Experimental and clinical evaluation of high-frequency positive-pressure ventilation (HFPPV) and the pneumatic valve principle in bronchoscopy under general anaesthesia

High-frequency jet ventilation in interventional bronchoscopy: factors with predictive value on high-frequency jet ventilation complications

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the incidence and impact on clinical outcome of complications observed during high-frequency jet ventilation (HFJV) at interventional bronchoscopy and to identify the perioperative factors that may be associated to an increased incidence of such complications.

DESIGN

Observational retrospective, study with an observational prospective validation of the statistically significant associations.

SETTING

University hospital.

PATIENTS

The retrospective study involved 276 patients who underwent an interventional rigid bronchoscopy during general anesthesia and HFJV. Forty consecutive patients were accrued for the prospective validation group. INTERVENTIONS/MEASUREMENTS: Information recorded included patient medical history and perioperative complications observed at HFJV-managed bronchoscopic procedures and their impact on clinical outcome until hospital discharge.

MAIN RESULTS

At least one complication was detected in 38% of retrospective patients and 55% of prospective patients. Most frequent complications were hypercapnia, hypoxemia, and hemodynamic instability, but just one case of barotrauma in the retrospective group. Despite the high incidence, these complications were transient and did not increase hospital stay, whereas technical failure to widen airway lumen was associated with an adverse prognosis. Several clinical parameters showed a significant association with complications in the univariate analysis. However, the multivariate analysis only evidenced two independent predictive factors: the ASA physical status scale and baseline oxygen saturation.

CONCLUSIONS

Classification in ASA physical status IV group and a baseline oxygen saturation of 95% or less independently predicted the development of complications during interventional rigid bronchoscopy with HFJV.

In what respect does high frequency positive pressure ventilation differ from conventional ventilation?

The original rationale for HFPPV was that under certain conditions adequate alveolar ventilation could be achieved with high ventilatory frequencies and small tidal volumes. It was theorized further that increased ventilatory frequencies and low tidal volumes would decrease the airway pressures, barotrauma, and cardiovascular and other systemic consequences seen with conventional mechanical ventilation. The first clinical applications of HFPPV were in bronchoscopy and laryngoscopy for diagnostic and/or therapeutic purposes. Apart from these endoscopic applications, volume-controlled HFPPV has been compared with conventional ventilation in upper abdominal surgery and coronary artery bypass grafting. The possible advantages of HFPPV over conventional volume-controlled ventilation in the intensive care setting are still unclear. Provided that the mean lung volumes are similar, oxygenation in acute respiratory failure is similar with both ventilation methods. Although the role of HFPPV in the management of pulmonary diseases still remains to be clarified, it does provide effective ventilation in selected types of patients needing ventilatory support. New modes of pressure-controlled ventilation have not resolved all clinical problems in severe ARDS and/or acute respiratory failure. The search for means of optimal ventilatory support with minimal complications must continue, as conventional ventilation does not always offer the best treatment.

A new ventilator for physiologic studies during high-frequency ventilation

Research in the field of high frequency ventilation (HFV) has been hampered by the difficulty of collecting and analyzing expired gas, uncontaminated by gas of inspiratory composition, at ventilatory frequencies in the relevant range. A new mechanical ventilator is described, which has been designed to facilitate studies on the respiratory physiology of small animals during HFV. Ventilation is controlled by a single rotary valve, which alternately switches the airway to an approximately constant-flow gas source during inspiration, and to gas measurement and analysis apparatus during expiration, which takes place passively. Theoretical and experimental studies, using the techniques of mechanical and mathematical modelling, are used to measure the performance of the ventilator and to demonstrate that it allows the quantitative collection of expired gas during ventilation at rates up to at least 20 Hz. The advantages and limitations of this approach are discussed.

Constancy of physiological dead space during high-frequency ventilation

A ventilator, specially designed to allow the direct measurement of expired gas volume and composition, was used to maintain gas exchange in anesthetized, paralyzed, New Zealand White rabbits at ventilatory frequencies up to 22 Hz. A total of eleven studies were carried out on seven animals. Determinations of the minute ventilation required to maintain a normal steady-state PCO2, together with the FECO2 and arterial PO2, PCO2, and pH, were made at a number of frequencies. The results so obtained were used to calculate the physiological dead space. It was found that this value remained remarkably constant for each individual rabbit over a range of ventilatory frequencies from 1 to 22 Hz. Our findings in rabbits are in contrast to those of other workers (in dogs) that adequate gas exchange can be maintained at high ventilatory frequencies with the use of tidal volumes much smaller than the volume of anatomical dead space.

High-frequency positive-pressure ventilation (HFPPV) in neonates and infants during neuroleptal analgesia and routine plastic surgery, and in postoperative management

The low pulmonary compliance, the high airway resistance and the "rapid" breathing pattern of neonatal and paediatric patients make it necessary to design special ventilators to match the pulmonary physiology of infants. A ventilator system which also in small children has a negligible compression volume was evaluated in a lung model and during repair of cleft lip and palate in 16 patients under general anaesthesia and in two other infants during other operations. High-frequency positive-pressure ventilation (HFPPV) was given with an insufflation frequency (f) of 60 per min and a relative insufflation time (t%) of 32%. In addition, two neonates treated postoperatively with HFPPV are reported. Despite the "open" character of the ventilator system both intra- and postoperative ventilation were uneventful in all patients. The arterial oxygenation was good in all cases, as judged from clinical signs or blood gas analyses. Postoperative ventilation required conventional clinical observation and intermittent analyses of blood. HFPPV has been shown to depress, or abolish, spontaneous respiration via reflex mechanisms. In all patients in this investigation respiratory movements were absent at normo- or slight hyperventilation during HFPPV.

Clinical evaluation of high-frequency positive-pressure ventilation (HFPPV) in laryngoscoy under general anaesthesia

A technique for automatic ventilation during laryngoscopy under general anaesthesia was evaluated in a lung model and in 5 patients (3--57 y) submitted for routine laryngoscopy. this technique has been given the name laryngoscopic HFPPV and utilizes an insufflation frequency (f) of 60 per min and a relative insufflation time (t%) of 22%. Ventilation is given via a nasotracheal insufflation catheter. Laryngoscopic HFPPV permits laryngeal surgery with a virtually unobstructed surgical field under complete muscular relaxation. The alveolar ventilation of the patient may be controlled by adjustment of the pressure of the anaesthetic gas mixture and there is no air entrainment through the larynx during insufflation. This makes possible use of O2/N2O mixtures and the oxygenation of the patient may be controlled by adjustment of the oxygen concentration of the anaesthetic gas mixture. As there is a continuous upward has flow through the larynx, blood or pieces of loose tissue are not sucked down into the trachea. A simple ventilation nomogram for clinical use is proposed. Adequately used, this nomogram guarantees safe ventilation during laryngoscopic HFPPV. An Fio2 of 0.3--0.4 gives adequate arterial oxygenation.

Physiologic evaluation of the HFPPV pneumatic valve principle and PEEP. An experimental study

In experiments in dogs the ventilatory and circulatory conditions prevailing with the ventilatory pattern in high-frequency positive-pressure ventilation (HFPPV) were investigated with use of a pneumatic valve principle and a ventilator system of an "open" character. Keeping the gas input constant the importance of insufflation frequency and insufflation time and the reactions to various levels of positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) were investigated in terms of changes in arterial pH, Pco2 and Po2. With the volumes of delivered gas kept constant, an increasing insufflation frequency from 60 to 100 per min gave a parallel decrease in tidal volume accompanied by lower maximum intratracheal pressures and a significant decrease in alveolar ventilation. Also taking into account the possibilities of inducing a suppression of the spontaneous respiration, higher ventilatory frequencies than 60 per min do now seem to introduce any further advantages. Including the associated effects on cardiac output and venous admixture, the cardio-pulmonary and circulatory parameters studied did not show any substantial changes with PEEP levels below 7.5--10 cm H2O. Thus the level of PEEP, which often is part of the ventilatory pattern in HFPPV, does not seem to have any untoward influence on the circulation (stroke volume, cardiac output, total peripheral vascular resistance) and oxygen transport (arterial oxygen content and oxygen flux) in normovolaemic dogs.