Emergence from isoflurane/N2O or isoflurane anaesthesia

Does anaesthesia with nitrous oxide affect mortality or cardiovascular morbidity? A systematic review with meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis

BACKGROUND

The role of nitrous oxide in modern anaesthetic practice is contentious. One concern is that exposure to nitrous oxide may increase the risk of cardiovascular complications. ENIGMA II is a large randomized clinical trial currently underway which is investigating nitrous oxide and cardiovascular complications. Before the completion of this trial, we performed a systematic review and meta-analysis, using Cochrane methodology, on the outcomes that make up the composite primary outcome.

METHODS

We used conventional meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis (TSA). We reviewed 8282 abstracts and selected 138 that fulfilled our criteria for study type, population, and intervention. We attempted to contact the authors of all the selected publications to check for unpublished outcome data.

RESULTS

Thirteen trials had outcome data eligible for our outcomes. We assessed three of these trials as having a low risk of bias. Using conventional meta-analysis, the relative risk of short-term mortality in the nitrous oxide group was 1.38 [95% confidence interval (CI) 0.22-8.71] and the relative risk of long-term mortality in the nitrous oxide group was 0.94 (95% CI 0.80-1.10). In both cases, TSA demonstrated that the data were far too sparse to make any conclusions. There were insufficient data to perform meta-analysis for stroke, myocardial infarct, pulmonary embolus, or cardiac arrest.

CONCLUSION

This systematic review demonstrated that we currently do not have robust evidence for how nitrous oxide used as part of general anaesthesia affects mortality and cardiovascular complications.

Nitrous oxide: still useful in the year 2000?

The risk-benefit ratio of using nitrous oxide has been debated for many years. In this article the adverse effects of nitrous oxide on patient well-being, including its role in postoperative nausea and vomiting, its toxic effects and adverse physiological changes are reviewed. Guidelines for the rational use of the drug are suggested.

Decreased respiratory depression during emergence from anesthesia with sevoflurane/N2O than with sevoflurane alone

PURPOSE

To investigate ventilation and gas elimination during the emergence from inhalational anesthesia with controlled normoventilation with either sevoflurane/N2O or sevoflurane alone.

METHODS

Twenty-four ASA I-II patients scheduled for abdominal hysterectomy were randomly allocated to receive either 1.3 MAC sevoflurane/N2O (n = 12) or equi-MAC sevoflurane (n = 12) in 30% oxygen (O2). Expired minute ventilation volumes (V(E)), end-tidal (ET) concentrations of O2, carbon dioxide (CO2), sevoflurane and N2O as well as pulse oximetry saturation (SpO2) and CO2 elimination rates (VCO2) were measured. The ET concentrations of sevoflurane and N2O were converted to total MAC values and gas elimination was expressed in terms of MAC reduction. Time to resumption of spontaneous breathing and extubation were recorded and arterial blood gas analysis was performed at the end of controlled normoventilation and at the beginning of spontaneous breathing.

RESULTS

Resumption of spontaneous breathing and extubation were 8 and 13 min less, respectively, in the sevoflurane/N2O than in the sevoflurane group. Spontaneous breathing was resumed in both groups when pH had decreased by 0.07-0.08 and PaCO2 increased by 1.3-1.5 kPa. Depression of V(E) and VCO2 were less, and MAC reduction more rapid in the sevoflurane/N2O than in the sevoflurane group.

CONCLUSIONS

Respiratory recovery was faster after sevoflurane/N2O than sevoflurane anesthesia. Changes in pH and PaCO2 rather than absolute values were important for resumption of spontaneous breathing after controlled normoventilation. In both groups, the tracheas were extubated at about 0.2 MAC.

Respiration during emergence from anaesthesia with desflurane/N2O vs. desflurane/air for gynaecological laparoscopy

BACKGROUND

The complications related to anaesthesia usually occur in the early postoperative period. Hypercapnia and hypoxaemia may result from any persistent depression of the respiratory drive relative to the metabolic demand. The purpose of this study was to compare the respiratory effects of desflurane anaesthesia with or without nitrous oxide during the period of emergence.

METHODS

Twenty patients scheduled for a standardised surgical procedure, laparoscopic hysterectomy, were randomly allocated to anaesthesia with 1.3 MAC of desflurane/N2O (Group 1) or desflurane alone (Group 2), with 10 patients in each group. Times of resumption of spontaneous breathing and extubation were recorded and elimination rates of carbon dioxide, end-tidal concentrations of desflurane and N2O, and blood gases were measured.

RESULTS

Spontaneous breathing was resumed in both groups when pH had decreased by about 0.07 and PaCO2 increased by about 1.4 kPa compared with the values at the end of 1.3 MAC anaesthesia with controlled normoventilation. There were no significant differences between the groups with regards to extubation time, 6 vs. 13 min, or total MAC value at extubation, 0.20 vs. 0.19 in Group 1 and 2, respectively. Neither did the groups differ in minute ventilation, end-tidal carbon dioxide, oxygen concentrations, or blood gases. CO2 elimination decreased in both groups from about 220 ml 70 kg-1 min-1 at the end of anaesthesia to a lowest value of about 160 ml 70 kg-1 min-1.

CONCLUSION

The respiratory profiles during recovery from gynaecological laparoscopy with either desflurane/N2O or desflurane anaesthesia were similar with fast resumption of spontaneous breathing, short time to extubation, and no signs of CO2 retention.