The costs and benefits of physiotherapy as first-line treatment for female stress urinary incontinence

How Much Allied Health Therapy Care Is Enough? An Evidence Scan

Purpose: Pressure to eliminate low-value health care is increasing internationally. This pressure has produced an urgent need to identify evidence-based methods to determine the value of allied health (AH) care, particularly to recognize when additional AH care adds no further benefits. This article reports on the published methods of determining the value of AH care. Method: We systematically scanned PubMed, MEDLINE, AMED, CINAHL, PsycINFO, and the Grey Literature Review database from inception until July 2018 for peer-reviewed English-language literature. Hierarchy of evidence and information on study design and the methods or measures used to determine the value of AH care were extracted. Results: Of 189 articles, 30 were potentially relevant; after the full text was read, all were included. Of these, 24 reported on ways of determining the value of AH care, and 6 described the optimal provision of AH episodes of care. No methods were reported that could be applied to establish when enough AH therapy had been provided. Conclusion: This review found a variety of attributes of value in AH care, but no standard value measure or methods to determine what constituted enough AH care. Repeated measurement of the standard attributes of value and costs is required throughout episodes of AH care to better understand the impact of AH care from the different stakeholders' perspectives.

A systematic review of the unit costs of allied health and community services used by older people in Australia

Background

An economic evaluation of interventions for older people requires accurate assessment of costing and consideration of both acute and long-term services. Accurate information on the unit cost of allied health and community services is not readily available in Australia however. This systematic review therefore aims to synthesise information available in the literature on the unit costs of allied health and community services that may be utilised by an older person living in Australia.

Method

A comprehensive search of Medline, Embase, CINAHL, Google Scholar and Google was undertaken. Specialised economic databases were also reviewed. In addition Australian Government Department websites were inspected. The search identified the cost of specified allied health services including: physiotherapy, occupational therapy, dietetics, podiatry, counselling and home nursing. The range of community services included: personal care, meals on wheels, transport costs and domestic services. Where the information was not available, direct contact with service providers was made.

Results

The number of eligible studies included in the qualitative synthesis was fourty-nine. Calculated hourly rates for Australian allied health services were adjusted to be in equivalent currency and were as follows as follows: physiotherapy $157.75, occupational therapy $150.77, dietetics $163.11, psychological services $165.77, community nursing $105.76 and podiatry $129.72.

Conclusions

Utilisation of the Medicare Benefits Scheduled fee as a broad indicator of the costs of services, may lead to underestimation of the real costs of services and therefore to inaccuracies in economic evaluation.

Assessment of the quality of cost analysis literature in physical therapy

BACKGROUND

Policy makers, payers, and other stakeholders increasingly call for greater evidence of the cost-effectiveness of health care interventions.

OBJECTIVE

The purposes of this study were to identify and rate the quality of cost analysis literature in physical therapy and to report summary information on the findings from the reviewed studies.

DESIGN

This study was a targeted literature review and rating of relevant studies published in the last decade using a quality evaluation tool for economic studies.

MEASUREMENTS

The Quality of Health Economic Studies (QHES) instrument was used to obtain quality scores.

RESULTS

Ninety-five in-scope studies were identified and rated using the QHES instrument. The average quality score was 82.2 (SD=15.8), and 81 of the studies received a score of 70 or higher, placing them in the "good" to "excellent" quality range. Investigators in nearly two thirds of the studies found the physical therapy intervention under investigation to be cost-effective.

LIMITATIONS

The small number of studies meeting the inclusion criteria was a limitation of the study.

CONCLUSIONS

The quality of the literature regarding the cost-effectiveness of physical therapy is very good, although the magnitude of this body of literature is small. Greater awareness of the strengths and limitations of cost analyses in physical therapy should provide guidance for conducting high-quality cost-effectiveness studies as demand increases for demonstrations of the value of physical therapy.

Current trends in the evaluation and management of female urinary incontinence

Despite its common occurrence and often seemingly obvious causes, female urinary incontinence requires a thorough and thoughtful evaluation for its proper diagnosis and treatment. With rare exceptions, urinary incontinence is the result of failure of the sphincter mechanism to resist bladder pressures encountered during daily activities. This may be the result of sphincter failure, overactivity of the bladder detrusor muscle or both. In uncomplicated cases, the diagnosis is usually based on an evaluation in the office. Urodynamic and cystoscopic study may be helpful in complex, resistant and recurring cases of urinary incontinence of any cause. Most cases of incontinence may be classified as stress, urge or mixed urinary incontinence. Treatment of stress urinary incontinence focuses on supplementing the urethral continence mechanisms, particularly the urethral supports and periurethral striated muscle function. The current paradigm for the treatment of urge incontinence centres on pharmacologic therapy, primarily by correcting detrusor overactivity with antimuscarinic drugs. Other therapies aimed at altering sensorimotor function may be used in resistant cases. The treatment of mixed urinary incontinence requires consideration of the contribution of each of its components. With proper diagnosis, effective treatment is possible for most patients.