Search for poly(A) polymerase targets in E. coli reveals its implication in surveillance of Glu tRNA processing and degradation of stable RNAs

Poly(A) tale: From A to A; RNA polyadenylation in prokaryotes and eukaryotes

Most eukaryotic mRNAs and different non-coding RNAs undergo a form of 3' end processing known as polyadenylation. Polyadenylation machinery is present in almost all organisms except few species. In bacteria, the machinery has evolved from PNPase, which adds heteropolymeric tails, to a poly(A)-specific polymerase. Differently, a complex machinery for accurate polyadenylation and several non-canonical poly(A) polymerases are developed in eukaryotes. The role of poly(A) tail has also evolved from serving as a degradative signal to a stabilizing modification that also regulates translation. In this review, we discuss poly(A) tail emergence in prokaryotes and its development into a stable, yet dynamic feature at the 3' end of mRNAs in eukaryotes. We also describe how appearance of novel poly(A) polymerases gives cells flexibility to shape poly(A) tail. We explain how poly(A) tail dynamics help regulate cognate RNA metabolism in a context-dependent manner, such as during oocyte maturation. Finally, we describe specific mRNAs in metazoans that bear stem-loops instead of poly(A) tails. We conclude with how recent discoveries about poly(A) tail can be applied to mRNA technology. This article is categorized under: RNA Evolution and Genomics > RNA and Ribonucleoprotein Evolution RNA Processing > 3' End Processing RNA Turnover and Surveillance > Regulation of RNA Stability.

Tyrosine phosphorylation controlled poly(A) polymerase I activity regulates general stress response in bacteria

RNA 3'-end polyadenylation that marks transcripts for degradation is implicated in general stress response in Escherichia coli Yet, the mechanism and regulation of poly(A) polymerase I (PAPI) in stress response are obscure. We show that pcnB (that encodes PAPI)-null mutation widely stabilises stress response mRNAs and imparts cellular tolerance to multiple stresses, whereas PAPI ectopic expression renders cells stress-sensitive. We demonstrate that there is a substantial loss of PAPI activity on stress exposure that functionally phenocopies pcnB-null mutation stabilising target mRNAs. We identify PAPI tyrosine phosphorylation at the 202 residue (Y202) that is enormously enhanced on stress exposure. This phosphorylation inhibits PAPI polyadenylation activity under stress. Consequentially, PAPI phosphodeficient mutation (tyrosine 202 to phenylalanine, Y202F) fails to stimulate mRNA expression rendering cells stress-sensitive. Bacterial tyrosine kinase Wzc phosphorylates PAPI-Y202 residue, and that wzc-null mutation renders cells stress-sensitive. Accordingly, wzc-null mutation has no effect on stress sensitivity in the presence of pcnB-null or pcnB-Y202F mutation. We also establish that PAPI phosphorylation-dependent stress tolerance mechanism is distinct and operates downstream of the primary stress regulator RpoS.

Acquisition of pcnB [poly(A) polymerase I] genes via horizontal transfer from the β, γ-Proteobacteria

Poly(A) polymerases (PAPs) and tRNA nucleotidyltransferases belong to a superfamily of nucleotidyltransferases and modify RNA 3'-ends. The product of the pcnB gene, PAP I, has been characterized in a few β-, γ- and δ-Proteobacteria. Using the PAP I signature sequence, putative PAPs were identified in bacterial species from the α- and ε-Proteobacteria and from four other bacterial phyla (Firmicutes, Actinobacteria, Bacteroidetes and Aquificae). Phylogenetic analysis, alien index and G+C content calculations strongly suggest that the PAPs in the species identified in this study arose by horizontal gene transfer from the β- and γ-Proteobacteria.

The Bacterial Ro60 Protein and Its Noncoding Y RNA Regulators

Ro60 ribonucleoproteins (RNPs), composed of the ring-shaped Ro 60-kDa (Ro60) protein and noncoding RNAs called Y RNAs, are present in all three domains of life. Ro60 was first described as an autoantigen in patients with rheumatic disease, and Ro60 orthologs have been identified in 3% to 5% of bacterial genomes, spanning the majority of phyla. Their functions have been characterized primarily in Deinococcus radiodurans, the first sequenced bacterium with a recognizable ortholog. In D. radiodurans, the Ro60 ortholog enhances the ability of 3'-to-5' exoribonucleases to degrade structured RNA during several forms of environmental stress. Y RNAs are regulators that inhibit or allow the interactions of Ro60 with other proteins and RNAs. Studies of Ro60 RNPs in other bacteria hint at additional functions, since the most conserved Y RNA contains a domain that is a close tRNA mimic and Ro60 RNPs are often encoded adjacent to components of RNA repair systems.

Polyadenylation and degradation of structurally abnormal mitochondrial tRNAs in human cells

RNA 3' polyadenylation is known to serve diverse purposes in biology, in particular, regulating mRNA stability and translation. Here we determined that, upon exposure to high levels of the intercalating agent ethidium bromide (EtBr), greater than those required to suppress mitochondrial transcription, mitochondrial tRNAs in human cells became polyadenylated. Relaxation of the inducing stress led to rapid turnover of the polyadenylated tRNAs. The extent, kinetics and duration of tRNA polyadenylation were EtBr dose-dependent, with mitochondrial tRNAs differentially sensitive to the stress. RNA interference and inhibitor studies indicated that ongoing mitochondrial ATP synthesis, plus the mitochondrial poly(A) polymerase and SUV3 helicase were required for tRNA polyadenylation, while polynucleotide phosphorylase counteracted the process and was needed, along with SUV3, for degradation of the polyadenylated tRNAs. Doxycycline treatment inhibited both tRNA polyadenylation and turnover, suggesting a possible involvement of the mitoribosome, although other translational inhibitors had only minor effects. The dysfunctional tRNALeu(UUR) bearing the pathological A3243G mutation was constitutively polyadenylated at a low level, but this was markedly enhanced after doxycycline treatment. We propose that polyadenylation of structurally and functionally abnormal mitochondrial tRNAs entrains their PNPase/SUV3-mediated destruction, and that this pathway could play an important role in mitochondrial diseases associated with tRNA mutations.

Distributive enzyme binding controlled by local RNA context results in 3' to 5' directional processing of dicistronic tRNA precursors by Escherichia coli ribonuclease P

RNA processing by ribonucleases and RNA modifying enzymes often involves sequential reactions of the same enzyme on a single precursor transcript. In Escherichia coli, processing of polycistronic tRNA precursors involves separation into individual pre-tRNAs by one of several ribonucleases followed by 5′ end maturation by ribonuclease P. A notable exception are valine and lysine tRNAs encoded by three polycistronic precursors that follow a recently discovered pathway involving initial 3′ to 5′ directional processing by RNase P. Here, we show that the dicistronic precursor containing tRNA^valV and tRNA^valW undergoes accurate and efficient 3′ to 5′ directional processing by RNase P in vitro. Kinetic analyses reveal a distributive mechanism involving dissociation of the enzyme between the two cleavage steps. Directional processing is maintained despite swapping or duplicating the two tRNAs consistent with inhibition of processing by 3′ trailer sequences. Structure-function studies identify a stem–loop in 5′ leader of tRNA^valV that inhibits RNase P cleavage and further enforces directional processing. The results demonstrate that directional processing is an intrinsic property of RNase P and show how RNA sequence and structure context can modulate reaction rates in order to direct precursors along specific pathways.

RNA polyadenylation and its consequences in prokaryotes

Post-transcriptional addition of poly(A) tails to the 3' end of RNA is one of the fundamental events controlling the functionality and fate of RNA in all kingdoms of life. Although an enzyme with poly(A)-adding activity was discovered in Escherichia coli more than 50 years ago, its existence and role in prokaryotic RNA metabolism were neglected for many years. As a result, it was not until 1992 that E. coli poly(A) polymerase I was purified to homogeneity and its gene was finally identified. Further work revealed that, similar to its role in surveillance of aberrant nuclear RNAs of eukaryotes, the addition of poly(A) tails often destabilizes prokaryotic RNAs and their decay intermediates, thus facilitating RNA turnover. Moreover, numerous studies carried out over the last three decades have shown that polyadenylation greatly contributes to the control of prokaryotic gene expression by affecting the steady-state level of diverse protein-coding and non-coding transcripts including antisense RNAs involved in plasmid copy number control, expression of toxin-antitoxin systems and bacteriophage development. Here, we review the main findings related to the discovery of polyadenylation in prokaryotes, isolation, and characterization and regulation of bacterial poly(A)-adding activities, and discuss the impact of polyadenylation on prokaryotic mRNA metabolism and gene expression.This article is part of the theme issue '5' and 3' modifications controlling RNA degradation'.

Polynucleotide phosphorylase: Not merely an RNase but a pivotal post-transcriptional regulator

Almost 60 years ago, Severo Ochoa was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his discovery of the enzymatic synthesis of RNA by polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase). Although this discovery provided an important tool for deciphering the genetic code, subsequent work revealed that the predominant function of PNPase in bacteria and eukaryotes is catalyzing the reverse reaction, i.e., the release of ribonucleotides from RNA. PNPase has a crucial role in RNA metabolism in bacteria and eukaryotes mainly through its roles in processing and degrading RNAs, but additional functions in RNA metabolism have recently been reported for this enzyme. Here, we discuss these established and noncanonical functions for PNPase and the possibility that the major impact of PNPase on cell physiology is through its unorthodox roles.

Major 3'-5' Exoribonucleases in the Metabolism of Coding and Non-coding RNA

3'-5' exoribonucleases are key enzymes in the degradation of superfluous or aberrant RNAs and in the maturation of precursor RNAs into their functional forms. The major bacterial 3'-5' exoribonucleases responsible for both these activities are PNPase, RNase II and RNase R. These enzymes are of ancient nature with widespread distribution. In eukaryotes, PNPase and RNase II/RNase R enzymes can be found in the cytosol and in mitochondria and chloroplasts; RNase II/RNase R-like enzymes are also found in the nucleus. Humans express one PNPase (PNPT1) and three RNase II/RNase R family members (Dis3, Dis3L and Dis3L2). These enzymes take part in a multitude of RNA surveillance mechanisms that are critical for translation accuracy. Although active against a wide range of both coding and non-coding RNAs, the different 3'-5' exoribonucleases exhibit distinct substrate affinities. The latest studies on these RNA degradative enzymes have contributed to the identification of additional homologue proteins, the uncovering of novel RNA degradation pathways, and to a better comprehension of several disease-related processes and response to stress, amongst many other exciting findings. Here, we provide a comprehensive and up-to-date overview on the function, structure, regulation and substrate preference of the key 3'-5' exoribonucleases involved in RNA metabolism.

Transfer RNA instability as a stress response in Escherichia coli: Rapid dynamics of the tRNA pool as a function of demand

Production of the translation apparatus of E. coli is carefully matched to the demand for protein synthesis posed by a given growth condition. For example, the fraction of RNA polymerases that transcribe rRNA and tRNA drops from 80% during rapid growth to 24% within minutes of a sudden amino acid starvation. We recently reported in Nucleic Acids Research that the tRNA pool is more dynamically regulated than previously thought. In addition to the regulation at the level of synthesis, we found that tRNAs are subject to demand-based regulation at the level of their degradation. In this point-of-view article we address the question of why this phenomenon has not previously been described. We also present data that expands on the mechanism of tRNA degradation, and we discuss the possible implications of tRNA instability for the ability of E. coli to cope with stresses that affect the translation process.

Landscape of RNA polyadenylation in E. coli

Polyadenylation is thought to be involved in the degradation and quality control of bacterial RNAs but relatively few examples have been investigated. We used a combination of 5΄-tagRACE and RNA-seq to analyze the total RNA content from a wild-type strain and from a poly(A)polymerase deleted mutant. A total of 178 transcripts were either up- or down-regulated in the mutant when compared to the wild-type strain. Poly(A)polymerase up-regulates the expression of all genes related to the FliA regulon and several previously unknown transcripts, including numerous transporters. Notable down-regulation of genes in the expression of antigen 43 and components of the type 1 fimbriae was detected. The major consequence of the absence of poly(A)polymerase was the accumulation of numerous sRNAs, antisense transcripts, REP sequences and RNA fragments resulting from the processing of entire transcripts. A new algorithm to analyze the position and composition of post-transcriptional modifications based on the sequence of unencoded 3΄-ends, was developed to identify polyadenylated molecules. Overall our results shed new light on the broad spectrum of action of polyadenylation on gene expression and demonstrate the importance of poly(A) dependent degradation to remove structured RNA fragments.

The small RNA SraG participates in PNPase homeostasis

The rpsO-pnp operon encodes ribosomal protein S15 and polynucleotide phosphorylase, a major 3'-5' exoribonuclease involved in mRNA decay in Escherichia coli The gene for the SraG small RNA is located between the coding regions of the rpsO and pnp genes, and it is transcribed in the opposite direction relative to the two genes. No function has been assigned to SraG. Multiple levels of post-transcriptional regulation have been demonstrated for the rpsO-pnp operon. Here we show that SraG is a new factor affecting pnp expression. SraG overexpression results in a reduction of pnp expression and a destabilization of pnp mRNA; in contrast, inhibition of SraG transcription results in a higher level of the pnp transcript. Furthermore, in vitro experiments indicate that SraG inhibits translation initiation of pnp Together, these observations demonstrate that SraG participates in the post-transcriptional control of pnp by a direct antisense interaction between SraG and PNPase RNAs. Our data reveal a new level of regulation in the expression of this major exoribonuclease.

Oligoadenylation of 3' decay intermediates promotes cytoplasmic mRNA degradation in Drosophila cells

Post-transcriptional 3' end addition of nucleotides is important in a variety of RNA decay pathways. We have examined the 3' end addition of nucleotides during the decay of the Hsp70 mRNA and a corresponding reporter RNA in Drosophila S2 cells by conventional sequencing of cDNAs obtained after mRNA circularization and by deep sequencing of dedicated libraries enriched for 3' decay intermediates along the length of the mRNA. Approximately 5%-10% of 3' decay intermediates carried nonencoded oligo(A) tails with a mean length of 2-3 nucleotides. RNAi experiments showed that the oligoadenylated RNA fragments were intermediates of exosomal decay and the noncanonical poly(A) polymerase Trf4-1 was mainly responsible for A addition. A hot spot of A addition corresponded to an intermediate of 3' decay that accumulated upon inhibition of decapping, and knockdown of Trf4-1 increased the abundance of this intermediate, suggesting that oligoadenylation facilitates 3' decay. Oligoadenylated 3' decay intermediates were found in the cytoplasmic fraction in association with ribosomes, and fluorescence microscopy revealed a cytoplasmic localization of Trf4-1. Thus, oligoadenylation enhances exosomal mRNA degradation in the cytoplasm.

Regulation and functions of bacterial PNPase

Polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase) is an exoribonuclease that catalyzes the processive phosphorolytic degradation of RNA from the 3'-end. The enzyme catalyzes also the reverse reaction of polymerization of nucleoside diphosphates that has been implicated in the generation of heteropolymeric tails at the RNA 3'-end. The enzyme is widely conserved and plays a major role in RNA decay in both Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria. Moreover, it participates in maturation and quality control of stable RNA. PNPase autoregulates its own expression at post-transcriptional level through a complex mechanism that involves the endoribonuclease RNase III and translation control. The activity of PNPase is modulated in an intricate and still unclear manner by interactions with small molecules and recruitment in different multiprotein complexes. Not surprisingly, given the wide spectrum of PNPase substrates, PNPase-defective mutations in different bacterial species have pleiotropic effects and perturb the execution of genetic programs involving drastic changes in global gene expression such as biofilm formation, growth at suboptimal temperatures, and virulence.

Experimental Genome-Wide Determination of RNA Polyadenylation in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The polyadenylation of RNA is a near-universal feature of RNA metabolism in eukaryotes. This process has been studied in the model alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii using low-throughput (gene-by-gene) and high-throughput (transcriptome sequencing) approaches that recovered poly(A)-containing sequence tags which revealed interesting features of this critical process in Chlamydomonas. In this study, RNA polyadenylation has been studied using the so-called Poly(A) Tag Sequencing (PAT-Seq) approach. Specifically, PAT-Seq was used to study poly(A) site choice in cultures grown in four different media types—Tris-Phosphate (TP), Tris-Phosphate-Acetate (TAP), High-Salt (HS), and High-Salt-Acetate (HAS). The results indicate that: 1. As reported before, the motif UGUAA is the primary, and perhaps sole, cis-element that guides mRNA polyadenylation in the nucleus; 2. The scope of alternative polyadenylation events with the potential to change the coding sequences of mRNAs is limited; 3. Changes in poly(A) site choice in cultures grown in the different media types are very few in number and do not affect protein-coding potential; 4. Organellar polyadenylation is considerable and affects primarily ribosomal RNAs in the chloroplast and mitochondria; and 5. Organellar RNA polyadenylation is a dynamic process that is affected by the different media types used for cell growth.

Next generation sequencing analysis reveals that the ribonucleases RNase II, RNase R and PNPase affect bacterial motility and biofilm formation in E. coli

Background

The RNA steady-state levels in the cell are a balance between synthesis and degradation rates. Although transcription is important, RNA processing and turnover are also key factors in the regulation of gene expression. In Escherichia coli there are three main exoribonucleases (RNase II, RNase R and PNPase) involved in RNA degradation. Although there are many studies about these exoribonucleases not much is known about their global effect in the transcriptome.

Results

In order to study the effects of the exoribonucleases on the transcriptome, we sequenced the total RNA (RNA-Seq) from wild-type cells and from mutants for each of the exoribonucleases (∆rnb, ∆rnr and ∆pnp). We compared each of the mutant transcriptome with the wild-type to determine the global effects of the deletion of each exoribonucleases in exponential phase. We determined that the deletion of RNase II significantly affected 187 transcripts, while deletion of RNase R affects 202 transcripts and deletion of PNPase affected 226 transcripts. Surprisingly, many of the transcripts are actually down-regulated in the exoribonuclease mutants when compared to the wild-type control. The results obtained from the transcriptomic analysis pointed to the fact that these enzymes were changing the expression of genes related with flagellum assembly, motility and biofilm formation. The three exoribonucleases affected some stable RNAs, but PNPase was the main exoribonuclease affecting this class of RNAs. We confirmed by qPCR some fold-change values obtained from the RNA-Seq data, we also observed that all the exoribonuclease mutants were significantly less motile than the wild-type cells. Additionally, RNase II and RNase R mutants were shown to produce more biofilm than the wild-type control while the PNPase mutant did not form biofilms.

Conclusions

In this work we demonstrate how deep sequencing can be used to discover new and relevant functions of the exoribonucleases. We were able to obtain valuable information about the transcripts affected by each of the exoribonucleases and compare the roles of the three enzymes. Our results show that the three exoribonucleases affect cell motility and biofilm formation that are two very important factors for cell survival, especially for pathogenic cells.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12864-015-1237-6) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Small stable RNA maturation and turnover in Bacillus subtilis

Stable RNA maturation is a key process in the generation of functional RNAs, and failure to correctly process these RNAs can lead to their elimination through quality control mechanisms. Studies of the maturation pathways of ribosomal RNA and transfer RNA in Bacillus subtilis showed they were radically different from Escherichia coli and led to the identification of new B. subtilis-specific enzymes. We noticed that, despite their important roles in translation, a number of B. subtilis small stable RNAs still did not have characterised maturation pathways, notably the tmRNA, involved in ribosome rescue, and the RNase P RNA, involved in tRNA maturation. Here, we show that tmRNA is matured by RNase P and RNase Z at its 5' and 3' extremities, respectively, whereas the RNase P RNA is matured on its 3' side by RNase Y. Recent evidence that several RNases are not essential in B. subtilis prompted us to revisit maturation of the scRNA, a component of the signal recognition particle involved in co-translational insertion of specific proteins into the membrane. We show that RNase Y is also involved in 3' processing of scRNA. Lastly, we identified some of the enzymes involved in the turnover of these three stable RNAs.

The interplay of Hfq, poly(A) polymerase I and exoribonucleases at the 3' ends of RNAs resulting from Rho-independent termination: A tentative model

Discovered in eukaryotes as a modification essential for mRNA function, polyadenylation was then identified as a means used by all cells to destabilize RNA. In Escherichia coli, most accessible 3' RNA extremities are believed to be potential targets of poly(A) polymerase I. However, some RNAs might be preferentially adenylated. After a short statement of the current knowledge of poly(A) metabolism, we discuss how Hfq could affect recognition and polyadenylation of RNA terminated by Rho-independent terminators. Comparison of RNA terminus leads to the proposal that RNAs harboring 3' terminal features required for Hfq binding are not polyadenylated, whereas those lacking these structural elements can gain the oligo(A) tails that initiate exonucleolytic degradation. We also speculate that Hfq stimulates the synthesis of longer tails that could be used as Hfq-binding sites involved in non-characterized functions of Hfq-dependent sRNAs.

Deregulation of poly(A) polymerase I in Escherichia coli inhibits protein synthesis and leads to cell death

Polyadenylation plays important roles in RNA metabolism in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Surprisingly, deregulation of polyadenylation by poly(A) polymerase I (PAP I) in Escherichia coli leads to toxicity and cell death. We show here that mature tRNAs, which are normally not substrates for PAP I in wild-type cells, are rapidly polyadenylated as PAP I levels increase, leading to dramatic reductions in the fraction of aminoacylated tRNAs, cessation of protein synthesis and cell death. The toxicity associated with PAP I is exacerbated by the absence of either RNase T and/or RNase PH, the two major 3' → 5' exonucleases involved in the final step of tRNA 3'-end maturation, confirming their role in the regulation of tRNA polyadenylation. Furthermore, our data demonstrate that regulation of PAP I is critical not for preventing the decay of mRNAs, but rather for maintaining normal levels of functional tRNAs and protein synthesis in E. coli, a function for polyadenylation that has not been observed previously in any organism.

Role of polyadenylation in regulation of the flagella cascade and motility in Escherichia coli

Polyadenylation is recognized as part of a surveillance machinery for eliminating defective RNA molecules in eukaryotes and prokaryotes. Escherichia coli strains, deficient in poly(A)polymerase I (PAP I), expressed less flagellin compared to wild-type strains. Because flagellin synthesis is a late step in the flagellar biosynthesis pathway, we assessed the role of PAP I in this cascade and in flagella function. Transcription of flhDC, fliA, and fliC was decreased in the PAP I mutant. These results provide evidence that polyadenylation positively controls the expression of genes belonging to the flagellar biosynthesis pathway and that this effect is mediated through the FlhDC master regulator. However, the downshift in flagella gene expression in the mutant strain did not provoke any noticeable defects in the synthesis of flagella, in biofilm formation and in swimming speed although there was a reduction in motility on soft agar. Our data support an alternative hypothesis that the reduced motility of the mutant resulted from an alteration of the cell membrane composition caused in part by the higher level of GlmS (Glucosamine-6P synthase) which accumulates in the mutant. In agreement with this hypothesis the mutant is more sensitive to hydrophobic agents and antibiotics and in particular to vancomycin. We propose that PAP I participates in the ability of the bacteria to adapt to and survive detrimental conditions by constantly monitoring and adjusting to its environment.

Novel one-step mechanism for tRNA 3'-end maturation by the exoribonuclease RNase R of Mycoplasma genitalium

Mycoplasma genitalium is expected to metabolize RNA using unique pathways because its minimal genome encodes very few ribonucleases. In this work, we report that the only exoribonuclease identified in M. genitalium, RNase R, is able to remove tRNA 3'-trailers and generate mature 3'-ends. Several sequence and structural features of a tRNA precursor determine its precise processing at the 3'-end by RNase R in a purified system. The aminoacyl-acceptor stem plays a major role in stopping RNase R digestion at the mature 3'-end. Disruption of the stem causes partial or complete degradation of the pre-tRNA by RNase R, whereas extension of the stem results in the formation of a product terminating downstream at the new mature 3'-end. In addition, the 3'-terminal CCA sequence and the discriminator residue influence the ability of RNase R to stop at the mature 3'-end. RNase R-mediated generation of the mature 3'-end prefers a sequence of RCCN at the 3' terminus of tRNA. Variations of this sequence may cause RNase R to trim further and remove terminal CA residues from the mature 3'-end. Therefore, M. genitalium RNase R can precisely remove the 3'-trailer of a tRNA precursor by recognizing features in the terminal domains of tRNA, a process requiring multiple RNases in most bacteria.