The ribosomal elongation cycle: tRNA binding, translocation and tRNA release

Further in vitro exploration fails to support the allosteric three-site model

Ongoing debate in the ribosome field has focused on the role of bound E-site tRNA and the Shine-Dalgarno-anti-Shine-Dalgarno (SD-aSD) interaction on A-site tRNA interactions and the fidelity of tRNA selection. Here we use an in vitro reconstituted Escherichia coli translation system to explore the reported effects of E-site-bound tRNA and SD-aSD interactions on tRNA selection events and find no evidence for allosteric coupling. A large set of experiments exploring the role of the E-site tRNA in miscoding failed to recapitulate the observations of earlier studies (Di Giacco, V., Márquez, V., Qin, Y., Pech, M., Triana-Alonso, F. J., Wilson, D. N., and Nierhaus, K. H. (2008) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 105, 10715-10720 and Geigenmüller, U., and Nierhaus, K. H. (1990) EMBO J. 9, 4527-4533); the frequency of miscoding was unaffected by the presence of E-site-bound cognate tRNA. Moreover, our data provide clear evidence that the reported effects of the SD-aSD interaction on fidelity can be attributed to the binding of ribosomes to an unanticipated site on the mRNA (in the absence of the SD sequence) that provides a cognate pairing codon leading naturally to incorporation of the purported "noncognate" amino acid.

Photoaffinity polyamines: interactions with AcPhe-tRNA free in solution or bound at the P-site of Escherichia coli ribosomes

Two photoreactive derivatives of spermine, azidobenzamidino (ABA)-spermine and azidonitrobenzoyl (ANB)-spermine, were used for mapping of polyamine binding sites in AcPhe-tRNA free in solution or bound at the P-site of Escherichia coli poly(U)-programmed ribosomes. Partial nuclease digestion indicated that the deep pocket formed by nucleosides of the D-stem and the variable loop, as well as the anticodon stem, are preferable polyamine binding sites for AcPhe-tRNA in the free state. ABA-spermine was a stronger cross-linker than ANB-spermine. Both photoprobes were linked to AcPhe-tRNA with higher affinity when the latter was non-enzymatically bound to poly(U)-programmed ribosomes. In particular, the cross-linking at the TpsiC stem and acceptor stem was substantially promoted. The photolabeled AcPhe-tRNA.poly(U).ribosome complex exhibited moderate reactivity towards puromycin. The attachment of photoprobes to AcPhe-tRNA was mainly responsible for this defect. A more complicated situation was revealed when the AcPhe-tRNA.poly(U).ribosome complex was formed in the presence of translation factors; the reactivity towards puromycin was stimulated by irradiating such a complex in the presence of photoprobes at 50 microM, with higher concentrations being inhibitory. The stimulatory effect was closely related with the binding of photoprobes to ribosomes. The results are discussed on the basis of possible AcPhe-tRNA conformational changes induced by the incorporation of photoprobes.

A conformational switch in Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA during decoding of messenger RNA

Direct evidence is presented for a conformational switch in 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) that affects tRNA binding to the ribosome and decoding of messenger RNA (mRNA). These data support the hypothesis that dynamic changes in rRNA structure occur during translation. The switch involves two alternating base-paired arrangements apparently facilitated by ribosomal proteins S5 and S12, and produces significant changes in the rRNA structure. Chemical probing shows reciprocal enhancements or protections at sites in 16S rRNA that are at or very near sites that were previously crosslinked to mRNA. These data indicate that the switch affects codon-anticodon arrangement and proper selection of tRNA at the ribosomal A site, and that the switch is a fundamental mechanism in all ribosomes.

Evidence for a conformational change in the exit site of the Escherichia coli ribosome upon tRNA binding

The exit (E) site of the Escherichia coli ribosome was investigated using oligodeoxyribonucleotides complementary to single-stranded regions of ribosomal RNA suggested to be involved in tRNA binding in the E site [Moazed, D., & Noller, H. (1989) Cell 57, 585-597]. Radiolabeled DNA oligomers (probes) were hybridized in situ to complementary sites on the ribosomal RNA of ribosomes or ribosomal subunits, and the effects of simultaneous tRNA or antibiotic binding on probe binding were measured using a nitrocellulose filtration binding assay. Site specificity of probe binding was assured using ribonuclease H to cleave the ribosomal RNA at the site of probe binding. When 50S subunits were hybridized with a probe spanning bases 2109-2119 and deacylated tRNA was added incrementally, probe binding decreased, suggesting that the probe and tRNA competed for the same binding site or that tRNA was allosterically affecting the probe binding site. When 70S ribosomes were substituted for 50S subunits, probe binding to this site initially increased and then decreased at higher concentrations of deacylated tRNA. Titrating probe-ribosome complexes with acylated tRNA, N-acetyl-acylated tRNA, tetracycline, or chloramphenicol had no effect on probe binding. The data presented provide evidence for tRNA/rRNA interaction at or near the E site of the E. coli ribosome and suggest that a conformational change occurs in the E site when deacylated tRNA is bound to the P site. The data suggest that deacylated tRNA in the P site serves as a translocational trigger by causing the E site to change conformations, making it more available for tRNA (and probe) binding and therefore promoting translocation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Interaction of human and Escherichia coli tRNA(Phe) with human 80S ribosomes in the presence of oligo- and polyuridylate templates

Human placenta and Escherichia coli Phe-tRNA(Phe) and N-AcPhe-tRNA(Phe) binding to human placenta 80S ribosomes was studied at 13 mM Mg2+ and 20 degrees C in the presence of poly(U), (pU)6 or without a template. Binding properties of both tRNA species were studied. Poly(U)-programmed 80S ribosomes were able to bind charged tRNA at A and P sites simultaneously under saturating conditions resulting in effective dipeptide formation in the case of Phe-tRNA(Phe). Affinities of both forms of tRNA(Phe) to the P site were similar (about 1 x 10(7) M-1) and exceeded those to the A site. Affinity of the deacylated tRNA(Phe) to the P site was much higher (association constant > 10(10) M-1). Binding at the E site (introduced into the 80S ribosome by its 60S subunit) was specific for deacylated tRNA(Phe). The association constant of this tRNA to the E site when A and P sites were preoccupied with N-AcPhe-tRNA(Phe) was estimated as (1.7 +/- 0.1) x 10(6) M-1. In the presence of (pU)6, charged tRNA(Phe) bound loosely at the A and P sites, and the transpeptidation level exceeded the binding level due to the exchange with free tRNA from solution. Affinities of aminoacyl-tRNA to the A and P sites in the presence of (pU)6 seem to be the same and much lower than those in the case of poly(U). Without a messenger, binding of the charged tRNA(Phe) to 80S ribosomes was undetectable, although an effective transpeptidation was observed suggesting a very labile binding of the tRNA simultaneously at the A and P sites.

The function of the translating ribosome: allosteric three-site model of elongation

During the last decade, a new model for the ribosomal elongation cycle has emerged. It is based on the finding that eubacterial ribosomes possess 3 tRNA binding sites. More recently, this has been confirmed for archaebacterial and eukaryotic ribosomes as well, and thus appears to be a universal feature of the protein synthetic machinery. Ribosomes from organisms of all 3 kingdoms harbor, in addition to the classical P and A sites, an E site (E for exit), into which deacylated tRNA is displaced during translocation, and from which it is expelled by the binding of an aminoacyl-tRNA to the A site at the beginning of the subsequent elongation round. The main features of the allosteric 3-site model of ribosomal elongation are the following: first, the third tRNA binding site is located 'upstream' adjacent to the P site with respect to the messenger, ie on the 5'-side of the P site. Second, during translocation, deacylated tRNA does not leave the ribosome from the P site, but co-translocates from the P site to the E site--when peptidyl-tRNA translocates from the A site to the P site. Third, deacylated tRNA is tightly bound to the E site in the post-translocational state, where it undergoes codon--anticodon interaction. Fourth, the elongating ribosome oscillates between 2 main conformations: (i), the pre-translocational conformer, where aminoacyl-tRNA (or peptidyl-tRNA) and peptidyl-tRNA (or deacylated tRNA) are firmly bound to the A and P sites, respectively; and (ii), the post-translocational conformer, where peptidyl-tRNA and deacylated tRNA are firmly bound to the P and E sites, respectively. The transition between the 2 states is regulated in an allosteric manner via negative cooperatively. It is modulated in a symmetrical fashion by the 2 elongation factors Tu and G. An elongating ribosome always maintains 2 high-affinity tRNA binding sites with 2 adjacent codon--anticodon interactions. The allosteric transition from the post- to the pre-translocational state is involved in the accuracy of aminoacyl-tRNA selection, and the maintenance of 2 codon--anticodon interactions helps to keep the messenger in frame during translation.

Partial release of AcPhe-Phe-tRNA from ribosomes during poly(U)-dependent poly(Phe) synthesis and the effects of chloramphenicol

Poly(U)-programmed 70S ribosomes can be shown to be 80% to 100% active in binding the peptidyl-tRNA analogue AcPhe-tRNA to their A or P sites, respectively. Despite this fact, only a fraction of such ribosomes primed with AcPhe-tRNA participate in poly(U)-directed poly(Phe) synthesis (up to 65%) at 14 mM Mg2+ and 160 mM NH4+. Here it is demonstrated that the apparently 'inactive' ribosomes (greater than or equal to 35%) are able to participate in peptide-bond formation, but lose their nascent peptidyl-tRNA at the stage of Ac(Phe)n-tRNA, with n greater than or equal to 2. The relative loss of early peptidyl-tRNAs is largely independent of the degree of initial saturation with AcPhe-tRNA and is observed in a poly(A) system as well. This observation resolves a current controversy concerning the active fraction of ribosomes. The loss of Ac(Phe)n-tRNA is reduced but still significant if more physiological conditions for Ac(Phe)n synthesis are applied (3 mM Mg2+, 150 mM NH4+, 2 mM spermidine, 0.05 mM spermine). Chloramphenicol (0.1 mM) blocks the puromycin reaction with AcPhe-tRNA as expected but, surprisingly, does not affect the puromycin reaction with Ac(Phe)2-tRNA nor peptide bond formation between AcPhe-tRNA and Phe-tRNA. The drug facilitates the release of Ac(Phe)2-4-tRNA from ribosomes at 14 mM Mg2+ while it hardly affects the overall synthesis of poly(Phe) or poly(Lys).

Reactivity of the P-site-bound donor in ribosomal peptide-bond formation

The puromycin reaction, catalyzed by the ribosomal peptidyltransferase, has been carried out so as to make the definition of two distinct parameters of this reaction possible. These are (a) the final degree of the reaction which gives the proportion of peptidyl (P)-site binding of the donor and (b) the reactivity of the donor substrate expressed as an apparent rate constant (kobs). This kobs varies with the concentration of puromycin; the maximal value (k3) of the kobs, at saturating concentrations of puromycin, gives the reactivity of the donor independently of the concentrations of both the donor and puromycin. k3 is also a measure of the activity of peptidyltransferase expressed as its catalytic rate constant (kcat). If we assume that the puromycin-reactive donor is bound at the ribosomal P site, we observe the following, depending on the conditions of the experiment: the proportion of P-site binding of the donor substrates AcPhe-tRNA or fMet-tRNA can be the same and close to 100%, while there is a tenfold increase in the reactivity of the donor (k3 = 0.8 min-1 versus 8.3 min-1). On the other hand there are conditions, under which the proportion of P-site binding increases from 30% to 100% while k3 remains low and equal to 0.8 min-1. Using the puromycin reaction it was also found that an increase of Mg2+ from 10 mM to 20 mM reduces the reactivity of the donor and, hence, the activity of peptidyltransferase, provided that this change in Mg2+ occurs during the binding of the donor but not when it occurs during peptide bond formation per se. The fact that the donor substrate may exist in various states of reactivity in this cell-free system raises the possibility that the rate of peptide bond formation may not be uniform during protein synthesis.

The ribosomal E site at low Mg2+: coordinate inactivation of ribosomal functions at Mg2+ concentrations below 10 mM and its prevention by polyamines

Under standard conditions (Mg2+/150 mM NH4+) ribosomes can quantitatively participate in tRNA binding at Mg2+ concentrations of 12 to 15 mM. The overall poly(U)-directed Phe incorporation and the extent of tRNA binding to either P, E or A sites decrease in a parallel manner when the Mg2+ concentration is lowered below 10 mM. At 4 mM the inactivation amounts to about 80%. The coordinate inactivation of all three binding sites is accompanied by an increasing impairment of the ability to translocate A-site bound AcPhe-tRNA to the P site. The translocation efficiency is already reduced at 10 mM Mg2+, and is completely blocked at 6-8 mM. The severe inactivation seen at 6 mM Mg2+ vanishes when the polyamines spermine (0.6 mM) and spermidine (0.4 mM) are present in the assay; tRNA binding again becomes quantitative, the total Phe synthesis even exceeds that observed in the absence of polyamines by a factor of 4. In the presence of polyamines and low Mg2+ (3 and 6 mM) two essential features of the allosteric three-site model (Rheinberger and Nierhaus, J. Biol. Chem. 261, 9133 (1986] are demonstrated. 1) Deacylated tRNA is not released from the P site, but moves to the E site during the course of translocation. 2) Occupation of the E site reduces the A site affinity and vice versa (allosteric interactions between E and A sites). The quality of an in vitro system for protein synthesis can be assessed by two criteria. First, the incubation conditions must allow a near quantitative tRNA binding. Secondly, protein synthesis should proceed with near in vivo rate and accuracy. The 3 mM Mg2+/NH4+/polyamine-system seems to be the best compromise at present between these two requirements.

Evidence that the G2661 region of 23S rRNA is located at the ribosomal binding sites of both elongation factors

Alpha-sarcin cleaves one phosphodiester bond of 23S rRNA within 70S ribosomes or 50S subunits derived from E. coli. The resulting fragment was isolated and sequenced. The cleavage site was identified as being after G2661 and is located within a universally conserved dodecamer. Cleavage after G2661 specifically blocked the binding of both elongation factors, i.e. that of the ternary complex Phe-tRNA*EF-Tu*GMPPNP and of EF-G*GMPPNP, whereas all elongation-factor independent functions of the ribosome, such as association of the ribosomal subunits, tRNA binding to A and P sites, the accuracy of tRNA selection at both sites, the peptidyl transferase activity, and the EF-G independent, spontaneous translocation, were not affected at all. Control experiments with wheat germ ribosomes yielded an equivalent inhibition pattern. The data suggest that the universally conserved dodecamer containing the cleavage site G2661 is located at the presumably overlapping region of the binding sites of both elongation factors.

Tetracycline can inhibit tRNA binding to the ribosomal P site as well as to the A site

A and P sites of Escherichia coli ribosomes were titrated with AcPhe-tRNAPhe, in the absence or presence of tetracycline. The P-site location of the bound AcPhe-tRNA was assessed by means of a quantitative puromycin reaction. The results demonstrate that, in agreement with the generally held view, tetracycline exclusively inhibits the A-site binding, if the statistical number of bound acyl-tRNA molecules per ribosome does not exceed about 0.5. However, above this value the P site becomes sensitive to tetracycline as well. It follows that the tightly coupled 70S ribosomes used in functional studies appear to be functionally heterogeneous, i.e. those P sites which cannot be affected by tetracycline are preferentially occupied by AcPhe-tRNA, whereas higher concentrations of this tRNA species are required to fill tetracycline-sensitive P sites. Furthermore, the results imply that under tRNA saturation conditions the tetracycline inhibition cannot be used as an indicator for the site location of bound tRNA.

Analysis of the puromycin reaction. The ribosomal exclusion principle for AcPhe-tRNA binding re-examined

The standard technique for determination of the ribosomal site location of bound tRNA, viz. the puromycin reaction, has been analyzed with regard to its applicability under tRNA saturation conditions. The criteria derived have been used to re-examine the exclusion principle for peptidyl-tRNA binding, which states that only one peptidyl-tRNA (AcPhe-tRNA) can be bound per ribosome although in principle two sites (A and P site) are available. The following results were obtained. The puromycin reaction is only appropriate for a site determination if the reaction conditions prevent one ribosome from performing more than one puromycin reaction. With an excess of AcPhe-tRNA over ribosomes, and in the absence of EF-G, this criterion is fulfilled at 0 degree C, where the P-site-bound material reacts with puromycin (quantitative reaction after 50 h), while the A-site-bound material does not. In contrast, at 37 degrees C the extent of the puromycin reaction can exceed the binding values by 2-4-fold ('repetitive reaction'). In the presence of EF-G a repetitive puromycin reaction is seen even at 0 degree C, i.e. EF-G can already promote a translocation reaction at 0 degree C. However, the extent of translocation becomes negligibly low for short incubation times (up to 60 min) at 0 degree C, if only catalytic amounts of EF-G are used. Using the criteria outlined above, the validity of the exclusion principle for Escherichia coli ribosomes was confirmed pursuing two different experimental strategies. Ribosomes were saturated with AcPhe-tRNA at one molecule per 70S ribosome, and a quantitative puromycin reaction demonstrated the exclusive P-site location of the AcPhe-tRNA. The same result was also found in the presence of viomycin, which blocks the translocation reaction. These findings also indicate that here nearly 100% of the ribosomes participate in AcPhe-tRNA binding to the P site. Precharging the P sites of 70S ribosomes with one Ac[14C]Phe-tRNA molecule per ribosome prevented additional Ac[3H]Phe-tRNA binding. In contrast, 70S particles carrying one molecule of [14C]tRNAPhe per ribosome were able to bind up to a further 0.64 molecule Ac[3H]Phe-tRNA per ribosome.

Pre-steady-state kinetics of ribosomal translocation

The two partial reactions of elongation factor G dependent translocation, the release of deacylated tRNA from the P site and the displacement of peptidyl tRNA from the A to the P site, have been studied with the stopped-flow technique. The experiments were performed with poly(U)-programmed ribosomes from Escherichia coli carrying deacylated tRNAPhe in the P site and N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe in the A site in the presence of GTP. The kinetics of the reaction were followed by monitoring either the intensity or the polarization of the fluorescence of both wybutine and proflavine located in the anticodon loop or of proflavine located in the D loop of yeast tRNAPhe or N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe. Both displacement and release fluorescence changes could be described by three exponentials, exhibiting apparent first-order rate-constants (20 degrees C) of 2 to 5 s-1 (15 s-1, 35 degrees C), 0.1 to 0.3 s-1, and 0.01 to 0.02 s-1, measured with a saturating concentration of elongation factor G (1 microM). The activation energy for the fast process of both reactions was found to be 70 kJ/mol (17 kcal/mol), while the intermediate process exhibits an activation energy of 30 kJ/mol (7 kcal/mol). The fast step is assigned to the displacement of the N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe from the A to the P site, and to the release of the tRNAPhe from the P site. The reactions take place simultaneously to form an intermediate post-translocation complex. The latter, in the intermediate step, rearranges to form a post-translocation complex carrying the deacylated tRNAPhe in an exit site and N-AcPhe-tRNAPhe in the P site, both in their equilibrium states. In parallel, or subsequently, the deacylated tRNAPhe spontaneously dissociates from the ribosome, thus completing the translocation process. The slow process has not been assigned.

Extension of Watson's model for the elongation cycle of protein biosynthesis

The scheme for the elongation cycle of protein biosynthesis is proposed based on modern quantitative data on the interactions of mRNA and different functional forms of tRNA with 70S ribosomes and their 30S and 50S subunits. This scheme takes into account recently discovered third ribosomal (E) site with presumable exit function. The E site is introduced into 70S ribosome by its 50S subunit, the codon-anticodon interaction does not take place at the E site, and the affinity of tRNA for the E site is considerably lower than that for the P site. On the other hand, the P and A sites are located mainly on a 30S subunit, the codon-anticodon interactions being realized on both these sites. An mRNA molecule is placed exclusively on a 30S subunit where it makes U-turn. The proposed scheme does not contradict to any data but includes all main postulates of the initial Watson's model (J. D. Watson, Bull. Soc. Chim. Biol. 46, 1399 (1964), and is considered as a natural extension of the later according to modern experimental data.

Adjacent codon-anticodon interactions of both tRNAs present at the ribosomal A and P or P and E sites

A labeled tRNA present at the A, P or E site can be partially chased from the ribosome, a cognate nonlabeled tRNA as chasing substrate being 3-12-times more efficient than non-cognate tRNA at a molar ratio tRNA: 70 S = 10:1. These findings indicate that a tRNA bound to a programmed ribosome undergoes codon-anticodon interaction at all three sites (A, P and E site). Furthermore, both labeled tRNA present on the ribosome can be chased more effectively with cognate than with non-cognate substrate at the same time. This finding provides strong evidence that both tRNAs present on the ribosome exhibit simultaneous codon-anticodon interaction. This is valid for both the pretranslocational state (Ac[3H]Lys-tRNALys in the A and [14C]tRNALys in the P site) as well as the posttranslocational state (Ac[3H]Lys-tRNALys in the P and [14C]tRNALys in the E site).

Different conformations of tRNA in the ribosomal P-site and A-site

Footprinting studies involving radioactively end-labelled tRNA species bound at either the ribosomal P- or A-site have yielded information that the tRNA's conformation is different in the two sites. Appropriate controls showed the relevance of using poly(U)-directed tRNAPhe binding in the P-site and Phe-tRNAPhe in the A-site. Digestion of the tRNA species was effected by RNases T1, T2 and cobra venom RNase. Experiments were performed with tRNAs 32P-labelled at either end to establish positions of primary cuts more confidently. In addition to the common protection of the aminoacyl-stem and anticodon-arm, footprinting experiments revealed striking differences in the accessibility of the T- and D-loops of tRNAs bound in the P- and A-sites. We observed a more open structure for the tRNA in the A-site. These results are consistent with a dynamic structure of tRNA during the translocation step of protein biosynthesis.

Conformational change of 50 S ribosomes on enzymatic binding of phenylalanyl-tRNA

Tight couple 70 S ribosomes are converted to loose couple ones on enzymatic binding of phenylalanyl-tRNA. Enzymatic binding at 0 degree C as well as nonenzymatic binding does not lead to any change. Further, no change takes place when the P site is occupied by N-acetylphenylalanyl-tRNA. Loose couple 70 S ribosomes are not affected by either enzymatic or nonenzymatic binding of phenylalanyl-tRNA.

Testing the classical two-tRNA-site model for the ribosomal elongation cycle

An experimental system where the elongation of a polypeptide (polyphenylalanine) is performed stepwise and synchronously by purified Escherichia coli ribosome in a matrix-coupled poly (U) column is proposed for testing the number of non-overlapping tRNA binding sites on the elongating ribosome. If phenylalanyl[3H]tRNA is introduced into the column and bound with the ribosomes at the beginning of a given elongation cycle, deacylated [3H]tRNA is shown to be released from the ribosomes and comes out from the column at the translocation step of the next elongation cycle. The result obtained is fully predicted by the classical two-tRNA-site model and contradicts any model involving more than two non-overlapping high-affinity tRNA binding sites in the ribosomal elongation cycle.

New aspects of the ribosomal elongation cycle

The ribosomal elongation cycle represents a series of reactions during which the polypeptide is prolonged by one amino acid and after which the prolonged polypeptidyl residue is again ready to accept the next aminoacyl residue. It is generally believed that the ribosome carries two tRNA binding sites, the A site for aminoacyl-tRNA and the P site for peptidyl-tRNA, leading to the classical two-site model of the ribosome as a description for the elongation cycle. However, evidence is accumulating which is in conflict with the classical two-site model. These conflicts are resolved in a new three-site model which is discussed in detail in this paper.