A "helix-scissors" mechanism for the hinge-bending conformational change in phosphoglycerate kinase

A database of macromolecular motions

We describe a database of macromolecular motions meant to be of general use to the structural community. The database, which is accessible on the World Wide Web with an entry point at http://bioinfo.mbb.yale.edu/MolMovDB , attempts to systematize all instances of protein and nucleic acid movement for which there is at least some structural information. At present it contains >120 motions, most of which are of proteins. Protein motions are further classified hierarchically into a limited number of categories, first on the basis of size (distinguishing between fragment, domain and subunit motions) and then on the basis of packing. Our packing classification divides motions into various categories (shear, hinge, other) depending on whether or not they involve sliding over a continuously maintained and tightly packed interface. In addition, the database provides some indication about the evidence behind each motion (i.e. the type of experimental information or whether the motion is inferred based on structural similarity) and attempts to describe many aspects of a motion in terms of a standardized nomenclature (e.g. the maximum rotation, the residue selection of a fixed core, etc.). Currently, we use a standard relational design to implement the database. However, the complexity and heterogeneity of the information kept in the database makes it an ideal application for an object-relational approach, and we are moving it in this direction. Specifically, in terms of storing complex information, the database contains plausible representations for motion pathways, derived from restrained 3D interpolation between known endpoint conformations. These pathways can be viewed in a variety of movie formats, and the database is associated with a server that can automatically generate these movies from submitted coordinates.

Conformational dynamics and enzyme activity

Conformational flexibility and structural fluctuations play an important role in enzyme activity. A great variety of internal motions ranging over different time scales and of different amplitudes are involved in the catalytic cycle. These different types of motions and their functional consequences are considered in the light of experimental data and theoretical analyses. The conformational changes upon substrate binding, and particularly the hinge-bending motion which occurs in enzymes made of two domains, are analyzed from several well documented examples. The conformational events accompanying the different steps of the catalytic cycle are discussed. The last section concerns the motions involved in the allosteric transition which regulates the enzyme activity.

Structural mechanisms for domain movements in proteins

We survey all the known instances of domain movements in proteins for which there is crystallographic evidence for the movement. We explain these domain movements in terms of the repertoire of low-energy conformation changes that are known to occur in proteins. We first describe the basic elements of this repertoire, hinge and shear motions, and then show how the elements of the repertoire can be combined to produce domain movements. We emphasize that the elements used in particular proteins are determined mainly by the structure of the interfaces between the domains.

Site-directed mutagenesis of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase. Arginines 65, 121 and 168

In the absence of a structure of the closed form of phosphoglycerate kinase we have modified by site directed mutagenesis several of the residues which, on the basis of the open form structure, are likely to be involved in substrate binding and catalysis. Here we report on the kinetic and anion activation properties of the yeast enzyme modified at positions 65, 121 and 168. In each case an arginine, thought to be involved in the binding of the sugar substrate's non-transferable phosphate group, has been replaced by lysine (same charge) and by methionine (no charge). Km values for 3-phosphoglycerate of all six mutant enzymes are only marginally higher than that of the wild-type enzyme. Removing the charge associated with two of the three arginine residues appears to influence (as judged by the measured Km's) the binding of ATP. Although binding affinity is not necessarily coupled to turnover the substitutions which have the greatest effect on the Km's do correlate with the reduction in enzymes maximum velocity. The one exception to this generalisation is the R65K mutant which, surprisingly, has a significantly higher kcat than the wild-type enzyme. In the open form structure of the pig muscle enzyme each of the three substituted arginines residues are seen to make two hydrogen bonds to the sugar substrate's non-transferable phosphate. From this it might be expected that anion activation would be similarly affected by the substitution of any one of these three residues. Although the interpretation of such effects are complicated by the fact that one of the mutants (R65M) unfolds at low salt concentrations, this appears not to be the case. Replacing Arg121 and Arg168 with methionine reduces the anion activation whereas a lysine in either of these two positions practically destroys the effect. With the substitutions at residue 65 the opposite is observed in that the lysine mutant shows anion activation whereas the methionine mutant does not.

Domain motions in phosphoglycerate kinase: determination of interdomain distance distributions by site-specific labeling and time-resolved fluorescence energy transfer

3-Phosphoglycerate kinase is composed of two globular domains separated by a wide cleft. The substrate binding sites are situated on the inner surfaces of the two domains. By analogy to other kinases, it has been postulated that the catalytic mechanism of phosphoglycerate kinase involves a hinge bending domain motion that brings the substrates together to allow phosphoryl transfer. To characterize this large-scale conformational change, as well as the dynamics of the unliganded enzyme in solution, we have applied site-directed mutagenesis and time-resolved nonradiative energy transfer techniques. Two genetically engineered cysteines (Cys-135 and Cys-290), one in each of the two domains, were covalently labeled with a donor and acceptor pair of fluorescent probes. Analysis of subnanosecond fluorescence decay curves yielded the equilibrium distribution of interdomain distances. In the absence of substrates, the distribution of distances between the two labeled sites was very broad, with a full width at half maximum estimated as 20 A or broader, indicative of a large number of conformational substates in solution. The mean distance, 31.5 +/- 1 A, was 8 A smaller than in the crystal structure. Upon addition of ATP alone or of ATP and 3-phosphoglycerate, the average distance increased to 38 +/- 1 A and the width of the distribution decreased. Addition of 3-phosphoglycerate alone induced a similar but smaller change. The rate of conformational state fluctuations (interconversion between states) was found to be slow on the nanosecond time scale, as expected for a protein with a relatively large interdomain contact area.

A study of the hinge-bending mechanism of yeast 3-phosphoglycerate kinase

The hinge-bending mechanism proposed as part of the catalytic mechanism for phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) has been investigated using yeast PGK and the site-directed mutant [H388Q]PGK, where His388 is replaced by Gln. The emission and quenching of fluorescence, supported by the aromatic CD band, show that the mutation in the waist region affects the tryptophan environment in the C-terminal domain. The mutant is also less stable to guanidine denaturation and less cooperative in its unfolding. The effect of substrates on the conformation of PGK was studied using 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulphonic acid (ANS), a competitive inhibitor of ATP binding to the C-terminal domain, and 8-(2-[(iodoacetyl)ethyl]amino)naphthalene (I-AEDANS), attached to Cys197 on the N-terminal domain. Under the influence of substrates the novel anisotropy decay curves for ANS indicate a 1-5 degrees change in the orientation of the probe, interpreted as a small reorientation of the domains about the waist region. The experimental data are interpreted as a small swivelling of the domains about the waist region under the influence of substrate. The results with AEDANS anisotropy decay are consistent with those for ANS. The enzyme activity of PGK shows a break in the Arrhenius plot at 20 degrees C mirrored by a break in the temperature dependence of tryptophan ellipticity. This is interpreted as a change in protein dynamics associated with destabilisation of the waist region. This destabilisation is shown to have already taken place in the mutant enzyme and in the wild type at pH 5.6, both of which exhibit linear Arrhenius plots. NMR titration curves show that the pH effect must be due to a group other than histidine. The results give further support to the permissive model of hinge bending previously proposed by one of the authors, in which binding of substrate destabilises the waist region. This loosens the hinge which can then swing slightly to bring the domains closer together to make favourable interactions between the domains and the substrates, with the exclusion of water.

Crystal structure of the binary complex of pig muscle phosphoglycerate kinase and its substrate 3-phospho-D-glycerate

Pig muscle phosphoglycerate kinase has been crystallized from polyethyleneglycol in the presence of its substrate 3-phospho-D-glycerate (3-PG) and the structure has been determined at 2.0 A resolution. The structure was solved using the known structure of the substrate-free horse muscle enzyme and has been refined to a crystallographic R-factor of 21.5%. 3-Phospho-D-glycerate is bound to the N-domain of the enzyme through a network of hydrogen bonds to a cluster of basic amino acid residues and by electrostatic interactions between the negatively charged phosphate and these basic protein side chains. This binding site is in good agreement with earlier proposals [Banks et al., Nature (London) 279:773-777, 1979]. The phosphate oxygen atoms are hydrogen bonded to His-62, Arg-65, Arg-122, and Arg-170. The 2-hydroxyl group, which defines the D-isomer of 3PG, is hydrogen bonded to Asp-23 and Asn-25. The carboxyl group of 3-PG points away from the N-domain towards the C-domain and is hydrogen bonded via a water molecule to main chain nitrogen atoms of helix-14. The present structure of the 3-PG-bound pig muscle enzyme is compared with the structure of the substrate-free horse enzyme. Major changes include an ordering of helix-13 and a domain movement, which brings the N-domain closer to the ATP-binding C-domain. This domain movement consists of a 7.7 degree rotation, which is less than previously estimated for the ternary complex. Local changes close to the 3-PG binding site include an ordering of Arg-65 and a shift of helix-5.

Conformational changes in yeast phosphoglycerate kinase upon ligand binding: fluorescence of a linked probe and chemical reactivity of genetically introduced cysteinyl residues

The effects of ligands on the conformation of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase were explored by introducing cysteinyl residues at different positions in the molecule by site-directed mutagenesis. Thus several mutants were constructed, each containing a unique cysteinyl residue. Neither the conformation nor the enzyme activity was affected by the substitutions. The reactivity of the thiol groups and the fluorescence of N-acetyl-N'-(5-sulfo-1-naphthyl)ethylene-diamine covalently linked to these thiols were used to monitor the conformational changes induced upon ligand binding. It was found that the observed changes mainly involve the part of the protein located in the cleft, particularly the environment of residues 35 and 183. No alteration was observed on the external side of the protein. Only 3-Phosphoglycerate induced these conformational changes. However, when the fluorescent probe was attached to residue 377, the binding of the two substrates was required to induce a modification in the fluorescence of the probe. These results indicate that the substrates separately or together induce discrete molecular motions in phosphoglycerate kinase.

Modelling of substrate binding to 3-phosphoglycerate kinase with analogues of 3-phosphoglycerate

Two short analogues of 3-phosphoglycerate, -OOC-CHOH-CH2-O-PO32-, phosphonolactate, (-OOC-CHOH-CH2-PO32-) and arsonolactate (-OOC-CHOH-CH2-AsO32-) have been tested with 3-phosphoglycerate kinase. None of these served as substrate for the kinase reaction, unlike the previously studied [Orr, G. A. & Knowles, J. R. (1974) Biochem. J. 141, 721-723] analogues -OOC-CHOH-CH2-CH2-PO32- and -OOC-CHOH-CH2-CH2-AsO32-, which are isosteric with 3-phosphoglycerate. Thus, a decrease in the substrate size and the accompanying stereochemical changes cannot be tolerated by the catalytic mechanism. Instead, both analogues acted as relatively poor competitive inhibitors with respect to both 3-phosphoglycerate and MgATP. AT pH 8.5 and 20 degrees C, the inhibitory constants (Ki) of phosphonolactate and arsnolactate against both substrates are 17 +/- 5 mM and 30 +/- 7 mM, respectively. Surprisingly, however, both analogues proved to be more effective than either 3-phosphoglycerate or its isosteric analogues in protecting the enzyme against modification of its fast-reacting thiols. This comparison suggests that the shorter analogues bind differently, and that the catalytic mechanism demands a precise fitting of the -CH2-O-PO32- segment of the substrate.

Flexibility and folding of phosphoglycerate kinase

Flexibility and folding of phosphoglycerate kinase, a two-domain monomeric enzyme, have been studied using a wide variety of methods including theoretical approaches. Mutants of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase have been prepared in order to introduce cysteinyl residues as local probes throughout the molecule without perturbating significantly the structural or the functional properties of the enzyme. The apparent reactivity of a unique cysteine in each mutant has been used to study the flexibility of PGK. The regions of larger mobility have been found around residue 183 on segment beta F in the N-domain and residue 376 on helix XII in the C-domain. These regions are also parts of the molecule which unfold first. Ligand binding induces conformational motions in the molecule, especially in the regions located in the cleft. Moreover, the results obtained by introducing a fluorescent probe covalently linked to a cysteine are in agreement with the helix scissor motion of helices 7 and 14 assumed by Blake to direct the hinge bending motion of the domains during the catalytic cycle. The folding process of both horse muscle and yeast phosphoglycerate kinases involves intermediates. These intermediates are more stable in the horse muscle than in the yeast enzyme. In both enzymes, domains behave as structural modules capable of folding and stabilizing independently, but in the horse muscle enzyme the C-domain is more stable and refolds prior to the N-domain, contrary to that which has been observed in the yeast enzyme. A direct demonstration of the independence of domains in yeast phosphoglycerate kinase has been provided following the obtention of separated domains by site-directed mutagenesis. These domains have a native-like structure and refold spontaneously after denaturation by guanidine hydrochloride.

Substitution of a proline for alanine 183 in the hinge region of phosphoglycerate kinase: effects on catalysis, activation by sulfate, and thermal stability

A "hinge-bending" domain movement has been postulated as an important part of the catalytic mechanism of phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) (Banks et al., 1979). In order to test the role of the flexibility of a putative interdomain hinge in the substrate- and sulfate-induced conformational transitions, alanine-183 was replaced by proline using site-directed mutagenesis. The maximal velocity of the Ala 183----Pro mutant, measured at saturating concentrations of ATP and phosphoglycerate (5 mM and 10 mM, respectively) and in the absence of sulfate ions, is increased approximately 21% in comparison to the wild type PGK. The Km values for both substrates are essentially unchanged. The effect of sulfate on the specific activity of the Ala 183----Pro mutant and the wild type PGK was measured in the presence of 1 mM ATP and 2 mM 3-phosphoglycerate (3-PG). A maximum activation of 70% was observed at 20 mM sulfate for the mutant enzyme, as compared to 130% activation at 30 mM sulfate for the wild type PGK. These results demonstrate that the increased rigidity of the putative hinge, introduced by the Ala----Pro mutation, does not impair catalytic efficiency of phosphoglycerate kinase, while it appears to decrease the sulfate-dependent activation. The differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) studies demonstrate an increased susceptibility of the Ala 183----Pro mutant to thermal denaturation. In contrast to one asymmetric transition observed in the DSC scan for the wild type PGK, with Tm near 54 degrees C, two transitions are evident for the mutant enzyme with Tm values of about 45 and 54 degrees C.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

One- and two-dimensional NMR studies of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase

One- and two-dimensional proton NMR studies have been carried out on yeast phosphoglycerate kinase (Mr approximately 45,000) in order to identify amino-acid spin systems and obtain sequence-specific assignments. A number of sequence-specific assignments have been made using a combination of structural information contained in nuclear Overhauser effect spectra and X-ray crystallographic data. The results of substrate binding studies (both 3-phosphoglycerate and Mg.ATP), which indicate mutual reorientation of certain assigned aromatic residues in the inter-domain region of the protein, are discussed.

A synthetic peptide analog of the putative substrate-binding motif activates protein kinase C

A 29-residue synthetic peptide, Leu530-Leu-Tyr-Glu-Met-Leu-Ala-Gly-Gln-Ala-Pro-Phe-Glu-Gly-Glu-Asp -Glu-Asp- Glu-Leu-Phe-Gln-Ser-Ile-Met-Glu-His-Asn-Val-NH2(558), corresponding to part of the catalytic domain of protein kinase C, is a potent activator of the enzyme, with a Ka of approx. 10 microM. Activation was 59 +/- 4% of that observed with phosphatidylserine, predominantly due to an increased Vmax, partially calcium-dependent, observed with all three isoenzymes (alpha, beta, gamma), and resulted in autophosphorylation. It is proposed that the region between Gly528 and Arg583 is part of the protein substrate binding region of protein kinase C and synthetic peptide analogs of this region activate the enzyme by blocking the action of the enzyme's basic pseudosubstrate autoregulatory region.

Correlation between enzyme activity and hinge-bending domain displacement in 3-phosphoglycerate kinase

Diffuse X-ray-scattering data give evidence for large-scale structural change in pig muscle 3-phosphoglycerate kinase upon substrate binding. Simultaneous binding of 3-phosphoglycerate and MgATP either to the unmodified enzyme or to its active methylated derivative leads to about an 0.1-nm decrease in radius of gyration. These data coincide well with the previous data for yeast 3-phosphoglycerate kinase. When, instead of methylation, the two reactive thiol groups of pig muscle 3-phosphoglycerate kinase are carboxamidomethylated, the enzyme becomes inactive and the radii of gyration of its 'apo' and 'holo' forms do not differ within limits of experimental error. Thus, a correlation exists between the activity of 3-phosphoglycerate kinase and its substrate-induced large-scale conformational change. This correlation is a strong argument in favor of the functional importance of domain locking in the reaction catalyzed by 3-phosphoglycerate kinase.

Limited proteolysis of 3-phosphoglycerate kinase without loss of enzymic activity

During tryptic digestion of pig muscle 3-phosphoglycerate kinase in the presence of 3-phosphoglycerate both the decrease of enzymic activity and the release of trichloroacetic acid-soluble peptides occur after a pronounced lag period. During this lag phase the native enzyme molecule is split into two fragments with molecular masses of about 30 and 18 kDa, as detected by SDS-PAGE. Under non-denaturing conditions, however, these fragments are held together by non-covalent forces and constitute an active, nicked enzyme molecule. In the absence of substrates or in the presence of MgATP the kinetics of tryptic digestion is apparently a single first order reaction leading to the formation of peptides with molecular masses of less than 10 kDa.

Structure-function relationships in 3-phosphoglycerate kinase: role of the carboxy-terminal peptide

Yeast 3-phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) is a monomeric enzyme (Mr approximately 45,000) composed of two globular domains. Each domain corresponds approximately to the amino- and carboxy-terminal halves of the polypeptide chain. The carboxy-terminal end extends over the interdomain "hinge" region and packs against the amino-terminal domain. It has been proposed that domain movement, resulting in closure of the active site cleft, is essential for the catalytic function of PGK. Large-scale conformational changes have also been postulated to explain activation of the enzyme by sulfate ions. Using site-specific mutagenesis, we have removed a 15-amino-acid carboxy-terminal fragment, in order to probe its role in the substrate- and sulfate-induced conformational changes. The truncated enzyme exhibited approximately 1% of the activity of native PGK and lost the ability to undergo sulfate-induced activation. The Km for ATP was essentially unchanged (Km = 0.23 mM) in comparison to the native enzyme (Km = 0.30 mM), whereas the Km value for 3-phosphoglycerate was increased about eightfold (Km = 3.85 mM and 0.50 mM, respectively). These results suggest that the carboxy-terminal segment is important for the mechanism of the substrate- and sulfate-induced conformational transitions. CD spectra and sedimentation velocity measurements indicate that the carboxy-terminal peptide is essential for structural integrity of PGK. The increased susceptibility of the truncated enzyme to thermal inactivation implies that the carboxy-terminal peptide also contributes to the stability of PGK.

Frequency domain fluorescence studies of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase and its ternary complex

A frequency domain fluorescence study of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase has been performed to observe the effect of substrates on the structure and dynamics of the enzyme. At 20 degrees C and pH 7.2, a biexponential decay is observed for tryptophanyl emission. The short fluorescence lifetime (0.4 ns) component is associated with a spectrum having a 329-nm maximum and a 18.4-kJ/mol activation energy, Ea, for thermal quenching. The long-lifetime (3.5 ns) component has a 338-nm maximum and an Ea of only 7.9 kJ/mol. Tentatively we assign the short and long-lifetime components to Trp-333 and Trp-308. Binding of the substrates ATP and 3-phosphoglycerate leads to a significant increase in the fluorescence lifetime, the red shift of the emission spectrum and in the decrease in the Ea for both components. Acrylamide-quenching studies indicate that the two tryptophan residues have about the same degree of kinetic exposure to the quencher and that the binding of the substrates causes a very slight change in the quenching pattern. These fluorescence studies indicate that the binding of the substrates to phosphoglycerate kinase may influence the conformational dynamics around the two tryptophan residues located on one of the protein's domains.