The antibiotics kirromycin and pulvomycin bind to different sites on the elongation factor Tu from Escherichia coli

Pangenome analyses of Clostridium butyricum provide insights into its genetic characteristics and industrial application

Clostridium butyricum is a Gram-positive anaerobic bacterium known for its ability to produce butyate. In this study, we conducted whole-genome sequencing and assembly of 14C. butyricum industrial strains collected from various parts of China. We performed a pan-genome comparative analysis of the 14 assembled strains and 139 strains downloaded from NCBI. We found that the genes related to critical industrial production pathways were primarily present in the core and soft-core gene categories. The phylogenetic analysis revealed that strains from the same clade of the phylogenetic tree possessed similar antibiotic resistance and virulence factors, with most of these genes present in the shell and cloud gene categories. Finally, we predicted the genes producing bacteriocins and botulinum toxins as well as CRISPR systems responsible for host defense. In conclusion, our research provides a desirable pan-genome database for the industrial production, food application, and genetic research of C. butyricum.

Identification of pulvomycin as an inhibitor of the futalosine pathway

Menaquinone is an essential cofactor in the electron-transfer pathway for bacteria. Menaquinone is biosynthesized from chorismate using either the well-known canonical pathway established by pioneering studies in model microorganisms or the futalosine pathway, which we discovered in Streptomyces. Because Helicobacter pylori, which causes stomach cancer, uses the futalosine pathway and most beneficial intestinal bacteria including lactobacilli use the canonical pathway, the futalosine pathway will be a great target to develop antibiotics specific for H. pylori. Here, we searched for such compounds from metabolites produced by actinomycetes and identified pulvomycin from culture broth of Streptomyces sp. K18-0194 as a specific inhibitor of the futalosine pathway.

Structural Basis of the Action of Pulvomycin and GE2270 A on Elongation Factor Tu,

Pulvomycin inhibits protein synthesis by preventing the formation of the ternary complex between elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) x GTP and aa-tRNA. In this work, the crystal structure of Thermus thermophilus EF-Tu x pulvomycin in complex with the GTP analogue guanylyl imino diphosphate (GDPNP) at 1.4 A resolution reveals an antibiotic binding site extending from the domain 1-3 interface to domain 2, overlapping the domain 1-2-3 junction. Pulvomycin binding interferes with the binding of the 3'-aminoacyl group, the acceptor stem, and 5' end of tRNA. Only part of pulvomycin overlaps the binding site of GE2270 A, a domain 2-bound antibiotic of a structure unrelated to pulvomycin, which also hinders aa-tRNA binding. The structure of the T. thermophilus EF-Tu x GDPNP x GE2270 A complex at 1.6 A resolution shows that GE2270 A interferes with the binding of the 3'-aminoacyl group and part of the acceptor stem of aa-tRNA but not with the 5' end. Both compounds, pulvomycin more markedly, hinder the correct positioning of domain 1 over domains 2 and 3 that characterizes the active form of EF-Tu, while they affect the domain 1 switch regions that control the EF-Tu x GDP/GTP transitions in different ways. This work reveals how two antibiotics with different structures and binding modes can employ a similar mechanism of action.

Effects of the antibiotic pulvomycin on the elongation factor Tu-dependent reactions. Comparison with other antibiotics

The antibiotic pulvomycin is an inhibitor of protein synthesis that prevents the formation of the ternary complex between elongation factor (EF-) Tu.GTP and aminoacyl-tRNA. In this report, novel aspects of its action on EF-Tu are described. Pulvomycin markedly affects the equilibrium and kinetics of the EF-Tu-nucleotide interaction, particularly of the EF-Tu.GTP complex. The binding affinity of EF-Tu for GTP is increased 1000 times, mainly as the consequence of a dramatic decrease in the dissociation rate of this complex. In contrast, the affinity for GDP is decreased 10-fold due to a marked increase in the dissociation rate of EF-Tu.GDP (25-fold) that mimics the action of EF-Ts, the GDP/GTP exchange factor of EF-Tu. The effects of pulvomycin and EF-Ts can coexist and are simply additive, supporting the conclusion that these two ligands interact with different sites of EF-Tu. This is further confirmed on native PAGE by the ability of EF-Tu to bind the EF-Ts and the antibiotic simultaneously. Pulvomycin enhances the intrinsic EF-Tu GTPase activity, like kirromycin, though to a much more modest extent. As with kirromycin, this stimulation depends on the concentration and nature of the monovalent cations, Li(+) being the most effective one, followed by Na(+), K(+), and NH(4)(+). In the presence of pulvomycin (in contrast to kirromycin), aa-tRNA and/or ribosomes do not enhance the GTPase activity of EF-Tu. The property of pulvomycin to modify selectively the conformation(s) of EF-Tu is also supported by its effect on heat- and urea-dependent denaturation, and tryptic digestion of the protein. Specific differences and similarities between the action of pulvomycin and the other EF-Tu-specific antibiotics are described and discussed.

EF-Tu binding peptides identified, dissected, and affinity optimized by phage display

The highly abundant GTP binding protein elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) fulfills multiple roles in bacterial protein biosynthesis. Phage-displayed peptides with high affinity for EF-Tu were selected from a library of approximately 4.7 x 10(11) different peptides. The lack of sequence homology among the identified EF-Tu ligands demonstrates promiscuous peptide binding by EF-Tu. Homolog shotgun scanning of an EF-Tu ligand was used to dissect peptide molecular recognition by EF-Tu. All homolog shotgun scanning selectants bound to EF-Tu with higher affinity than the starting ligand. Thus, homolog shotgun scanning can simultaneously optimize binding affinity and rapidly provide detailed structure activity relationships for multiple side chains of a polypeptide ligand. The reported peptide ligands do not compete for binding to EF-Tu with various antibiotic EF-Tu inhibitors, and could identify an EF-Tu peptide binding site distinct from the antibiotic inhibitory sites.

Mechanisms of EF-Tu, a pioneer GTPase

This review considers several aspects of the function of EF-Tu, a protein that has greatly contributed to the advancement of our knowledge of both protein biosynthesis and GTP-binding proteins in general. A number of topics are described with emphasis on the function-structure relationships, in particular of EF-Tu's domains, the nucleotide-binding site, and the magnesium-binding network. Aspects related to the interaction with macromolecular ligands and antibiotics and to folding and GTPase activity are also presented and discussed. Comments and criticism are offered to draw attention to remaining discrepancies and problems.

The major head protein of bacteriophage T4 binds specifically to elongation factor Tu

The Lit protease in Escherichia coli K-12 strains induces cell death in response to bacteriophage T4 infection by cleaving translation elongation factor (EF) Tu and shutting down translation. Suicide of the cell is timed to the appearance late in the maturation of the phage of a short peptide sequence in the major head protein, the Gol peptide, which activates proteolysis. In the present work we demonstrate that the Gol peptide binds specifically to domains II and III of EF-Tu, creating the unique substrate for the Lit protease, which then cleaves domain I, the guanine nucleotide binding domain. The conformation of EF-Tu is important for binding and Lit cleavage, because both are sensitive to the identity of the bound nucleotide, with GDP being preferred over GTP. We propose that association of the T4 coat protein with EF-Tu plays a role in phage head assembly but that this association marks infected cells for suicide when Lit is present. Based on these data and recent observations on human immunodeficiency virus type 1 maturation, we speculate that associations between host translation factors and coat proteins may be integral to viral assembly in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

Functional role of the noncatalytic domains of elongation factor Tu in the interactions with ligands

Elongation factor (EF) Tu from Escherichia coli contains three domains, of which domain 1 (N-terminal domain) harbors the site for nucleotide binding and GTP hydrolysis. To analyze the function of domains 2 [middle (M) domain] and 3 [C-terminal (C) domain], EF-Tu(DeltaM) and EF-Tu(DeltaC) were engineered as GST-fused products and purified. Circular dichroism and thermostability showed that both constructs have conserved organized structures. Though inactive in poly(Phe) synthesis the two constructs could bind GDP and GTP with comparable micromolar affinities. Therefore, like the isolated N-terminal domain, they had lost a typical feature of EF-Tu, the >100 times stronger affinity for GDP than for GTP. EF-Tu(DeltaM) and EF-Tu(DeltaC) had an intrinsic GTPase activity comparable to that of wild-type EF-Tu. Ribosomes did not stimulate the GTPase activity of either factor, while kirromycin increased the GTPase activity of both constructs, particularly of EF-Tu(DeltaC), to a level, however, much lower than that of the intact molecule. The interaction with aa-tRNA of both mutants was >90% reduced. As a major result, their GDP-bound form could efficiently respond to EF-Ts. All four EF-Tu-specific antibiotics [kirromycin, pulvomycin, GE2270 A (=MDL 62 879), and enacyloxin IIa] retarded significantly the dissociation of EF-Tu(DeltaC).GTP, showing the same kind of effect as on EF-Tu.GTP, but they were little active on EF-Tu(DeltaM). GTP. Like EF-Tu(DeltaC).GTP, EF-Tu(DeltaM).GTP was, however, able to bind efficiently kirromycin and enacyloxin IIa, as determined via competition with EF-Ts. Together, these results enlight selective functions of domains 2 and 3, particularly toward the interaction with EF-Ts and antibiotics, and emphasize their functional cooperativity for an efficient interaction of EF-Tu with ribosomes and aa-tRNA and for maintaining the differential affinity for GTP and GDP.

Antibiotics MDL 62,879 and kirromycin bind to distinct and independent sites of elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu)

Antibiotic MDL 62,879 inhibits bacterial protein synthesis by acting on elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu). In this study we show that the inhibition of protein synthesis by MDL 62,879 in an Escherichia coli cell-free system was fully reversed by addition of stoichiometric amounts of EF-Tu but not by large excesses of EF-Ts, ribosomes, or aa-tRNA. MDL 62,879 bound tightly to EF-Tu and formed a stable 1:1 MDL 62,879:EF-Tu (M:EF-Tu) complex. We show that binding of MDL 62,879 to EF-Tu strongly affects the interaction of EF-Tu with aa-tRNA and causes rapid dissociation of preformed EF-Tu.aa-tRNA complex, suggesting that inhibition of aa-tRNA binding is due to a conformational change in EF-Tu rather than competition for the aa-tRNA binding site. Indication of a conformational change in EF-Tu induced by MDL 62,879 is further confirmed by proteolytic cleavage experiments: MDL 62,879 binding strongly protects EF-Tu against trypsin cleavage. The observed effects of MDL 62,879 appear to be different from those of the kirromycin class of antibiotics, which also inhibit protein synthesis by binding to EF-Tu, suggesting two distinct binding sites. Indeed, the M:EF-Tu complex was able to bind stoichiometric amounts of kirromycin to form a 1:1:1 M:EF-Tu:kirromycin (M:EF-Tu:K) complex, providing direct evidence that the two antibiotics bind to independent and distinct sites on the EF-Tu molecule. The interaction of the M:EF-Tu:K complex with aa-tRNA and other co-factors suggest that the contemporary binding of the two antibiotics locks EF-Tu into an intermediate conformation in which neither antibiotic exhibits complete dominance.

Antibiotic resistance mechanisms of mutant EF-Tu species in Escherichia coli

Analysis of antibiotic-resistant EF-Tu mutants has revealed a connection between resistance and structural elements that participate in the GTPase switching mechanism. Both random and site-directed mutagenesis methods have yielded sets of purified mutant EF-Tu resistant to kirromycin (kirT) or pulvomycin (pulT). All kirT mutations cluster in the interface of domain 1 and 3 of EF-Tu in its GTP-bound conformation, not in that of EF-Tu.GDP. Other evidence also suggests that kirromycin binds to the interface of wild-type EF-Tu, thereby jamming the GTPase switch. Various functional studies reveal two subsequent resistance mechanisms. The first hinders kirromycin binding to EF-Tu.GTP and the second occurs after GTP hydrolysis by rejection of bound kirromycin. All pulT mutations cluster in the three-domain junction interface of EF-Tu. GTP (which is an open hole in EF-Tu.GDP) and destabilize a salt-bridge network. Pulvomycin may bind nearby and overlap with tRNA binding. Mutations show that a D99-R230 salt bridge is not essential for the transduction of the GTPase switch signal from domain 1. In vivo and in vitro studies reveal that pulvomycin sensitivity is dominant over resistance. This demands a revision of the current view of the mechanism of pulvomycin inhibition of protein synthesis and may support a translation model with two EF-Tus on the ribosome. Several mutant EF-Tu species display altered behaviour towards aminoacyl-tRNA with interesting effects on translational accuracy. KirT EF-Tu(A375T) is able to reverse the streptomycin-dependent phenotype of a ribosomal protein S12 mutant strain to streptomycin sensitivity.

Substitution of Arg230 and Arg233 in Escherichia coli elongation factor Tu strongly enhances its pulvomycin resistance

Pulvomycin is a strong inhibitor of protein synthesis, known to prevent the binding of aminoacyl-tRNA to elongation factor Tu.GTP (EF-Tu.GTP). Recently, three pulvomycin-resistant mutant strains have been isolated by targeted mutagenesis of the tufA gene resulting in EF-Tu substitutions at positions 230, 333 or 334. In order to analyze the functions of arginine residues located in domain II, with respect to pulvomycin resistance and the interaction with aminoacyl-tRNA, we have investigated the effect of the substitutions of the highly conserved residues Arg230 and Arg233 by site-directed mutagenesis. We have purified two mutants species, [R233S]EF-TuHis and [R230V, R233F]EF-TuHis, both with a C-terminal histidine extension to enable purification by Ni2+ affinity chromatography. In this study, we describe the in vitro characterization of these mutant proteins. The results show that the concomitant substitution of residues at positions 230 and 233, dramatically increases the pulvomycin resistance. Preliminary evidence is presented that protein synthesis is inhibited by an EF-Tu.GDP.pulvomycin complex rather than by EF-Tu.GTP.pulvomycin. Moreover, the mutant [R230V, R233F]EF-TuHis shows a stronger protection of the ester bond of aminoacyl-tRNA than wild-type EF-Tu.

Crystal structure of active elongation factor Tu reveals major domain rearrangements

The crystal structure of intact elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) from Thermus thermophilus has been determined and refined at an effective resolution of 1.7 A, with incorporation of data extending to 1.45 A. The effector region, including interaction sites for the ribosome and for transfer RNA, is well defined. Molecular mechanisms are proposed for transduction and amplification of the signal induced by GTP binding as well as for the intrinsic and effector-enhanced GTPase activity of EF-Tu. Comparison of the structure with that of EF-Tu-GDP reveals major mutual rearrangements of the three domains of the molecule.

Isolation and functional analysis of histidine-tagged elongation factor Tu

The study of the structure/function relationships of the Escherichia coli elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) via mutagenesis has been hampered by difficulties encountered in separating the mutated factor from other proteins, in particular native EF-Tu. Here we describe a novel system for the purification of EF-Tu mutant species, based on metal-ion affinity chromatography. To facilitate rapid and efficient purification we designed a recombinant EF-Tu with an additional C-terminal sequence of one serine and six histidine residues. A cell extract containing the His-tagged EF-Tu (EF-TuHis) is applied to a Ni(2+)-nitrilotriacetic acid column. EF-TuHis can be selectively eluted with an imidazole containing buffer, yielding a preparation of more than 95% purity, free of wild-type EF-Tu. In-vitro and in-vivo functional analyses show that EF-TuHis resembles the wild-type EF-Tu, which makes this one-step isolation procedure a promising tool for the study of the interactions of mutant EF-Tu with the various components of the elongation cycle. The new isolation procedure was successfully applied for the purification of a mutant EF-TuHis with a Glu substitution for Lys237, a residue possibly involved in the binding of aminoacyl-tRNA.

Overproduction of the Thermus thermophilus elongation factor Tu in Escherichia coli

The elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) encoded by the tufl gene of the extreme thermophilic bacterium Thermus thermophilus HB8 was expressed under control of the tac promoter from the recombinant plasmid pEFTu-10 in Escherichia coli. Thermophilic EF-Tu-GDP, which amounts to as much as 35% of the cellular protein content, was separated from the E coli EF-Tu-GDP by thermal denaturation at 60 degrees C. The overproduced E coli-born T thermophilus EF-Tu was characterized by: i) recognition through T thermophilus anti-EF-Tu antibodies; ii) analysis of the peptides obtained by cyanogen bromide cleavage; iii) thermostability; iv) guanine nucleotide binding activity in the absence and the presence of elongation factor Ts; and v) ternary complex formation with phenylalanyl-tRNAPhe and GTP.

Unique antibiotic sensitivity of archaebacterial polypeptide elongation factors

The antibiotic sensitivity of the archaebacterial factors catalyzing the binding of aminoacyl-tRNA to ribosomes (elongation factor Tu [EF-Tu] for eubacteria and elongation factor 1 [EF1] for eucaryotes) and the translocation of peptidyl-tRNA (elongation factor G [EF-G] for eubacteria and elongation factor 2 [EF2] for eucaryotes) was investigated by using two EF-Tu and EF1 [EF-Tu(EF1)]-targeted drugs, kirromycin and pulvomycin, and the EF-G and EF2 [EF-G(EF2)]-targeted drug fusidic acid. The interaction of the inhibitors with the target factors was monitored by using polyphenylalanine-synthesizing cell-free systems. A survey of methanogenic, halophilic, and sulfur-dependent archaebacteria showed that elongation factors of organisms belonging to the methanogenic-halophilic and sulfur-dependent branches of the "third kingdom" exhibit different antibiotic sensitivity spectra. Namely, the methanobacterial-halobacterial EF-Tu(EF1)-equivalent protein was found to be sensitive to pulvomycin but insensitive to kirromycin, whereas the methanobacterial-halobacterial EF-G(EF2)-equivalent protein was found to be sensitive to fusidic acid. By contrast, sulfur-dependent thermophiles were unaffected by all three antibiotics, with two exceptions; Thermococcus celer, whose EF-Tu(EF1)-equivalent factor was blocked by pulvomycin, and Thermoproteus tenax, whose EF-G(EF2)-equivalent factor was sensitive to fusidic acid. On the whole, the results revealed a remarkable intralineage heterogeneity of elongation factors not encountered within each of the two reference (eubacterial and eucaryotic) kingdoms.