Donor-derived disorders of hemostasis and thrombosis in liver transplantation: Considerations for deceased donor liver selection

OLT is known to be associated with a precarious perioperative hemostatic state due to dysregulation of procoagulant and anticoagulant factors, endothelial injury, and inflammation. Transmission of inherited bleeding and clotting disorders from the liver donor to the recipient may further complicate hemostasis during and after transplantation. As a result, consideration of congenital coagulation disorders in the liver donor is a practical concern for donor selection. However, there is no clear consensus regarding the selection of donors with known or suspected thrombophilia or bleeding disorders. While multiple case reports and retrospective studies, subject to reporting bias, describe donor-derived thrombophilic and bleeding disorders, there are no large-scale studies in the adult liver transplant literature that examine the frequency of transmission, utility of donor screening, or clinical impact of donor hemostatic disorders. Based on the reported literature, we summarize our approach for donor selection with an aim to balance improved organ utility and optimal post-transplant outcomes.

Perioperative management of antithrombotic treatment

End-stage liver disease is characterized by multiple and complex alterations of hemostasis that are associated with an increased risk of both bleeding and thrombosis. Liver transplantation further challenges the feeble hemostatic balance of patients with decompensated cirrhosis, and the management of antithrombotic treatment during and after transplant surgery, which is particularly difficult. Bleeding was traditionally considered the major concern during and early after surgery, but it is increasingly recognized that transplant recipients may also develop thrombotic complications. Pathophysiology of hemostatic complications during and after transplantation is multifactorial and includes pre-, intra-, and postoperative risk factors. Risk stratification is important, as it helps the identification of high-risk recipients in whom antithrombotic prophylaxis should be considered. In recipients who develop thrombosis during or after surgery, prompt treatment is indicated to prevent graft failure, retransplantation, and death.

Combined Congenital Hypodysfibrinogemia and Factor XI Deficiency in a Chinese Family

Both congenital hypodysfibrinogenemia and factor XI deficiency are rare coagulopathies caused by mutations within the fibrinogen and F11 genes, respectively. To investigate the pathogenesis of combined congenital hypodysfibrinogenemia with factor XI (FXI) deficiency in a Chinese family, coagulation assays, FXI activity (the 1-stage method), fibrinogen activity (the Clauss method), and antigen (prothrombin time [PT]-derived method) were performed. The sequences of fibrinogen genes and F11 were amplified by PCR and analyzed by direct sequencing. The proband as well as his grandmother, father, aunt, and sister showed a low plasma concentration of fibrinogen measured by the Clauss method and a slightly decreased result by the PT-derived method; finally, c.1097A>G in exon 8 of FGG was detected in the pedigree, which caused His340Arg mutation. His grandfather had a slightly prolonged activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT) due to low FXI activity. FXI deficiency was a compound heterozygote inherited with missense mutations of c.434A>G in exon 5 as well as c.1253G>T in exon 11 which caused HGV p.His145Arg and Gly400Val mutations, respectively. The grandfather had no qualitative or quantitative defect in fibrinogen. The proband and his father and aunt had c.434A>G at the exon 5 mutation site and no decrease in FXI activity. His mother had no fibrinogen or F11 gene mutations. Plasma fibrin polymerization was delayed. The proband in our study showed typical changes of congenital hypodysfibrinogemia in the clotting analyses with delayed fibrin polymerization, but although he was a heterozygous carrier of the c.434A>G variant in the F11 gene, he had no decrease in FXI activity and no bleeding tendency, thus questioning the pathogenicity of the identified variant in the F11 gene. To our knowledge, this is the first report of a case of combined hypodysfibrinogenemia and FXI deficiency confirmed by molecular genetic tests.

Donor-to-recipient transmission of factor XII deficiency by orthotopic liver transplantation

Transmission of congenital clotting factor deficiencies following orthotopic liver transplantation is rare. There has been one reported case of donor-to-recipient transmission of factor XII deficiency in a transplant, and we report the second case.

Recurrent superficial venous thrombophlebitis because of mutations in the protein C and fibrinogen genes in a young Argentinian female

: Hypodysfibrinogenemia and protein C deficiency are coagulopathies and in this report, we describe a young patient with both defects confirmed by molecular genetic tests. The patient was a 24-year-old woman referred for recurrent thrombophlebitis and finally deep venous thrombosis. Routine coagulation studies revealed mild decrease of protein C (0.49 IU, reference values 0.7-1.40 IU) and hypodysfibrinogenemia (0.88 g/l and 1.83 g/l for activity and antigen, respectively, reference values 2.0-4.0 g/l). Direct sequencing analyses were performed on FGA, FGB, and FGG genes to confirm hypodysfibrinogenemia and on the protein C gene to confirm protein C deficiency. As a result, the patient was shown to be heterozygous p.Ala82Gly in the FGG gene (Fibrinogen Dunedin) and for compound heterozygous missense mutation in protein C gene. To our knowledge, this is the first report on a case of combined dysfibrinogenemia and protein C deficiency confirmed by molecular genetic tests.

Afibrinogenemia Acquired by Liver Transplant

Liver transplant is a life-saving procedure in patients with end-stage liver disease. However, this procedure may be associated with transmission of various deficiencies of proteins synthesized by the liver. Factor I (fibrinogen) deficiency is one of the rare inherited coagulation disorders with an extremely low risk of transmission by liver transplant. We report a case of a patient with no inherited coagulation disorders but who demonstrated disturbance of fibrinogen after liver transplant. This case highlights the ever-present risk of donor-to-recipient disease transmission during transplant and emphasizes the difficulty in procuring organs from donors in which standard blood tests are insufficient to determine the likelihood of this event.

Cardiovascular disease risk in patients receiving organ transplantation: a national cohort study

Although organ transplantation is the definitive treatment for end-stage organ failure, the post-transplant outcomes can be substantially influenced by cardiovascular complications. A national cohort study was performed to estimate risks of cardiovascular diseases in those with heart, lung, kidney, and liver transplantation. This cohort study consisted of 5978 solid organ transplantations identified using the Taiwan National Health Insurance Database. Cardiovascular and mortality risks in transplant recipients were evaluated using standardized incidence ratios, excess absolute risks, and standardized mortality ratios as compared to those in the general population. In heart, kidney, and liver recipients, the standardized incidence ratios of overall cardiovascular diseases were 9.41 (7.75-11.44), 3.32 (2.29-3.77), and 1.4 (1.15-1.7) and the overall standardized mortality ratios were 5.23 (4.54-6.03), 1.48 (1.34-1.63), and 3.95 (3.64-4.28), respectively. Except for heart organ recipients who were at highest risk for coronary artery disease with a standardized incidence ratio of 13.12 (10.57-16.29), kidney and liver organ recipients had a ninefold increased risk in developing deep vein thrombosis post-transplant. In conclusion, solid organ transplant patients are at risk of cardiovascular disease, in particular, deep vein thrombosis, which may warrant early identification of high-risk patients in addition to prompt and adequate thromboprophylaxis perioperatively.

Genetic, hematological, and immunological disorders transmissible with liver transplantation

It is well recognized that solid organ transplantation can transmit bacterial infection and chronic viral hepatitis as well as certain cancers. As indications for liver transplantation (LT) have expanded, it has been used to treat and even cure certain genetic cholestatic disorders, urea cycle defects, and coagulation abnormalities; many of these conditions are potentially transmissible with LT as well. It is important for clinicians and transplant patients to be aware of these potentially transmissible conditions as unexplained post-LT complications can sometimes be related to donor transmission of disease and thus should prompt a thorough exploration of the donor allograft history. Herein, we will review the reported genetic, metabolic, hematologic, and immunological disorders that are transmissible with LT and describe clinical scenarios in which these cases have occurred, such as in inadvertent or recognized transplantation of a diseased organ, domino transplantation, and with living related liver donation. Liver Transplantation 23 663-678 2017 AASLD.

Perioperative thrombotic complications in liver transplantation

Although the perioperative bleeding complications and the major side effects of blood transfusion have always been the primary concern in liver transplantation (OLT), the possible cohesion of an underestimated intrinsic hypercoagulative state during and after the transplant procedure may pose a major threat to both patient and graft survival. Thromboembolism during OLT is characterized not only by a complex aetiology, but also by unpredictable onset and evolution of the disease. The initiation of a procoagulant process may be triggered by various factors, such as inflammation, venous stasis, ischemia-reperfusion injury, vascular clamping, anatomical and technical abnormalities, genetic factors, deficiency of profibrinolytic activity, and platelet activation. The involvement of the arterial system, intracardiac thrombosis, pulmonary emboli, portal vein thrombosis, and deep vein thrombosis, are among the most serious thrombotic events in the perioperative period. The rapid detection of occlusive vascular events is of paramount importance as it heavily influences the prognosis, particularly when these events occur intraoperatively or early after OLT. Regardless of the lack of studies and guidelines on anticoagulant prophylaxis in this setting, many institutions recommend such an approach especially in the subset of patients at high risk. However, the decision of when, how and in what doses to use the various chemical anticoagulants is still a difficult task, since there is no common consensus, even for high-risk cases. The risk of postoperative thromboembolism causing severe hemodynamic events, or even loss of graft function, must be weighed and compared with the risk of an important bleeding. In this article we briefly review the risk factors and the possible predictors of major thrombotic complications occurring in the perioperative period, as well as their incidence and clinical features. Moreover, the indications to pharmacological prophylaxis and the current treatment strategies are also summarized.

Coexisting congenital dysfibrinogenemia with a novel mutation in fibrinogen γ chain (γ322 Phe→Ile, Fibrinogen Beijing) and haemophilia B in a family

INTRODUCTION

Both congenital dysfibrinogenemia and haemophilia B (HB) are rare coagulopathies caused by mutations within the fibrinogen and F9 genes respectively.

AIM

To investigate the pathogenesis of combined dysfibrinogenemia with HB in a family.

METHODS

Coagulation assays, factor IX (FIX) activity (one-stage method), fibrinogen activity (Clauss method), antigen (immunoturbidimetry), fibrinogen polymerization and fibrinolysis velocity were measured. The sequences of fibrinogen genes and F9 were amplified by PCR and analysed by sequencing.

RESULTS

The proband, a 16-year-old boy with HB (FIX 2 IU dL(-1) ), also had persistently low Clauss fibrinogen level (0.64-0.65 g L(-1) ) with normal antigen level (2.23 g L(-1) ). The mother had a FIX 45 IU dL(-1) and similarly discrepant low Clauss fibrinogen (0.79 g L(-1) ) to antigen levels (2.23 g L(-1) ). Thrombin time for both were either slightly prolonged or at boundary value. Genetic analysis of the proband and the mother identified similar mutations in the FGG gene (heterozygous c.1042T>A resulting in p.Phe348Ile or γPhe322Ile in the mature protein) and in the F9 gene (c.1243del p.His415Metfs*11 and c.1245T>A p.His415Gln). The father had no fibrinogen or F9 gene mutations. Plasma fibrinogen polymerization was delayed, but fibrinolysis velocity was normal in the proband and his mother.

CONCLUSION

To our knowledge, this is the first report of a family with combined novel dysfibrinogen (Fibrinogen Beijing) and HB with bleeding manifestations.

Liver transplantation using grafts with rare metabolic disorders

Metabolic diseases that involve the liver represent a heterogeneous group of disorders. Apart from the metabolic defect, the subject's liver functions may be normal. With the increasing need for organs, livers from donors with metabolic diseases other than familial amyloid polyneuropathy might be possibly used for transplantation. However, whether such livers qualify as grafts and how they might impact recipient outcome are still unanswered questions. This review of the literature summarizes current experience in the use of such grafts in the context of cadaveric, domino, and living-related liver transplantation.

Acquired factor XI deficiency: a rare complication after liver transplantation

BACKGROUND

A majority of coagulation factors are synthesized in the liver. Factor XI (FXI) deficiency (Rosenthal syndrome) is one of the rare inherited coagulation disorders with an extremely low risk of transmission by liver transplantation (LT).

CASE REPORT

We report here the case of a 50-year-old man who unknowingly acquired FXI deficiency by LT. During 1 year of post-transplant follow-up, his activated partial thromboplastin time (aPTT) remained prolonged, but he did not develop bleeding complications. The patient required retransplantation due to chronic rejection and is currently doing well 4 years after his first liver transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

The presence of a prolonged aPTT in a deceased donor should raise suspicion for the presence of rare coagulation factor deficiencies. During urgent, lifesaving procedures such as LT, it may be impossible to avoid transmission. Awareness of this possibility will allow early detection and management.

Domino liver transplantation: indications, techniques, and outcomes

The long-term shortage of livers available for transplantation has spurred the development of many strategies to bolster the donor organ supply. One particularly innovative strategy is domino liver transplantation in which a select group of liver transplant recipients can donate their explanted native livers for use as liver grafts in other patients. Several hereditary metabolic diseases (such as familial amyloid polyneuropathy, maple syrup urine disease, and familial hypercholesterolemia) are caused by aberrant or deficient protein production in the liver, and these conditions can be cured with an orthotopic liver transplant. Although their native livers eventually caused severe systemic disease in these patients, these livers are otherwise structurally and functionally normal, and they have been used successfully in domino liver transplants for the past 15 years. This article will review the indications for donating or receiving a domino liver transplant, the surgical techniques necessary to perform these transplants, as well as the recently revealed long-term outcomes and risks of domino transplantation.

Clinicopathologic findings and outcomes of liver transplantation using grafts from donors with unrecognized and unusual diseases

Despite certain strict criteria for suitable organ donors, some unrecognized and unusual diseases have been transmitted through liver transplantation to recipients. In the current series, we review our experience with 14 patients who underwent liver transplantation using donor grafts with unusual pathology, including amyloidosis (6), schistosomiasis (3), iron overload (2), and alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency (3). One of 6 patients who received grafts with amyloidosis developed vasculitis associated with the presence of arterial amyloid. With proper management, patients with donor schistosomiasis, iron overload and alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency appear to have outcomes comparable to liver transplantation using grafts without these findings. In conclusion, long-term follow-up is necessary to confirm these findings and understand the impact of using these grafts.

Recurrent deep-vein thrombosis based on homozygous factor V Leiden mutation acquired after liver transplantation

Several genetic liver diseases can be treated by liver transplantation (LT). However, some genetic defects also may be acquired by this procedure. We describe a patient who developed recurrent deep-vein thromboses after LT for hepatitis C virus-associated hepatocellular carcinoma on the basis of a homozygous Leiden mutation of the factor V gene in the donor liver. Liver donors with a history of venous thrombosis should be screened for the presence of activated protein C (APC) resistance. In addition, we recommend looking for APC resistance in liver recipients who develop venous thromboembolic disease in the post-LT course. Molecular analysis of donor tissue may be necessary to make a definite diagnosis of factor V Leiden mutation in these patients. As a consequence, intensified postoperative thromboprophylaxis or lifelong anticoagulant therapy may be necessary if this thrombophilic gene defect is detected.

Acquired hemophilia A after liver transplantation: a case report

It is well recognized that orthotopic liver transplantation rapidly corrects the coagulation disorder observed in patients with hemophilia A or B combined with end-stage liver disease; however, the transmission of hemophilia from a donor to a transplant recipient has not been reported previously. We describe a patient who developed acquired hemophilia A after liver transplantation due to the unknown presence of factor VIII inhibitor in the donor. The resulting coagulation disorder was unresponsive to standard factor replacement therapy, and was ultimately corrected with retransplantation. Hemophiliac donors should not be precluded from organ donation, though the presence of factor VIII inhibitor should be actively sought before organ procurement. High levels of factor VIII inhibitor represents an absolute contraindication to liver donation.

Acquired protein S deficiency with multiple thrombotic complications after orthotopic liver transplant

BACKGROUND

Orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) is frequently complicated by thrombotic events that may threaten the viability of the allograft and severely compromise the overall outcome in these patients. Although multiple prothrombotic pathogenic mechanisms may be involved, a role for inadequate natural anticoagulant levels in the early postoperative period has been postulated.

METHODS

We describe a case of a woman who suffered multiple thrombotic complications after a second OLT. Prospective assays of procoagulant and natural anticoagulant factor levels, in addition to screening tests for a variety of inherited and acquired hypercoagulable states, were carried out.

RESULTS

Serial studies confirmed an acquired, isolated deficiency of Protein S associated with the second transplanted liver. Protein S levels were normal after the patient's first and third OLTs. There was no laboratory evidence of other underlying prothrombotic conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

This unusual case of acquired Protein S deficiency demonstrates that the hypercoagulable phenotype may develop in the recipient of a liver from a heterozygous deficient donor. Furthermore, isolated low Protein S may be causally associated with hepatic artery thrombosis after OLT.