Repeatability of corneal and ocular aberration measurements and changes in aberrations over one week

Influence of perfluorohexyloctane (Evotears®) on higher order aberrations

PURPOSE

To prospectively assess the effect of regular application of perfluorohexyloctane (F6H8; Evotears®) on the tear film lipid layer, higher order aberrations (HOA) and the repeatability of measurements in healthy eyes.

METHODS

This prospective clinical study included 104 eyes treated with F6H8 four times daily for four weeks (group A) and 101 eyes that served as controls (group B). Measurements were performed with the WASCA aberrometer (Carl Zeiss Meditec GmbH, Jena, Germany). Main outcome measurement in addition to subjective refraction were the root mean square values of HOA measured before and after the intervention.

RESULTS

Regular use of F6H8 over a period of four weeks significantly increases HOA in healthy eyes (p < 0.05). In addition, the repeatability of measurement increases after the application of F6H8.

CONCLUSION

F6H8 may be a suitable treatment option to improve the accuracy of refractive assessment, although it increases HOA. Further studies are needed to confirm the effect on HOA and the repeatability of measurement.

The Effect of Accommodation on Peripheral Refraction under Two Illumination Conditions

The clinical importance of peripheral refraction as a function of accommodation has become increasingly evident in the last years with special attention given to myopia control. Low order ocular aberrations were measured with a Hartmann–Shack aberrometer in a sample of 28 young emmetropic subjects. A stationary Maltese cross was presented at 2.5 D and 5.0 D of accommodative demand and at 0°, 10° and 20° of eccentricity in the horizontal visual field under two different illumination conditions (white and red light). Wavefront data for a 3 mm pupil diameter were analyzed in terms of the vector components of refraction (M, J0 and J45) and the relative peripheral refractive error (RPRE) was calculated. M was myopic at both accommodative demands and showed a statistically significant myopic increase with red illumination. No significant change in J0 and J45 was found with accommodation nor between illumination conditions. However, J0 increased significantly with eccentricity, exhibiting a nasal-temporal asymmetry. The RPRE was myopic at both accommodation demands and showed a statistically significant hyperopic shift at 20° in the nasal retina. The use of red light introduced statistically and clinically significant changes in M, explained by the variation of the ocular focal length under a higher wavelength illumination, increasing the experimental accommodative demand. These findings may be of relevance for research exploring peripheral refraction under accommodation, as the choice of target illumination is not trivial.

Agreement of wavefront-based refraction, dry and cycloplegic autorefraction with subjective refraction

PURPOSE

To evaluate the agreement of dry, and cycloplegic autorefraction and wavefront-based refraction with subjective refraction.

METHOD

83 subjects aged 19-57 years were included in this cross-sectional study. Refractive status was determined using four methods including subjective refraction, wavefront-based refraction, dry and cycloplegic autorefraction. Refractive data were recorded as sphere, cylinder and spherical equivalent (SE). Power vector components were used to compare the astigmatism obtained using the different methods of refraction.

RESULTS

The more negative spherical, cylindrical and SE components were obtained using dry autorefraction, wavefront-based refraction and dry autorefraction, respectively. The less negative spherical, cylindrical and SE components were obtained using cycloplegic autorefraction, subjective refraction and cycloplegic autorefraction, respectively. Considering the spherical component, there was a statistically significant hyperopic shift (0.12 ± 0.29 D, p = 0.001) with cycloplegic autorefraction and a significant myopic shift (-0.17 ± 0.32 D, p < 0.001) with dry autorefraction compared to subjective refraction, while the difference between wavefront-based and subjective refraction was not significant statistically (p = 0.145). The calculated cylindrical component using subjective refraction showed statistically significant difference with dry auto-refraction (p < 0.001), cycloplegic auto-refraction (p = 0.041) and wavefront refraction (p < 0.001). The highest correlation with subjective refraction in sphere, cylinder and SE was observed for cycloplegic auto-refraction (rs = 0.967), dry auto-refraction (rs = 0.983) and cycloplegic auto-refraction (rs = 0.982), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

As subjective refraction is gold standard in our study, sphere in cycloplegic auto-refraction and astigmatism in dry auto-refraction showed better agreement and correlation.

Comparative Study of Asymmetric Versus Non-asymmetric Intrastromal Corneal Ring Segments for the Management of Keratoconus

PURPOSE

To compare the outcomes obtained with models of asymmetric and non-asymmetric intracorneal ring segments (ICRS) in keratoconic eyes with asymmetric topo-graphic patterns.

METHODS

In this prospective observational study, ICRS were implanted alternately in patients with the same tomographic patterns of keratoconus assigned to four groups. Patients with the "duck" phenotype received one asymmetric or non-asymmetric ICRS and patients with the "snowman" pheno-type received two asymmetric or non-asymmetric ICRS. Visual, refractive, astigmatism, keratometric, and corneal aberrometry changes were evaluated over a 6-month follow-up period.

RESULTS

Sixty-eight eyes were analyzed. No significant difference was observed between the use of one asymmetric and one non-asymmetric ICRS in duck phenotypes. In snowman keratoconus, the inferior-superior index decreased significantly (P = .03) with asymmetric but not with non-asymmetric ICRS implantation. Total corneal higher order aberrations and coma rates were lower, but not significantly so, after the implantation of two asymmetric ICRS in snowman phenotypes (2.85 ± 0.89 to 2.60 ± 0.91 µm, P = .20 and 2.64 ± 0.93 to 2.39 ± 0.98 µm, P = .21), and significantly higher after the implantation of two non-asymmetric ICRS (2.56 ± 1.28 to 3.08 ± 1.62 µm, P = .02 and 2.34 ± 1.27 to 2.84 ± 1.62 µm, P = .02).

CONCLUSIONS

Asymmetric ICRS did not improve the outcomes of ICRS implantation in duck keratoconus. However, the implantation of two asymmetric ICRS was more effective than that of two non-asymmetric ICRS for decreasing vertical asymmetry and preventing increases in corneal aberration in the snowman phenotype of keratoconus. [J Refract Surg. 2021;37(8):552-561.].

Precision and agreement of higher order aberrations measured with ray tracing and Hartmann-Shack aberrometers

BACKGROUND

To assess the precision and agreement of measurements of higher order aberrations (HOAs) obtained with a ray tracing aberrometer (iTrace) and a Hartmann-Shack aberrometer (Topcon KR-1 W).

METHODS

Prospective evaluation of the diagnostic test. Data from the right eyes of 92 normal subjects obtained using the two devices were included in this study. Two observers performed 3 consecutive scans to determine the intraobserver repeatability and interobserver reproducibility. About one week later, one observer performed an additional 3 consecutive scans to obtain the intersession reproducibility. The within-subject standard deviation (Sw), test-retest repeatability (TRT) and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) were used to assess the precision, while Bland-Altman plots were performed to assess the agreement.

RESULTS

For intraobserver repeatability of the ocular, corneal and internal HOAs, Topcon KR-1 W showed a 2.77Sw of 0.079 μm or less and ICCs of 0.761 or more; and iTrace showed a 2.77Sw of 0.105 μm or less and ICCs of 0.805 or more. The ICCs of the internal HOAs of interobserver reproducibility were less than 0.75 except for spherical aberration (SA) (0.862), and interobserver reproducibility of the counterpart showed similar but lower results. For the ocular, corneal and internal HOA measurements, statistically significant differences existed between the Topcon KR-1 W and iTrace (all P < 0.05). No significant differences were observed in the ocular SA and internal coma.

CONCLUSIONS

The ray tracing and Hartmann-Shack method aberrometers provided excellent repeatability but less reliable reproducibility in the measurement of HOAs (except for SA). The two aberrometers should not be interchangeable in clinical application because of the significant differences in HOA measurements between them.

Scheimpflug image-based changes in anterior segment parameters during accommodation induced by short-term reading

PURPOSE

To analyze the effect of the accommodation on the anterior segment data (corneal and anterior chamber parameters) induced by short-time reading in a healthy, nonpresbyopic adult patient group.

METHODS

Images of both eyes of nonpresbyopic volunteers were captured with a Scheimpflug device (Pentacam HR) in a nonaccommodative state. Fifteen minutes of reading followed and through fixation of the built-in target of Pentacam HR further accommodation was achieved and new images were captured by the device. Anterior segment parameters were observed and the differences were analyzed.

RESULTS

Fifty-two healthy eyes of 26 subjects (range 20.04-28.58 years) were analyzed. No significant differences were observed in the keratometric values before and after the accommodative task (p = 0.35). A statistically significant difference was measured in the 5.0-mm-diameter and the 7.0-mm-diameter corneal volume (p = 0.01 and p = 0.03) between accommodation states. Corneal aberrometric data did not change significantly during short-term accommodation. Significant differences were observed between nonaccommodative and accommodative states of the eyes for all measured anterior chamber parameters.

CONCLUSIONS

Among the parameters of the cornea, only corneal volume changed during the short-term accommodation process, showing some fine changes with accommodation of the cornea in young, emmetropic patients. The position of the pupil and the anterior chamber parameters were observed to change with accommodation as captured by a Scheimpflug device.

Biomechanical Measurement of Rabbit Cornea by a Modified Scheimpflug Device

Purpose. To explore the probability and variation in biomechanical measurements of rabbit cornea by a modified Scheimpflug device. Methods. A modified Scheimpflug device was developed by imaging anterior segment of the model imitating the intact eye at various posterior pressures. The eight isolated rabbit corneas were mounted on the Barron artificial chamber and images of the anterior segment were taken at posterior pressures of 15, 30, 45, 60, and 75 mmHg by the device. The repeatability and reliability of the parameters including CCT, ACD, ACV, and CV were evaluated at each posterior pressure. All the variations of the parameters at the different posterior pressures were calculated. Results. All parameters showed good intraobserver reliability (Cronbach's alpha; intraclass correlation coefficient, α, ICC > 0.96) and repeatability in the modified Scheimpflug device. With the increase of posterior pressures, the ratio of CCT decreased linearly and the bulk modulus gradually reduced to a platform. The increase of ACD was almost linear with the posterior pressures elevated. Conclusions. The modified Scheimpflug device was a valuable tool to investigate the biomechanics of the cornea. The posterior pressure 15-75 mmHg range produced small viscoelastic deformations and nearly linear pressure-deformation response in the rabbit cornea.

Repeatability of aberrometric measurements with a new instrument for vision analysis based on adaptive optics

PURPOSE

To evaluate intersession and intrasession repeatability of aberration data obtained with a new visual simulator based on adaptive optics, which includes a Hartmann-Shack aberrometer (Adaptive Optics Vision Analyzer; Voptica S.L., Murcia, Spain).

METHODS

Thirty-one healthy right eyes were included in the study. To evaluate intrasession repeatability, three consecutive measurements without repositioning the patient or realigning the eye were obtained. Intersession repeatability was evaluated in three sessions. Aberrometric data computed from the second to the fifth order for a 4-mm pupil were used. Statistical analysis included the repeated measures analysis of variance (or the Wilcoxon signed rank test), the coefficient of repeatability, the Bland-Altman method, and the intraclass correlation coefficient.

RESULTS

No significant differences in the intrasession and intersession repeatability analysis for any of the parameters (P > .05) were found, suggesting a consistent variability of the instrument over time. Similar coefficient of repeatability values were obtained in the three sessions. The Bland-Altman analysis confirmed differences close to zero and the variations were independent of the mean within and between sessions. The intersession intraclass correlation coefficient values were generally above 0.75, suggesting moderate to high repeatability. However, some exceptions were found in the intrasession analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings suggest that the new instrument provides consistent and repeatable aberrometric data. It is therefore a suitable tool to perform consistent and repeatable visual simulations.

Progression of lower and higher-order aberrations: a longitudinal study

BACKGROUND

The aim of the present study was to investigate the effect of near-work on lower and higher-order aberrations, and its progression over a 9-month period during the school year.

METHODS

Data from 24 young-adult myopic eyes, and 24 non-myopic eyes were used in this investigation. The lower-order aberrations, coma, spherical aberration (SA), and total root mean square (RMS) of higher order aberrations (total HOA) were measured using an open-field iTrace aberrometer, at both the initial baseline evaluation, and then at the follow-up visits over a 9-month period. Pupil size of 4 mm was used for the aberration measurements.

RESULTS

The group mean (SD) of the subjects (mean age: 23.6 +/- 3.4 years) at the initial and follow-up visit was 0.47D (0.47D) and 0.31D (0.41D), in the non-myopes and -3.58D (2.08D) and -3.86D (2.14D) in the myopes, respectively. Significant increases in myopic refraction were observed. The group mean (SD) total HOA at the initial and final visit was 0.12 (0.08) and 0.11 (0.06) microns, in the non-myopes, and 0.15 (0.08) and 0.15 (0.08) microns, in the myopes, respectively. The group mean RMS of the coma at the initial and final visit was 0.06 (0.04) and 0.07 (0.05), in the non-myopes, and 0.08 (0.06) and 0.09 (0.06) microns, in the myopes, respectively. The group mean SA of the subjects at the initial and last visit was 0.04 (0.04) and 0.03 (0.03), in the non-myopes, and 0.04 (0.04) and 0.04 (0.04) microns, in the myopes, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

There was a significant difference in myopic refraction, over the 9-month assessment period. However, no significant difference in total HOA, SA, and coma between the initial and follow-up visits in both the myopes and the non-myopes was observed.

Higher order aberrations of the corneal surface after laser subepithelial keratomileusis

PURPOSE

To evaluate the changes of higher order aberrations (HOAs) before and after laser subepithelial keratomileusis (LASEK) and to analyze the influence of tear film instability on HOAs of the corneal surface after LASEK.

METHODS

In this cross-sectional study, 31 patients who underwent LASEK were divided into dry eye (16 patients, 32 eyes) and non-dry eye groups (15 patients, 30 eyes). Uncorrected distance visual acuity, spherical equivalent refraction, ablation depth, tear film parameters and Ocular Surface Disease Index (OSDI) questionnaire scores were evaluated in both groups. Total HOA root mean square (RMS), third-order coma, third-order trefoil and fourth-order spherical aberration (SA) of the corneal surface immediately and at 10 seconds after blinking were measured before and after surgery.

RESULTS

The total HOA RMS, coma, trefoil and SA significantly increased after LASEK compared with preoperative values in both groups. In the dry eye group, total HOA RMS, coma and trefoil significantly increased except for SA at 10 seconds after blinking compared with those measured immediately after blinking. In addition, the changes of total HOA RMS, coma and trefoil were negatively correlated with tear film break-up time (R = -0.420, -0.473 and -0.439, respectively), but positively correlated with OSDI score (R = 0.433, 0.499 and 0.532, respectively). In the non-dry eye group, there were no significant differences between HOAs measured at 10 seconds after blinking and those measured immediately after blinking.

CONCLUSIONS

The HOAs including coma, trefoil and SA significantly increased after LASEK. The tear film instability in the dry eye can be associated with more deterioration of the optical quality after LASEK, due to more significant increase of total HOA RMS, coma and trefoil.

Diurnal variations in ocular aberrations of human eyes

PURPOSE

To investigate the diurnal variations in ocular wavefront aberrations over two consecutive days in young adult subjects.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Measurements of both lower-order (sphero-cylindrical refractive powers) and higher-order (third and fourth-order aberration terms) ocular aberrations were collected for 30 young adult subjects at 10 different times over two consecutive days using a Hartmann-Shack aberrometer. Seventeen subjects were myopic and 13 were emmetropic. Five sets of measurements were collected each day at approximately 3 hourly intervals, with the first measurement taken at ∼9 am and the final measurement at ∼9 pm.

RESULTS

Spherical equivalent refraction (p = 0.029) and spherical aberration (p = 0.043) were both found to undergo significant diurnal variation over the two measurement days. The spherical equivalent was typically found to be at a maximum (i.e. most hyperopic) at the morning measurement, with a small myopic shift of 0.37 ± 0.15 D observed over the course of the day. The mean spherical aberration of all subjects (0.038 ± 0.048 μm) was found to be positive during the day and gradually became more negative into the evening, with a mean amplitude of change of 0.036 ± 0.02 μm. None of the other considered sphero-cylindrical refractive power components or higher-order aberrations exhibited significant diurnal variation over the two days of the experiment (p > 0.05). Except for the lower-order astigmatism at 90/180 degree (p = 0.040), there were no significant differences between myopes and emmetropes in the magnitude and timing of the observed diurnal variations (p > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Significant diurnal variations in spherical equivalent and spherical aberration were consistently observed over two consecutive days of measurement. Research and clinical applications requiring precise refractive error and wavefront measurements should take these diurnal changes into account when interpreting wavefront data.

Repeatability of internal aberrometry with a new simultaneous capture aberrometer/corneal topographer

PURPOSE

To compare repeatability of internal eye aberrations derived from aberrometry and corneal topography (CT) measured simultaneously by the Innovative Visual Systems Discovery, against time displaced but same instrument measurement (Nidek OPD-Scan 3), and time displaced different instrument measurement (Medmont E300 and Imagine Eyes irx3).

METHODS

Three aberrometry and CT measurements were captured with each instrument, except for the OPD-Scan 3 where three aberrometry scans were followed by a single CT. Measurements were repeated across 2 days. Corneal surface Zernike coefficients were derived from CT and subtracted from aberrometry to establish internal aberration coefficients. For the OPD-Scan 3, internal Zernike coefficients were derived by the instrument's software. Repeatability for second-order root mean square (RMS), spherical aberration, coma RMS, trefoil RMS, and the refraction components M, J0, and J45 were assessed using intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).

RESULTS

Intrasession repeatability was similar between the Discovery and E300/irx3, with the E300/irx3 slightly more repeatable for second-order RMS. Across days, the Discovery was most repeatable for second-order RMS (ICC 0.98) followed by the E300/irx3 (ICC 0.96) and OPD-Scan 3 (ICC 0.88). All instruments were less repeatable for higher order aberrations with only the Discovery moderately repeatable for spherical aberration and trefoil RMS (both ICC ≥ 0.75). The Discovery was highly repeatable for all derived refractive components (ICC ≥ 0.96). The E300/irx3 was highly repeatable for M (ICC 0.98) and moderately repeatable for J0 (ICC 0.89). The OPD-Scan 3 was highly repeatable for the M component (ICC 0.98) but not repeatable for the cylindrical components.

CONCLUSIONS

The Discovery was highly repeatable for second-order RMS and derived refractive components. The lower repeatability for internal higher order aberrations measured with all instruments suggests caution in their use until further work is carried out to investigate sources of error and to develop methods to improve repeatability.

Changes in refraction, ocular aberrations, and corneal structure after suspending rigid gas-permeable contact lens wear in keratoconus

PURPOSE

This study reports on changes in visual acuity, ocular higher-order aberrations, and refraction after suspending rigid gas-permeable lens wear for 1 week in 15 patients with moderate to severe keratoconus. Alterations in the anterior surface, central corneal powers and axes, and central corneal thickness were also explored.

METHODS

Scheimpflug photography and Hartmann-Shack aberrometry were performed at 2 visits, 7 days apart, after the patients had removed their habitual contact lenses. Subjective refraction and both high- and low-contrast logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution visual acuities were also recorded at both visits.

RESULTS

Reductions in both high-contrast visual acuity (P = 0.001) and low-contrast visual acuity (P = 0.002), along with an increase in third-order root mean square aberrations (P = 0.008), occurred after rigid gas-permeable lens wear was suspended in these patients with keratoconus. However, no significant changes in subjective refraction were found over the 1-week period (P ≥ 0.10). Significant correlations were observed between third-order coma root mean square aberrations and the measured high-contrast (r(p) ≥ 0.59; P ≤ 0.02) and low-contrast visual acuities (r(P) ≥ 0.61; P ≤ 0.015). In addition to increases in the anterior surface central corneal powers (P ≤ 0.02), a reduction in central corneal thickness also was found between the 2 visits (P = 0.00016).

CONCLUSIONS

Changes in the optical and structural parameters of the keratoconic cornea occur after suspending rigid gas-permeable contact lens wear. This information may be of interest to practitioners concerned with prescribing aberration-controlling soft contact lenses for such patients.

Peripheral aberration measurements: elliptical pupil transformation and variations in horizontal coma across the visual field

BACKGROUND

The aim was to determine the critical eccentricity at which two methods of elaborating peripheral wavefront measurements are significantly different and to characterise horizontal coma in healthy young adults.

METHODS

Peripheral aberrations were determined for 20 observers for central and eight peripheral gaze positions up to 20° using an IRX-3 aberrometer. In one subject, additional measurements up to 40° were obtained. Two definitions of stretching coefficients were compared. The raw empirical data were compared with theoretical modelling.

RESULTS

For both 3.5 mm and 6.0 mm pupils, no significant differences were observed between recalculated and non-recalculated elliptical pupils for both methods (p > 0.05) up to 20° eccentricity. For eccentricities greater than 20° and up to 40°, significant differences between circular and elliptical pupils at some eccentricities were apparent, which corresponded to theoretical models. Wide individual variations in horizontal coma across the peripheral field were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

The data suggest that for eyes with average levels of aberrations, the elliptical transformation is of no practical importance for eccentricities up to 20°. In some cases the slope of horizontal coma was reversed compared with previous findings in normal eyes.

Intrasubject repeatability of internal aberrometry obtained with a new integrated aberrometer

PURPOSE

To evaluate the intrasubject repeatability of the internal aberrometry obtained with a new integrated aberrometer in a sample of normal eyes to assess its clinical usefulness.

METHODS

Twenty-six healthy eyes of 26 participants, aged 20 to 50 years, were included in the study. All eyes achieved corrected distance visual acuity of 1.0 (Snellen decimal notation) and did not undergo previous ocular surgeries. Three consecutive measurements of internal aberrations were obtained with the KR-1W system (Topcon Corp) by an experienced examiner. Intrasubject repeatability for 4- and 6-mm pupils was evaluated by the within-subject standard deviation (S(w)) and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC).

RESULTS

Low values of S(w) and values of ICC close to 1 were found for the 4-mm pupil astigmatism and for several aberrometric coefficients: primary spherical aberration and higher order, third order, and trefoil root-mean-square (RMS). Significant correlations of the S(w) for the 4-mm pupil higher order aberrations RMS with the magnitude of different aberrometric coefficients were found (r≥0.611, P<.01). In addition, tetrafoil RMS for 4-mm pupils correlated significantly with the S(w) for some higher order errors (r≥0.675, P<.01). Significantly larger values of S(w) for 6-mm pupils were found for trefoil (P<.01) and secondary astigmatism RMS (P=.02).

CONCLUSIONS

The KR-1W provided repeatable measurements of internal astigmatism and some higher order aberrations, although consistency of such measurements appears to be limited by the level of aberration.

Corneal thickness association with ocular and corneal high-order aberrations

PURPOSE

To investigate the association among central corneal thickness, peripheral corneal thickness (PCT), and wavefront aberrations in the anterior cornea, posterior cornea and the whole eye in myopia.

METHODS

Sixty-four eyes of 64 myopic subjects were evaluated with a Pentacam rotating Scheimpflug camera (Oculus, Inc., WA) corneal topographer for: (1) wavefront aberrations from the anterior and posterior corneal surface, (2) corneal thickness (central and peripheral), and (3) with a wavefront aberration-supported cornea ablation wavefront analyzer (Wavescan, Visx, Inc., Santa Clara, CA) for wavefront aberrations generated in the whole eye. Relationships between the wavefront aberrations and corneal thickness were analyzed.

RESULTS

The mean age of subjects was 34.75 +/- 10.08 years. The central corneal thickness was 550.5 +/- 28.459 microm. The mean peripheral thickness was 629.9 +/- 32.1 microm. Central and PCTs were not significantly correlated with corneal or ocular high-order aberrations. Intraocular pressure was significantly correlated with ocular trefoil (r = -0.307, P=0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Central and PCT were not significantly associated with either anterior or posterior corneal Zernike aberrations; in addition, no association with the whole ocular wavefront aberrations was found.