples, two projective and four nonlinear.

Colorimetry for the stain technologist. I. The specification of color

This paper describes color specification for the stain technologist. The principles of color stimulus specification are reviewed in terms of the conventions of the Commission Internationale de l'Eclairage (CIE). The text is largely self-contained and has been written so that it can be understood easily by a reader with no prior knowledge of color science. The paper starts with definitions of color and related psychological, psychophysical and colorimetric terms. X, Y, Z color space is described. It is shown that any color stimulus may be unambiguously defined in terms of a set of three numbers. The CIE 1931 Chromaticity Diagram is described. Worked examples are given for the calculation of tristimulus values and chromaticity coordinates using three different illuminants. The usefulness of color specification is illustrated by a number of examples using Romanowsky stained blood cells or Papanicolaou stained epithelial cells from the uterine cervix.

Studies on Papanicolaou staining. III. Quantitative investigations of orangeophilia and cyanophilia

This paper provides data derived from the visible light absorbance spectra of Papanicolaou stained epithelial cells from the uterine cervix. Twenty-four types of spectra have been considered, namely, those derived from orangeophilic and cyanophilic nuclei and cytoplasms of superficial, intermediate, parabasal and dysplastic cells, and cells of carcinoma in situ and invasive carcinoma. Wavelengths of maximum absorbance and peak absorbances are tabulated. The proportions of bound orange G, eosin Y, aluminum-hematein and light green SF yellowish have been calculated. For the majority of cell types, dyebinding differences between orangeophilic and corresponding cyanophilic substrates were statistically significant. CIE coordinates were calculated from absorbance spectra; again differences between organeophilic and cyanophilic cells were statistically significant in most cases. Although the designation of cells as orangeophilic or cyanophilic is made on the basis of cytoplasmic coloration, the nucleus is also usually orangeophilic or cyanophilic. These nuclear differences are real and not due to the effects of over- and underlying cytoplasm.

Microspectrophotometric studies of Romanowsky stained blood cells. IV. Maturation of myeloid and erythroid cell lines in bone marrow

A quantitative characterization has been made of azure B/eosin stained cells from bone marrow. Two cell lines were followed: the myeloid line (white cell blast, promyelocyte, neutrophilic myelocyte, neutrophilic metamyelocyte, neutrophilic band, neutrophilic segmented) and the erythroid line (rubriblast, prorubricyte, rubricyte, metarubricyte, diffusely basophilic erythrocyte, erythrocyte). A consensus scheme was used to obtain the "true" classification of the cells. Cell types were characterized by three methods: absorbance spectra, dye binding, and chromaticities. Within both cell lines nuclear maturation is accompanied by an overall increase in peak absorbance with little shift in the position of the maximum. Generally, binding of azure B and eosin increases; azure B dimer/monomer ratios show a slight downward trend during maturation. Changes in chromaticities are to bluish purples of increasing saturation. Cytoplasmic changes accompanying maturation are much more striking than nuclear changes, and again the two cell lines show similarities. Generally, there is decreased binding of azure B during maturation. In the erythroid line, the Soret band of hemoglobin becomes increasingly prominent. Chromaticities change from bluish purples to purplish pinks, particularly in the erythroid line.

[Romanowsky dyes and the Romanowsky-Giemsa effect. 3. Microspectrophotometric studies of Romanowsky-Giemsa staining. Spectroscopic evidence of a DNA-azure B-eosin Y complex producing the Romanowsky-Giemsa effect]

The Romanowsky-Giemsa staining (RG staining) has been studied by means of microspectrophotometry using various staining conditions. As cell material we employed in our model experiments mouse fibroblasts, LM cells. They show a distinct Romanowsky-Giemsa staining pattern. The RG staining was performed with the chemical pure dye stuffs azure B and eosin Y. In addition we stained the cells separately with azure B or eosin Y. Staining parameters were pH value, dye concentration, staining time etc. Besides normal LM cells we also studied cells after RNA or DNA digestion. The spectra of the various cell species were measured with a self constructed microspectrophotometer by photon counting technique. The optical ray pass and the diagramm of electronics are briefly discussed. The nucleus of RG stained LM cells, pH congruent to 7, is purple, the cytoplasm blue. After DNA or RNA digestion the purple respectively blue coloration in the nucleus or the cytoplasm completely disappeares. Therefore DNA and RNA are the preferentially stained biological substrates. In the spectrum of RG stained nuclei, pH congruent to 7, three absorption bands are distinguishable: They are A1 (15400 cm-1, 649 nm), A2 (16800 cm-1, 595 nm) the absorption bands of DNA-bound monomers and dimers of azure B and RB (18100 cm-1, 552 nm) the distinct intense Romanowsky band. Our extensive experimental material shows clearly that RB is produced by a complex of DNA, higher polymers of azure B (degree of association p greater than 2) and eosin Y. The complex is primarily held together by electrostatic interaction: inding of polymer azure B cations to the polyanion DNA generates positively charged binding sites in the DNA-azure B complex which are subsequently occupied by eosin Y anions. It can be spectroscopically shown that the electronic states of the azure B polymers and the attached eosin Y interact. By this interaction the absorption of eosin Y is red shifted and of the azure B polymers blue shifted. The absorption bands of both molecular species overlap and generate the Romanowsky band. Its strong maximum at 18100 cm-1 is due to the eosin Y part of the DNA-azure B-eosin Y complex. The discussed red shift of the eosin Y absorption is the main reason for the purple coloration of RG stained nuclei. Using a special technique it was possible to prepare an artificial DNA-azure B-eosin Y complex with calf thymus DNA as a model nucleic acid and the two dye stuffs azure B and eosin Y.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Microspectrophotometric studies of Romanowsky stained blood cells. III. The action of methylene blue and azure B

The performances of two standardized Romanowsky stains (azure B/eosin and azure B/methylene blue/eosin) have been compared with each other and with a methylene blue/eosin stain. Visible-light absorbance spectra of various hematological substrates have been measured. These have been analyzed in terms of the quantities of bound azure B, methylene blue and eosin dimers and monomers, and in terms of the CIE color coordinates. It has been found that the addition of methylene blue to azure B/eosin produces little change in performance, at least using these two analytical methods. Methylene blue/eosin does not produce the purplish colorations typical of the Romanowsky effect. This is due not to differences between the spectra of methylene blue and azure B, but to the fact that methylene blue does not facilitate the binding of eosin to cellular substrates to the same extent as azure B.

On the nature of Romanowsky--Giemsa staining and its significance for cytochemistry and histochemistry: an overall view

The chances of Romanowsky---Giemsa (RG) staining becoming a reliable and useful histochemical procedure are reviewed, based on the now proven fact that RG staining requires two dyes only, namely, cationic Azure B and anionic Eosin Y. These two dyes differ from otherwise similar dye combinations in that they give, on distinct biological substrates, one additional colour, purple, which cannot be obtained by the use of either dye alone. The purple colour characterizes the Romanowsky--Giemsa effect (RGE), which is the essential feature of RG staining. Consideration is given to the physico-chemical and morphological implications of RGE. Of primary importance is the nature of the biological substrates where RGE occurs, and also of those where it has never been observed. The way substrates react to RG stains largely depends on the kind of pretreatment they have received; for instance, alcoholic fixation preserves RGE but formaldehyde may inhibit it. Physico-chemical factors are considered which, by altering either the biological substrates or the composition of the staining solutions, may modify the RG staining pattern. This review also serves as an introduction for a series of experimental papers that will follow and which are intended to consolidate the basis of RG staining, a method which holds much promise as a useful histochemical tool.