Varicocele--a clinical enigma

The varicocele argument resurfaces

A recent series of articles and reviews published in Fertility and Sterility have rekindled the more than half century debate on varicocelectomy. Every one of these articles favored strongly the repair of varicocele for male infertility. Since my review paper on this issue in 2001, published in Human Reproduction Update, and since advent of ICSI in 1993, I had thought that most reproductive physicians felt negatively about the benefit of varicocelectomy. However, more recent urological papers are causing this negative view to be re-evaluated. It is now advocated by some urologists that varicocelectomy improves sperm count and testosterone levels, and even improves the results with ICSI. Thus, it may be appropriate to revisit older studies again and review the newer ones in this never ending controversy. Newer studies are re-opening the door to review and possibly re-instate varicocelectomy. This dilemma may never be fully resolved, but it is important to keep an open mind.

Sperm concentration and forward motility are not correlated with age in adolescents with an idiopathic varicocele and symmetrical testicular volumes

AIM

Idiopathic varicocele is a common condition that may impair fertility. Its treatment in children and adolescents is reserved for those patients who develop symptoms or testicular growth arrest. We evaluated the trends in sperm parameters among adolescent varicocele patients with symmetrical testicular volumes who have not undergone varicocelectomy.

METHOD

Data were prospectively collected from a single institution (2009 to 2014). Post-pubertal patients aged 12 to 17years produced semen samples by masturbation. Outcomes measured were semen volume, sperm concentration, and forward motility. Additional variables recorded included: a) testicular volume (ultrasound measurement), b) clinical varicocele grade, c) venous Doppler grading. Linear regression analysis was performed using Fisher's transformation. P<0.05 was considered significant, and data are presented as median (IQ range).

RESULTS

Forty-one patients with a median age of 15.4 (15.0-15.9) years each provided a sperm sample during the study period. Thirty-five had grade 3 (visible) varicocele, and 6 had grade 2 (palpable) varicocele. All patients had spontaneous venous reflux on Doppler ultrasound, and none had undergone varicocelectomy prior to producing the sperm sample. Table 1 summarizes the sperm parameters according to patient age. The overall median sperm concentration was 37 (16-64) millions/ml and was not correlated with age. The overall median forward motility was 55% (44-64) and was not correlated with age. Thirty-four patients had normal sperm parameters, which remained within the WHO range of normality.

CONCLUSIONS

Following the European Association of Urology guidelines does not cause progressive deterioration of sperm parameters between the age of 12 and 17years.

Surgical management of adolescent varicocele: Systematic review of the world literature

Historically, idiopathic varicocele is the most commonly diagnosed pre-pubertal andrological condition. The clinical presentation of varicocele may vary from dull and dragging unilateral or bilateral testicular pain to visible varicose veins lying over the hemiscrotum. Over the last decade, significant strides were made in managing symptomatic varicoceles, particularly minimal invasive procedures and surgeries. We sought to review the published literature in a systematic manner to gain an overview and streamline the presentations and main treatment modalities.

Gonadal vein embolization: treatment of varicocele and pelvic congestion syndrome

Therapeutic embolization of the gonadal veins is performed on male and female patients for different clinical situations using similar techniques. The testicular varicocele is a common clinical problem associated with pain and reduced fertility rates. In women, chronic pelvic pain can be attributed to pelvic congestion syndrome, which is said to result from retrograde flow in incompetent ovarian veins. Both of these clinical problems respond well to gonadal vein embolization. In this article, we review the clinical evaluation, diagnostic workup, and technical aspects of percutaneous intervention of gonadal vein embolization. The supporting literature is also reviewed.

The complex structure of the smooth muscle layer of spermatic veins and its potential role in the development of varicocele testis

OBJECTIVES

Varicocele, a dilatation of the pampiniform venous plexus, is considered to cause male infertility. The exact mechanism of varicocele development is not clarified yet. This study focused on the structure of varicocele veins, compared with normal spermatic veins, and its potential role in varicocele development.

METHODS

Morphologic and immunohistochemical studies using antibodies against vWF and neurofilament-200 (NF-200) were performed on spermatic vein fragments of 20 varicocele patients and 40 normal spermatic cords. Casting preparation of veins was performed on five normal spermatic cords.

RESULTS

Casting preparation frequently revealed circular constrictions of normal spermatic vein lumina. Histologic evaluation showed a strong longitudinal smooth muscle layer in the adventitia of large veins in addition to the circularly organised tunica media. Serial sections showed smooth muscle fibres branching from the outer longitudinal into the inner circular layer. Immunostaining for vWF revealed high vascularisation of this outer layer. Interestingly, the number of nerve fibres marked by NF-200 immunostaining was considerably higher in large veins compared to the testicular artery. The longitudinal smooth muscle layer was significantly degraded in the presence of varicocele grades I and II, and did not even exist in varicocele grade III. Correspondingly, the number of vasa vasorum and nerve fibres was reduced in varicocele veins.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data show a complex smooth muscle organisation of spermatic veins, which serves the basis for a contractile mechanism, providing an effective blood transport through pampiniform plexus. This mechanism is obviously damaged in the varicocele. Molecular processes behind this impairment remain to be clarified.

Testicular varicoceles

A testicular varicocele represents an abnormal degree of venous dilatation of the pampiniform plexus. It is a relatively common condition and may present at scrotal pain and swelling. An association with male subfertility is an area of debate. This article describes the present day radiological criteria and imaging techniques to aid accurate diagnosis of varicoceles. In addition, the role of the interventional radiologist in treating this condition is discussed.

Follow-up of varicocele treated with percutaneous retrograde sclerotherapy: technical, clinical and seminal aspects

Varicocele is a common cause of male infertility; it can be treated by percutaneous retrograde embolization of the internal spermatic vein in order to improve sperm parameters and male fertility. The aim of this study was to verify the improvement of semen parameters after varicocele retrograde sclerotherapy. We evaluated 223 patients with left (206) or bilateral (17) varicocele (mean age +/- SD, 27.3 +/- 4.7 yr, range 18-37) by clinical, Doppler and seminal examinations; all the patients underwent phlebography, using 5F Cobra catheter from the right femoral vein access to the internal spermatic vein and varicocele sclerosing with Hydroxy-polyaethoxydodecanol. Doppler and seminal examinations 6 months after sclerotherapy were requested for the follow-up. Sixty-seven patients with left or bilateral varicocele who did not undergo sclerotherapy were studied as controls. Six months after sclerotherapy, a complete resolution of left varicocele was present in 172 patients (77.1%), while a partial improvement was obtained in 34 patients (15.3%). In these 206 patients seminal examination showed a significant improvement of sperm concentration (mean +/- SEM, 52.1 +/- 4.1 vs 44.2 +/- 3.6 million/ml, p = 0.002) and progressive motility (40.5 +/- 2.2 vs 33.3 +/- 2.0%, p = 0.0001), but not of normal sperm morphology (38.9 +/- 2.3 vs 37.4 +/- 2.1%, ns). In the control group no significant variations of seminal parameters were observed 6 months after the basal examination. In conclusion, varicocele retrograde sclerotherapy is a well-tolerated technique with a low cost-benefit ratio, able to improve semen parameters.

Percutaneous retrograde varicocele embolisation using tungsten embolisation coils: a five year audit

OBJECTIVE

To assess the efficacy of percutaneous retrograde varicocele embolisation using Spirale tungsten coils over a period of five years.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Fifty consecutive patients underwent local anaesthetic day case varicocele embolisation via a right femoral approach. Venous anatomy was identified and classified. Morbidity and recurrence were recorded at three month clinical follow up.

RESULTS

The procedurewas technically successful in 94% of the patients. The varicocele recurred in 16%, the majority of whom had complex venous anatomy. 8% of the patients complained of discomfort at follow up.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the coils used in this study have been withdrawn, a high technical success rate is described with failure being predominantly due to complex venous anatomy.

Varicocele in schoolboys

This study was conducted to examine the effect of height and weight on the incidence of varicocele in schoolboys aged 5-16 years and the impact of varicocele on testicular size. Genital stage, height, weight, varicocele grade, and testicular size were recorded for 3047 school boys who were clinically examined while standing by a specialist in urology. Left varicocele was detected in 98 of the boys who were all aged 9-16 years. The mean weight of boys with and without varicocele was 42 kg (95% confidence interval [CI] 40-44 kg) and 47 (95% CI 47-47 kg), respectively (p =.00). There was no difference in mean height between the two groups nor in left and right testicular volume. Although 6 boys with varicocele had a left testicular volume > or =2 mL less than right, there were also 7 boys of comparable age who had a left testicular volume > or =2 mL larger than right. The incidence of varicocele in Greek adolescents is low. Boys with varicocele weighed significantly less but there were no significant differences in height or left versus right testicular volumes. In the light of these observations, the use of left testicular hypotrophy (> or =2 mL compared with the right testicle) should be reconsidered as an indicator for varicocele-induced damage of the testicle in this age group.

Nitric oxide synthase patterns in normal and varicocele testis in adolescents

OBJECTIVE

To determine if the testes of normal adolescents can produce nitric oxide (NO), by assessing NO synthase (NOS) activity, and whether this activity changes in adolescents with left idiopathic varicocele.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

After obtaining informed consent, testicular biopsies were obtained from eight adolescents (mean age 16.4 years; controls) who underwent surgery for inguinal hernia or hydrocele, and from 20 adolescents (mean age 16.2 years) operated for left idiopathic varicocele. Inducible and endothelial NOS (iNOS and eNOS) isoforms were investigated in the biopsy specimens by immunohistochemical localization and Western blot analysis using specific fluorescein-conjugated antibodies.

RESULTS

Both normal and pathological samples expressed eNOS at the level of vessels and Leydig cells. The iNOS was expressed in Leydig cells of normal testes and over-expressed in Leydig cells of varicocele testes.

CONCLUSION

Leydig cells of adolescent testes constitutively express iNOS. Under pathological conditions, e.g. varicocele, iNOS is up-regulated and is a possible source of NO overproduction. These results could be useful in explaining the pathogenesis of both testis and sperm dysfunction in varicocele.

Nitric oxide production is increased in the spermatic veins of adolescents with left idiophatic varicocele

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

The existence of an excessive release of nitric oxide (NO) within dilated spermatic veins has been recorded in adults with varicocele suggesting a high oxidative stress. The authors investigated whether NO overproduction is already present in the dilated veins of adolescent varicocele and which enzymatic isoforms in the spermatic vein could be expressed.

METHODS

The study group consisted of 10 adolescent patients affected by left idiophatic varicocele of grade II and III. The increase in NO production was established by determination of serum concentration of L-hydroxyarginine (L-NHA) and Nitrite/nitrate (NOx). Both endothelial and inducible NOsynthase (NOS) were investigated by Western blot analysis and by immunohistochemical localization using specific monoclonal fluorescein conjugated antibodies.

RESULTS

Serum L-NHA levels were significantly greater in the spermatic veins when compared with the peripheral veins 176.8 +/- 32.3 micromol/L versus 3.38 +/- 0.64 micromol/L (P =.0004 Similarly, NOx levels were increased, respectively, 68.2 +/- 16.7 nmol/mL versus 12.9 +/- 2.65 nmol/mL (P =.029). Endothelial NOS was localized in the spermatic vein of varicocele patients, but not overexpressed; the inducible isoform was not detected.

CONCLUSIONS

Adolescents with varicocele already present an increase in NO within dilated veins. The dilated spermatic vein is not the major source for the increase in NO level. These results could have an implication in the natural history of adolescent varicocele and in programming the ideal time for surgical treatment.

New concepts in operative andrology: a review

Several recently published, or about to be published, controversial issues in operative andrology are clarified and reviewed in this paper. The microsurgical technique for sperm retrieval for nonobstructive azoospermia, the round spermatid controversy and the varicocoele dilemma (why does everybody keep doing varicocoelectomy for male factor infertility?) are presented with salient points that have recently been presented elsewhere and referenced. Finally, at the end, we review briefly what is known about the likelihood of genetic transmission of infertility from male factor patients to their offspring as a result of the new ICSI technology.

Clinical assessment after varicocelectomy

The present study, conducted in Hong Kong, was designed to evaluate the clinical assessment and interobserver variation between doctors with different levels of training in the assessment of recurrent varicoceles, and to compare their findings with those made by ultrasound. Fifteen patients, previously operated for left varicocele testis, were evaluated clinically by four observers. The mean age was 12.9 years (range 8-15 years) at surgery. The testicular texture, size and flow with and without the Valsalva manoeuvre were determined by colour Doppler sonography. The follow-up time was 6-48 months after surgery. The echotexture of the testes was normal in all patients. The mean volumes of the left and right testes were equal after surgery (left 9.0 ml [range 2.4-15.2 ml and right 8.7 ml [range 3.4-15.6 ml]). There was large variation between observers in the predictability of both positive and negative clinical findings of varicocele testis when compared with ultrasound. Objective assessment in grading varicocele testis and testicular volume using ultrasound is required for both clinical management and scientific research.

A morphometric and ultrastructural study of the changes in the lamina propria in adolescents with varicocele

OBJECTIVE

To verify if changes in the lamina propria and its components, reported in adults with varicocele, are already present in adolescents with idiopathic varicocele, using a morphometric and ultrastructural study.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty testicular biopsies from adolescents (mean age 15.6 years) were obtained during surgery for left idiopathic varicocele; five testicular biopsies from adolescents (mean age 16 years) undergoing surgery for hydrocele or inguinal hernia were used as controls. Biopsy specimens were processed for light and transmission electron microscopy; the sections were evaluated morphometrically using computerized image analysis.

RESULTS

Morphometric and ultrastructural examination of the testes with varicocele showed an increased thickness in the lamina propria, caused principally by an increase in the extracellular matrix components, and deep invaginations towards the germinal epithelium.

CONCLUSION

There is detectable damage of the lamina propria in adolescents affected by left idiopathic varicocele, although not as well developed or as severe as in adults.

A follow-up study of semen quality and fertility in men with varicocele testis and in control subjects

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate semen quality and fecundity in a group of men with initially untreated varicocele testis, in comparison with control subjects.

PATIENTS, SUBJECTS AND METHODS

In a prospective, longitudinal study, 77 men (39 with varicocele and 38 control subjects) were evaluated in 1989 and re-investigated after 8 years. Fifty-seven men (29 with varicocele, 28 controls) were available for evaluation and they all completed a questionnaire. Semen from a total of 46 men (24 with varicocele) was compared with findings in 22 men from the control group.

RESULTS

There was a decline in sperm count in the control group from 80 x 10(6)/mL to 55 x 10(6)/mL over the 8-year period, but nearly no change in the sperm count in the men with varicocele. The withdrawal rate from each group was the same and included both men with and without reduced semen quality. There were no differences between the groups in sperm motility values (straight-line velocity, curvilinear velocity) evaluated using computer-assisted semen analysis. Paternity was achieved by 10 of 14 men in the varicocele group, compared with 14 of 16 in the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

There was no evidence that varicocelectomy might benefit patients, because the sperm concentration did not decline among men with varicocele over time. Computer-assisted semen analysis provided a good assessment of various sperm motility characteristics and we recommend evaluation using such objective methods, to allow comparison among studies

Biomechanical properties of normal and varicose internal spermatic veins

To investigate possible differences in biomechanical properties between varicose spermatic veins and controls. During surgery on 12 patients for grade 3 left-sided varicocele testis, 2 cm of the vein was obtained for comparison with: (i) samples of the left internal spermatic vein taken from the same anatomical localization from 8 patients without scrotal disease, and (ii) samples from the right internal spermatic vein from 7 other patients also without scrotal disease. The biomechanical properties of ring-shaped venous specimens were investigated by loading the specimen at a constant deformation rate until rupture. The relative amounts of collagen in the specimens were determined as the contents of hydroxyproline. There was a significant difference between varicocele testis/right spermatic vein in UC (unit collagen), F-max (maximum strength), Strain (ultimate extensibility) and E-fail (relative failure energy), but not in LD (diameter) and Tan-a (stiffness of the specimen). There were no significant differences between left and right spermatic vein in LD, UC, F-max, Strain, Tan-a and E-fail. There was a significant difference in LD between varicocele testis/left spermatic vein, but no relationship in UC, F-max, Strain, Tan-a and E-fail. Biomechanical analyses of the spermatic veins from patients operated for varicocele seem to support the hypothesis that a difference in biomechanical properties plays a part in the development of varicocele because a significant increase in extensibility of varicocele samples was found compared with normal right spermatic vein samples.

Repair versus observation in adolescent varicocele: a prospective study

PURPOSE

We designed a randomized prospective study of male adolescents with moderate and severe varicoceles to determine whether prophylactic varicocele repair is beneficial.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We evaluated 2,100 boys (10 to 20 years old) for genitourinary abnormalities. From this population 2 groups of adolescents 15 to 19 years old with grade 2 or 3 varicoceles were created, including 88 who underwent varicocele repair and 36 controls. Testicular volume and pampiniform vein diameter were measured, and Doppler ultrasound was performed.

RESULTS

After 12 months volume of the involved left testis increased to almost normal in treated boys (mean atrophy index 12.7% at surgery and 3% 12 months later). In controls the corresponding atrophy indexes were 10 and 9%, respectively. The relative increase in left testicular volume was 26% in the surgery group and 11% in controls. In the surgery group mean pampiniform vein diameter decreased from 2.8 preoperatively to 2 mm. postoperatively but there was no change in controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Varicocele repair in adolescents with moderate and severe varicocele reversed testicular growth arrest and resulted in catch-up growth within 12 month of surgery.

Relationship between semen quality improvement after varicocelectomy and preoperative levels of hypophyseal and gonadal hormones

Evaluation of serum levels of FSH, LH, prolactin, testosterone and oestradiol is not predictive of the increases of sperm count after varicocelectomy. Increased level of oestradiol reflects the lack of possibility of sperm motility increase after varicocelectomy.

Percutaneous varicocele embolization in the treatment of infertility

Clinical and sub-clinical varicoceles are associated with infertility and abnormal sperm parameters. Percutaneous embolization is a minimally invasive, safe, outpatient method of treatment which is cost effective in comparison to surgery. This study is a retrospective review of embolization of the spermatic vein using stainless steel occluding spring coils, performed in 116 males from two infertility clinics. Follow-up results were complete in 87 patients of which 79 (91%) were successful both technically and clinically and all had sperm analysis performed both before and within 2 years after embolization. There was a highly significant increase in motility (mean 35% before, mean 46% after, p < 0.001). Sperm density showed a trend towards improvement, but only p < 0.10, and there was no significant change in semen volume or morphology. The partners of 29 men (33%) became pregnant in a total of 241 years of follow-up.

High dose testosterone therapy for reduction of final height in constitutionally tall boys: does it influence testicular function in adulthood?

OBJECTIVE

We have studied the effect of treatment with high doses of androgens during puberty on testicular function in adult men with constitutionally tall stature, taking into account confounding factors interfering with sperm quality, since existing published data do not include whether testicular function is impaired by such treatment.

DESIGN

Historical cohort study.

PATIENTS

Forty-three previously androgen treated tall men (cases) and 30 non-treated tall men (controls).

MEASUREMENTS

Physical examination, semen analysis and plasma levels of LH, FSH, testosterone (T), sex hormone binding globulin (SHBG) and inhibin.

RESULTS

Sperm quality and testis volume were comparable between cases and controls. Mean sperm concentration was 66.4 x 10(6)/ml in cases and 66.2 x 10(6)/ml in controls. A left-sided varicocele was found in 45% of the cases and 37% of the controls. In cases we observed a significant effect of the age at start of androgen therapy on sperm motility (regr. coeff. (SE): 4.92 (2.41)%, P = 0.048). In addition, testicular size at start of therapy had a significant effect on sperm concentration (regr. coeff. (SE): 5.57 (1.54) x 10(6)/ml, P = 0.0012) and on total sperm count (regr. coeff. (SE): 43.1 (7.73) x 10(6), P = 0.0001). Plasma levels of T, SHBG and inhibin were not statistically different between the groups. Cases had significantly higher FSH levels (mean (SD) 3.3 (2.2) vs 2.1 (0.8) IU/I, P = 0.004) and significantly lower LH levels (mean (SD) 2.3 (0.9) vs 3.1 (1.4) IU/I, P = 0.019). We found a significant effect of age at start of therapy on plasma FSH level in the treated men (regr. coeff. (SE): -0.73 (0.18) IU/I, P = 0.0003).

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment with high doses of androgens for reduction of final height in constitutionally tall stature has no long-term side-effect on sperm quality, testicular volume or plasma testosterone levels. However, treated men had significantly higher plasma levels of FSH compared with controls. The meaning of this difference remains to be established. Varicocele was present in 42% of the adult tall men.