Benign Partial Epilepsy in Infancy: Myth or Reality?

Benign convulsions in newborns and infants: occurrence, clinical course and prognosis

BACKGROUND

During early development severe epilepsies may appear, some with well established occurrence. Benign non-epileptic and epileptic paroxysmal syndromes with excellent prognosis occur in the same period. There are no exact data on their occurrence.

AIM

We have reviewed medical histories of children with benign non-epileptic or benign epileptic events: benign myoclonus of early infancy, benign neonatal sleep myoclonus, benign sleep myoclonus in infancy, benign partial epilepsy in infancy (BPEI) and benign infantile familial convulsions (BIFC) were established. The occurrence, clinical characteristics and prognosis of these syndromes were evaluated.

METHODS

Inclusion criteria were met in 31 children. Research included retrospective analysis of clinical characteristics, laboratory values, neuroimaging and neurophysiological assessments, followed by evaluation of psychosocial development with the use of the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ), fulfilled by parents.

RESULTS

In our group the incidence of benign non-epileptic convulsions was 6.69 per 10 000 live births and the incidence of benign epileptic convulsions was 1.35 per 10 000. Male/female ratio in the group of children with non-epileptic events was 2.1:1. Among non-epileptic group 5 out of 23 children and among epileptic group 3 out of 8 children had minimal, mild or moderate abnormalities at neurological assessment at the time of the first clinical examination. Nonspecific changes in laboratory values were seen in 6 out of 23 in the non-epileptic and in 1 out of 8 children in the epileptic group. Neurophysiological assessments showed subtle changes in 4/23 in the non-epileptic and 6/8 in the epileptic group. Neuroimaging was not optimal in 5/23 with non-epileptic and 3/8 with epileptic events. Analysis of SDQ did not show significant deviations in psyhosocial development. Statistically significant deviation was observed only in relations with peers (p = 0.009).

CONCLUSIONS

Benign neonatal and infantile convulsions are more frequent than severe epilepsies of the same age period. Results show higher proportion of males with benign non-epileptic conditions. No deviations in further development was found. Laboratory values, neuroimaging and neurophysiological assessments were normal or nonspecifically changed.

Transiently reduced water diffusion in the corpus callosum in infants with benign partial epilepsy in infancy

Neuroimaging findings are usually normal in children with benign partial epilepsy in infancy. However, we found a transient reduction of water diffusion in the corpus callosum in two patients with probable benign partial epilepsy in infancy. The patients were admitted to our hospital because of seizure clusters. No delay in the developmental milestones was seen, and no neurological abnormalities were observed during the interictal period. Interictal electroencephalography was normal in both infants. However, the diffusion-weighted images showed abnormal high intensities in both the genu and splenium in one patient and in the splenium only in the other. No diffusion abnormalities were observed in follow-up magnetic resonance imaging. The clustered seizures may be related to the transient callosal lesions seen in our patients.

Ictal EEG in benign partial epilepsy in infancy

The aim of this study is to further clarify ictal electroencephalographic findings of patients with benign partial epilepsy in infancy in order to better understand its neurophysiologic features. The study group consisted of 13 infants with definite benign partial epilepsy in infancy, in whom ictal electroencephalograms were recorded and its benignity was confirmed at 8 years or more. The seizure manifestation was reviewed on the basis of video findings in eight patients in whom simultaneous video-electroencephalography recording was available. In the other five patients, the seizure manifestations were determined according to the observations of physicians, nurses, or technicians. Thirteen seizures from eight patients were complex partial, and six seizures from six patients were secondarily generalized ones. Ictal discharges at the onset of a seizure were focal in all seizures. The site of the origin of seizures was in the temporal area in 10 of 13 complex partial seizures, whereas it was in the parietal or occipital area in all 6 secondarily generalized seizures. Among 13 complex partial seizures, paroxysmal discharges remained focal throughout the seizures in 6 seizures, whereas they spread to one hemisphere in the other 7 seizures. Motion arrest or decreased responsiveness was uniformly observed. Lateral eye deviation was commonly recognized in complex partial seizures, whereas head rotation was observed only in seizures in which hemispheric propagation of ictal discharges was observed. Ictal electroencephalographic findings of patients with benign partial epilepsy in infancy were relatively uniform, suggesting the homogeneity of patients with benign partial epilepsy in infancy.