Transplantation in the patient with hepatitis C

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is the most frequent cause of liver disease after renal transplantation. Its clinical course is irrelevant in the short term, except for rare cases of fibrosing cholestatic hepatitis. However, in the long run, HCV infection can lead to major liver complications. Because interferon (IFN) is generally contraindicated in renal transplant patients, the best approach is to treat patients on dialysis. Until more information with pegylated-IFN is available, the use of alpha-IFN monotherapy is recommended. Most of the patients with sustained virological response remain HCV RNA negative after transplantation. HCV-positive renal transplant patients have a higher risk for proteinuria, chronic rejection, infections and post-transplant diabetes (PTDM). Long-term patient- and graft-survival rates are lower in HCV-positive patients. Mortality is higher, mainly as a result of liver disease and infections. HCV can contribute to the development of certain neoplasias such as post-transplant lymphoproliferative disease (PTLD). HCV infection is also an independent risk factor for graft loss. PTDM, transplant glomerulopathy and HCV-related glomerulonephritis can contribute to graft failure. Despite this, transplantation is the best option for end-stage renal disease in HCV-positive patients. Several measures to minimize the consequences of HCV infection have been recommended. Adjustment of immunosuppression and careful follow up in the outpatient clinic for early detection of HCV-related complications are mandatory.

Does cyclosporine have a beneficial effect on the course of chronic hepatitis C infection after renal transplantation?

The aim of our study was to assess the long-term liver histology in renal transplant patients infected with hepatitis C virus (HCV) who were treated with a cyclosporine-based regimen. Among 55 anti-HCV+/RNA+ patients, liver biopsies (LB) were requested every 3 to 4 years after transplantation: two LBs (n=55); three LBs (n=44); four LBs (n=10). Overall, the rate of liver fibrosis progression was 0.07+/-0.03 Metavir U/y. Only three patients out of 55 (5.4%) developed cirrhosis. Liver fibrosis remained stable throughout follow-up in 21 patients; increased in 21 patients; and improved in the remaining 13 patients. The incidence of posttransplant diabetes mellitus was low (9%). We concluded that HCV infection is not harmful to liver histology in more than 50% of renal transplant patients with grafts functioning more than 6 years. Cyclosporine might have beneficial effects on the natural course of HCV infection after renal transplantation.

[The evolution of the hypervariable region-1 of hepatitis C virus may predict liver fibrosis outcome after renal transplantation]

The aim of our study was to assess hepatitis C virus (HCV) evolution and long term liver histology outcome in anti-HCV(+)/RNA(+) renal-transplant (RT) patients. Fifty-five anti-HCV(+)/RNA(+) RT patients underwent every 3-4 years after transplantation liver biopsies (LB) (2 LBs, N = 55; 3 LBs, N = 44; 4 LBs, N = 10). The hypervariable region (HVR)-1 of the HCV genome from all patients was characterized over time. Overall, the rate of liver fibrosis progression was 0.07 +/- 0.03 Metavir units/year. We identified three groups of patients: those in whom liver fibrosis remained stable (group I, N = 21), those with progressing liver fibrosis (group II, N = 21), and those with a regression in liver fibrosis (group III, N = 13). Initial fibrosis stage and high diversification of the HVR-1 of HCV genome between the transplantation and the first liver biopsy were independent factors associated with liver fibrosis regression. In conclusion, in this study, after renal transplantation, HCV infection is not harmful upon liver histology in more than fifty percent of the patients. The diversification of the HVR-1 of the HCV genome might be used to predict liver fibrosis outcome.

Natural history of hepatitis C virus-related liver fibrosis after renal transplantation

The aim of our study was to assess hepatitis C virus (HCV) evolution and long-term liver histology outcome in anti-HCV(+)/RNA(+) renal transplant (RT) patients. A total of 51 anti-HCV(+)/RNA(+) RT patients underwent liver biopsies (LB) every 3-4 years after transplantation (two LBs, n = 51; three LBs, n = 42; four LBs, n = 9). The hypervariable region (HVR)-1 of the HCV genome from all patients was characterized over time. Overall, the rate of liver fibrosis progression was 0.09 +/- 0.03 Metavir units/year. We identified three groups of patients: those in whom liver fibrosis remained stable (n = 21), those with progressing liver fibrosis (n = 21) and those with a regression in liver fibrosis (n = 10). In the last two groups, the progression and the regression of liver fibrosis were gradual during follow-up. Ferritin levels and hepatosiderosis were significantly higher in fibrosers. Initial fibrosis stage and high diversification of the HVR-1 of HCV genome between transplantation and the first liver biopsy were independent factors associated with liver fibrosis regression. In conclusion, in the current study, more than 10 years after renal transplantation, HCV infection was not harmful upon liver histology in more than 50% of patients. The diversification of the HVR-1 might be used to predict liver fibrosis outcome.

Comparison of clinical features and liver histology in hepatitis C-positive dialysis patients and renal transplant recipients

OBJECTIVE

Liver biopsies in hepatitis C virus (HCV)-positive end stage renal disease (ESRD) patients before or after renal transplantation were compared to study the effect of transplant-related immunosuppression.

METHODS

In this prospective study all patients on the active transplant list and all patients with functioning renal transplants at our hospital were tested for HCV antibody (ELISA-2) over a 30-month period. HCV infection was confirmed by polymerase chain reaction in most patients. All HCV-positive patients were asked to undergo liver biopsy without regard to serum transaminase levels. Patients were interviewed, examined, and had detailed chart review. By protocol, liver histology was evaluated according to stage and inflammatory activity in a blinded fashion.

RESULTS

There were 129 HCV-antibody-positive patients, of 795 tested. Sixty-seven agreed to liver biopsy. Of these, 22 patients had never been transplanted and 45 had received transplants. Mean transplant duration before biopsy was 41.2 months (range, 1-204 months). Transplant patients had significantly longer duration of ESRD and estimated duration of HCV infection than patients not transplanted. Dialysis patients had significantly more portal inflammatory activity and lymphoid follicles on biopsy whereas transplant patients had more piecemeal necrosis and steatosis. However, the total histological activity score and stage were similar between groups. Multivariate analysis confirmed the association between transplant and steatosis. But independent variables including transplant duration, HCV infection duration, and ESRD duration were not correlated with histological findings.

CONCLUSION

Renal transplantation may not be associated with an increased risk of progressive liver disease in HCV-positive patients, compared with ESRD patients receiving chronic dialysis. Long-term studies with serial liver biopsies are needed to resolve this issue.

Hepatitis C virus and renal transplantation

During the past 12 months additional evidence has emerged from several studies, indicating that hepatitis C virus infection is the most important liver disease after renal transplantation. A new, severe and rare entity called fibrosing cholestatic hepatitis can lead to early liver failure, although the most important complications appeared in the long-run. Encouraging results with ribavirin have been described. Although glomerular lesions and more severe infections can appear in hepatitis C virus patients, graft and patient survival rates in most series are similar to those in hepatitis-C-negative patients. Survival is also better among hepatitis-C-positive patients after renal transplantation than in hepatitis-C-positive patients on dialysis on the waiting list for transplantation. Finally, the use of kidneys from hepatitis-C-positive donors is suggested for transplant into hepatitis C RNA positive patients matching the hepatitis C genotype.

The impact of renal transplantation on survival in hepatitis C-positive end-stage renal disease patients

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is common in end-stage renal failure patients. It is not known whether the prognosis of HCV-positive patients differs depending on whether they remain on dialysis or receive a kidney transplant. To address this question, we compared the outcomes of HCV-positive renal transplant recipients and HCV-positive patients who were acceptable candidates but had not yet received transplants. We reviewed all patients referred to our institution for renal transplantation evaluation between January 1992 and December 1995. Anti-HCV antibody was detected in 151 of 2,053 (7.4%) patients. HCV-positive patients were more often male (74% v 56%; P < 0.0001), black (68% v 49%; P = 0.001), unemployed (87% v 74%; P = 0.0004), on dialysis (88% v 78%; P = 0.0026), and on dialysis longer (30 +/- 44 months v 13 +/- 23 months; P = 0.0001) than HCV-negative patients. We determined the outcomes of HCV-positive patients who had at least 2 years' follow-up. Thirty-three HCV-positive patients received kidney transplants (group I); 25 HCV-positive patients were acceptable transplant candidates but had not yet received an allograft (group II). Group I and II HCV-positive patients were similar with respect to age, race, duration of dialysis, cause of renal failure, prevalence of heart disease, and results of liver function tests. Survival was significantly decreased in group II versus group I (P = 0.043). Our study showed that HCV-positive renal transplant recipients had a better survival than similar HCV-positive patients awaiting transplantation.