Comparative oxidation of loxapine and clozapine by human neutrophils

Long-term treatment with clozapine and other antipsychotic drugs and the risk of haematological malignancies in people with schizophrenia: a nationwide case-control and cohort study in Finland

BACKGROUND

Clozapine is the most efficacious treatment for schizophrenia and is associated with lower overall mortality than are other antipsychotic drugs, despite the risk of agranulocytosis. Preliminary reports over the past 10 years suggest a possible risk of haematological malignancies, but the issue has remained unsettled. We aimed to study the risk of haematological malignancies associated with use of clozapine and other antipsychotics.

METHODS

We did a nationwide case-control (and cohort) study of people with schizophrenia, using prospectively gathered data from Finnish national registers. A nested case-control study was constructed by individually matching cases of lymphoid and haematopoietic tissue malignancy with up to ten controls without cancer by age, sex, and time since first schizophrenia diagnosis. For the case-control study, we restricted inclusion criteria to malignancies diagnosed on a histological basis, and excluded individuals outside of the age range 18-85 years, and any patients that had a previous malignancy. Analyses were done using conditional logistic regression adjusting for comorbid conditions.

FINDINGS

For the case-control study 516 patients with a first-time diagnosis of lymphoid and haematopoietic tissue malignancy during years 2000-17 and diagnosed after their first diagnosis of schizophrenia were identified. 102 patients were excluded due to diagnosis that was without a histological basis, five patients were excluded because of their age, and 34 were excluded for a previous malignancy, resulting in 375 patients being matched to controls. We selected up to ten controls without cancer (3734 in total) for each case from the base cohort of people with schizophrenia. For the cohort study, data for 55 949 people were included for analysis. Cumulative incidence of haematological malignancies during the mean follow-up of 12·3 years (SD 6·5) was 102 (0·7%) cases among 13 712 patients who had used clozapine (corresponding to event rate of 61 cases per 100 000 person-years), and during mean follow-up of 12·9 years (SD 7·2) was 235 (0·5%) malignancies among 44 171 patients having used other antipsychotic medication than clozapine (corresponding to 41 cases per 100 000 person-years). Of the 375 individuals with haematological malignancies (305 lymphomas, 42 leukaemia, 22 myelomas, 6 unspecified) observed from 2000-17, 208 (55%) were males and 167 (45%) were female. Ethnicity data were not available. Compared with non-use of clozapine (most had used other antipsychotics and a few had used no antipsychotics), clozapine use was associated with increased odds of haematological malignancies in a dose-response manner (adjusted odds ratio 3·35, [95% CI 2·22-5·05] for ≥5000 defined daily dose cumulative exposure, p<0·0001). Exposure to other antipsychotic drugs was not associated with increased odds. A complementary analysis showed that the clozapine-related risk increase was specific for haematological malignancies, because no such finding was observed for other malignancies. Over 17 years of follow-up of the base cohort, 37 deaths occurred due to haematological malignancy among patients exposed to clozapine (26 with ongoing use at time of haematological malignancy diagnosis, and 11 in patients who did not use clozapine at the exact time of their cancer diagnosis), whereas only three deaths occurred due to agranulocytosis.

INTERPRETATION

Unlike other antipsychotics, long-term clozapine use is associated with increased odds of haematological malignancies. Long-term clozapine use has a higher effect on mortality due to lymphoma and leukaemia than due to agranulocytosis. However, acknowledging that the absolute risk is small compared with the previously observed absolute risk reduction in all-cause mortality is important. Our results suggest that patients and caregivers should be informed about warning signs of haematological malignancies, and mental health clinicians should be vigilant for signs and symptoms of haematological malignancy in patients treated with clozapine.

FUNDING

The Finnish Ministry of Social Affairs and Health and Academy of Finland.

Haematologic malignancies associated with clozapine v. all other antipsychotic agents: a pharmacovigilance study in VigiBase®

BACKGROUND

Clozapine is mainly used in patients with treatment-resistant schizophrenia and may lead to potentially severe haematologic adverse events, such as agranulocytosis. Whether clozapine might be associated with haematologic malignancies is unknown. We aimed to assess the association between haematologic malignancies and clozapine using Vigibase®, the WHO pharmacovigilance database.

METHODS

We performed a disproportionality analysis to compute reporting odds-ratio adjusted for age, sex and concurrent reporting of antineoplastic/immunomodulating agents (aROR) for clozapine and structurally related drugs (loxapine, olanzapine and quetiapine) compared with other antipsychotic drugs. Cases were malignant lymphoma and leukaemia reports. Non-cases were all other reports including at least one antipsychotic report.

RESULTS

Of the 140 226 clozapine-associated reports, 493 were malignant lymphoma cases, and 275 were leukaemia cases. Clozapine was significantly associated with malignant lymphoma (aROR 9.14, 95% CI 7.75-10.77) and leukaemia (aROR 3.54, 95% CI 2.97-4.22). Patients suffering from those haematologic malignancies were significantly younger in the clozapine treatment group than patients treated with other medicines (p < 0.001). The median time to onset (available for 212 cases) was 5.1 years (IQR 2.2-9.9) for malignant lymphoma and 2.5 years (IQR 0.6-7.4) for leukaemia. The aROR by quartile of dose of clozapine in patients with haematologic malignancies suggested a dose-dependent association.

CONCLUSIONS

Clozapine was significantly associated with a pharmacovigilance signal of haematologic malignancies. The risk-benefit balance of clozapine should be carefully assessed in patients with risk factors of haematologic malignancies. Clozapine should be used at the lowest effective posology.

Interaction of clozapine and its nitrenium ion with rat D2 dopamine receptors: in vitro binding and computational study

The interaction of diazepine analogues like clozapine or olanzapine with D2 receptor was greatly affected by a mixture of HRP/H(2)O(2) known to induce the formation of nitrenium ion. Unlike diazepine derivatives, the oxidative mixture had low impact on the affinity of oxa- and thiazepine derivatives such as loxapine, clothiapine or JL13 for the D2 receptor. Molecular docking simulations revealed a huge difference between the mode of interaction of clozapine nitrenium ion and the parent drug. Electronic and geometric changes of the tricyclic ring system caused by the oxidation appeared to prevent the compound finding the correct binding mode and could therefore explain the difference observed in binding affinities.

Testing the hypothesis that vitamin C deficiency is a risk factor for clozapine-induced agranulocytosis using guinea pigs and ODS rats

The use of clozapine is limited by a relatively high incidence of drug-induced agranulocytosis. Clozapine is oxidized by bone marrow cells to a reactive nitrenium ion. Although many idiosyncratic drug reactions are immune-mediated, the fact that patients with a history of clozapine-induced agranulocytosis do not immediately develop agranulocytosis on rechallenge suggests that some other factor may be responsible for the idiosyncratic nature of this reaction. The reactive nitrenium ion is very rapidly reduced back to clozapine by vitamin C, and many schizophrenic patients are vitamin C deficient. We set out to test the hypothesis that vitamin C deficiency is a major risk factor for clozapine-induced agranulocytosis using a vitamin C deficient guinea pig model. Although the vitamin C deficient guinea pigs did not develop agranulocytosis, the amount of clozapine covalent binding in these animals was less than we had previously observed in samples from rats and humans. Therefore, we studied ODS rats that also cannot synthesize vitamin C. Vitamin C deficient ODS rats also did not develop agranulocytosis, and furthermore, although covalent binding in the bone marrow was greater than that in the guinea pig, it was not increased in the vitamin C deficient ODS rats relative to ODS rats that had adequate vitamin C in their diet. Therefore, it is very unlikely that vitamin C deficiency is a major risk factor for clozapine-induced agranulocytosis.

Clozapine bioactivation induces dose-dependent, drug-specific toxicity of human bone marrow stromal cells: A potential in vitro system for the study of agranulocytosis

Clozapine, an atypical antipsychotic drug effective in treatment of refractory schizophrenia causes potentially life-threatening agranulocytosis. The drug undergoes bioactivation to a toxic, chemically reactive intermediate with capacity to target stromal cells, central components of the bone marrow microenvironment implicated in neutrophil development. To identify possible mechanisms underpinning disruption of stroma as a site of drug bioactivation, toxicity was induced in vitro. Therefore metabolite generation procedures utilizing HOCl or HRP-H(2)O(2) as primary components involved in clozapine metabolism were adapted for stromal culture and coupled with viability determinations. Drug oxidation by HOCl was less toxic to stromal cells than HRP-H(2)O(2) based methods. More specifically, clozapine bioactivation by HRP-H(2)O(2) caused dose-dependent inhibition of stromal viability at therapeutically relevant concentrations. Differences in susceptibility of HAS303 and LP101 cells to the clozapine nitrenium ion were also evident. Stromal cell death was attributed to clozapine in the presence of a complete metabolising system comprising HRP and H(2)O(2). In the absence of a complete metabolising system clozapine was not cytotoxic. For LP101 cells, drug plus HRP (minus H(2)O(2)) also induced toxicity. Importantly, other antipsychotic drugs including risperidone, olanzapine and haloperidol when bioactivated, were not cytotoxic, indicating system specificity for clozapine. Exogenous GSH, N-acetylcysteine, l-ascorbic acid, catalase, and sodium azide afforded protection to cells whereas S-methylGSH, GSSG, ketoprofen and proadifen did not. Thus functional data derived from the in vitro stromal system defined in these studies may enable further investigation of the mechanisms subserving stromal impairment in clozapine-induced agranulocytosis and direct attention to improved methods for its prevention.