Role of 16-S RNA in ribosome messenger recognition

Single mutation in Shine-Dalgarno-like sequence present in the amino terminal of lactate dehydrogenase of Plasmodium effects the production of an eukaryotic protein expressed in a prokaryotic system

One of the most important step in structure-based drug design studies is obtaining the protein in active form after cloning the target gene. In one of our previous study, it was determined that an internal Shine-Dalgarno-like sequence present just before the third methionine at N-terminus of wild type lactate dehydrogenase enzyme of Plasmodium falciparum prevent the translation of full length protein. Inspection of the same region in P. vivax LDH, which was overproduced as an active enzyme, indicated that the codon preference in the same region was slightly different than the codon preference of wild type PfLDH. In this study, 5'-GGAGGC-3' sequence of P. vivax that codes for two glycine residues just before the third methionine was exchanged to 5'-GGAGGA-3', by mimicking P. falciparum LDH, to prove the possible effects of having an internal SD-like sequence when expressing an eukaryotic protein in a prokaryotic system. Exchange was made by site-directed mutagenesis. Results indicated that having two glycine residues with an internal SD-like sequence (GGAGGA) just before the third methionine abolishes the enzyme activity due to the preference of the prokaryotic system used for the expression. This study emphasizes the awareness of use of a prokaryotic system to overproduce an eukaryotic protein.

In polycistronic Qbeta RNA, single-strandedness at one ribosome binding site directly affects translational initiations at a distal upstream cistron

In Qβ RNA, sequestering the coat gene ribosome binding site in a putatively strong hairpin stem structure eliminated synthesis of coat protein and activated protein synthesis from the much weaker maturation gene initiation site, located 1300 nucleotides upstream. As the stability of a hairpin stem comprising the coat gene Shine-Dalgarno site was incrementally increased, there was a corresponding increase in translation of maturation protein. The effect of the downstream coat gene ribosome binding sequence on maturation gene expression appeared to have occurred only in cis and did not require an AUG start codon or initiation of coat protein synthesis. In all cases, no structural reorganization was predicted to occur within Qβ RNA. Our results suggest that protein synthesis from a relatively weak translational initiation site is greatly influenced by the presence or absence of a stronger ribosome binding site located elsewhere on the same RNA molecule. The data are consistent with a mechanism in which multiple ribosome binding sites compete in cis for translational initiations as a means of regulating protein synthesis on a polycistronic messenger RNA.

Design of 5'-untranslated region variants for tunable expression in Escherichia coli

Redesign or modification of the cellular physiology requires a quantitatively well-controlled expression system known as the "tunable expression." Although the modification of promoters demonstrates the great impact on the translation efficiency, it is difficult to detect the proper variants required for tunable expression. The 5'-untranslated region (UTR), however, can be an important target for tunable expressions because the ribosome binding affinity is directly modulated by the sequence variants of the Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence and the AU-rich sequence, which are the ribosome binding sites and a SD-sequence-independent translation enhancer, respectively. This study developed a simple method to obtain numerous 5'-UTR variants and analyze their translation efficiency based on the PCR-based site-directed mutagenesis and the expressional PCR using coupled in vitro transcription/translation system derived from Escherichia coli and eGFP gene as a template. SD sequence variants (18) and AU-rich sequence variants (36), which have a wide range of relative expression levels ranging from 0.1 to 2.0, were obtained. The translation efficiency was affected by the ribosome binding affinity and its accessibility that is dependent on the secondary structure around the 5'-UTR.

Specialized ribosomes: highly specific translation in vivo of a single targetted mRNA species

In previous studies [Hui and de Boer, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 84 (1987) (1987) 4762-4766; Hui et al., Methods Enzymol. 153 (1987) 432-452], it was shown that efficient translation of the human growth hormone mRNA (hGH) species having an altered Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence, 5'-GUGUG-3', depends on the presence of specialized (spc) ribosomes containing the modified anti-SD (ASD) sequence, 5'-CACAC-3', near the 3' end of their 16S rRNA. In spite of the altered ASD sequence, spc ribosomes were not found to be committed exclusively to the translation of the hGH mRNA; no more than 30% of the total amount of protein synthesized by such ribosomes was hGH. Once we replace the coding sequence of the hGH mRNA with that of chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT), the specificity of spc ribosomes for translation of a single targetted mRNA, relative to the endogenous mRNAs, is greatly enhanced; an estimated 80% of the total amount of protein synthesized by spc ribosomes is CAT. Using the inducible spc ribosome system containing the cat gene, we show that, upon induction, spc ribosomes accumulate in large excess over the number needed for optimal translation of the targetted cat mRNA. Despite the excess, only few spc ribosomes initiate translation on a limited number of endogenous mRNAs. The excessive accumulation of spc ribosomes, which are predominantly present as free 30S subunits, is neither deleterious to the cells, nor does it lead to a feedback inhibition of the synthesis of wild-type ribosomes.

Probing dynamic changes in rRNA conformation in the 30S subunit of the Escherichia coli ribosome

Ribosomal RNA molecules within each ribosomal subunit are folded in a specific three-dimensional form. The accessibility of specific sequences of rRNA of the small ribosomal subunit of Escherichia coli was analyzed using complementary oligodeoxyribonucleotides, 6-15 nucleotides long. The degree of hybridization of these oligomers to their RNA complements within the 30S subunit was assessed using nitrocellulose membrane filter binding assays. Specifically, the binding of short DNA oligomers (hexameric and longer) complementary to nucleotides 919-928, 1384-1417, 1490-1505, and 1530-1542 of 16S rRNA was monitored, and in particular how such binding was affected by the change in the activation state of the subunit. We found that nucleotides 1397-1404 comprise an unusually accessible sequence in both active and inactive subunits. Nucleotides 919-924 are partially available for hybridization in active subunits and somewhat more so in inactive subunits. Nucleotides 1534-1542 are freely accessible in active, but only partially accessible in inactive subunits, while nucleotides 1490-1505 and 1530-1533 are inaccessible in both, under the conditions tested. These results are in general agreement with results obtained using other methods and suggest a significant conformational change upon subunit activation.

Probing the initiation complex formation on E coli ribosomes using short complementary DNA oligomers

Interactions between Escherichia coli 16S rRNA sequences (as components of 30S ribosomal subunits or tight-couple 70S ribosomes) with the ligands poly(U), poly(AGU), tRNAPhe, tRNAfMet, and the initiation factors have been studied. The ligands were employed as competitors for selected sites on 16S rRNA known to be accessible for hybridization to cDNA oligomers, regions 517-528, 1397-1404, and 1534-1542. The binding of cDNAs 1534-1541 and 1398-1403 decreased in the presence of the ligand pair poly(U)/tRNAPhe. Only the binding of cDNA 1534-1541 was affected by poly(AGU), while none of the complementary DNA oligomer binding was affected by tRNAPhe or tRNAfMet alone. The poly(AGU)/tRNAfMet ligand pair caused an additional decline in the binding of cDNA 1534-1541, relative to that caused by poly(AGU) alone, but the ligand pair did not affect the binding of the cDNA oligomers 517-528 or 1398-1403. The inclusion of the initiation factors did not significantly alter the binding level decreases observed for cDNA 1534-1541 in the presence of mRNAs or tRNA. At the 517-528 and 1398-1403 regions, the inclusion of the initiation factors, in either the presence or absence of the other ligands, caused a large decrease in the binding of the cDNA oligomers. The oligomers complementary to 16S bases 517-528 and 1398-1403 did not bind to tight-couple or reassociated 70S ribosomes. The data are discussed in terms of the decoding site hypothesis, and in terms of the mRNA alignment mechanism proposed by Trifonov [1].

Detection of Escherichia coli ribosome binding at translation initiation sites in the absence of tRNA

Binary complexes between messenger RNA and E. coli ribosomes were examined. A ribosome-mRNA binary complex on T4 gene 32 mRNA withstood inhibition by antibodies against ribosomal protein S1. Anti-S1 blocks ternary complex formation, as measured by "extension inhibition" or "toeprinting" analysis, only when preincubated with ribosomes prior to mRNA addition and not when anti-S1 was added after preincubation of ribosomes and mRNA. The ribosome was directly localized in a binary complex on two translation initiation sites by toeprinting analysis. In the absence of tRNA the ribosome halted cDNA synthesis by reverse transcriptase close to the Shine and Dalgarno sequence. Binary complex formation was inhibited by an oligodeoxynucleotide competitor of the Shine and Dalgarno sequence.

Influence of mRNA determinants on translation initiation in Escherichia coli

We have studied the classic initiation elements of mRNA sequence and structure to better understand their influence on translation initiation rates in Escherichia coli. Changes introduced in the initiation codon, the Shine and Dalgarno sequence, the spacing between those two elements, and in the secondary structures within initiation domains each change the rate of 30 S ternary complex formation. We measured these differences using extension inhibition analysis, a technique we have called "toeprinting". The rate of 30 S initiation complex formation in the absence of initiation factors agrees well with in vivo translation rates in some instances, although in others a regulatory role of initiation factors in 30 S complex formation is likely. Nucleotides 5' to the Shine and Dalgarno domain facilitate ternary complex formation.

Ribosome-messenger recognition: mRNA target sites for ribosomal protein S1

Ribosomal protein S1 is known to play an important role in translational initiation, being directly involved in recognition and binding of mRNAs by 30S ribosomal particles. Using a specially developed procedure based on efficient crosslinking of S1 to mRNA induced by UV irradiation, we have identified S1 binding sites on several phage RNAs in preinitiation complexes. Targets for S1 on Q beta and fr RNAs are localized upstream from the coat protein gene and contain oligo(U)-sequences. In the case of Q beta RNA, this S1 binding site overlaps the S-site for Q beta replicase and the site for S1 binding within a binary complex. It is reasonable that similar U-rich sequences represent S1 binding sites on bacterial mRNAs. To test this idea we have used E. coli ssb mRNA prepared in vitro with the T7 promoter/RNA polymerase system. By the methods of toeprinting, enzymatic footprinting, and UV crosslinking we have shown that binding of the ssb mRNA to 30S ribosomes is S1-dependent. The oligo(U)-sequence preceding the SD domain was found to be the target for S1. We propose that S1 binding sites, represented by pyrimidine-rich sequences upstream from the SD region, serve as determinants involved in recognition of mRNA by the ribosome.

The effect of oligonucleotides complementary to the 3' end of the 16S rRNA on the formation of the bacterial 30S initiation complex

Although much attention was focused on the role of the 16S RNA in mRNA selection by the 30S ribosomal subunit no true consensus site has emerged as yet. Oligonucleotides such as GAGG, UGAU and CCAA which are complementary to the 3' end of the 16S RNA stimulate the AUG-dependent binding of fMet-tRNA to 30S subunits. If those tetranucleotides are used in combination or if the octanucleotides GAGGUGAU and UGAUCCAA are applied, the degree of stimulation remains unchanged. Effects are strictly dependent on the presence of initiation factor 2 (IF-2) and cannot be produced by using A4 or U4. With sequences covalently linked to the AUG as in CCAAAUG and UGAUCCAAAUG, the efficiency of the initiation complex formation decreases significantly as compared to AUG with UGAUCCAAAUG being the least efficient mRNA analogue. The pentadecanucleotide GAGGUGAUCCAAAUG, however, shows the highest efficiency in directing the binding of the fMet-tRNA to 30S subunits and is clearly superior to AUG. Initiation factor 2 (IF-2), which stimulates tRNA binding significantly with AUG and CCAAAUG, both in terms of slope and plateau values of the binding curves, does not effect the initial rate of tRNA binding to GAGGUGAUCCAAAUG. In another set of experiments, where GAGG and AUG are separated by oligo(U) or oligo(A) sequences, the effect of chain length was investigated. mRNA analogues with a spacer of 6-9 nucleotides show the highest binding efficiencies, with a U spacer being superior to an A spacer, indicating that a more flexible spacer favours tRNA binding.

An additional ribosome-binding site on mRNA of highly expressed genes and a bifunctional site on the colicin fragment of 16S rRNA from Escherichia coli: important determinants of the efficiency of translation-initiation

For various genes of E. coli, three regions (-55 to -1; -35 to -1; -21 to -1) 5' to AUG codon on mRNA were searched for sites of interaction with colicin fragment of 16S rRNA. The detailed sequence comparison points out that apart from Shine-Dalgarno base pairing, an additional ribosome-binding site, a subsequence of 5'-UGAUCC-3' invariably exists in mRNA for highly expressed genes. Poorly expressed genes appear to be controlled by only Shine-Dalgarno base pairing. The analysis indicates that in the initiator region, the -55 to -1 region contains the signal which decides the efficiency of the translation-initiation. The site on 16S rRNA, 5'-GGAUCA-3' at position 1529, that can base pair to the above site, has a recognition site on 23S rRNA at position 2390. In the light of the conserved nature and accessibility of these sites, it is proposed that the site on 16S rRNA plays a bifunctional role--initially it binds to mRNA from highly expressed genes to form a stable 30S initiation complex, and upon association with 50S subunit it exchanges base pairing with 23S rRNA, thus leaving the site on mRNA free.

Complementary oligodeoxynucleotide probes of RNA conformation within the Escherichia coli small ribosomal subunit

The large RNA molecule within each ribosomal subunit is folded in a specific and compact form. The availability of specific 16S RNA sequences on the surface of the small ribosomal subunit has been probed by using complementary oligodeoxynucleotides. The hybridization of 8-15-nucleotide-long oligomers to their RNA complements within the subunit was quantitated by using a nitrocellulose membrane filter binding assay. The probes have been grouped into classes on the basis of sequence-specific binding ability under different conditions of ionic environment, incubation temperature, and subunit activation state [as defined by the ability to bind phenylalanyl-tRNA in response to a poly(uridylic acid) message]. Oligodeoxynucleotides complementary to nucleotides flanking 7-methylguanosine residue 527 and to the 3'-terminal sequence bound 30S subunits regardless of the activation state. Oligodeoxynucleotides that complement 16S ribosomal RNA residues 1-16, 60-70, 685-696, and 1330-1339 and the sequence adjacent to the colicin E3 cleavage site at residue 1502 all bound efficiently only to subunits in an inactivated conformation. Probes complementary to residues 1-11 and 446-455 bound only inactivated subunits, and then with low efficiency. Sequences complementary to nucleotides 6-16, 99-109, 1273-1281, and 1373-1383 bound 30S subunits poorly regardless of the activation state. With one exception, each probe was bound by native or heat-denatured 16S ribosomal RNA (as determined by size-exclusion chromatography). We conclude that complementary oligodeoxynucleotide binding efficiency is a sensitive measure of the availability of specific RNA sequences under easily definable conditions.

Point mutations that affect translation initiation in the Escherichia coli gal E gene

This paper describes the selection and characterization of several mutations in the Escherichia coli galactose operon that affect translation initiation of the galE gene but are located outside of the Shine-Dalgarno sequence and the initiator codon. One mutation lies in the gal promoter region and shifts transcription initiation from the galP1 to the galP2 promoter. This results in a gal messenger that is five nucleotides longer and that is translated threefold more efficiently in vivo. This accords with previous observations from in vitro experiments which showed that the longer gal messenger was better translated (Queen & Rosenberg, 1981). The other mutations that affect galE translation are located in the coding sequence immediately downstream from the initiator codon. In contrast to the promoter mutation, these cause alterations in galE expression only when the gene carries a mutated initiator codon or Shine-Dalgarno sequence and have no effect on the wild-type galE gene. These findings are discussed with respect to our present knowledge of translation initiation mechanisms.

Basepairing of oligonucleotides to the 3' end of 16S ribosomal RNA is not stabilized by ribosomal proteins

We have studied the binding of the octanucleotide (5'-3')d(AAGGAGGT) which is fully complementary to the 3' end of 16S ribosomal RNA, to ribosomes and to the isolated target sequence (5'-3') (ACCUCCUUA). The binding constant for 30S or 70S ribosomes is (5 +/- 2) X 10(7) mol-1, whereas the duplex containing the octa- and the nonanucleotide has an association constant of (6 +/- 3) X 10(7) mol-1. The two values are the same within the experimental error. This result suggests that basepairing at the 3' end of 16S rRNA is not stabilized by ribosomal proteins.

Recognition of messenger RNA during translational initiation in Escherichia coli

The structural aspects of recognition by E. coli ribosomes of translational initiation regions on homologous messenger RNAs have been reviewed. Also discussed is the location of initiation region on mRNA, its confines, typical nucleotide sequences responsible for initiation signal, and the influence of RNA macrostructure on protein synthesis initiation. Most of the published DNA nucleotide sequences surrounding the start of various E. coli genes and those of its phages have been collected.

Higher order structure in the 3'-minor domain of small subunit ribosomal RNAs from a gram negative bacterium, a gram positive bacterium and a eukaryote

An experimental approach was used to determine and compare the highest order structure within the 150 to 200 nucleotides at the 3'-ends of the RNAs from the small ribosomal subunits of Escherichia coli, Bacillus stearothermophilus and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Chemical reagents were employed to establish the degree of stacking and/or accessibility of each adenosine, guanosine and cytidine. The double helices were probed with a cobra venom ribonuclease from Naja naja oxiana, and the relatively unstructured and accessible sequences were localized with the single strand-specific ribonucleases A, T1, T2 and S1. The data enabled the various minimal secondary structural models, proposed for the 3'-regions of the E. coli and S. cerevisiae RNAs, to be critically examined, and to demonstrate that the main common features of these models are correct. The results also reveal the presence and position of additional higher order structure in the renatured free RNA. It can be concluded that a high level of conservation of higher order structure has occurred during the evolution of the gram negative and gram positive eubacteria and the eukaryote in both the double helical regions and the "unstructured" regions. Several unusual structural features were detected. Multiple G X A pairings in two of the putative helices, which are compatible with phylogenetic sequence comparisons, are strongly supported by the occurrence of cobra venom ribonuclease cuts adjacent to, and in one case between, these pairings. Evidence is also provided for the stacking of an A X A pair within a double helix of the yeast RNA. Other special structural features include adenosines bulged out from double helices; such nucleotides, which are hyper-reactive, have been implicated in protein recognition in 5 S ribosomal RNA. The 3'-terminal regions of the RNAs are particularly important for the functioning of the ribosome. They are involved in mRNA, tRNA and ribosomal factor binding. The results reveal that while the functionally important RNA sequences tend to be conserved, they are not always accessible in the free RNA; the pyrimidine-rich "Shine and Dalgarno" sequence, for example, which is involved in mRNA recognition, occurs in a double helix in both eubacterial RNAs.

Effect of the sequences upstream from the ribosome-binding site on the yield of protein from the cloned gene for phage MS2 coat protein

The translational efficiency of the coat protein gene of phage MS2 has been examined in vivo with respect to neighbouring sequences. The cloned MS2 DNA has been gradually shortened starting at the 5' or 3' terminus, and its effect on coat protein synthesis monitored. Removal of the 3'-terminal sequences had little influence. In contrast, the gradual removal of the 5'-terminal region profoundly reduces translation. Long before the ribosomal binding site (RBS) of the coat protein (CP) gene is reached, the yield of CP has dropped by one order of magnitude. Functional half-lives of the various messengers were found not to be significantly different. Available evidence indicates that the secondary structure of the RBS in native and shortened MS2 RNA is identical. We infer that important determinants for ribosome recognition lie 5' to the RBS region of the MS2 RNA coat gene.

The function of ribosomal protein S21 in protein synthesis

The function of ribosomal protein S21 in protein synthesis has been examined by (a) inactivation of S21 in situ with specific antibodies and (b) the use of 30-S subunits reconstituted in the absence of S21. The results from the two approaches are consistent, 30-S subunits treated with anti-S21 or lacking S21 are still active in the translation of poly(U) or poly(A, G, U). They are also functional in fMet-tRNA binding when directed by poly(A, G, U) or the AUG triplet. They are not active in the translation of MS2 RNA or Escherichia coli mRNA. The defect of S21-deficient 30-S ribosomes can be traced back to their inability to bind MS2 RNA at the initiation step of protein synthesis. Addition of S21 to S21-deprived subunits restores the MS2-RNA-dependent initiation complex formation.

Basepairing potential of the 3' terminus of 16S RNA: dependence on the functional state of the 30S subunit and the presence of protein S21

The deoxyoctanucleotide 5'd (AAGGAGGT) which is complementary to the 3' terminus of 16S RNA has been used as a probe to measure the potential of this rRNA region to engage in intermolecular basepairing. The site specific binding of the octanucleotide is shown by labeling 16S RNA in situ at its 3' end with [32P]pCp and T4 RNA ligase (EC 6.5.1.3.). The label can be released as pA[32P]pCp by the simultaneous action of RNAse H (EC 3.1.4.34) and 5'd(AAGGAGGT). WE show that (1) 30S subunits prepared according to standard procedures, bind less than one copy of 5'd(AAGGAGGT); (2) isolated 16S RNA and 30S subunits inactivated by transcient exposure to 0.5 mM Mg2+ do not bind the octanucleotide; (3) binding to inactive subunits can be restored by a brief heat treatment; (4) 30S subunits lacking protein S21 do not bind 5'd(AAGGAGGT) even when submitted to heat treatment; (5) addition of protein S21 to subunits lacking S21 restores octamer binding; (6) the apparent exposure of the 16S RNA 3' terminus brought about by protein S21 is accompanied by the potential of the subunits to accept MS2 RNA as messenger; (7) the presence or absence of S1 on 30S subunits has no effect on their octanucleotide binding property.