DNA linking potential generated by gyrase

RGEN-seq for highly sensitive amplification-free screen of off-target sites of gene editors

Sensitive detection of off-target sites produced by gene editing nucleases is crucial for developing reliable gene therapy platforms. Although several biochemical assays for the characterization of nuclease off-target effects have been recently published, significant technical and methodological issues still remain. Of note, existing methods rely on PCR amplification, tagging, and affinity purification which can introduce bias, contaminants, sample loss through handling, etc. Here we describe a sensitive, PCR-free next-generation sequencing method (RGEN-seq) for unbiased detection of double-stranded breaks generated by RNA-guided CRISPR-Cas9 endonuclease. Through use of novel sequencing adapters, the RGEN-Seq method saves time, simplifies workflow, and removes genomic coverage bias and gaps associated with PCR and/or other enrichment procedures. RGEN-seq is fully compatible with existing off-target detection software; moreover, the unbiased nature of RGEN-seq offers a robust foundation for relating assigned DNA cleavage scores to propensity for off-target mutations in cells. A detailed comparison of RGEN-seq with other off-target detection methods is provided using a previously characterized set of guide RNAs.

Modulated control of DNA supercoiling balance by the DNA-wrapping domain of bacterial gyrase

Negative supercoiling by DNA gyrase is essential for maintaining chromosomal compaction, transcriptional programming, and genetic integrity in bacteria. Questions remain as to how gyrases from different species have evolved profound differences in their kinetics, efficiency, and extent of negative supercoiling. To explore this issue, we analyzed homology-directed mutations in the C-terminal, DNA-wrapping domain of the GyrA subunit of Escherichia coli gyrase (the 'CTD'). The addition or removal of select, conserved basic residues markedly impacts both nucleotide-dependent DNA wrapping and supercoiling by the enzyme. Weakening CTD-DNA interactions slows supercoiling, impairs DNA-dependent ATP hydrolysis, and limits the extent of DNA supercoiling, while simultaneously enhancing decatenation and supercoil relaxation. Conversely, strengthening DNA wrapping does not result in a more extensively supercoiled DNA product, but partially uncouples ATP turnover from strand passage, manifesting in futile cycling. Our findings indicate that the catalytic cycle of E. coli gyrase operates at high thermodynamic efficiency, and that the stability of DNA wrapping by the CTD provides one limit to DNA supercoil introduction, beyond which strand passage competes with ATP-dependent supercoil relaxation. These results highlight a means by which gyrase can evolve distinct homeostatic supercoiling setpoints in a species-specific manner.

Superhelicity Constrains a Localized and R-Loop-Dependent Formation of G-Quadruplexes at the Upstream Region of Transcription

Transcription induces formation of intramolecular G-quadruplex structures at the upstream region of a DNA duplex by an upward transmission of negative supercoiling through the DNA. Currently the regulation of such G-quadruplex formation remains unclear. Using plasmid as a model, we demonstrate that while it is the dynamic negative supercoiling generated by a moving RNA polymerase that triggers a formation of a G-quadruplex, the constitutional superhelicity determines the potential and range of the formation of a G-quadruplex by constraining the propagation of the negative supercoiling. G-quadruplex formation is maximal in negatively supercoiled and nearly abolished in relaxed plasmids while being moderate in nicked and linear ones. The formation of a G-quadruplex strongly correlates with the presence of an R-loop. Preventing R-loop formation virtually abolished G-quadruplex formation even in the negatively supercoiled plasmid. Enzymatic action and protein binding that manipulate supercoiling or its propagation all impact the formation of G-quadruplexes. Because chromosomes and plasmids in cells in their natural form are maintained in a supercoiled state, our findings reveal a physical basis that justifies the formation and regulation of G-quadruplexes in vivo. The structural features involved in G-quadruplex formation may all serve as potential targets in clinical and therapeutic applications.

Preferential relaxation of positively supercoiled DNA by E. coli topoisomerase IV in single-molecule and ensemble measurements

We show that positively supercoiled [(+) SC] DNA is the preferred substrate for Escherichia coli topoisomerase IV (topo IV). We measured topo IV relaxation of (-) and (+) supercoils in real time on single, tethered DNA molecules to complement ensemble experiments. We find that the preference for (+) SC DNA is complete at low enzyme concentration. Otherwise, topo IV relaxed (+) supercoils at a 20-fold faster rate than (-) supercoils, due primarily to about a 10-fold increase in processivity with (+) SC DNA. The preferential cleavage of (+) SC DNA in a competition experiment showed that substrate discrimination can take place prior to strand passage in the presence or absence of ATP. We propose that topo IV discriminates between (-) and (+) supercoiled DNA by recognition of the geometry of (+) SC DNA. Our results explain how topo IV can rapidly remove (+) supercoils to support DNA replication without relaxing the essential (-) supercoils of the chromosome. They also show that the rate of supercoil relaxation by topo IV is several orders of magnitude faster than hitherto appreciated, so that a single enzyme may suffice at each replication fork.

The topodynamics of incision of UV-irradiated covalently closed DNA by the Escherichia coli Uvr(A)BC endonuclease

The Escherichia coli Uvr(A)BC endonuclease (Uvr(A)BC) initiates nucleotide excision repair of a large variety of DNA damages. The damage recognition and incision steps by the Uvr(A)BC is a complex process utilizing an ATP-dependent DNA helix-tracking activity associated with the UvrA2B1 complex. The latter activity leads to the generation of highly positively supercoiled DNA in the presence of E. coli topoisomerase I in vitro. Such highly positively supercoiled DNA, containing ultraviolet irradiation-induced photoproducts (uvDNA), is resistant to the incision by Uvr(A)BC, whereas the negatively supercoiled and relaxed forms of the uvDNA are effectively incised. The E. coli gyrase can contribute to the above reaction by abolishing the accumulation of highly positively supercoiled uvDNA thereby restoring Uvr(A)BC-catalyzed incision. Eukaryotic (calf thymus) topoisomerase I is able to substitute for gyrase in restoring this Uvr(A)BC-mediated incision reaction. The inability of Uvr(A)BC to incise highly positively supercoiled uvDNA results from the failure of the formation of UvrAB-dependent obligatory intermediates associated with the DNA conformational change. In contrast to Uvr(A)BC, the Micrococcus luteus UV endonuclease efficiently incises uvDNA regardless of its topological state. The in vitro topodynamic system proposed in this study may provide a simple model for studying a topological aspect of nucleotide excision repair and its interaction with other DNA topology-related processes in E. coli.

Effect of ethidium binding and superhelix density on the supercoiling free energy and torsion and bending constants of p30 delta DNA

Topoisomer distributions created by the action of topoisomerase I on p30 delta DNA in the presence of various concentrations of ethidium are measured and analyzed using recently developed theory to obtain the twist energy parameter (ET) that governs the free energy of supercoiling in each case. Competitive dialysis experiments to investigate the relative affinity of ethidium for linear and supercoiled DNAs at different binding ratios are assayed fluorometrically and the results are analyzed using related theory. The topoisomer distributions and fluorescence intensity ratios agree well with the theory, which is based on the assumption that the supercoiling free energy varies quadratically with the effective linking difference, regardless of ethidium binding or superhelix density. The topoisomer distribution experiments alone yield an average best-fit value, ET = 950 +/- 80, independent of ethidium binding ratio from r = 0 to 0.082, while the combined topoisomer distribution and ethidium binding experiments yield an average best-fit value, ET = 1030 +/- 90, which is essentially independent of ethidium binding ratio from r = 0 to 0.082 and superhelix density from sigma = 0 to (-)0.053. One may conclude that the supercoiling free-energy-varies quadratically with effective linking difference over the entire range of observed ethidium binding ratios and superhelix densities. The independently measured torsion constant (alpha) of p30 delta DNA is likewise essentially independent of superhelix density and ethidium binding ratio. The observed invariance of ET and alpha implies that the bending constant kappa beta is similarly invariant to superhelix density and ethidium binding ratio. The apparently ideal behavior displayed by p30 delta DNA is not exhibited by pBR322 DNA, which is discussed in the following companion paper.

Effect of ethidium on the torsion constants of linear and supercoiled DNAs

The torsion elastic constants (alpha) of linear pBR322 (4363 bp) and pUC8 (2717 bp) DNAs and supercoiled pBR322 and pJMSII (4375 bp) DNAs are measured in 0.1 M NaCl as a function of added ethidium/base-pair (EB/BP) ratio by studying the fluorescence polarization anisotropy (FPA) of the intercalated ethidium. The time-resolved FPA is measured by using a picosecond dye laser for excitation and time-correlated single photon counting detection. Previously developed theory for the emission anisotropy is generalized to incorporate rotations of the transition dipole due to excitation transfer. The excitation transfers are simulated by a Monte Carlo procedure (Genest et al., Biophys. Chem. 1 (1974) 266-278) and the consequent rotations of the transition dipole are superposed on the Brownian rotations. After accounting for excitation transfer, the torsion constants of the linear DNAs are found to be essentially independent of intercalated ethidium up to a binding ratio r = 0.10 dye/bp. Dynamic light scattering measurements on linear pUC8 DNA confirm that the torsion constant is independent of binding ratio up to r = 0.20 dye/bp. If alpha d denotes the torsion constant between ethidium and a base-pair, and alpha 0 that between two base-pairs, then our data imply that alpha d/alpha 0 lies in the range 0.65 to 1.64 with a most probable value of 1.0. The torsion constants of supercoiled DNAs decrease substantially with increasing binding ratio even after accounting for excitation transfer. At the binding ratio r* = 0.064, where the superhelix density vanishes and superhelical strain is completely relaxed, the torsion constant of the supercoiled pBR322 DNA/dye complex lies below that of the corresponding linear DNA/dye complex by about 30%. This contradicts the conventional view according to which linear, nicked circular, and supercoiled DNA/dye complexes with r = r* should coexist with the same concentration of free dye, display the same distribution of bound dye, and exhibit identical secondary structures, twisting and bending rigidities, and FPA dynamics. These and other observations imply the existence of metastable secondary structure in freshly relaxed supercoiled DNAs. A tentative explanation is presented for these and other unexpected observations on supercoiled DNAs.

Computer simulation of DNA supercoiling

We treat supercoiled DNA within a wormlike model with excluded volume. A modified Monte Carlo approach has been used, which allowed computer statistical-mechanical simulations of moderately and highly supercoiled DNA molecules. Even highly supercoiled molecules do not have a regular shape, though with an increase in writhing the chains look more and more like branched interwound helixes. The averaged writhing (Wr) approximately 0.7 delta Lk. The superhelical free energy F is calculated as a function of the linking number. Lk. The calculations have shown that the generally accepted quadratic dependence of F on Lk is valid for a variety of conditions, though it is by no means universal. Significant deviations from the quadratic dependence are expected at high superhelical density under ionic conditions where the effective diameter of DNA is small. The results are compared with the available experimental data.