Imino-proton resonances of yeast tRNAPhe studied by two-dimensional nuclear Overhauser enhancement spectroscopy

Instrumental analysis of RNA modifications

Organisms from all domains of life invest a substantial amount of energy for the introduction of RNA modifications into nearly all transcripts studied to date. Instrumental analysis of RNA can focus on the modified residues and reveal the function of these epitranscriptomic marks. Here, we will review recent advances and breakthroughs achieved by NMR spectroscopy, sequencing, and mass spectrometry of the epitranscriptome.

1H, 15N chemical shift assignments of the imino groups of yeast tRNAPhe: influence of the post-transcriptional modifications

Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) are heavily decorated with post-transcriptional modifications during their biosynthesis. To fulfil their functions within cells, tRNAs undergo a tightly controlled biogenesis process leading to the formation of mature tRNAs. In particular, the introduction of post-transcriptional modifications in tRNAs is controlled and influenced by multiple factors. In turn, tRNA biological functions are often modulated by their modifications. Although modifications play essential roles in tRNA biology, methods to directly detect their introduction during tRNA maturation are rare and do not easily provide information on the temporality of modification events. To obtain information on the tRNA maturation process, we have developed a methodology, using NMR as a tool to monitor tRNA maturation in a non-disruptive and continuous fashion in cellular extracts. Here we report the ¹H,¹⁵N chemical shift assignments of imino groups in three forms of the yeast tRNA^Phe differing in their modification content. These assignments are a prerequisite for the time-resolved NMR monitoring of yeast tRNA^Phe maturation in yeast extracts.

Time-resolved NMR monitoring of tRNA maturation

Although the biological importance of post-transcriptional RNA modifications in gene expression is widely appreciated, methods to directly detect their introduction during RNA biosynthesis are rare and do not easily provide information on the temporal nature of events. Here, we introduce the application of NMR spectroscopy to observe the maturation of tRNAs in cell extracts. By following the maturation of yeast tRNA^Phe with time-resolved NMR measurements, we show that modifications are introduced in a defined sequential order, and that the chronology is controlled by cross-talk between modification events. In particular, we show that a strong hierarchy controls the introduction of the T54, Ψ55 and m¹A58 modifications in the T-arm, and we demonstrate that the modification circuits identified in yeast extract with NMR also impact the tRNA modification process in living cells. The NMR-based methodology presented here could be adapted to investigate different aspects of tRNA maturation and RNA modifications in general.

Transfer RNA (tRNA) is regulated by RNA modifications. Here the authors employ time-resolved NMR to monitor modifications of yeast tRNA^Phe in cellular extracts, revealing a sequential order and cross-talk between modifications.

Physicochemical analysis of rotavirus segment 11 supports a 'modified panhandle' structure and not the predicted alternative tRNA-like structure (TRLS)

Rotaviruses are a major cause of acute gastroenteritis, which is often fatal in infants. The viral genome consists of 11 double-stranded RNA segments, but little is known about their cis-acting sequences and structural elements. Covariation studies and phylogenetic analysis exploring the potential structure of RNA11 of rotaviruses suggested that, besides the previously predicted “modified panhandle” structure, the 5’ and 3’ termini of one of the isoforms of the bovine rotavirus UKtc strain may interact to form a tRNA-like structure (TRLS). Such TRLSs have been identified in RNAs of plant viruses, where they are important for enhancing replication and packaging. However, using tRNA mimicry assays (in vitro aminoacylation and 3’- adenylation), we found no biochemical evidence for tRNA-like functions of RNA11. Capping, synthetic 3’ adenylation and manipulation of divalent cation concentrations did not change this finding. NMR studies on a 5’- and 3’-deletion construct of RNA11 containing the putative intra-strand complementary sequences supported a predominant panhandle structure and did not conform to a cloverleaf fold despite the strong evidence for a predicted structure in this conserved region of the viral RNA. Additional viral or cellular factors may be needed to stabilise it into a form with tRNA-like properties.

Higher-order structure and thermal instability of bovine mitochondrial tRNASerUGA investigated by proton NMR spectroscopy

Although mammalian mitochondrial serine-specific tRNA with the anticodon UGA (tRNASerUGA) appears to possess an almost normal cloverleaf secondary structure, it exhibits an extraordinarily low melting temperature (tm). An in vitro tRNASerUGA transcript without modified nucleosides had an even lower tm and slightly less hyperchromicity, but its tertiary structure was apparently very similar to that of the native counterpart judging from its aminoacylation activity and the body of experimental evidence so far obtained for canonical tRNAs. The transcript was therefore used to investigate the higher-order structure and thermal instability of tRNASerUGA. 1H-NMR analysis of the transcript showed that it takes a nearly L-shaped tertiary structure with similar tertiary base-pairings to those found in yeast tRNAPhe, which is representative of canonical tRNAs. However, magnesium ion titration revealed that Mg2+ affected the chemical shifts of the tRNASerUGA transcript differently than those of canonical tRNAs so far studied; the former was less sensitive toward Mg2+, especially in the D-arm region. This observation was confirmed by NMR analysis with paramagnetic manganese ion titration. Hill plots derived from the CD spectral changes caused by titration with Mg2+ suggested that the tRNASerUGA transcript had fewer Mg2+ binding sites than those of yeast tRNAPhe as well as its transcript, a finding that was consistent with the NMR data. We thus surmise that the thermal instability of both the transcript and tRNASerUGA itself originated from a reduction in the number of the divalent ion binding sites within the tRNA molecule. These results suggest a new type of thermal instability for mitochondrial tRNA.

Conformational transitions of an unmodified tRNA: implications for RNA folding

Unmodified tRNAs are powerful systems to study the effects of posttranscriptional modifications and site-directed mutations on both the structure and function of these ribonucleic acids. To define the general limitations of synthetic constructs as models for native tRNAs, it is necessary to elucidate the conformational states of unmodified tRNAs as a function of solution conditions. Here we report the conformational properties of unmodified yeast tRNAPhe as a function of ionic strength, [Mg2+], and temperature using a combination of spectroscopic measurements along with chemical and enzymatic probes. We find that in low [Na+] buffer at low temperature, native yeast tRNAPhe adopts tertiary structure in the absence of Mg2+. By contrast, tertiary folding of unmodified yeast tRNAPhe has an absolute requirement for Mg2+. Below the melting temperature of the cloverleaf, unmodified yeast tRNAPhe exists in a Mg2+-dependent equilibrium between secondary and tertiary structure. Taken together, our findings suggest that although the tertiary structures of tRNAs are broadly comparable, the intrinsic stability of the tertiary fold, the conformational properties of intermediate states, and the stability of intermediate states can differ significantly between tRNA sequences. Thus, the use of unmodified tRNAs as models for native constructs can have significant limitations. Broad conclusions regarding "tRNA folding" as a whole must be viewed cautiously, particularly in cases where structural changes occur, such as during protein synthesis.

Interaction of retroviral nucleocapsid proteins with transfer RNAPhe: a lead ribozyme and 1H NMR study

In the initiation of reverse transcription in retroviruses, nucleocapsid (NC) protein accelerates the rate of annealing of transfer RNA replication primer to a complementary sequence on the genomic RNA. In this report, we have probed the conformational changes induced by HIV-1 NC protein and domain deletion mutants in a structurally well-characterized transfer RNA, yeast tRNAPhe, as a model for the natural primer. One molar equivalent of recombinant 71 amino acid HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein (NC 1-71) is sufficient to completely inhibit the Pb2(+)-ribozyme activity of tRNAPhe at 25 degrees C, pH 7.0 and 15 mM MgCl2, Zn2 HIV-1 NC proteins which lack one or both flexible terminal domains also inhibit the ribozyme activity. 1H NMR spectra acquired for Mg(2+)-tRNAPhe suggest that NC 1-71 and NC 12-55 (lacking residues 1-11 and 56-71) inhibit the lead-ribozyme activity by only modestly altering the active site region rather than inducing large-scale unfolding of the molecule. In the absence of Mg2+, the extent of destabilization of tRNAPhe is greater but appears to be confined to internal regions of the acceptor and T psi C helices, as evidenced by the selectively enhanced exchange rates for imino protons associated with these base pairs. These findings show that NC destabilizes the folded form of tRNAPhe and by extension, other complex RNAs, in tertiary and secondary structural regions most susceptible to thermally-induced denaturation.

Unusual anticodon loop structure found in E.coli lysine tRNA

Although both tRNA(Lys) and tRNA(Glu) of E. coli possess similar anticodon loop sequences, with the same hypermodified nucleoside 5-methylaminomethyl-2-thiouridine (mnm5s2U) at the first position of their anticodons, the anticodon loop structures of these two tRNAs containing the modified nucleoside appear to be quite different as judged from the following observations. (1) The CD band derived from the mnm5s2U residue is negative for tRNA(Glu), but positive for tRNA(Lys). (2) The mnm5s2U monomer itself and the mnm5s2U-containing anticodon loop fragment of tRNA(Lys) show the same negative CD bands as that of tRNA(Glu). (3) The positive CD band of tRNA(Lys) changes to negative when the temperature is raised. (4) The reactivity of the mnm5s2U residue toward H2O2 is much lower for tRNA(Lys) than for tRNA(Glu). These features suggest that tRNA(Lys) has an unusual anticodon loop structure, in which the mnm5s2U residue takes a different conformation from that of tRNA(Glu); whereas the mnm5s2U base of tRNA(Glu) has no direct bonding with other bases and is accessible to a solvent, that of tRNA(Lys) exists as if in some way buried in its anticodon loop. The limited hydrolysis of both tRNAs by various RNases suggests that some differences exist in the higher order structures of tRNA(Lys) and tRNA(Glu). The influence of the unusual anticodon loop structure observed for tRNA(Lys) on its function in the translational process is also discussed.

Effect of nucleoside modifications on the structure and thermal stability of Escherichia coli valine tRNA

Transfer RNA transcribed in vitro lacks the base modifications found in native tRNA. To understand the effect of base modifications on the structure of tRNA, the downfield region of the 1H NMR spectrum of in vitro transcribed E coli tRNAVal in aqueous phosphate buffer in the presence of excess Mg2+ was investigated. The resonances of all imino protons involved in hydrogen bonds in the helical stem regions and in tertiary interactions were assigned using two-dimensional nuclear Overhauser enhancement spectroscopy (NOESY) and one-dimensional difference nuclear Overhauser effect (NOE) methods. In addition, some aromatic C2 and C8 proton resonances as well as one amino proton resonance were assigned. The chemical shifts of the assigned resonances of unmodified E coli tRNAVal were compared with those of the native tRNA molecule under similar solution conditions. The similarity of the NMR data for unmodified and modified tRNA indicates that the in vitro transcribed tRNA has nearly the same solution structure as the native molecule in the presence of excess Mg2+. The only significant differences were the chemical shifts of resonances corresponding to protons in (or interacting with) bases, indicating the possibility of local structural perturbations. The thermal stability of E coli modified and unmodified tRNAVal in the presence of Mg2+ was also investigated by analyzing the temperature dependence of the imino proton spectra. Several tertiary interactions involving modified nucleosides in native E coli tRNAVal are less stable in the absence of base modifications.

Ternary complex between elongation factor Tu.GTP and Phe-tRNA(Phe)

The effect of aminoacylation and ternary complex formation with elongation factor Tu.GTP on the tertiary structure of yeast tRNA(Phe) was examined by 1H-NMR spectroscopy. Esterification of phenylalanine to tRNA(Phe) does not lead to changes with respect to the secondary and tertiary base pair interactions of tRNA. Complex formation of Phe-tRNA(Phe) with elongation factor Tu.GTP results in a broadening of all imino proton resonances of the tRNA. The chemical shifts of several NH proton resonances are slightly changed as compared to free tRNA, indicating a minor conformational rearrangement of Phe-tRNA(Phe) upon binding to elongation factor Tu.GTP. All NH proton resonances corresponding to the secondary and tertiary base pairs of tRNA, except those arising from the first three base pairs in the aminoacyl stem, are detectable in the Phe-tRNA(Phe)-elongation factor Tu-GTP ternary complex. Thus, although the interactions between elongation factor Tu and tRNA accelerate the rate of NH proton exchange in the aminoacyl stem-region, the Phe-tRNA(Phe) preserves its typical L-shaped tertiary structure in the complex. At high (> 10(-4) M) ligand concentrations a complex between tRNA(Phe) and elongation factor Tu-GDP can be detected on the NMR time-scale. Formation of this complex is inhibited by the presence of any RNA not related to the tRNA structure. Using the known tertiary structures of yeast tRNA(Phe) and Thermus thermophilus elongation factor Tu in its active, GTP form, a model of the ternary complex was constructed.

Assignment of the magnetic resonances of the imino protons and methyl protons of Bombyx mori tRNA(GlyGCC) and the effect of ion binding on its structure

The magnetic resonances in the low-field H-NMR spectra of Bombyx mori tRNA(GlyGCC), corresponding to the hydrogen-bonded imino protons of the helical stems and tertiary base pairs, could be tentatively assigned by means of the sequential nuclear Overhauser effects. While B. mori tRNA(GlyGCC) does not contain the G19C56 tertiary base pair, the D20G57 base pair exists between the D and T loops, which was not found in the X-ray crystal structure of yeast tRNA(Phe). The effects of Mg2+, spermine and temperature on the conformation of this tRNA have also been examined based on the behavior of the assigned resonance signals. Mg2+ stabilize the D and T stems and the tertiary structure between the D and T loops. Spermine affects the resonances of the D and anticodon stems, and A23G9, but does not stabilize them. While the acceptor stem melts sequentially from both ends (G7C66 and G1C72) with increasing temperature, the anticodon stem melts from only one end (G39C31) and the G26C44 base pair is the most stable. In the tertiary structure between the variable loop and D stem, G10G45 melts first and G22G46 last. Yeast tRNA(Phe) has also been examined, and the results were compared with those for B. mori tRNA(Gly).

Structural elements in RNA

This chapter describes the RNA structural characteristics that have emerged so far. Folded RNA molecules are stabilized by a variety of interactions, the most prevalent of which are stacking and hydrogen bonding between bases. Many interactions among backbone atoms also occur in the structure of tRNA, although they are often ignored when considering RNA structure because they are not as well-characterized as interactions among bases. Backbone interactions include hydrogen bonding and the stacking of sugar or phosphate groups with bases or with other sugar and phosphate groups. The interactions found in a three-dimensional RNA structure can be divided into two categories: secondary interactions and tertiary interactions. This division is useful for several reasons. Secondary structures are routinely determined by a combination of techniques discussed in chapter, whereas tertiary interactions are more difficult to determine. Computer algorithms that generate RNA structures can search completely through possible secondary structures, but the inclusion of tertiary interactions makes a complete search of possible structures impractical for RNA molecules even as small as tRNA. The division of RNA structure into building blocks consisting of secondary or tertiary interactions makes it easier to describe RNA structures. In those cases in which RNA studies are incomplete, the studies of DNA are described with the rationalization that RNA structures may be analogous to DNA structures, or that the techniques used to study DNA could be applied to the analogous RNA structures. The chapter focuses on the aspects of RNA structure that affect the three-dimensional shape of RNA and that affect its ability to interact with other molecules.

Permanent dipole moment of tRNA's and variation of their structure in solution

The structure of six different tRNA molecules has been analyzed in solution by electrooptical measurements and by bead model simulations. The electric dichroism measured as a function of the field strength shows that tRNA's are associated with substantial permanent dipole moments, which are in the range of 1 x 10(-27) cm(identical to 300 D; before correction for the internal directing field). Rotational diffusion time constants of tRNA molecules in their native state at 2 degrees C show a considerable variation. A particularly large value found for tRNA(Tyr) (50 ns) can be explained by its nine additional nucleotide residues. However, remarkable variations remain for tRNA molecules with the standard number of 76 nucleotide residues (tRNA(Phe) [yeast] 41.6 ns, tRNA(Val) [Escherichia coli] 44.9 ns, tRNA(Glu) [E. coli] 46.8 ns; tRNA(Phe) [E. coli] 48.3 ns). These variations indicate modulations of the tertiary structure, which may be due to a change of the L-hinge angle. Bead models are used to simulate both electric and hydrodynamic parameters of tRNA molecules according to the crystal structure of tRNA(Phe) (yeast). The asymmetric distribution of phosphate charges with respect to the center of diffusion leads, under the assumption of a constant charge reduction to 15% by ion condensation, to a theoretical dipole moment of 7.2 x 10(-28) cm, which is in reasonable agreement with the measurements. The dichroism decay curve calculated for tRNA(Phe) (yeast) is also consistent with the measurements and thus the structure in solution and in the crystal must be very similar in this case. However, our measurements also indicate that the structure of some other tRNA's in solution is different, even in cases with the same number of nucleotide residues.

Determination of three-dimensional structures of proteins and nucleic acids in solution by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has evolved over the last decade into a powerful method for determining three-dimensional structures of biological macromolecules in solution. Key advances have been the introduction of two-dimensional experiments, high-field superconducting magnets, and computational procedures for converting the NMR-derived interproton distances and torsion angles into three-dimensional structures. This article outlines the methodology employed, describes the major NMR experiments necessary for the spectral analysis of macromolecules, and discusses the computational approaches employed to date. The present state of the art is illustrated using a variety of examples, and future developments are indicated.

DNA and RNA: NMR studies of conformations and dynamics in solution

The early NMR research on nucleic acids was of a qualitative nature and was restricted to partial characterization of short oligonucleotides in aqueous solution. Major advances in magnet design, spectrometer electronics, pulse techniques, data analysis and computational capabilities coupled with the availability of pure and abundant supply of long oligonucleotides have extended these studies towards the determination of the 3-D structure of nucleic acids in solution.

Sequential NMR assignments of labile protons in DNA using two-dimensional nuclear-Overhauser-enhancement spectroscopy with three jump-and-return pulse sequences

Two-dimensional nuclear Overhauser enhancement (NOESY) spectra of labile protons were recorded in H2O solutions of a protein and of a DNA duplex, using a modification of the standard NOESY experiment with all three 90 degree pulses replaced by jump-and-return sequences. For the protein as well as the DNA fragment the strategically important spectral regions could be recorded with good sensitivity and free of artifacts. Using this procedure, sequence-specific assignments were obtained for the imino protons, C2H of adenine, and C4NH2 of cytosine in a 23-base-pair DNA duplex which includes the 17-base-pair OR3 repressor binding site of bacteriophage lambda. Based on comparison with previously published results on the isolated OR3 binding site, these data were used for a study of chain termination effects on the chemical shifts of imino proton resonances of DNA duplexes.

Study of the interaction between uncharged yeast tRNAPhe and elongation factor Tu from Bacillus stearothermophilis

Proton NMR studies are presented on the interaction of nonaminoacylated yeast tRNAPhe and elongation factor Tu X GTP from Bacillus stearothermophilis. From experiments in which transfer of magnetization is observed between proton spins of tRNA and the protein, it is concluded that complex formation takes place. Amino acid residues of the protein come into close contact with the base pair A5U68 and/or U52A62 of the acceptor T psi C limb of the tRNA molecule. From the line broadening of tRNA resonances, associated with complex formation, an association constant of 10(3)-10(4) M-1 is estimated. The NMR experiments do not monitor a significant conformational change of the tRNA molecule upon interaction with the protein. However, at times long after the onset of complex formation, spectral changes indicate that the upper part of the acceptor helix becomes distorted.

Imino proton NMR assignments and ion-binding studies on Escherichia coli tRNA3Gly

The imino region of the proton NMR spectrum of Escherichia coli tRNA3Gly has been assigned mainly by sequential nuclear Overhauser effects between neighbouring base pairs and by comparison of assignments of other tRNAs. The effects of magnesium, spermine and temperature on the 1H and 31P NMR spectra of this tRNA were studied. Both ions affect resonances close to the G15 . C48 tertiary base pair and in the ribosylthymine loop. The magnesium studies indicate the presence of an altered tRNA conformer at low magnesium concentrations in equilibrium with the high magnesium form. The temperature studies show that the A7 . U66 imino proton (from a secondary base pair) melts before some of the tertiary hydrogen bonds and that the anticodon stem does not melt sequentially from the ends. Correlation of the ion effects in the 1H and 31P NMR spectra has led to the tentative assignment of two 31P resonances not assigned in the comparable 31P NMR spectrum of yeast tRNAPhe. 31P NMR spectra of E. coli tRNA3Gly lack resolved peaks corresponding to peaks C and F in the spectra of E. coli tRNAPhe and yeast tRNAPhe. In the latter tRNAs these peaks have been assigned to phosphate groups in the anticodon loop. Ion binding E. coli tRNA3Gly and E. coli tRNAPhe had different effects on their 1H NMR spectra which may reflect further differences in their charge distribution and conformation.

Influence of the polyamines spermine and spermidine on yeast tRNAPhe as revealed from its imino proton NMR spectrum

A comparison of imino proton NMR spectra of yeast tRNAPhe recorded at various solution conditions indicates, that polyamines have a limited effect on the structure of this tRNA molecule. Polyamines are found to catalyse the solvent exchange of several imino protons in yeast tRNAPhe not only of non hydrogen bonded imino protons, but also of imino protons of the GU and of some AU and tertiary base pairs. It is concluded that at low levels of catalysing components the exchange rates of the latter protons are not determined by the base pair lifetime. In the presence of high levels of spermidine the solvent exchange rates of imino protons of several base pairs in the molecule were assessed as a function of the temperature. Apparent activation energies derived from these rates were found to be less than 80 kJ/mol, which is indicative for (transient) independent opening of the corresponding base pairs. In the acceptor helix the GU base pair acts as a dynamic dislocation. The AU base pairs at one side of the GU base pair exhibit faster transient opening than the GC base pairs on the other side of this wobble pair. The base pairs m2GC10 and GC11 from the D stem and GC28 from the anticodon stem show relatively slow opening up to high temperatures. Model studies suggest that 1-methyladenosine, an element of tRNA itself, catalyses imino proton solvent exchange in a way similar to polyamines.