Redox titration of two [4Fe-4S] clusters in the photosynthetic reaction center from the anaerobic green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium vibrioforme

Redox Potentials of Iron-Sulfur Clusters in Type I Photosynthetic Reaction Centers

The electron transfer pathways in type I photosynthetic reaction centers, such as photosystem I (PSI) and reaction centers from green sulfur bacteria (GsbRC), are terminated by two Fe4S4 clusters, FA and FB. The protein structures are the basis of understanding how the protein electrostatic environment interacts with the Fe4S4 clusters and facilitates electron transfer. Using the protein structures, we calculated the redox potential (Em) values for FA and FB in PSI and GsbRC, solving the linear Poisson-Boltzmann equation. The FA-to-FB electron transfer is energetically downhill in the cyanobacterial PSI structure, while it is isoenergetic in the plant PSI structure. The discrepancy arises from differences in the electrostatic influences of conserved residues, including PsaC-Lys51 and PsaC-Arg52, located near FA. The FA-to-FB electron transfer is slightly downhill in the GsbRC structure. Em(FA) and Em(FB) exhibit similar levels upon isolation of the membrane-extrinsic PsaC and PscB subunits from the PSI and GsbRC reaction centers, respectively. The binding of the membrane-extrinsic subunit at the heterodimeric/homodimeric reaction center plays a key role in tuning Em(FA) and Em(FB).

Thermodynamics of the Electron Acceptors in Heliobacterium modesticaldum: An Exemplar of an Early Homodimeric Type I Photosynthetic Reaction Center

The homodimeric type I reaction center in heliobacteria is arguably the simplest known pigment-protein complex capable of conducting (bacterio)chlorophyll-based conversion of light into chemical energy. Despite its structural simplicity, the thermodynamics of the electron transfer cofactors on the acceptor side have not been fully investigated. In this work, we measured the midpoint potential of the terminal [4Fe-4S](2+/1+) cluster (FX) in reaction centers from Heliobacterium modesticaldum. The FX cluster was titrated chemically and monitored by (i) the decrease in the level of stable P800 photobleaching by optical spectroscopy, (ii) the loss of the light-induced g ≈ 2 radical from P800(+•) following a single-turnover flash, (iii) the increase in the low-field resonance at 140 mT attributed to the S = (3)/2 ground spin state of FX(-), and (iv) the loss of the spin-correlated P800(+) FX(-) radical pair following a single-turnover flash. These four techniques led to similar estimations of the midpoint potential for FX of -502 ± 3 mV (n = 0.99), -496 ± 2 mV (n = 0.99), -517 ± 10 mV (n = 0.65), and -501 ± 4 mV (n = 0.84), respectively, with a consensus value of -504 ± 10 mV (converging to n = 1). Under conditions in which FX is reduced, the long-lived (∼15 ms) P800(+) FX(-) state is replaced by a rapidly recombining (∼15 ns) P800(+)A0(-) state, as shown by ultrafast optical experiments. There was no evidence of the presence of a P800(+) A1(-) spin-correlated radical pair by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) under these conditions. The midpoint potentials of the two [4Fe-4S](2+/1+) clusters in the low-molecular mass ferredoxins were found to be -480 ± 11 mV/-524 ± 13 mV for PshBI, -453 ± 6 mV/-527 ± 6 mV for PshBII, and -452 ± 5 mV/-533 ± 8 mV for HM1_2505 as determined by EPR spectroscopy. FX is therefore suitably poised to reduce one [4Fe-4S](2+/1+) cluster in these mobile electron carriers. Using the measured midpoint potential of FX and a quasi-equilibrium model of charge recombination, the midpoint potential of A0 was estimated to be -854 mV at room temperature. The midpoint potentials of A0 and FX are therefore 150-200 mV less reducing than their respective counterparts in Photosystem I of cyanobacteria and plants. This places the redox potential of the FX cluster in heliobacteria approximately equipotential to the highest-potential iron-sulfur cluster (FA) in Photosystem I, consistent with its assignment as the terminal electron acceptor.

The bound iron-sulfur clusters of type-I homodimeric reaction centers

The hallmark of a Type-I photosynthetic reaction center (RC) is the presence of three [4Fe-4S](2+/1+) clusters, named F(X), F(A), and F(B) that act as terminal electron acceptors. Their function is to increase the distance, and hence the lifetime, of the initial charge-separated state so that diffusion-mediated processes, such as the reduction of ferredoxin, can occur. Type-I homodimeric RCs, such as those found in heliobacteria, green-sulfur bacteria, and Candidatus Chloracidobacterium thermophilum, are less well understood than Photosystem I, the prototypical Type-I heterodimeric RC found in cyanobacteria and plants. Here, we review recent progress that has been made in elucidating the spectroscopic and biochemical properties of the bound Fe/S clusters and their cognate proteins in homodimeric Type-I RCs. In Heliobacterium modesticaldum, the identification and characterization of two loosely bound polypeptides, PshBI and PshBII that harbor the F(A) and F(B) clusters threatens to break the long-accepted assumption that Type-I RCs harbor one tightly bound F(A)/F(B)-containing protein. Additionally, the detection of the F(X) cluster in S = 1/2 and S = 3/2 ground spin states has resolved the long-standing issue of its missing EPR spectrum. In Chlorobaculum tepidum, the focus is on the biochemical properties of the unusual extrinsic Fe/S protein, PscB, which is readily dissociable from the RC core. The C-terminal domain of PscB is constructed as a bacterial ferredoxin, harboring the F(A) and F(B) clusters, but the N-terminal domain contains a number of PxxP motifs and is rich in Lys, Pro, and Ala residues, features characteristic of proteins that interact with SH3 domains. Little is known about Candidatus Chloracidobacterium thermophilum except that the photosynthetic RC is predicted to be a Type-I homodimer with an F(X)-binding site. These findings are placed in a context that promises to unify the acceptor side of homodimeric Type-I RCs in prokaryotic phototrophs.

The reaction center of green sulfur bacteria(1)

The composition of the P840-reaction center complex (RC), energy and electron transfer within the RC, as well as its topographical organization and interaction with other components in the membrane of green sulfur bacteria are presented, and compared to the FeS-type reaction centers of Photosystem I and of Heliobacteria. The core of the RC is homodimeric, since pscA is the only gene found in the genome of Chlorobium tepidum which resembles the genes psaA and -B for the heterodimeric core of Photosystem I. Functionally intact RC can be isolated from several species of green sulfur bacteria. It is generally composed of five subunits, PscA-D plus the BChl a-protein FMO. Functional cores, with PscA and PscB only, can be isolated from Prostecochloris aestuarii. The PscA-dimer binds P840, a special pair of BChl a-molecules, the primary electron acceptor A(0), which is a Chl a-derivative and FeS-center F(X). An equivalent to the electron acceptor A(1) in Photosystem I, which is tightly bound phylloquinone acting between A(0) and F(X), is not required for forward electron transfer in the RC of green sulfur bacteria. This difference is reflected by different rates of electron transfer between A(0) and F(X) in the two systems. The subunit PscB contains the two FeS-centers F(A) and F(B). STEM particle analysis suggests that the core of the RC with PscA and PscB resembles the PsaAB/PsaC-core of the P700-reaction center in Photosystem I. PscB may form a protrusion into the cytoplasmic space where reduction of ferredoxin occurs, with FMO trimers bound on both sides of this protrusion. Thus the subunit composition of the RC in vivo should be 2(FMO)(3)(PscA)(2)PscB(PscC)(2)PscD. Only 16 BChl a-, four Chl a-molecules and two carotenoids are bound to the RC-core, which is substantially less than its counterpart of Photosystem I, with 85 Chl a-molecules and 22 carotenoids. A total of 58 BChl a/RC are present in the membranes of green sulfur bacteria outside the chlorosomes, corresponding to two trimers of FMO (42 Bchl a) per RC (16 BChl a). The question whether the homodimeric RC is totally symmetric is still open. Furthermore, it is still unclear which cytochrome c is the physiological electron donor to P840(+). Also the way of NAD(+)-reduction is unknown, since a gene equivalent to ferredoxin-NADP(+) reductase is not present in the genome.

Iron-sulfur clusters in type I reaction centers

Type I reaction centers (RCs) are multisubunit chlorophyll-protein complexes that function in photosynthetic organisms to convert photons to Gibbs free energy. The unique feature of Type I RCs is the presence of iron-sulfur clusters as electron transfer cofactors. Photosystem I (PS I) of oxygenic phototrophs is the best-studied Type I RC. It is comprised of an interpolypeptide [4Fe-4S] cluster, F(X), that bridges the PsaA and PsaB subunits, and two terminal [4Fe-4S] clusters, F(A) and F(B), that are bound to the PsaC subunit. In this review, we provide an update on the structure and function of the bound iron-sulfur clusters in Type I RCs. The first new development in this area is the identification of F(A) as the cluster proximal to F(X) and the resolution of the electron transfer sequence as F(X)-->F(A)-->F(B)-->soluble ferredoxin. The second new development is the determination of the three-dimensional NMR solution structure of unbound PsaC and localization of the equal- and mixed-valence pairs in F(A)(-) and F(B)(-). We provide a survey of the EPR properties and spectra of the iron-sulfur clusters in Type I RCs of cyanobacteria, green sulfur bacteria, and heliobacteria, and we summarize new information about the kinetics of back-reactions involving the iron-sulfur clusters.

Photoreduction and reoxidation of the three iron-sulfur clusters of reaction centers of green sulfur bacteria

Iron-sulfur clusters are the terminal electron acceptors of the photosynthetic reaction centers of green sulfur bacteria and photosystem I. We have studied electron-transfer reactions involving these clusters in the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum, using flash-absorption spectroscopic measurements. We show for the first time that three different clusters, named F(X), F(1), and F(2), can be photoreduced at room temperature during a series of consecutive flashes. The rates of electron escape to exogenous acceptors depend strongly upon the number of reduced clusters. When two or three clusters are reduced, the escape is biphasic, with the fastest phase being 12-14-fold faster than the slowest phase, which is similar to that observed after single reduction. This is explained by assuming that escape involves mostly the second reducible cluster. Evidence is thus provided for a functional asymmetry between the two terminal acceptors F(1) and F(2). From multiple-flash experiments, it was possible to derive the intrinsic recombination rates between P840(+) and reduced iron-sulfur clusters: values of 7, 14, and 59 s(-1) were found after one, two and three electron reduction of the clusters, respectively. The implications of our results for the relative redox potentials of the three clusters are discussed.

Photoinduced transient absorbance spectra of P840/P840(+) and the FMO protein in reaction centers of Chlorobium vibrioforme

The kinetics of photoinduced absorbance changes in the 400-ns to 100-ms time range were studied between 770 and 1025 nm in reaction center core (RCC) complexes isolated from the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium vibrioforme. A global, multiple stretched-exponential analysis shows the presence of two distinct but strongly overlapping spectra. The spectrum of the 70-micros component consists of a broad bleaching with two minima at 810 and 825 nm and a broad positive band at wavelengths greater than 865 nm and is assigned to the decay of (3)Bchl a of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) protein. The contribution of the 70-micros component correlates with the amount of FMO protein in the isolated RCC complex. The spectrum of the 1.6-micros component has a sharp bleaching at 835 nm, a maximum at 805 nm, a broad positive band at wavelengths higher than 865 nm, and a broad negative band at wavelengths higher than 960 nm. When the RCC is incubated with inorganic iron and sulfur, the 1.6-micros component is replaced by a component with a lifetime of approximately 40 micros, consistent with the reconstruction of the F(X) cluster. We propose that the 1.6-micros component results from charge recombination between P840(+) and an intermediate electron acceptor operating between A(0) and F(X). Our studies in Chlorobium RCCs show that approaches that employ a single wavelength in the measurement of absorption changes have inherent limitations and that a global kinetic analysis at multiple wavelengths in the near-infrared is required to reliably separate absorption changes due to P840/P840(+) from the decay of (3)Bchl a in the FMO protein.

Electron transfer in reaction center core complexes from the green sulfur bacteria Prosthecochloris aestuarii and Chlorobium tepidum

Electron transfer in reaction center core (RCC) complexes from the green sulfur bacteria Prosthecochloris aestuarii and Chlorobium tepidum was studied by measuring flash-induced absorbance changes. The first preparation contained approximately three iron-sulfur centers, indicating that the three putative electron acceptors F(X), F(A), and F(B) were present; the Chl. tepidum complex contained on the average only one. In the RCC complex of Ptc. aestuarii at 277 K essentially all of the oxidized primary donor (P840(+)) created by a flash was rereduced in several seconds by N-methylphenazonium methosulfate. In RCC complexes of Chl. tepidum two decay components, one of 0.7 ms and a smaller one of about 2 s, with identical absorbance difference spectra were observed. The fast component might be due to a back reaction of P840(+) with a reduced electron acceptor, in agreement with the notion that the terminal electron acceptors, F(A) and F(B), were lost in most of the Chl. tepidum complexes. In both complexes the terminal electron acceptor (F(A) or F(B)) could be reduced by dithionite, yielding a back reaction of 170 ms with P840(+). At 10 K in the RCC complexes of both species P840(+) was rereduced in 40 ms, presumably by a back reaction with F(X)(-). In addition, a 350 micros component occurred that can be ascribed to decay of the triplet of P840, formed in part of the complexes. For P840(+) rereduction a pronounced temperature dependence was observed, indicating that electron transfer is blocked after F(X) at temperatures below 200 K.

The bound electron acceptors in green sulfur bacteria: resolution of the g-tensor for the F(X) iron-sulfur cluster in Chlorobium tepidum

The photosynthetic reaction center (RC) of green sulfur bacteria contains two [4Fe-4S] clusters named F(A) and F(B), by analogy with photosystem I (PS I). PS I also contains an interpolypeptide [4Fe-4S] cluster named F(X); however, spectroscopic evidence for an analogous iron-sulfur cluster in green sulfur bacteria remains equivocal. To minimize oxidative damage to the iron-sulfur clusters, we studied the sensitivity of F(A) and F(B) to molecular oxygen in whole cells of Chlorobium vibrioforme and Chlorobium tepidum and obtained highly photoactive membranes and RCs from Cb. tepidum by adjusting isolation conditions to maximize the amplitude of the F(A)(-)/F(B)(-) electron paramagnetic resonance signal at g = 1.89 (measured at 126 mW of microwave power and 14 K) relative to the P840(+) signal at g = 2.0028 (measured at 800 microW of microwave power and 14 K). In these optimized preparations we were able to differentiate F(X)(-) from F(A)(-)/F(B)(-) by their different relaxation properties. At temperatures between 4 and 9 K, isolated membranes and RCs of Cb. tepidum show a broad peak at g = 2.12 and a prominent high-field trough at g = 1.76 (measured at 126 mW of microwave power). The complete g-tensor of F(X)(-), extracted by numerical simulation, yields principal values of 2.17, 1.92, and 1. 77 and is similar to F(X) in PS I. An important difference from PS I is that because the bound cytochrome is available as a fast electron donor in Chlorobium, it is not necessary to prereduce F(A) and F(B) to photoaccumulate F(X)(-).

Electron transfer kinetics in purified reaction centers from the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum studied by multiple-flash excitation

Reaction center preparations from the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum, which contain monoheme cytochrome c, were studied by flash-absorption spectroscopy in the near-UV, visible, and near-infrared regions. The decay kinetics of the photooxidized primary donor P840(+), together with the amount of photooxidized cytochrome c, were analyzed along a series of four flashes spaced by 1 ms: 95% of the P840(+) was reduced by cytochrome c with a t(1/2) of approximately 65 micros after the first flash, 80% with a t(1/2) of approximately 100 micros after the second flash, and 23% with a t(1/2) of approximately 100 micros after the third flash; after the fourth flash, almost no cytochrome c oxidation occurred. The observed rates, the establishment of redox equilibrium after each flash, and the total amount of photooxidizable cytochrome c are consistent with the presence of two equivalent cytochrome c molecules per photooxidizable P840. The data are well fitted assuming a standard free energy change DeltaG degrees of -53 meV for electron transfer from one cytochrome c to P840(+), DeltaG degrees being independent of the oxidation state of the other cytochrome c. These observations support a model with two monoheme cytochromes c which are symmetrically arranged around the reaction center core. From the ratio of menaquinone-7 to the bacteriochlorophyll pigment absorbing at 663 nm, it was estimated that our preparations contain 0.6-1.2 menaquinone-7 molecules per reaction center. However, no transient signal due to menaquinone could be observed between 360 and 450 nm in the time window from 10 ns to 4 micros. No recombination reaction between the primary partners P840(+) and A(0)(-) could be detected under normal conditions. Such a recombination was observed (t(1/2) approximately 19 ns) under highly reducing conditions or after accumulation of three electrons on the acceptor side during a series of flashes, showing that the secondary acceptors can stabilize three electrons. From our data, there is no evidence for involvement of menaquinone in charge separation in the reaction center of green sulfur bacteria.

Site-directed mutagenesis of the PsaC subunit of photosystem I. F(b) is the cluster interacting with soluble ferredoxin

The two [4Fe-4S] clusters F(A) and F(B) are the terminal electron acceptors of photosystem I (PSI) that are bound by the stromal subunit PsaC. Soluble ferredoxin (Fd) binds to PSI via electrostatic interactions and is reduced by the outermost iron-sulfur cluster of PsaC. We have generated six site-directed mutants of the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii in which residues located close to the iron-sulfur clusters of PsaC are changed. The acidic residues Asp(9) and Glu(46), which are located one residue upstream of the first cysteine liganding cluster F(B) and F(A), respectively, were changed to a neutral or a basic amino acid. Although Fd reduction is not affected by the E46Q and E46K mutations, a slight increase of Fd affinity (from 1.3- to 2-fold) was observed by flash absorption spectroscopy for the D9N and D9K mutant PSI complexes. In the FA(2) triple mutant (V49I/K52T/R53Q), modification of residues located next to the F(A) cluster leads to partial destabilization of the PSI complex. The electron paramagnetic resonance properties of cluster F(A) are affected, and a 3-fold decrease of Fd affinity is observed. The introduction of positively charged residues close to the F(B) cluster in the FB(1) triple mutant (I12V/T15K/Q16R) results in a 60-fold increase of Fd affinity as measured by flash absorption spectroscopy and a larger amount of PsaC-Fd cross-linking product. The first-order kinetics are similar to wild type kinetics (two phases with t((1)/(2)) of <1 and approximately 4.5 microseconds) for all mutants except FB(1), where Fd reduction is almost monophasic with t((1)/(2)) < 1 microseconds. These data indicate that F(B) is the cluster interacting with Fd and therefore the outermost iron-sulfur cluster of PSI.

Oxygen uncouples light absorption by the chlorosome antenna and photosynthetic electron transfer in the green sulfur bacterium chlorobium tepidum

In photosynthetic green sulfur bacteria excitation energy is transferred from large bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) c chlorosome antennas via small BChl a antennas to the reaction centers which then transfer electrons from cytochrome c to low-potential iron-sulfur proteins. Under oxidizing conditions a reversible mechanism is activated in the chlorosomes which quenches excited BChl c. We used flash-induced cytochrome c oxidation to investigate the effect of this quenching on photosynthetic electron transfer in whole cells of Chlorobium tepidum. The extent of cytochrome c photooxidation under aerobic conditions decreased to approx. 3% of that under anaerobic conditions when BChl c was excited under light-limiting conditions. Photooxidation obtained by excitation of BChl a was similar under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. We interpret this drastic decrease in energy transfer from BChl c to the reaction center as a consequence of the quenching mechanism which is activated by O2. This reversible uncoupling of the chlorosome antenna might prevent formation of toxic reactive oxygen species from photosynthetically produced reductants under aerobic conditions. The green filamentous bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus also contains chlorosomes but energy transfer from the BChl c and BChl a antennas to the reaction center in this species was not affected by O2.

Menaquinone-7 in the reaction center complex of the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium vibrioforme functions as the electron acceptor A1

Photosynthetically active reaction center complexes were prepared from the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium vibrioforme NCIMB 8327, and the content of quinones was determined by extraction and high-performance liquid chromatography. The analysis showed a stoichiometry of 1.7 molecules of menaquinone-7/reaction center. No other quinones were detected in the isolated reaction centers, whereas membrane preparations also contained chlorobiumquinone. The possible involvement of quinones in electron transport was investigated by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. A highly anisotropic radical was detected by Q-band EPR spectroscopy in both membranes and isolated reaction centers following dark reduction with sodium dithionite and photoaccumulation at 205 K. At 34 GHz, the EPR spectrum is characterized by a g tensor with gxx = 2.0063, gyy = 2.0052, gzz = 2.0020 and delta B of 0.7 mT, consistent with its identification as a quinone. This spectrum is highly similar in terms of g values and line widths to photoaccumulated A1- in photosystem I of Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002. The results indicate that menaquinone-7 in the green sulfur bacterial reaction center is analogous to phylloquinone in photosystem I.