The origin of human triploidy: an integration of qualitative and quantitative evidence

Restricted development of mouse triploid fetuses with disorganized expression of imprinted genes

Eukaryotic species commonly contain a diploid complement of chromosomes. The diploid state appears to be advantageous for mammals because it enables sexual reproduction and facilitates genetic recombination. Nonetheless, the effects of DNA ploidy on mammalian ontogeny have yet to be understood. The present study shows phenotypic features and expression patterns of imprinted genes in tripronucleate diandric and digynic triploid (DAT and DGT) mouse fetuses on embryonic day 10.5 (E10.5). Measurement of crown–rump length revealed that the length of DGT fetuses (1.87 ± 0.13 mm; mean ± standard error of the mean) was much smaller than that of diploid fetuses (4.81 ± 0.05 mm). However, no significant difference was observed in the crown–rump length between diploid and DAT fetuses (3.86 ± 0.43 mm). In DGT fetuses, the expression level of paternally expressed genes, Igf2, Dlk1, Ndn, and Peg3, remained significantly reduced and that of maternally expressed genes, Igf2r and Grb10, increased. Additionally, in DAT fetuses, the Igf2 mRNA expression level was approximately twice that in diploid fetuses, as expected. These results provide the first demonstration that imprinted genes in mouse triploid fetuses show distinctive expression patterns independent of the number of parental-origin haploid sets. These data suggest that both DNA ploidy and asymmetrical functions of parental genomes separately influence mammalian ontogeny.

When a conception fails to become a pregnancy

Other contributors to this symposium have analysed in great detail the many components that go to make up reproductive success, so it is fitting to conclude with some thoughts about the aetiology of reproductive failure. Firstly, there are occasions when reproduction can be too successful, so that a density-dependent mechanism for inducing early embryonic mortality may be a most valuable protective mechanism. This is particularly true for polytocous species, where it may be necessary to achieve some regulation of litter size by differential embryonic mortality. Even in monotocous species some degree of embryonic mortality may also be advantageous as a way of prolonging the interval between successive births, for if one infant follows too hard upon the heels of another, the normal growth and development of both offspring will be permanently impaired. Embryonic mortality is also likely to be an effective insurance mechanism against the production of genetically defective offspring, because the absence of haploid gene expression will protect the spermatozoon from maternal immunological surveillance systems. With these concepts in mind, it is interesting to look at the nature and extent of embryonic loss in man and animals.

CaMKII can participate in but is not sufficient for the establishment of the membrane block to polyspermy in mouse eggs

Fertilization triggers initiation of development and establishment of blocks on the egg coat and plasma membrane to prevent fertilization by multiple sperm (polyspermy). The mechanism(s) by which mammalian eggs establish the membrane block to polyspermy is largely unknown. Ca(2+)/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMKII) appears to be the key regulator of several egg activation events (completion of meiosis, progression to embryonic interphase, recruitment of maternal mRNAs). Since sperm-induced increases in cytosolic Ca(2+) play a role in establishment of the membrane block to polyspermy in mouse eggs, we hypothesized that CaMKII was a Ca(2+)-dependent effector leading to this change in egg membrane function. To test this hypothesis, we modulated CaMKII activity in two ways: activating eggs parthenogenetically by introducing constitutively active CaMKIIalpha (CA-CaMKII) into unfertilized eggs, and inhibiting endogenous CaMKII in fertilized eggs with myristoylated autocamtide 2-related inhibitory peptide (myrAIP). We find that eggs treated with myrAIP establish a less effective membrane block to polyspermy than do control eggs, but that CA-CaMKII is not sufficient for membrane block establishment, despite the fact that CA-CaMKII-activated eggs undergo other egg activation events. This suggests that: (1) CaMKII activity contributes to the membrane block, but this not faithfully mimicked by CA-CaMKII and furthermore, other pathways, in addition to those activated by Ca(2+) and CaMKII, also participate in membrane block establishment; (2) CA-CaMKII has a range of effects as a parthenogenetic trigger of egg activation (high levels of cell cycle resumption, modest levels of cortical granule exocytosis, and no membrane block establishment).

Causes of Fetal Wastage

Fetal wastage has many causes, but genetic factors are by far the most common. The earlier the pregnancy loss occurs, the greater the likelihood of genetic causation. Among first trimester abortions, 50% to 80% show chromosomal abnormalities, usually aneuploidy. This is greater than all other causes combined. Chromosomal numerical abnormalities can be recurrent and sporadic; failure to take this into account is a major pitfall in many reports addressing causation. Moreover, many causes of fetal wastage that are traditionally considered to be "nongenetic" are actually the result of perturbations of gene products-proteins. Among nongenetic causes of first trimester fetal wastage, the best established are thyroid abnormities; antifetal antibodies; and the inherited and acquired thrombophilias. The latter are more established in the second trimester. Uterine anomalies can lead to second trimester losses. Infections seem uncommon, and alloimmune causes are not validated.

Secretory mechanisms and Ca2+ signaling in gametes: similarities to regulated neuroendocrine secretion in somatic cells and involvement in emerging pathologies

Recent studies demonstrate that regulated secretion in probably all mammalian cells, from gonadotropes to gametes, utilizes similar signaling systems, intracellular Ca(2+) regulation, Ca(2+)-dependent proteins, cytoskeletal participation, and SNARE-mediated fusion. Thus, highly specialized cells, like sperm and eggs, should no longer be considered to have evolved a cell-type specific secretory mechanism. In gametes, Ca(2+)-dependent proteins and enzymes transduce elevations of intracellular Ca(2+) into secretory events, i.e., exocytosis of the acrosome in sperm and cortical granules in the egg. Just as secretory deficiencies have clinical consequences in endocrine and exocrine cells, failure of secretion of cortical granules or the acrosome can result in failure of normal fertilization or fertilization followed by abnormal development. With the advent of human in vitro fertilization, such gamete pathologies have been recently identified and have led to new clinical procedures to achieve normal fertilization and pregnancies. A better understanding of the common Ca(2+)-dependent secretory pathways in both gametes and somatic cells should be beneficial to investigating mis-regulation in either cell type.

Membrane and cortical abnormalities in post-ovulatory aged eggs: analysis of fertilizability and establishment of the membrane block to polyspermy

Fertilization at increased times after ovulation is associated with poor reproductive outcomes. This study examines the effects of post-ovulatory ageing on egg membrane function through analyses of mouse eggs collected at 13 and 22 h post-HCG ('young' and 'aged' eggs, respectively). Experiments in which fertilized zona pellucida-free young and aged eggs are challenged with additional sperm reveal that aged eggs are less able to establish a membrane block to prevent polyspermy, since sperm penetrate 24% of fertilized aged eggs but are unable to penetrate fertilized young eggs. This is not due to a failure of aged eggs to respond to fertilization, as the extent of sperm-induced cortical granule exocytosis is similar in aged and young eggs. Post-ovulatory ageing also affects egg membrane receptivity to sperm as a subset of zona pellucida-free aged eggs are slow to fertilize or resistant to fertilization. Sperm binding to young and aged eggs is similar, but aged eggs develop cytoskeletal abnormalities that may affect membrane/cortical function, such as the ability of the egg membrane to support sperm-egg fusion. These data demonstrate that the poor reproductive outcomes associated with post-ovulatory ageing could be a result of reduced fertilization, due to reduced egg membrane receptivity to sperm, or a result of increased incidence of polyspermy, due to the reduced ability to establish a membrane block to polyspermy. This analysis of egg membrane function deficiencies provides insights into post-ovulatory ageing and has implications for assisted reproductive technologies.

The biology of cortical granules

An egg-that took weeks to months to make in the adult-can be extraordinarily transformed within minutes during its fertilization. This review will focus on the molecular biology of the specialized secretory vesicles of fertilization, the cortical granules. We will discuss their role in the fertilization process, their contents, how they are made, and the molecular mechanisms that regulate their secretion at fertilization. This population of secretory vesicles has inherent interest for our understanding of the fertilization process. In addition, they have import because they enhance our understanding of the basic processes of secretory vesicle construction and regulation, since oocytes across species utilize this vesicle type. Here, we examine diverse animals in a comparative approach to help us understand how these vesicles function throughout phylogeny and to establish conserved themes of function.

Placental pathology of triploidy

Triploidy is a common chromosome abnormality in spontaneous abortions. Previous studies of spontaneous abortions have suggested that approximately 85% of triploid abortuses show the placental changes of partial hydatidiform mole (PHM) and that this appearance was associated, possibly attributable, to paternal origin of the extra haploid set of chromosomes. More recent work, however, has shown that most triploidy is the result of digyny--the extra set of chromosomes originating from the mother. Given the association of PHM with diandry, these results would appear to be at odds with the results of previous studies of placental morphology in triploids. The authors reviewed the placental pathology of all cases of triploidy examined at their institution over a 2-year period and established that PHM occurs in a minority of triploid conceptuses. These results support the findings of studies showing that digyny is the most common origin of triploidy.

Cleavage rate of diandric triploid mouse embryos during the preimplantation period

The postimplantation development of human and animal triploid embryos is well documented, but there is little informative data on their preimplantation development. An analysis of cell number at appropriate times during this period and thus their cleavage rate would give an indication of the potential triploids have for further development and may explain some problems associated with their postimplantation development. To rule out any effects of technical procedures on cleavage rate, appropriate controls were used. Diandric triploid embryos were produced using standard micromanipulatory techniques, which involved the injection of a male pronucleus into a recipient one-cell-stage embryo. The karyoplast was fused to the cytoplasm by electrofusion, and the resulting tripronucleate diandric triploid embryos were transferred to appropriate pseudopregnant recipients. At specific times after the transfer, the embryos were recovered and cell numbers established. The results were plotted and regression lines drawn. Three controls were used 1) micromanipulated diploid embryos from which the male pronucleus had been removed and immediately reinserted and fused to restore diploidy, 2) diploid embryos that had been briefly incubated in cytochalasin D and colcemid to find out the effects these agents had on development, and 3) diploid embryos that had been isolated and briefly incubated in tissue culture medium. All embryos were subsequently transferred to recipients. After isolation at specific times during the preimplantation period, cell numbers were also established and the results plotted.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The pattern of X-chromosome inactivation in the embryonic and extra-embryonic tissues of post-implantation digynic triploid LT/Sv strain mouse embryos

Spontaneously cycling LT/Sv strain female mice were mated to hemizygous Rb(X.2)2Ad males in order to facilitate the distinction of the paternal X chromosome, and the pregnant females were autopsied at about midday on the tenth day of gestation. Out of a total of 222 analysable embryos recovered, 165 (74.3%) were diploid and 57 (25.7%) were triploid. Of the triploids, 26 had an XXY and 31 an XXX sex chromosome constitution. Both embryonic and extra-embryonic tissue samples from the triploids were analysed cytogenetically by G-banding and by the Kanda technique to investigate their X-inactivation pattern. The yolk sac samples were separated enzymatically into their endodermally-derived and mesodermally-derived components, and these were similarly analysed, as were similar samples from a selection of control XmXp diploid embryos. In the case of the XmXmY digynic triploid embryos, a single darkly-staining Xm chromosome was observed in 485 (82.9%) out of 585, 304 (73.3%) out of 415, and 165 (44.7%) out of 369 metaphases from the embryonic, yolk sac mesodermally-derived and yolk sac endodermally-derived tissues, respectively. The absence of a darkly staining X-chromosome in the other metaphase spreads could either indicate that both X-chromosomes present were active, or that the Kanda technique had failed to differentially stain the inactive X-chromosome(s) present. In the case of the XmXmXp digynic triploid embryos, virtually all of the tissues analysed comprised two distinct cell lineages, namely those with two darkly-staining X-chromosomes, and those with a single darkly staining X-chromosome.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Incidence and timing of pregnancy losses: relevance to evaluating safety of early prenatal diagnosis

Knowing the frequency and timing of pregnancy loss during normal gestation is integral to evaluating the safety of prenatal diagnostic techniques. That preclinical loss rates are high in humans has long been suspected, but in the past decade new data concerning these losses have become available. Cohort studies indicate that many women who show positive beta-HCG assays never show clinical evidence of pregnancy. Cytogenetic abnormalities have also recently been documented in 20% of ostensibly normal in vitro fertilization embryos. All the above are consistent with the sentinel studies of Hertig and Rock, who showed high frequencies of morphological abnormalities in preimplantation embryos. The frequency of fetal losses after clinical recognition of pregnancy is 12-15%; however, more sensitive (ultrasonographic) methods of detecting fetal demise now indicate that most clinically recognized pregnancies occur prior to 8-9 weeks, being retained in utero 2-3 weeks prior to expulsion. Loss rates are influenced by maternal age, smoking, alcohol, and other confounding variables that if not taken into account could yield spurious results concerning safety of prenatal diagnostic techniques. After 8 weeks gestation the likelihood of losing a viable pregnancy is only 3% and after 16 weeks only 1%.

Triploidy: pregnancy complications and clinical findings in seven cases

Seven cases of triploidy were encountered by the Prenatal Diagnosis Program at Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center over an 8-year period through associated pregnancy complications. We describe the characteristic findings that facilitate prenatal diagnosis and management. Our experience includes fetuses with major central nervous system abnormalities (spina bifida aperta, holoprosencephaly) and anterior abdominal wall defects, which are detectable with routine prenatal diagnostic screening examinations (ultrasound and AFP). In addition, we stress the importance of recognizing obstetric complications and associated cystic placental changes, which are quite common among triploid conceptuses. Molar changes associated with triploidy have a more benign prognosis than that associated with diploid moles. Such molar changes may relate to the presence of a diploid paternal chromosome complement. The usefulness of cytofluorometric DNA determinations in helping to confirm a clinical suspicion of triploidy is emphasized. These cases are presented in an effort to facilitate prenatal recognition and management of this common cytogenetic condition and prevent unnecessary Caesarean section deliveries.

Differentiation of binuclear spermatozoa in mice

In an electron microscopy study of abnormal spermatogenesis in mice, we have found that two discrete haploid nuclei may be located in a single spermatid cytoplasm after the second meiotic division. The spermatid continues to differentiate and forms a binucleate spermatozoon with both nuclei separately packaged within the sperm head. The Golgi apparatus of the double spermatid forms a single proacrosome that attaches to both nuclei. Apparently, one acrosomal structure differentiates to cover and compartmentalize the two haploid nuclei within the sperm head. Chromatin condensation appears normal. The head morphology and number of flagella vary in mature spermatozoa produced by this process. This work demonstrates one pathway by which polyploid spermatids continue to differentiate to spermatozoa after failure of cytoplasmic division or possibly cellular fusion.

The effect of polyploidy on embryo cleavage after in vitro fertilization in humans

The effect of polyploidy on the early development of human embryos is unknown. This study compares the early development of 90 polyploid and 275 diploid human embryos conceived in vitro. Between May 1983 and January 1986, 3081 oocytes were recovered during 631 cycles of laparoscopy for in vitro fertilization (4.9 oocytes/cycle); 1924 oocytes (62.4%) fertilized. There were 90 oocytes with more than two pronuclei (4.7% of fertilized oocytes), identified in 72 cycles (11.4% of cycles). In these cycles, the proportion of diploid oocytes (n = 275) that cleaved (cleavage rate) (92.7%) was significantly greater than the proportion of polyploid oocytes (n = 90) that cleaved (65.5%) (P less than 0.001). The cleavage rate for all diploid oocytes (n = 1834) was 90.4%. There was no significant difference in the stage of development (number of blastomeres; mean +/- standard deviation [SD]) on the day of embryo transfer between diploid (4.3 +/- 2.1) and polyploid (4.1 +/- 2.1) embryos that cleaved, but a plot of the frequency distribution of cleavage stages revealed that significantly more polyploid than diploid embryos had an uneven number of blastomeres at that time (33% versus 8%, respectively; P less than 0.001). Polyploidy confers an immediate developmental disadvantage; one third of polyploid embryos fail to cleave, and those that do divide demonstrate more asynchronous divisions.

Origin of triploidy in spontaneous abortuses

Fourteen triploid spontaneous abortuses were studied cytogenetically by sequential Q and C banding and the marker chromosomes were compared with those of the parents. The abortuses comprised all triploid cases in a series of 288 consecutive abortuses of the first 16 weeks of pregnancy occurring in one hospital. In 12 of the triploids the origin of the extra haploid set was conclusively determined, revealing six cases of dispermy, five failures in the first maternal and one failure in the first paternal meiotic division. The results were combined with those of five other studies comprising a total of 48 informative cases. Non-reduction in the second meiotic division seems to be of little or no significance in the origin of human triploidy. Dispermy is the predominant source, accounting for 40--50% of the triploid spontaneous abortuses. Non-reduction in the first meiotic division of the father seems to be the second-most frequent source although in the present material the corresponding maternal non-reduction is much more common.

The induction of sex-chromosomal nondisjunction and diploid spermatids following x-irradiation of pre-spermatid stages in the northern vole Microtus oeconomus

Chromosome nondisjunction seems to be one of the most important mutagenic effects occurring in man and makes an enormous contribution to human foetal wastage. As yet, little or no information is available on which environmental factors are important in inducing nondisjunction and accordingly we have investigated the effect of X-irradiation on inducing nondisjunction in male germ cells of an experimental mammal, the Northern vole-Microtus oeconomus. Using a staining technique based upon the presence of heterochromatin we have scored the number of sex chromosomes in early spermatids in both irradiated and unirradiated animals. A significant increase in nondisjunction, following treatment, was found with all doses between 25 and 200 R. However, variations in nondisjunction induction at various time intervals following irradiation suggest variations in cell stage sensitivity. More surprising was the large induction of diploid gametes which also demonstrated a significant induction with all irradiation doses. From the distribution of sex chromosomes we conclude that both nondisjunction and diploid gamete induction occur at both meiotic divisions. At present it is not possible to conclude whether the radiation response is linear and to define the cell-stage sensitivity with precision. The reasons for this appear to be variations in sensitivity between animals and also that there is a clear overlap between the duration of the early spermatid stage analyzed (4 days) and the interval between sampling times.

Digynic triploidy in rabbit blastocysts after delayed insemination

The origin of triploid (3N) 5½-day blastocysts in rabbits is inferred from the segregation of sex chromosomes and of an autosomal M-marker whose properties are described. 39 triploids and no tetraploids were scored among 1454 chromosomally scored blastocysts. A delay of 8 h between an ovulatory injection and subsequent insemination raised the estimated normal incidence of 0·59% triploid blastocysts to 3·13%. The increase is ascribed primarily to digyny (17 blastocysts), and to diandry probably mediated by dispermy (1 blastocyst). The triploid components of the two 2N/3N mosaics and the one 3N/6N were digynic. Neither superovulation nor insemination of excessive numbers of spermatozoa could be shown to give rise to triploid embryos. The diandric triploid was X Y Y, the first of this constitution apparently reported in the rabbit. There was some evidence that X X Y triploid blastocysts up to 5½-day gestation are more viable than X X X. In the 2N/3N mosaics each component had been entered by one spermatozoon, and the dliploid component could not have been merely a contamination by dliploid maternal somatic cells. In 2N/4N, 2N/4N/8N and 3N/6N mosaics, each polyploid component showed an exact doubling of the marker chromosome constitution of a component of lower ploidy; their origin is ascribed to doubling or redoubling of chromosome number in isolated embryonic cells. With earlier data included, 49·08 (± s.e. 1·96)% of 652 diploid blastocysts were X Y. 460 non-experimental weaned rabbits were all cliploid.