A rare case of bullous contact dermatitis caused by severe organophosphorus pesticides poisoning

Potential toxic effects of 4-OH-chlorothalonil and photodegradation product on human skin health

Chlorothalonil (CHT) is widely used in agriculture as a fungicide and has been detected in various ecosystems along with its degradation products. A primary intermediate product of degradation, 4-hydroxychlorothalonil (4-OH-CHT) has demonstrated toxic effects on aquatic organisms. However, the toxic effects of 4-OH-CHT on human health and the impacts of environmental factors on the toxicity remain unclear. To understand the environmental modification on the toxicity of 4-OH-CHT to human health, we used a three-dimensional human skin culture model. 4-OH-CHT and irradiated 4-OH-CHT were applied to the model for the dermatoxicity analyses. Although neither the 4-OH-CHT nor the irradiated 4-OH-CHT inhibited the cell proliferation, the 4-OH-CHT significantly attenuated the keratinocyte migration by 26% at a concentration of 20 ppb and by 44 % at 100 ppb. The 4-OH-CHT also demonstrated inhibitory effects on keratinocyte differentiation at both 20 ppb and 100 ppb. In contrast, photodegraded 4-OH-CHT did not show inhibitory effects on the migration and differentiation of the keratinocytes at any concentration. Similarly, the 4-OH-CHT treated 3D keratinocyte culture dramatically activated the co-cultured dermal fibroblast cells by increasing the production of α smooth muscle actin (α-SMA) and pro-Collagen Iα. The mRNA levels of these two proteins were upregulated by 1.13 and 10.97 folds with the stimulation of 100 ppb 4-OH-CHT. The protein level of pro-Collagen Iα in dermal fibroblast cells was increased by 68 % with 100 ppb 4-OH-CHT. The photodegraded 4-OH-CHT failed to activate the co-cultured fibroblast cells. The 4-OH-CHT also enhanced pro-inflammatory cytokine production in keratinocytes compared to the photodegraded products. These results suggest that exposure to environmental 4-OH-CHT could increase the risk of inflammatory skin diseases in humans.

Potential risk to human skin cells from exposure to dicloran photodegradation products in water

Exposure to sunlight and certain pesticides can induce phototoxic responses. Long- and short-term exposure to the photoactivated pesticides can cause a variety of skin diseases. However, assessment of pesticide phototoxicity on human skin is difficult. In the present study, human skin keratinocytes were cultured in several forms: monolayer cell sheet, three-dimensional culture, and keratinocyte-fibroblast co-culture. A common fungicide, dicloran (DC, 2,6‑dichloro‑4‑nitroaniline), was irradiated with simulated sunlight for 2 (DC-PD-2h) and 4 (DC-PD-4h) hours. Dicloran, and two purified intermediate photodegradation products, 2‑chloro‑1,4‑benzoquinone (CBQ) and 1,4‑benzoquinone (BQ), were applied in toxicity tests independently with the keratinocyte culture models. The cell migration, cell differentiation, pro-inflammatory molecule production, and dermal fibroblast cell activation were all measured in the keratinocytes treated with the chemicals described above. These parameters were used as references for dicloran phototoxicity assessment. Among all tested chemicals, the DC-PD-4h and BQ demonstrated elevated toxicities to the keratinocytes compared to dicloran based on our results. The application of DC-PD-4h or BQ significantly delayed the migration of keratinocytes in monolayer cell sheets, inhibited the keratinocyte differentiation, increased the production of pro-inflammatory molecules by 3D keratinocyte culture, and enhanced the ability of 3D cultured keratinocytes in the activation of co-cultured dermal fibroblast cells. In contrast, dicloran, DC-PD-2h, and CBQ showed minimal effects on the keratinocytes in all assays. The results suggested that the four-hour photodegraded dicloran was likely to induce inflammatory skin diseases in the natural human skin. The 1,4‑benzoquinone, which is the predominant degradation product detected following 4 h of irradiation, was the main factor for this response. Photoactivation increased the risk of skin exposed to dicloran in nature. Our models provided an efficient tool in the assessment of toxicity changes in pesticide following normal use practices under typical environmental conditions.