An appraisal of ultramicrotomy, FIBSEM and cryogenic FIBSEM techniques for the sectioning of biological cells on titanium substrates for TEM investigation

Applications of scanning electron microscopy and focused ion beam milling in dental research

The abilities of scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and focused ion beam (FIB) milling for obtaining high-resolution images from top surfaces, cross-sectional surfaces, and even in three dimensions, are becoming increasingly important for imaging and analyzing tooth structures such as enamel and dentin. FIB was originally developed for material research in the semiconductor industry. However, use of SEM/FIB has been growing recently in dental research due to the versatility of dual platform instruments that can be used as a milling device to obtain low-artifact cross-sections of samples combined with high-resolution images. The advent of the SEM/FIB system and accessories may offer access to previously inaccessible length scales for characterizing tooth structures for dental research, opening exciting opportunities to address many central questions in dental research. New discoveries and fundamental breakthroughs in understanding are likely to follow. This review covers the applications, key findings, and future direction of SEM/FIB in dental research in morphology imaging, specimen preparation for transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis, and three-dimensional volume imaging using SEM/FIB tomography.

Room temperature synthesis of pillared-layer metal–organic frameworks (MOFs)

A strategy for the production of water stable pillared-layer MOFs in less toxic solvents and potentially in large amounts.

Cryo-FIB-lift-out: practically impossible to practical reality

In this paper, we explore the development of the Cryo-Lift-Out (cryo-LO) technique as preparation tool for cryogenic transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM). What started in early work defying what was considered 'practically impossible' has developed into state-of-the-art practical reality. This paper presents the key hardware, basic principles and key considerations for the practical usage of cryogenic Lift-Out for those new to the field. Detailed protocols and in-depth description of considerations and points for further development are presented. The authors have attempted to formalise everything known about the technique gathered together from their expertise gained in the development of this approach. LAY DESCRIPTION: A major challenge in electron microscopy is the production of suitable samples from hydrated biological and soft-matter materials for subnanometre resolution imaging in a cryo-Transmission Electron Microscope (TEM). A well-known solution for room temperature materials is called (in situ) Lift-Out. It uses a fine needle that picks up a tiny section called a lamella. Lamellae are made by a Focused Ion Beam (FIB). In this paper, we seek to set out the beginnings of Lift-Out sample preparation conducted under cryogenic conditions and the development of this approach as applied to frozen, hydrated biological and soft-matter samples. We discuss the required basic hardware and provide a thorough description of developed protocols. We aim at those new to the field of cryo-Lift-Out to fully educate them in the finer points of hardware setup and practical considerations when attempting to perform cryo-Lift-Out and to demonstrate what has been achieved thus far. We also discuss areas of further improvement and talking points for the future direction of this promising sample preparation technique.

Efficient Transmission Electron Microscopy Characterization of Cell-Nanostructure Interfacial Interactions

Engineered nano-bio interfaces driven by tunable vertically configured nanostructures have recently emerged as a powerful tool for cellular manipulations and interrogations. Yet the interplay between substrate topography and cellular behavior is highly complex and not fully understood. A new experimental design is proposed that enables generation of ultrathin sections (lamellae) of cell-nanostructure imprints with minimal artifacts. We demonstrate the potential of such lamellae for efficient transmission electron microscopy (TEM) characterization of interfacial interactions between adherent cells and vertically aligned Si nanostructures. This approach will advance understanding of cellular responses to extracellular biophysical and biochemical cues-which is likely to facilitate the design of improved cellular manipulation technologies.

An introduction to cryo-FIB-SEM cross-sectioning of frozen, hydrated Life Science samples

The introduction of cryo‐techniques to the focused ion‐beam scanning electron microscope (FIB‐SEM) has brought new opportunities to study frozen, hydrated samples from the field of Life Sciences. Cryo‐techniques have long been employed in electron microscopy. Thin electron transparent sections are produced by cryo‐ultramicrotomy for observation in a cryo‐transmission electron microscope (TEM). Cryo‐TEM is presently reaching the imaging of macromolecular structures. In parallel, cryo‐fractured surfaces from bulk materials have been investigated by cryo‐SEM.

Both cryo‐TEM and cryo‐SEM have provided a wealth of information, despite being 2D techniques. Cryo‐TEM tomography does provide 3D information, but the thickness of the volume has a maximum of 200–300 nm, which limits the 3D information within the context of specific structures. FIB‐milling enables imaging additional planes by creating cross‐sections (e.g. cross‐sectioning or site‐specific X‐sectioning) perpendicular to the cryo‐fracture surface, thus adding a third imaging dimension to the cryo‐SEM. This paper discusses how to produce suitable cryo‐FIB‐SEM cross‐section results from frozen, hydrated Life Science samples with emphasis on ‘common knowledge’ and reoccurring observations.

Lay Description

Life Sciences studies life down to the smallest details. Visualising the smallest details requires electron microscopy, which utilises high‐vacuum chambers. One method to maintain the integrity of Life Sciences samples under vacuum conditions is freezing. Frozen samples can remain in a suspended state. As a result, research can be carried out without having to change the chemistry or internal physical structure of the samples.

Two types of electron microscopes equipped with cryo‐sample handling facilities are used to investigate samples: The scanning electron microscope (SEM) which investigates surfaces and the transmission electron microscope (TEM) which investigates thin electron transparent sections (called lamellae). A third method of investigation combines a SEM with a focused ion beam (FIB) to form a cryo‐FIB‐SEM, which is the basis of this paper. The electron beam images the cryo‐sample surface while the ion beam mills into the surface to expose the interior of the sample. The latter is called cross‐sectioning and the result provides a way of investigating the 3rd dimension of the sample. This paper looks at the making of cross‐sections in this manner originating from knowledge and experience gained with this technique over many years. This information is meant for newcomers, and experienced researchers in cryo‐microscopy alike.

Cryo-FIB preparation of whole cells and tissue for cryo-TEM: use of high-pressure frozen specimens in tubes and planchets

The desire to study macromolecular complexes within their cellular context requires the ability to produce thin samples suitable for cryo‐TEM (cryo‐transmission electron microscope) investigations. In this paper, we discuss two similar approaches, which were developed independently in Utrecht (the Netherlands) and Albany (USA). The methods are particularly suitable for both tissue samples and cell suspensions prepared by a high‐pressure freezer (HPF). The workflows are explained with particular attention to potential pitfalls, while underlying principles are highlighted (‘why to do so’). Although both workflows function with a high success rate, full execution requires considerable experience and remains demanding. In addition, throughput is low. We hope to encourage other research groups worldwide to take on the challenge of improving the HPF– cryo‐FIB‐SEM – cryo‐TEM workflow. We discuss a number of suggestions to this end.

Lay Description

Life is ultimately dictated by the interaction of molecules in our bodies. Highly complex equipment is being used and further developed to study these interactions. The present paper describes methods to prepare small, very thin lamellae (area of 5×5 µm², thickness 50–300 nm) of a cell to be studied in a cryo‐transmission electron microscope (cryo‐TEM). Special care must be taken to preserve the natural state of molecules in their natural environment. In the case of cryo‐TEM, the samples must be frozen and kept frozen to be compatible with the vacuum conditions in the microscope. The frozen condition imposes technical challenges which are addressed. Two approaches to obtain the thin lamellae are described. Both make use of a focused ion beam (FIB) microscope. The FIB allows removal of material with nanometre precision by focusing a beam of ionised atoms (gallium ions) onto the sample. Careful control of the FIB allows cutting out of the required thin lamellae. In both strategies, the thin lamellae remain attached to the original sample, and the ensemble of sample with section and sample holder is transported from the FIB microscope to the TEM while being kept frozen.

Challenges in TEM sample preparation of solvothermally grown CuInS2 films

Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) is a widely used tool to characterize materials. The required samples need to be electron transparent which should be achieved without changing the microstructure. This work describes different TEM sample preparation techniques of nanostructured CuInS₂ thin films on fluorine-doped tin oxide substrates, synthesized solvothermally using l-cysteine as sulfur source. Focused ion beam lamellae, conventional cross section samples and scratch samples have been prepared and investigated. It was possible to prepare appropriate samples with each technique, however, each technique brings with it certain advantages and disadvantages. FIB preparation of solvothermally synthesized CuInS₂ suffers from two main drawbacks. First, the whole CuInS₂ layer displays a strongly increased Cu content caused by Cu migration and preferential removal of In. Further, electron diffraction shows the formation of an additional CuS phase after Ga⁺ bombardment. Second, diffraction analysis is complicated by a strong contribution of crystalline Pt introduced during the FIB preparation and penetrating into the porous film surface. The conventional cross sectional CuInS₂ sample also shows a Cu signal enhancement which is caused by contribution of the brass tube material used for embedding. Additionally, Cu particles have been observed inside the CuInS₂ which have been sputtered on the film during preparation. Only the scratch samples allow an almost artefact-free and reliable elemental quantification using energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy. However, scratch samples suffer from the drawback that it is not possible to determine the layer thickness, which is possible for both cross sectional preparation techniques. Consequently, it is concluded that the type of sample preparation should be chosen dependent on the required information. A full characterization can only be achieved when the different techniques are combined.

Cryo-planing of frozen-hydrated samples using cryo triple ion gun milling (CryoTIGM™)

Cryo-SEM is a high throughput technique for imaging biological ultrastructure in its most pristine state, i.e. without chemical fixation, embedding, or drying. Freeze fracture is routinely used to prepare internal surfaces for cryo-SEM imaging. However, the propagation of the fracture plane is highly dependent on sample properties, and the resulting surface frequently shows substantial topography, which can complicate image analysis and interpretation. We have developed a broad ion beam milling technique, called cryogenic triple ion gun milling (CryoTIGM™ ['krī-ə-,tīm]), for cryo-planing frozen-hydrated biological specimens. Comparing sample preparation by CryoTIGM™ and freeze fracture in three model systems, Baker's yeast, mouse liver tissue, and whole sea urchin embryos, we find that CryoTIGM™ yields very large (∼700,000 μm(2)) and smooth sections that present ultrastructural details at similar or better quality than freeze-fractured samples. A particular strength of CryoTIGM™ is the ability to section samples with hard-soft contrast such as brittle calcite (CaCO3) spicules in the sea urchin embryo.

Three dimensional reconstruction by electron microscopy in the life sciences: An introduction for cell and tissue biologists

Early applications of transmission electron microscopy (TEM) in the life sciences have contributed tremendously to our current understanding at the subcellular level. Initially limited to two-dimensional representations of three-dimensional (3D) objects, this approach has revolutionized the fields of cellular and structural biology-being instrumental for determining the fine morpho-functional characterization of most cellular structures. Electron microscopy has progressively evolved towards the development of tools that allow for the 3D characterization of different structures. This was done with the aid of a wide variety of techniques, which have become increasingly diverse and highly sophisticated. We start this review by examining the principles of 3D reconstruction of cells and tissues using classical approaches in TEM, and follow with a discussion of the modern approaches utilizing TEM as well as on new scanning electron microscopy-based techniques. 3D reconstruction techniques from serial sections and (cryo) electron-tomography are examined, and the recent applications of focused ion beam-scanning microscopes and serial-block-face techniques for the 3D reconstruction of large volumes are discussed. Alternative low-cost techniques and more accessible approaches using basic transmission or field emission scanning electron microscopes are also examined.

Optimal sample preparation to characterize corrosion in historical photographs with analytical TEM

An alternative focused ion beam preparation method is used for sampling historical photographs containing metallic nanoparticles in a polymer matrix. We use the preparation steps of classical ultra-microtomy with an alternative final sectioning with a focused ion beam. Transmission electron microscopy techniques show that the lamella has a uniform thickness, which is an important factor for analytical transmission electron microscopy. Furthermore, the method maintains the spatial distribution of nanoparticles in the soft matrix. The results are compared with traditional preparation techniques such as ultra-microtomy and classical focused ion beam milling.

Ultrastructural evaluation of shrinkage artefacts induced by fixatives and embedding resins on osteocyte processes and pericellular space dimensions

The integrity of the interface between the osteocyte (Ot) process and the canalicular wall was investigated in terms of change in the lateral dimensions of the Ot process in relation to the canalicular width, i.e., widening of the pericellular space. This has been interpreted as shrinkage of the Ot process relative to the canalicular wall during sample preparation stages of fixation, dehydration, and resin embedding. Sprague-Dawley rat tibial cross-sections were prepared for transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Four different fixative preparations: paraformaldehyde (PF), modified Karnovsky's (MK), glutaraldehyde (GRR) with ruthenium red (GRR), and zinc formalin (ZF); and two different embedding resins: LR Gold (LRG) and Epon812 (Epon) were evaluated. It was found that for LRG embedding, formalin-only fixatives (PF and ZF) induced lower shrinkage than GRR-containing fixatives (MK and GRR). In contrast, for Epon embedding, MK showed the highest shrinkage, while no differences were found between the remaining fixatives (PF, ZF, and GRR). All formalin-containing fixatives (MK, PF, and ZF) induced similar shrinkage in both embedding media. The most dramatic difference was for GRR fixation, which in combination with LRG embedding showed ∼ 62% more shrinkage than with Epon embedding, suggesting that the combination of GRR fixation and LRG embedding synergistically amplifies Ot shrinkage. These differences likely suggest a role of the resin in secondarily influencing the tissue structure following fixation. Further, the work confirms LRG as a poor embedding medium for bone specimens, as it causes large variations in shrinkage depending on fixation.

Practical workflow for cryo focused-ion-beam milling of tissues and cells for cryo-TEM tomography

Vitreous freezing offers a way to study cells and tissue in a near-native state by cryo-transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM), which is important when structural information at the macromolecular level is required. Many cells - especially those in tissue - are too thick to study intact in the cryo-TEM. Cryo focused-ion-beam (cryo-FIB) milling is being used in a few laboratories to thin vitreously frozen specimens, thus avoiding the artifacts and difficulties of cryo-ultramicrotomy. However, the technique is challenging because of the need to avoid devitrification and frost accumulation during the entire process, from the initial step of freezing to the final step of loading the specimen into the cryo-TEM. We present a robust workflow that makes use of custom fixtures and devices that can be used for high-pressure-frozen bulk tissue samples as well as for samples frozen on TEM grids.

In-situ integrity control of frozen-hydrated, vitreous lamellas prepared by the cryo-focused ion beam-scanning electron microscope

Recently a number of new approaches have been presented with the intention to produce electron beam transparent cryo-sections (lamellas in FIB-SEM terminology) from hydrated vitreously frozen cryo samples with a Focused Ion Beam (FIB) system, suitable for cryo-Transmission Electron Microscopy (cryo-TEM). As the workflow is still challenging and time consuming, it is important to be able to determine the integrity and suitability (cells vs. no cells; vitreous vs. crystalline) of the lamellas. Here we present an in situ method that tests both conditions by using the cryo-Scanning Electron Microscope (cryo-SEM) in transmission mode (TSEM; Transmission Scanning Electron Microscope) once the FIB-made lamella is ready. Cryo-TSEM imaging of unstained cells yields strong contrast, enabling direct imaging of material present in the lamellas. In addition, orientation contrast is shown to be suitable for distinguishing crystalline lamellas from vitreous lamellas. Tilting the stage a few degrees results in changes of contrast between ice grains as a function of the tilt angle, whereas the contrast of areas with vitreous ice remains unchanged as a function of the tilt angle. This orientation contrast has subsequently been validated by cryo-Electron BackScattered Diffraction (EBSD) in transmission mode. Integration of the presented method is discussed and the role it can play in future developments for a new and innovative all-in-one cryo-FIB-SEM life sciences instrument.

Mapping the complex morphology of cell interactions with nanowire substrates using FIB-SEM

Using high resolution focused ion beam scanning electron microscopy (FIB-SEM) we study the details of cell-nanostructure interactions using serial block face imaging. 3T3 Fibroblast cellular monolayers are cultured on flat glass as a control surface and on two types of nanostructured scaffold substrates made from silicon black (Nanograss) with low- and high nanowire density. After culturing for 72 hours the cells were fixed, heavy metal stained, embedded in resin, and processed with FIB-SEM block face imaging without removing the substrate. The sample preparation procedure, image acquisition and image post-processing were specifically optimised for cellular monolayers cultured on nanostructured substrates. Cells display a wide range of interactions with the nanostructures depending on the surface morphology, but also greatly varying from one cell to another on the same substrate, illustrating a wide phenotypic variability. Depending on the substrate and cell, we observe that cells could for instance: break the nanowires and engulf them, flatten the nanowires or simply reside on top of them. Given the complexity of interactions, we have categorised our observations and created an overview map. The results demonstrate that detailed nanoscale resolution images are required to begin understanding the wide variety of individual cells’ interactions with a structured substrate. The map will provide a framework for light microscopy studies of such interactions indicating what modes of interactions must be considered.

Transient serum exposure regimes to support dual differentiation of human mesenchymal stem cells

Human mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs), which can generate both osteoblasts and chondrocytes, represent an ideal resource for orthopaedic repair using tissue-engineering approaches. One major difficulty for the development of osteochondral constructs using undifferentiated MSCs is that serum is typically used in culture protocols to promote differentiation of the osteogenic component, whereas existing chondrogenic differentiation protocols rely on the use of serum-free conditions. In order to define conditions which could be compatible with both chondrogenic and osteogenic differentiation in a single bioreactor, we have analysed the efficiency of new biphasic differentiation regimes based on transient serum exposure followed by serum-free treatment. MSC differentiation was assessed either in serum-free medium or with a range of transient exposure to serum, and compared to continuous serum-containing treatment. Although osteogenic differentation was not supported in the complete absence of serum, marker expression and extensive mineralization analyses established that 5 days of transient exposure triggered a level of differentiation comparable to that observed when serum was present throughout. This initial phase of serum exposure was further shown to support the successful chondrogenic differentiation of MSCs, comparable to controls maintained in serum-free conditions throughout. This study indicates that a culture based on temporal serum exposure followed by serum-free treatment is compatible with both osteogenic and chondrogenic differentiation of MSCs. These results will allow the development of novel strategies for osteochondral tissue engineering approaches using MSCs for regenerative medicine.

Nanomechanics of the Cartilage Extracellular Matrix

Cartilage is a hydrated biomacromolecular fiber composite located at the ends of long bones that enables proper joint lubrication, articulation, loading, and energy dissipation. Degradation of extracellular matrix molecular components and changes in their nanoscale structure greatly influence the macroscale behavior of the tissue and result in dysfunction with age, injury, and diseases such as osteoarthritis. Here, the application of the field of nanomechanics to cartilage is reviewed. Nanomechanics involves the measurement and prediction of nanoscale forces and displacements, intra- and intermolecular interactions, spatially varying mechanical properties, and other mechanical phenomena existing at small length scales. Experimental nanomechanics and theoretical nanomechanics have been applied to cartilage at varying levels of material complexity, e.g., nanoscale properties of intact tissue, the matrix associated with single cells, biomimetic molecular assemblies, and individual extracellular matrix biomolecules (such as aggrecan, collagen, and hyaluronan). These studies have contributed to establishing a fundamental mechanism-based understanding of native and engineered cartilage tissue function, quality, and pathology.

Cryo DualBeam Focused Ion Beam-Scanning Electron Microscopy to Evaluate the Interface Between Cells and Nanopatterned Scaffolds

With the advance of nanotechnology in biomaterials science and tissue engineering, it is essential that new techniques become available to observe processes that take place at the direct interface between tissue and scaffold materials. Here, Cryo DualBeam focused ion beam-scanning electron microscopy (FIB-SEM) was used as a novel approach to observe the interactions between frozen hydrated cells and nanometric structures in high detail. Through a comparison of images acquired with transmission electron microscopy (TEM), conventional FIB-SEM operated at ambient temperature, and Cryo DualBeam FIB-SEM, the advantages and disadvantages of each technique were evaluated. Ultrastructural details of both (extra)cellular components and cell organelles were best observe with TEM. However, processing artifacts such as shrinkage of cells at the substrate interface were introduced in both TEM and conventional FIB-SEM. In addition, the cellular contrast in conventional FIB-SEM was low; consequently, cells were difficult to distinguish from the adjoining substrate. Cryo DualBeam FIB-SEM did preserve (extra)cellular details like the contour, cell membrane, and mineralized matrix. The three described techniques have proven to be complementary for the evaluation of processes that take place at the interface between tissue and substrate.

Towards native-state imaging in biological context in the electron microscope

Modern cell biology is reliant on light and fluorescence microscopy for analysis of cells, tissues and protein localisation. However, these powerful techniques are ultimately limited in resolution by the wavelength of light. Electron microscopes offer much greater resolution due to the shorter effective wavelength of electrons, allowing direct imaging of sub-cellular architecture. The harsh environment of the electron microscope chamber and the properties of the electron beam have led to complex chemical and mechanical preparation techniques, which distance biological samples from their native state and complicate data interpretation. Here we describe recent advances in sample preparation and instrumentation, which push the boundaries of high-resolution imaging. Cryopreparation, cryoelectron microscopy and environmental scanning electron microscopy strive to image samples in near native state. Advances in correlative microscopy and markers enable high-resolution localisation of proteins. Innovation in microscope design has pushed the boundaries of resolution to atomic scale, whilst automatic acquisition of high-resolution electron microscopy data through large volumes is finally able to place ultrastructure in biological context.