Analysis of membrane protein interaction: ToxR can dimerize the amino terminus of phage lambda repressor

Structural Insights into Regulation of Vibrio Virulence Gene Networks

One of the best studied aspects of pathogenic Vibrios are the virulence cascades that lead to the production of virulence factors and, ultimately, clinical outcomes. In this chapter, we will examine the regulation of Vibrio virulence gene networks from a structural and biochemical perspective. We will discuss the recent research into the numerous proteins that contribute to regulating virulence in Vibrio spp such as quorum sensing regulator HapR, the transcription factors AphA and AphB, or the virulence regulators ToxR and ToxT. We highlight how insights gained from these studies are already illuminating the basic molecular mechanisms by which the virulence cascade of pathogenic Vibrios unfold and contend that understanding how protein interactions contribute to the host-pathogen communications will enable the development of new antivirulence compounds that can effectively target these pathogens.

The Xenogeneic Silencer Histone-Like Nucleoid-Structuring Protein Mediates the Temperature and Salinity-Dependent Regulation of the Type III Secretion System 2 in Vibrio parahaemolyticus

The marine bacterium Vibrio parahaemolyticus is a major seafood-borne pathogen that causes acute diarrhea in humans. A crucial virulence determinant of V. parahaemolyticus is the type III secretion system 2 (T3SS2), which is encoded on the Vibrio parahaemolyticus pathogenicity island (Vp-PAI), in which gene expression is dependent on environmental cues, such as temperature and salinity. This characteristic may implicate the adaptation of V. parahaemolyticus from its natural habitat to the human body environment during infection; however, the underlying mechanism remains unknown. Here, we describe the regulatory role of the histone-like nucleoid-structuring protein (H-NS), which is a xenogeneic silencing protein, in T3SS2 gene expression through the conditional silencing of the gene encoding a master regulator of Vp-PAI, VtrB. The hns deletion canceled the temperature- and salinity-dependent differential T3SS2 gene expression. H-NS bound to the vtrB promoter containing AT-rich sequences, and the binding sites partially overlapped the binding sites of two positive regulators of vtrB (i.e., VtrA and ToxR), which may block the transcriptional activation of vtrB. H-NS-family proteins multimerize along the DNA strand, forming stiffened filament and/or bridging DNA duplexes for its target silencing. In V. parahaemolyticus, mutations at conserved residues that are required for the multimerization of H-NS abolished the repressive activity on VtrB expression, supporting the contention that H-NS multimerization is also critical for vtrB silencing in V. parahaemolyticus. Taken together, these findings demonstrate the principal role of H-NS as a thermal and salt switch with sensory and regulatory properties for ensuring T3SS2 gene regulation in V. parahaemolyticus. IMPORTANCE In the major seafood-borne pathogen Vibrio parahaemolyticus, the type III secretion system 2 (T3SS2) is a major virulence factor that is responsible for the enterotoxicity of this bacterium. The expression of T3SS2 varies according to changes in temperature and salinity, but the mechanism via which T3SS2 expression is regulated in response to such physical cues remains unknown. Here, we report that H-NS, a xenogeneic silencer that is widespread in Gram-negative bacteria, modulates the entirety of T3SS2 gene expression through the transcriptional silencing of the gene encoding the T3SS2 master regulator VtrB in a temperature- and salinity-dependent manner. Thus, our findings provide insights into how this pathogen achieves the appropriate control of the expression of virulence genes in the transition between aquatic and human environments.

A disulfide constrains the ToxR periplasmic domain structure, altering its interactions with ToxS and bile-salts

ToxR is a transmembrane transcription factor that, together with its integral membrane periplasmic binding partner ToxS, is conserved across the Vibrionaceae family. In some pathogenic Vibrios, including V. parahaemolyticus and V. cholerae, ToxR is required for bile resistance and virulence, and ToxR is fully activated and protected from degradation by ToxS. ToxS achieves this in part by ensuring formation of an intra-chain disulfide bond in the C-terminal periplasmic domain of ToxR (dbToxRp). In this study, biochemical analysis showed dbToxRp to have a higher affinity for the ToxS periplasmic domain than the non-disulfide bonded conformation. Analysis of our dbToxRp crystal structure showed this is due to disulfide bond stabilization. Furthermore, dbToxRp is structurally homologous to the V. parahaemolyticus VtrA periplasmic domain. These results highlight the critical structural role of disulfide bond in ToxR and along with VtrA define a domain fold involved in environmental sensing conserved across the Vibrionaceae family.

Host stimuli and operator binding sites controlling protein interactions between virulence master regulator ToxR and ToxS in Vibrio cholerae

Protein-protein interactions (PPIs) are key mechanisms in the maintenance of biological regulatory networks. Herein, we characterize PPIs within ToxR and its co-activator, ToxS, to understand the mechanisms of ToxR transcription factor activation. ToxR is a key transcription activator that is supported by ToxS for virulence gene regulation in Vibrio cholerae. ToxR comprises a cytoplasmic DNA-binding domain that is linked by a transmembrane domain to a periplasmic signal receiver domain containing two cysteine residues. ToxR-ToxR and ToxR-ToxS PPIs were detected using an adenylate-cyclase-based bacterial two-hybrid system approach in Escherichia coli. We found that the ToxR-ToxR PPIs are significantly increased in response to ToxR operators, the co-activator ToxS and bile salts. We suggest that ToxS and bile salts promote the interaction between ToxR molecules that ultimately results in dimerization. Upon binding of operators, ToxR-ToxR PPIs are found at the highest frequency. Moreover, disulfide-bond-dependent interaction in the periplasm results in homodimer formation that is promoted by DNA binding. The formation of these homodimers and the associated transcriptional activity of ToxR were strongly dependent on the oxidoreductases DsbA/DsbC. These findings show that protein and non-protein partners, that either transiently or stably interact with ToxR, fine-tune ToxR PPIs, and its associated transcriptional activity in changing environments.

The wing of the ToxR winged helix-turn-helix domain is required for DNA binding and activation of toxT and ompU

ToxR and TcpP, two winged helix-turn-helix (w-HTH) family transcription factors, co-activate expression of the toxT promoter in Vibrio cholerae. ToxT then directly regulates a number of genes required for virulence. In addition to co-activation of toxT, ToxR can directly activate the ompU promoter and repress the ompT promoter. Based on a previous study suggesting that certain wing residues of ToxR are preferentially involved in toxT co-activation compared to direct ompU activation, we employed alanine-scanning mutagenesis to determine which residues in the wing of ToxR are required for activation of each promoter. All of the ToxR wing residues tested that were critical for transcriptional activation of toxT and/or ompU were also critical for DNA binding. While some ToxR wing mutants had reduced interaction with TcpP, that reduced interaction did not correlate with a specific defect in toxT activation. Rather, such mutants also affected ompU activation and DNA binding. Based on these findings we conclude that the primary role of the wing of ToxR is to bind DNA, along with the DNA recognition helix of ToxR, and this function is required both for direct activation of ompU and co-activation of toxT.

Formation of an Intramolecular Periplasmic Disulfide Bond in TcpP Protects TcpP and TcpH from Degradation in Vibrio cholerae

TcpP and ToxR coordinately regulate transcription of toxT, the master regulator of numerous virulence factors in Vibrio cholerae. TcpP and ToxR are membrane-localized transcription factors, each with a periplasmic domain containing two cysteines. In ToxR, these cysteines form an intramolecular disulfide bond and a cysteine-to-serine substitution affects activity. We determined that the two periplasmic cysteines of TcpP also form an intramolecular disulfide bond. Disruption of this intramolecular disulfide bond by mutation of either cysteine resulted in formation of intermolecular disulfide bonds. Furthermore, disruption of the intramolecular disulfide bond in TcpP decreased the stability of TcpP. While the decreased stability of TcpP-C207S resulted in a nearly complete loss of toxT activation and cholera toxin (CT) production, the second cysteine mutant, TcpP-C218S, was partially resistant to proteolytic degradation and maintained ∼50% toxT activation capacity. TcpP-C218S was also TcpH independent, since deletion of tcpH did not affect the stability of TcpP-C218S, whereas wild-type TcpP was degraded in the absence of TcpH. Finally, TcpH was also unstable when intramolecular disulfides could not be formed in TcpP, suggesting that the single periplasmic cysteine in TcpH may assist with disulfide bond formation in TcpP by interacting with the periplasmic cysteines of TcpP. Consistent with this finding, a TcpH-C114S mutant was unable to stabilize TcpP and was itself unstable. Our findings demonstrate a periplasmic disulfide bond in TcpP is critical for TcpP stability and virulence gene expression.

IMPORTANCE

The Vibrio cholerae transcription factor TcpP, in conjunction with ToxR, regulates transcription of toxT, the master regulator of numerous virulence factors in Vibrio cholerae. TcpP is a membrane-localized transcription factor with a periplasmic domain containing two cysteines. We determined that the two periplasmic cysteines of TcpP form an intramolecular disulfide bond and disruption of the intramolecular disulfide bond in TcpP decreased the stability of TcpP and reduced virulence gene expression. Normally TcpH, another membrane-localized periplasmic protein, protects TcpP from degradation. However, we found that TcpH was also unstable when intramolecular disulfides could not be formed in TcpP, indicating that the periplasmic cysteines of TcpP are required for functional interaction with TcpH and that this interaction is required for both TcpP and TcpH stability.

Role of ToxS in the proteolytic cascade of virulence regulator ToxR in Vibrio cholerae

Two of the primary virulence regulators of Vibrio cholerae, ToxR and TcpP, function together with cognate effector proteins. ToxR undergoes regulated intramembrane proteolysis (RIP) during late stationary phase in response to nutrient limitation at alkaline pH; however, the specific function of its cognate ToxS remains unresolved. In this work, we found that ToxR rapidly becomes undetectable in a ΔtoxS mutant when cultures are exposed to either starvation conditions or after alkaline pH shock individually. A ΔtoxS mutant enters into a dormant state associated with the proteolysis of ToxR at a faster rate than wild-type, closely resembling a ΔtoxR mutant. Using a mutant with a periplasmic substitution in ToxS, we found that the proteases DegS and DegP function additively with VesC and a novel protease, TapA, to degrade ToxR in the mutant. Overall, the results shown here reveal a role for ToxS in the stabilization of ToxR by protecting the virulence regulator from premature proteolysis.

Disulfide bond formation and ToxR activity in Vibrio cholerae

Virulence factor production in Vibrio cholerae is complex, with ToxRS being an important part of the regulatory cascade. Additionally, ToxR is the transcriptional regulator for the genes encoding the major outer membrane porins OmpU and OmpT. ToxR is a transmembrane protein and contains two cysteine residues in the periplasmic domain. This study addresses the influence of the thiol-disulfide oxidoreductase system DsbAB, ToxR cysteine residues and ToxR/ToxS interaction on ToxR activity. The results show that porin production correlates with ToxR intrachain disulfide bond formation, which depends on DsbAB. In contrast, formation of ToxR intrachain or interchain disulfide bonds is dispensable for virulence factor production and in vivo colonization. This study further reveals that in the absence of ToxS, ToxR interchain disulfide bond formation is facilitated, whereat cysteinyl dependent homo- and oligomerization of ToxR is suppressed if ToxS is coexpressed. In summary, new insights into gene regulation by ToxR are presented, demonstrating a mechanism by which ToxR activity is linked to a DsbAB dependent intrachain disulfide bond formation.

Dynamics of the SetCD-regulated integration and excision of genomic islands mobilized by integrating conjugative elements of the SXT/R391 family

Mobilizable genomic islands (MGIs) are small genomic islands that are mobilizable by SXT/R391 integrating conjugative elements (ICEs) due to similar origins of transfer. Their site-specific integration and excision are catalyzed by the integrase that they encode, but their conjugative transfer entirely depends upon the conjugative machinery of SXT/R391 ICEs. In this study, we report the mechanisms that control the excision and integration processes of MGIs. We found that while the MGI-encoded integrase Int(MGI) is sufficient to promote MGI integration, efficient excision from the host chromosome requires the combined action of Int(MGI) and of a novel recombination directionality factor, RdfM. We determined that the genes encoding these proteins are activated by SetCD, the main transcriptional activators of SXT/R391 ICEs. Although they share the same regulators, we found that unlike rdfM, int(MGI) has a basal level of expression in the absence of SetCD. These findings explain how an MGI can integrate into the chromosome of a new host in the absence of a coresident ICE and shed new light on the cross talk that can occur between mobilizable and mobilizing elements that mobilize them, helping us to understand part of the rules that dictate horizontal transfer mechanisms.

Detection and function of an intramolecular disulfide bond in the pH-responsive CadC of Escherichia coli

Background

In an acidic and lysine-rich environment Escherichia coli induces expression of the cadBA operon which encodes CadA, the lysine decarboxylase, and CadB, the lysine/cadaverine antiporter. cadBA expression is dependent on CadC, a membrane-integrated transcriptional activator which belongs to the ToxR-like protein family. Activation of CadC requires two stimuli, lysine and low pH. Whereas lysine is detected by an interplay between CadC and the lysine-specific transporter LysP, pH alterations are sensed by CadC directly. Crystal structural analyses revealed a close proximity between two periplasmic cysteines, Cys208 and Cys272.

Results

Substitution of Cys208 and/or Cys272 by alanine resulted in CadC derivatives that were active in response to only one stimulus, either lysine or pH 5.8. Differential in vivo thiol trapping revealed a disulfide bond between these two residues at pH 7.6, but not at pH 5.8. When Cys208 and Cys272 were replaced by aspartate and lysine, respectively, virtually wild-type behavior was restored indicating that the disulfide bond could be mimicked by a salt bridge.

Conclusion

A disulfide bond was found in the periplasmic domain of CadC that supports an inactive state of CadC at pH 7.6. At pH 5.8 disulfide bond formation is prevented which transforms CadC into a semi-active state. These results provide new insights into the function of a pH sensor.

Influence of high pressure on the dimerization of ToxR, a protein involved in bacterial signal transduction

High hydrostatic pressure (HHP) is suggested to influence the structure and function of membranes and/or integrated proteins. We demonstrate for the first time HHP-induced dimer dissociation of membrane proteins in vivo with Vibrio cholerae ToxR variants in Escherichia coli reporter strains carrying ctx::lacZ fusions. Dimerization ceased at 20 to 50 MPa depending on the nature of the transmembrane segments rather than on changes in the ToxR lipid bilayer environment.

Structural studies on Vibrio cholerae ToxR periplasmic and cytoplasmic domains

The transcription activator ToxR controls the expression of cholera toxin, pilus colonization factor and outer membrane protein in Vibrio cholerae. It binds to the 5'-TTTTGAT-3' tandemly repeated DNA sequence in the cholera toxin promoter region. ToxR is a membrane protein having distinct periplasmic and cytoplasmic domains. The two domains have been cloned, over-expressed and purified for structural studies. The cytoplasmic domain is more compact than the periplasmic domain. The periplasmic domain exists as dimer due to the presence of an interchain disulfide linkage, while the cytoplasmic domain is monomeric in solution implying the importance of the disulfide bond to homodimerize the native ToxR. By replacing one of the cysteines C293 with alanine, using site-directed mutagenesis, a C293A mutant was created at the periplasmic domain to elucidate the role of cysteine in dimerization of ToxR.

Degradation of the membrane-localized virulence activator TcpP by the YaeL protease in Vibrio cholerae

A common mechanism inhibiting the activity of transcription factors is their sequestration to the membrane until they are needed, at which point they are released from the membrane by proteolysis. Acting in contrast to this inhibition mechanism are virulence regulators of Vibrio cholerae, the ToxR and TcpP proteins, which are localized to the inner membrane of the cell, where they bind promoter DNA and activate gene expression. TcpP is rapidly degraded in the absence of another protein, TcpH. We used a genetic screen to identify regulators of TcpP stability and identified the YaeL membrane-localized zinc metalloprotease as responsible for degrading TcpP in the absence of TcpH. In Escherichia coli, DegS and YaeL cooperate to degrade RseA, an antisigma factor that sequesters sigma(E) to the inner membrane, thereby inhibiting the activity of sigma(E). When yaeL was disrupted in a V. cholerae tcpH mutant, we observed accumulation of a lower molecular weight species of TcpP. This observation is consistent with TcpP being partially degraded in the absence of YaeL. A mutant lacking both DegS and YaeL continued to accumulate the TcpP degradation product, indicating that protease other than DegS is acting before YaeL in degrading TcpP. The YaeL-dependent degradation pathway is active in TcpH(+) cells under conditions that are not favorable for virulence gene activation. This work expands the knowledge of YaeL-dependent processing in the bacterial cell and reveals an unexpected layer of virulence gene regulation in V. cholerae.

The EAL domain protein VieA is a cyclic diguanylate phosphodiesterase

The newly recognized bacterial second messenger 3',5'-cyclic diguanylic acid (cyclic diguanylate (c-di-GMP)) has been shown to regulate a wide variety of bacterial behaviors and traits. Biosynthesis and degradation of c-di-GMP have been attributed to the GGDEF and EAL protein domains, respectively, based primarily on genetic evidence. Whereas the GGDEF domain was demonstrated to possess diguanylate cyclase activity in vitro, the EAL domain has not been tested directly for c-di-GMP phosphodiesterase activity. This study describes the analysis of c-di-GMP hydrolysis by an EAL domain protein in a purified system. The Vibrio cholerae EAL domain protein VieA has been shown to inversely regulate biofilm-specific genes (vps) and virulence genes (ctxA), presumably by decreasing the cellular pool of c-di-GMP. VieA was maximally active at neutral pH, physiological ionic strength, and ambient temperatures and demonstrated c-di-GMP hydrolytic activity with a Km of 0.06 microM. VieA was unable to hydrolyze cGMP. The putative metal coordination site of the EAL domain, Glu170, was demonstrated to be necessary for VieA activity. Furthermore, the divalent cations Mg2+ and Mn2+ were necessary for VieA activity; conversely, Ca2+ and Zn2+ were potent inhibitors of the VieA phosphodiesterase. Calcium inhibition of the VieA EAL domain provides a potential mechanism for regulation of c-di-GMP degradation.

A ToxR-based two-hybrid system for the detection of periplasmic and cytoplasmic protein-protein interactions in Escherichia coli: minimal requirements for specific DNA binding and transcriptional activation

The Vibrio cholerae transcriptional regulator ToxR is anchored in the cytoplasmic membrane by a single transmembrane segment, its C-terminal domain facing the periplasm. Most of its N-terminal cytoplasmic domain shares sequence similarity with the winged helix-turn-helix (wHTH) motif of OmpR-like transcriptional regulators. In the heterologous host Escherichia coli ToxR activates transcription at the V.cholerae ctx promoter in a dimerization-dependent manner, which has led to its employment as a genetic indicator for protein-protein interactions. However, although offering a broader potential application range than other prokaryotic two-hybrid systems described to date, ToxR has so far only been used to study interactions between heterologous transmembrane segments or to monitor homodimerization of C-terminal fusion partners in the periplasm and the cytoplasm of E.coli. Here we show that the ToxR-system also allows the detection of heterodimerization in both cellular compartments of E.coli. In addition, to better understand ToxR's mode of action at ctx in E.coli, we have investigated the minimal requirements for its function as a transcriptional activator. We show that the wHTH motif of ToxR's N-terminal domain constitutes the minimal structural element required to activate transcription at ctx in E.coli when fused to a dimerizing protein module.

Bile acids induce cholera toxin expression in Vibrio cholerae in a ToxT-independent manner

The production of cholera toxin (CT) during Vibrio cholerae infection results in the hallmark diarrhea that characterizes the disease cholera. The transmembrane protein ToxR was originally identified as a functional transcriptional activator of ctxAB in a heterologous Escherichia coli system. However, direct ToxR activation of the ctxAB promoter in V. cholerae has not been previously demonstrated. Instead, a regulatory cascade has been defined in which the activators ToxRS and TcpPH modulate ctxAB expression by acting in concert to transcriptionally activate another regulator, ToxT. ToxT, in turn, directly activates ctxAB expression as well as expression of the tcp genes and other virulence-associated genes. In this study, we show that ToxRS directly activates ctxAB in a ToxT-independent manner in a classical biotype V. cholerae, and that this activation requires the presence of bile acids. Although the levels of CT induced by this mechanism are lower than levels induced under other in vitro conditions, the bile-dependent conditions described here are more physiologic, being independent of pH and temperature. We further show that the inability of bile acids to stimulate ToxRS-dependent expression of CT in El Tor biotype strains is related to the differences between classical and El Tor ctxAB promoters, which differ in the number of heptad TTTTGAT repeats in their respective upstream regions. The ability of bile acids to stimulate direct activation of ctxAB by ToxRS depends upon the transmembrane domain of ToxR, which may interact with bile acids in the inner membrane of V. cholerae.

TcpH influences virulence gene expression in Vibrio cholerae by inhibiting degradation of the transcription activator TcpP

Expression of toxT, the transcription activator of cholera toxin and pilus production in Vibrio cholerae, is the consequence of a complex cascade of regulatory events that culminates in activation of the toxT promoter by TcpP and ToxR, two membrane-localized transcription factors. Both are encoded in operons with genes whose products, TcpH and ToxS, which are also membrane localized, are hypothesized to control their activity. In this study we analyzed the role of TcpH in controlling TcpP function. We show that a mutant of V. cholerae lacking TcpH expressed virtually undetectable levels of TcpP, although tcpP mRNA levels remain unaffected. A time course experiment showed that levels of TcpP, expressed from a plasmid, are dramatically reduced over time without co-overexpression of TcpH. By contrast, deletion of toxS did not affect ToxR protein levels. A fusion protein in which the TcpP periplasmic domain is replaced with that of ToxR remains stable, suggesting that the periplasmic domain of TcpP is the target for degradation of the protein. Placement of the periplasmic domain of TcpP on ToxR, an otherwise stable protein, results in instability, providing further evidence for the hypothesis that the periplasmic domain of TcpP is a target for degradation. Consistent with this interpretation is our finding that derivatives of TcpP lacking a periplasmic domain are more stable in V. cholerae than are derivatives in which the periplasmic domain has been truncated. This work identifies at least one role for the periplasmic domain of TcpP, i.e., to act as a target for a protein degradation pathway that regulates TcpP levels. It also provides a rationale for why the V. cholerae tcpH mutant strain is avirulent. We hypothesize that regulator degradation may be an important mechanism for regulating virulence gene expression in V. cholerae.

Membrane localization of the ToxR winged-helix domain is required for TcpP-mediated virulence gene activation in Vibrio cholerae

ToxR is a bitopic membrane protein that controls virulence gene expression in Vibrio cholerae. Its cytoplasmic domain is homologous to the winged helix-turn-helix ('winged helix') DNA-binding/transcription activation domain found in a variety of prokaryotic and eukaryotic regulators, whereas its periplasmic domain is of ill-defined function. Several genes in V. cholerae are regulated by ToxR, but by apparently different mechanisms. Whereas ToxR directly controls the transcription of genes encoding two outer membrane proteins, OmpU and OmpT, it co-operates with a second membrane-localized transcription factor called TcpP to activate transcription of the gene encoding ToxT, which regulates transcription of cholera toxin (ctxAB) and the toxin-co-regulated pilus (tcp). To determine the requirements for gene activation by ToxR, different domains of the protein were analysed for their ability to control expression of toxT, ompU and ompT. Soluble forms of the cytoplasmic winged-helix domain regulated ompU and ompT gene expression properly but did not activate toxT transcription. Membrane localization of the winged helix was sufficient for both omp gene regulation and TcpP-dependent toxT transcription, irrespective of the type of periplasmic domain or even the presence of a periplasmic domain. These results suggest that (i) the major function for membrane localization of ToxR is for its winged-helix domain to co-operate with TcpP to activate transcription; (ii) the periplasmic domain of ToxR is not required for TcpP-dependent activation of toxT transcription; and (iii) membrane localization is not a strict requirement for DNA binding and transcription activation by ToxR.

A novel cytology-based, two-hybrid screen for bacteria applied to protein-protein interaction studies of a type IV secretion system

DivIVA of Bacillus subtilis and FtsZ of Escherichia coli were used to target heterologous protein complexes to cell division sites of E. coli and Agrobacterium tumefaciens. DivIVA and FtsZ that were fused to the dimerizing leucine zipper (LZ) domain of the yeast transcription activator GCN4 directed the green fluorescent protein (GFP) that was fused to an LZ domain to E. coli division sites, resulting in fluorescence patterns identical to those observed with DivIVA::GFP and FtsZ::GFP. These cell division proteins also targeted the VirE1 chaperone and VirE2 secretion substrate complex to division sites of E. coli and A. tumefaciens. Coproduction of the native VirE1 or VirE2 proteins inhibited the dihybrid interaction in both species, as judged by loss of GFP targeting to division sites. The VirE1 chaperone bound independently to N- and C-terminal regions of VirE2, with a requirement for residues 84 to 147 and 331 to 405 for these interactions, as shown by dihybrid studies with VirE1::GFP and DivIVA fused to N- and C-terminal VirE2 fragments. DivIVA also targeted homo- and heterotypic complexes of VirB8 and VirB10, two bitopic inner membrane subunits of the A. tumefaciens T-DNA transfer system, in E. coli and homotypic complexes of VirB10 in A. tumefaciens. VirB10 self-association in bacteria was mediated by the C-terminal periplasmic domain, as shown by dihybrid studies with fusions to VirB10 truncation derivatives. Together, our findings establish a proof-of-concept for the use of cell-location-specific proteins for studies of interactions among cytosolic and membrane proteins in diverse bacterial species.

Two-hybrid systems and their usage in infection biology

Two-hybrid systems are powerful tools to study protein-protein interactions in biological systems. The role of protein-protein interactions involved in pathogenesis of bacterial and viral infections were defined by using yeast or bacterial two-hybrid screens. Examples are given to highlight the specificity of interactions in signaling pathways, in regulation, secretion and structure-function relationships of virulence factors and their cellular targets. Two-hybrid systems were also used to establish large-scale protein interaction maps of viral and bacterial pathogens, that might be useful to identify targets for new drugs or vaccines.

Bacterial virulence gene regulation: an evolutionary perspective

Coevolution between bacteria and their plant or animal hosts determines characteristics of the interaction, the bacterial virulence genes involved, and the regulatory systems controlling expression of virulence genes. The long-standing association between Salmonellae and their animal hosts has resulted in the acquisition by Salmonella subspecies of a variety of virulence genes and the evolution of complex regulatory networks. The particular repertoire of virulence genes acquired by different Salmonella enterica subspecies and the regulatory systems that control them dictate subspecies-specific infection characteristics. Although the association between Vibrio cholerae and humans appears to be more recent, to reflect a simpler pathogenic strategy, and to involve fewer virulence genes than that of Salmonellae, complex virulence-regulatory networks have nonetheless evolved. In contrast, there is no evidence for acquisition of virulence genes by horizontal gene transfer in bordetellae, and their virulence regulon is less complex in overall structure than those of salmonellae and Vibrio cholerae. In Bordetellae, subspecies-specific differences in pathogenic strategy appear to result from differential gene expression within and across Bordetella subspecies.

Genetic systems for analyzing protein-protein interactions in bacteria

Analysis of protein-protein interactions has been revolutionized by the yeast two-hybrid system introduced by Fields and coworkers. In recent years, similar genetic assays have been developed in bacteria. We describe here several of these systems and highlight some potential applications of these technologies.

Characterization of vibrio cholerae O1 antigen as the bacteriophage K139 receptor and identification of IS1004 insertions aborting O1 antigen biosynthesis

Bacteriophage K139 was recently characterized as a temperate phage of O1 Vibrio cholerae. In this study we have determined the phage adsorption site on the bacterial cell surface. Phage-binding studies with purified lipopolysaccharide (LPS) of different O1 serotypes and biotypes revealed that the O1 antigen serves as the phage receptor. In addition, phage-resistant O1 El Tor strains were screened by using a virulent isolate of phage K139. Analysis of the LPS of such spontaneous phage-resistant mutants revealed that most of them synthesize incomplete LPS molecules, composed of either defective O1 antigen or core oligosaccharide. By applying phage-binding studies, it was possible to distinguish between receptor mutants and mutations which probably caused abortion of later steps of phage infection. Furthermore, we investigated the genetic nature of O1-negative strains by Southern hybridization with probes specific for the O antigen biosynthesis cluster (rfb region). Two of the investigated O1 antigen-negative mutants revealed insertions of element IS1004 into the rfb gene cluster. Treating one wbeW::IS1004 serum-sensitive mutant with normal human serum, we found that several survivors showed precise excision of IS1004, restoring O antigen biosynthesis and serum resistance. Investigation of clinical isolates by screening for phage resistance and performing LPS analysis of nonlysogenic strains led to the identification of a strain with decreased O1 antigen presentation. This strain had a significant reduction in its ability to colonize the mouse small intestine.

Vibrio vulnificus has the transmembrane transcription activator ToxRS stimulating the expression of the hemolysin gene vvhA

In an attempt to dissect the virulence regulatory mechanism in Vibrio vulnificus, we tried to identify the V. cholerae transmembrane virulence regulator toxRS (toxRS(Vc)) homologs in V. vulnificus. By comparing the sequences of toxRS of V. cholerae and V. parahaemolyticus (toxRS(Vp)), we designed a degenerate primer set targeting well-conserved sequences. Using the PCR product as an authentic probe for Southern blot hybridization, a 1.6-kb BglII-HindIII fragment and a 1.2-kb HindIII fragment containing two complete open reading frames and one partial open reading frame attributable to toxR(Vv), toxS(Vv), and htpG(Vv) were cloned. ToxR(Vv) shared 55.0 and 63.0% sequence homology with ToxR(Vc) and ToxR(Vp), respectively. ToxS(Vv) was 71.5 and 65.7% homologous to ToxS(Vc) and ToxS(Vp), respectively. The amino acid sequences of ToxRS(Vv) showed transmembrane and activity domains similar to those observed in ToxRS(Vc) and ToxRS(Vp). Western blot analysis proved the expression of ToxR(Vv) in V. vulnificus. ToxRS(Vv) enhanced, in an Escherichia coli background, the expression of the V. vulnificus hemolysin gene (vvhA) fivefold. ToxRS(Vv) also activated the ToxR(Vc)-regulated ctx promoter incorporated into an E. coli chromosome. A toxR(Vv) null mutation decreased hemolysin production. The defect in hemolysin production could be complemented by a plasmid harboring the wild-type gene. The toxR(Vv) mutation also showed a reversed outer membrane protein expression profile in comparison to the isogenic wild-type strain. These results demonstrate that ToxR(Vv) may regulate the virulence expression of V. vulnificus.

Escherichia coli one- and two-hybrid systems for the analysis and identification of protein-protein interactions

Genetic methods based on fusion proteins allow the power of a genetic approach to be applied to the self-assembly of proteins or protein fragments, regardless of whether or not the normal function of the fused assembly domains is either known or amenable to selection or screening. The widespread adoption of variations of the yeast two-hybrid system originally described by S. Fields and O. Song (1989, Nature 340, 245-246) demonstrates the usefulness of these kinds of assays. This review describes some of the many systems used to select or screen for protein-protein interactions based on the regulation of reporter constructs by hybrid proteins expressed in bacteria, including recent implementations of generalizable two-hybrid systems for Escherichia coli.

Genetic rearrangements of the regions adjacent to genes encoding heat-labile enterotoxins (eltAB) of enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli strains

One of the most common bacterially mediated diarrheal infections is caused by enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli (ETEC) strains. ETEC-derived plasmids are responsible for the distribution of the genes encoding the main toxins, namely, the heat-labile and heat-stable enterotoxins. The origins and transfer modes (intra- or interplasmid) of the toxin-encoding genes have not been characterized in detail. In this study, we investigated the DNA regions located near the heat-labile enterotoxin-encoding genes (eltAB) of several clinical isolates. It was found that the eltAB region is flanked by conserved 236- and 280-bp regions, followed by highly variable DNA sequences which consist mainly of partial insertion sequence (IS) elements. Furthermore, we demonstrated that rearrangements of the eltAB region of one particular isolate, which harbors an IS91R sequence next to eltAB, could be produced by a recA-independent but IS91 sequence-dependent mechanism. Possible mechanisms of dissemination of IS element-associated enterotoxin-encoding genes are discussed.

Dimerization of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB4 ATPase and the effect of ATP-binding cassette mutations on the assembly and function of the T-DNA transporter

The Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB4 ATPase functions with other VirB proteins to export T-DNA to susceptible plant cells and other DNA substrates to a variety of prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. Previous studies have demonstrated that VirB4 mutants with defects in the Walker A nucleotide-binding motif are non-functional and exert a dominant negative phenotype when synthesized in wild-type cells. This study characterized the oligomeric structure of VirB4 and examined the effects of Walker A sequence mutations on complex formation and transporter activity. VirB4 directed dimer formation when fused to the amino-terminal portion of cI repressor protein, as shown by immunity of Escherichia coli cells to lambda phage infection. VirB4 also dimerized in Agrobacterium tumefaciens, as demonstrated by the recovery of a detergent-resistant complex of native protein and a functional, histidine-tagged derivative by precipitation with anti-His6 antibodies and by Co2+ affinity chromatography. Walker A sequence mutants directed repressor dimerization in E. coli and interacted with His-VirB4 in A. tumefaciens, indicating that ATP binding is not required for self-association. A dimerization domain was localized to a proposed N-terminal membrane-spanning region of VirB4, as shown by the dominance of an allele coding for the N-terminal 312 residues and phage immunity of host cells expressing cI repressor fusions to alleles for the first 237 or 312 residues. A recent study reported that the synthesis of a subset of VirB proteins, including VirB4, in agrobacterial recipients has a pronounced stimulatory effect on the virB-dependent conjugal transfer of plasmid RSF1010 by agrobacterial donors. VirB4'312 suppressed the stimulatory effect of VirB proteins for DNA uptake when synthesized in recipient cells. In striking contrast, Walker A sequence mutants contributed to the stimulatory effect of VirB proteins to the same extent as native VirB4. These findings indicate that the oligomeric structure of VirB4, but not its capacity to bind ATP, is important for the assembly of VirB proteins as a DNA uptake system. The results of these studies support a model in which VirB4 dimers or homomultimers contribute structural information for the assembly of a transenvelope channel competent for bidirectional DNA transfer, whereas an ATP-dependent activity is required for configuring this channel as a dedicated export machine.

ToxR co-operative interactions are not modulated by environmental conditions or periplasmic domain conformation

ToxR is a transmembrane regulatory protein that controls virulence gene expression in Vibrio cholerae. Previous experiments using lambda repressor-ToxR chimeric proteins and a lambda repressor-controlled reporter system (OR1 PR-lacZY) established that ToxR sequences can effectively dimerize the amino-terminal domain of lambda repressor in Escherichia coli. However, in E. coli, ToxR does not respond to environmental signals that control virulence gene expression in V. cholerae. Here, we report the results of experiments designed to test whether environmental signals that modulate virulence gene expression in V. cholerae also modulate a monomer to dimerization transition of lambda-ToxR chimeras. When the OR1 PR-lacZY reporter fusion and chimeric proteins were transferred to V. cholerae, we unexpectedly found that lambda-ToxR chimeras did not dimerize significantly. Interestingly, experiments evaluating the ability of lambda-ToxR proteins to form tetramers in E. coli suggested that lambda-ToxR dimers could act co-operatively. Using a redesigned reporter system containing multiple lambda operator sites (OR1 OR2 OR3 PR-lacZY), we found that lambda-ToxR could dimerize quite efficiently in V. cholerae. These data imply that multiple DNA binding sites might enhance the ability of ToxR to dimerize in V. cholerae and suggest that ToxR dimers might be capable of co-operative interactions. However, we falled to correlate a monomer-dimer transition of the lambda-ToxR chimeras with changes in virulence gene expression in response to environmental signals in V. cholerae. Finally, because of conflicting results in the literature, the importance of membrane localization of ToxR and dimerization of the ToxR periplasmic domain was re-evaluated. This was accomplished by measuring the ability of various chimeric proteins to activate toxin gene expression in both E. coli and V. cholerae. These assays suggest that, in V. cholerae, deletion of the transmembrane domain has a profound effect on ToxR activity, although it is not an absolute requirement when ToxR is dimerized by a heterologous domain. In addition, we noted differences in chimeric protein activity when expressed in E. coli and V. cholerae. A construct substituting the monomeric MalE domain for the periplasmic domain of ToxR was unable to activate a ctx::lacZ reporter fusion in E. coli. Although the addition of leucine zipper sequences to this construct resulted in enhanced activity of the chimera in E. coli, both chimeras were able to produce wild-type levels of toxin in V. cholerae. These data support the notion that dimerization of ToxR stimulates its activity as a transcriptional activator in E. coli. In V. cholerae, however, we present data that do not demonstrate a correlation between dimerization of the periplasmic domain and ToxR activity.

In vivo transposon mutagenesis in Haemophilus influenzae

In order to devise an in vivo insertion mutagenesis scheme for Haemophilus influenzae, a novel set of transposons has been constructed. These are Tn10-based minitransposons carried on pACYC184- and pACYC177-based replicons, which are suitable for in vivo transposition in H. influenzae. The transposon delivery system was designed to contain an H. influenzae-specific uptake signal sequence which facilitates DNA transformation into H. influenzae. The following mini-Tn10 elements have been made suitable for specific tasks in H. influenzae: (i) Tn10d-cat, which can be used to generate chloramphenicol-selectable insertion mutations; (ii) Tn10d-bla, an ampicillin-selectable translational fusion system allowing the detection of membrane or secreted proteins; and (iii) Tn10d-lacZcat, a chloramphenicol-selectable lacZ transcriptional fusion system. For the rapid identification of the transposon insertions, a PCR fragment enrichment method was developed. This report demonstrates that this in vivo mutagenesis technique is a convenient tool for the analysis of biochemical and regulatory pathways in the human pathogen H. influenzae.

Lambda repressor N-terminal DNA-binding domain as an assay for protein transmembrane segment interactions in vivo

To understand the determinants of membrane protein interactions, we have developed an in vivo genetic assay system for detecting homodimerization of transmembrane (TM) segments from integral membrane proteins. Our approach is to generate gene fusions between potentially dimerizing TM segments and a cytoplasmic DNA-binding protein that lacks its intrinsic dimerization domain. This genetic approach allows us to screen and distinguish among known dimerizing domains and weakly dimerizing mutants, as well as non-dimerizing TM segments. We replaced the bacteriophage lambda cI repressor C-terminal dimerization domain with the human erythrocyte glycophorin A transmembrane segment (GpA TM). GpA TM forms SDS-resistant homodimers in vitro. Expression of this membrane-associated fusion in Escherichia coli conferred the same degree of immunity to lambda cI phages as the wild-type, intact lambda repressor. Single amino acid substitutions that disrupt the GpA TM dimer interface were introduced into the lambda-GpA TM fusion proteins. These mutations dramatically reduced immunity of E. coli to lambda cI, such that the efficiency of plating these phages increased by greater than 10,000-fold over that conferred by the wild-type lambda-GpA TM fusion. Introduction of the putatively non-dimerizing first TM from E. coli MalF into the lambda-TM fusion vector resulted in no immunity to lambda cI phages. Fusion of the homodimeric, periplasmically localized, mature alkaline phosphatase domain to the C terminus of the lambda-TM fusion proteins containing weakly to non-dimerizing TM segments restored immunity to lambda cI phages. Results from this in vivo genetic assay system demonstrate that (1) dimerization of the lambda cI DNA-binding domain can be promoted by dimerizing TM segments, (2) strongly, weakly, and non-dimerizing TM segments can be distinguished on the basis of their ability to confer immunity to lambda cI phages, and (3) introduction of a dimerizing periplasmic domain can provide functionality to lambda-TM fusions containing weakly to non-dimerizing TM segments.

Analysis of ToxR-dependent transcription activation of ompU, the gene encoding a major envelope protein in Vibrio cholerae

The membrane proteins ToxR and ToxS regulate a variety of genes associated with the virulence of Vibrio cholerae, the agent of human cholera. One of the ToxRS-regulated genes is the ompU gene, which encodes a porin that may also act as an adhesin. To begin to understand the mechanism of ompU transcription activation by ToxRS, we performed genetic and biochemical studies on the ompU promoter. Deletions with a 5' end-point at or downstream of -128, relative to the start site for transcription, did not direct expression of a lacZ reporter gene in wild-type V. cholerae, although the -128 promoter fragment did direct ToxRS-dependent reporter gene activity under conditions of ToxR overexpression in E. coli. Consistent with the activation data is that membranes containing ToxR and ToxS caused a gel electrophoretic mobility shift when mixed at low concentrations with deletion fragments whose end-point is at -211, but not with -128 or -68 fragments. ToxRS membranes did shift the -128 fragment when added at higher concentrations. DNase I footprinting analysis of ompU promoter DNA complexed with ToxRS membranes demonstrated protection of three sites: an upstream site ranging from -238 to -139, and two downstream sites ranging from -116 to -58 and -53 to -24. Within the DNA protected from DNase I digestion by ToxRS membranes, there are no elements bearing similarity to those identified previously within the promoters of two other ToxR-dependent genes, ctxA and toxT. We suggest a model for transcription activation that involves sequential ToxR-binding events to distinct regions in the ompU promoter.

Changes in the periplasmic linker and in the expression level affect the activity of ToxR and lambda-ToxR fusion proteins in Escherichia coli

In order to assess the potentiality of Vibrio cholerae ToxR protein and of bacteriophage lambda repressor as indicators of the dimerization of periplasmic proteins in Escherichia coli, we have constructed a series of plasmids encoding transmembrane fusion proteins. The amino-terminal part, containing the DNA binding domain of either ToxR or lambda repressor, is located in the cytoplasm and acts as reporter for dimerization. As models of periplasmic proteins we have used alkaline phosphatase (a dimer) and beta-lactamase (a monomer). Both the expression level and the distance between the transmembrane segment and the periplasmic protein substantially affect the activity of the reporter domains.

Genetic analysis of the interaction between Vibrio cholerae transcription activator ToxR and toxT promoter DNA

Expression of many virulence genes in Vibrio cholerae is under the control of the ToxT protein. These include genes whose products are required for the biogenesis of the toxin-coregulated pilus, accessory colonization factor, and cholera toxin. ToxT is a member of the AraC family of transcriptional activators and is part of the ToxR regulatory cascade. ToxR is a transmembrane DNA-binding protein that is required for transcription of toxT and also can directly activate transcription of the cholera toxin operon (ctxAB). The sequences upstream of ctxAB and toxT to which ToxR binds show no obvious similarity, which implies that ToxR may be recognizing a degenerate sequence or, alternatively, a common structural motif within both binding sites. Data presented in this report demonstrate that nucleotides within the upstream half-site of an inverted repeat element in the toxT promoter are critical for ToxR-regulated activation of transcription in V. cholerae. In addition, gene fusion and DNA-binding studies with mutant ToxR proteins indicate that residues of ToxR required for binding to the ctx promoter are also required for binding to the toxT promoter. These data suggest that ToxR is not recognizing an inverted repeat sequence per se in the activation of toxT but, rather, some motif composed in part of sequences within the upstream half-site of the inverted repeat and that ToxR recognizes similar motifs within the ctxAB and toxT promoters.

The ToxR protein of Vibrio cholerae forms homodimers and heterodimers

The ToxR protein of Vibrio cholerae regulates the expression of several virulence factors that play important roles in the pathogenesis of cholera. Previous experiments with ToxR-alkaline phosphatase (ToxR-PhoA) fusion proteins suggested a model for gene regulation in which the inactive form of ToxR was a monomer and the active form of ToxR was a dimer (V. L. Miller, R. K. Taylor, and J. J. Mekalanos, Cell 48:271-279, 1987). In order to examine whether ToxR exists in a dimeric form in vivo, biochemical cross-linking analyses were carried out. Different dimeric cross-linked species were detected depending on the expression level of ToxR: when overexpressed, ToxR+ToxR homodimers and ToxR+ToxS heterodimers were detected, and when ToxR was expressed at normal levels, exclusively ToxR+ToxS heterodimers were detected. The amount of overexpression was quantitated by using ToxR-PhoA fusion proteins and was found to correspond to 2.7-fold the normal level of ToxR. The formation of both homodimeric ToxR species and heterodimeric ToxR+ToxS species is consistent with previously reported genetic data that suggested that both types of ToxR oligomeric interactions occur. However, variation in the amount of either the homodimeric or heterodimeric form detectable by this cross-linking analysis was not observed to correlate with laboratory culture conditions known to modulate ToxR activity. Thus, genetic and biochemical data indicate that ToxR is able to interact with both itself and ToxS but that these interactions may not explain mechanistically the observed changes in ToxR activity that occur in response to environmental conditions.