Home care: past and present, problems and potential

Primary care clinic visits in formerly evacuated areas due to radiation disaster following the Great East Japan Earthquake: A retrospective descriptive study

Radiation disasters pose distinctive medical challenges, requiring diverse care approaches. Beyond radiation exposure assessment, addressing health impacts due to lifestyle changes, especially among vulnerable populations, is vital. Evacuation orders issued in radiation-affected areas introduce unique healthcare dynamics, with their duration significantly influencing the recovery process. Understanding evolving patient demographics and medical needs after lifting evacuation orders is crucial for post-disaster care planning. Minamisoma Municipal Odaka Hospital, located 13 to 20 km from Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear power plant in a post-evacuation zone, was greatly affected by the Great East Japan Earthquake and subsequent radiation disaster. Data were retrospectively collected from patient records, including age, gender, visit date, diagnoses, and addresses. Patient records from April 2014 to March 2020 were analyzed, comparing data before and after the July 2016 evacuation order lift. Data was categorized into pre and post-evacuation order lifting periods, using International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Edition codes, to identify the top diseases. Statistical analyses, including χ-square tests, assessed changes in disease distributions. Population data for Odaka Ward and Minamisoma City fluctuated after lifting evacuation orders. As of March 11, 2011, Odaka Ward had 12,842 residents (27.8% aged 65+ years), dropping to 8406 registered residents and 2732 actual residents by April 30, 2018 (49.7%). Minamisoma City also saw declines, with registered residents decreasing from 71,561 (25.9%) to 61,049 (34.1%). The study analyzed 11,100 patients, mostly older patients (75.1%), between 2014 and 2020. Post-lifting, monthly patient numbers surged from an average of 55.2 to 213.5, with female patients increasing from 33.8% to 51.7%. Disease patterns shifted, with musculoskeletal cases declining from 23.8% to 13.0%, psychiatric disorders increasing from 9.3% to 15.4%, and trauma-related cases decreasing from 14.3% to 3.9%. Hypertension (57.1%) and dyslipidemia (29.2%) prevailed post-lifting. Urgent cases decreased from 1.3% to 0.1%. This study emphasizes the importance of primary care in post-evacuation zones, addressing diverse medical needs, including trauma, noncommunicable diseases, and psychiatric disorders. Changing patient demographics require adaptable healthcare strategies and resource allocation to meet growing demands. Establishing a comprehensive health maintenance system tailored to these areas' unique challenges is crucial for future disaster recovery efforts.

Barriers to Making House Calls by Primary Care Physicians and Solutions: A Literature Review

BACKGROUND

The number of house calls made by physicians has been declining over the years, while the number of people requiring house calls, especially the elderly, is growing.

AIM

To consolidate the literature regarding the barriers faced by primary care physicians in making house calls.

DESIGN OF THE STUDY

Literature review.

METHOD

Studies were sourced from PubMed and Embase.

RESULTS

7 studies were selected to be in the literature review. Barriers to making house calls by primary care physicians include inadequate remuneration, lack of time and training, unconducive home environment, concerns with professional liability and safety, and perceived low value-added in the patient's quality of care.

CONCLUSION

While primary care physicians do recognize the value of house calls in patient care, the perceived limited standard of care that can be achieved in the home setting, busy clinic practice (large patient loads), coupled with inadequate remuneration make house calls unrealistic for many doctors. These barriers must be addressed to ensure accessibility to primary health care services for the immobile, frail, and sick is not being compromised. One of the solutions may be to expose medical students and residents to house calls early through mentorship.

Caretaking as articulation work: the effects of taking up responsibility for a child with asthma on labor force participation

A well-established quantitative literature has documented the financial toll for women's caretaking. Still, we do not know much about the process by which women end up taking on an extensive caretaking role and what they do on a daily basis. Based on in-depth interviews with a convenience sample of fifty caretakers of school aged children with asthma and nine health professionals in the USA, this study examines how health professionals socialize mothers into an intensive caretaking role for their children with asthma, how mothers negotiated and perform that role, and the impact of care work on their labor force participation. Care providers assign broad caretaking tasks that require further articulation work to get the job done. Although mothers care for their children in varied ways, caring for a child with a chronic disease remains a time-consuming activity. Mothers pay a price for the indeterminate nature of articulation work by scaling back their involvement in the paid labor force.

Atendimento domiciliar ao idoso: problema ou solução?

O atendimento domiciliar ao idoso tem se tornado um importante instrumento de assistência nos últimos anos, tanto nos países desenvolvidos quanto nos países em desenvolvimento. Vários aspectos éticos, sociais e operacionais têm sido negligenciados e a literatura nacional é escassa em relação a esta temática. A partir de revisão bibliográfica em atendimento domiciliar, este artigo enfoca, do ponto de vista bioético, os potenciais problemas advindos com a implantação dessa crescente e importante modalidade de atendimento. Conclui ser necessário um maior direcionamento ético na implantação do atendimento domiciliar, com políticas de proteção ao paciente, à família e ao cuidador, visando a aperfeiçoar a qualidade dos programas oferecidos.

Home Hospitalization Service for Acute Uncomplicated First Ischemic Stroke in Elderly Patients: A Randomized Trial

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate whether home treatment of elderly patients with acute uncomplicated first ischemic stroke is associated with different mortality rates and clinical outcomes from those of patients treated on a general medical ward (GMW).

DESIGN

Randomized, controlled, single-blind trial.

SETTING

S. Giovanni Battista Hospital of Turin.

PARTICIPANTS

One hundred twenty elderly patients admitted to the emergency department of the hospital with first acute ischemic stroke were randomized to home treatment from a geriatric home hospitalization service (GHHS) or to GMW treatment.

MEASUREMENT

Main outcome was cumulative survival at 6 months in the two groups. Residual functional impairment, neurological deficit, depression, morbidity, and admission to rehabilitation and long-term care facilities were considered as secondary outcomes in survivors.

RESULTS

One hundred twenty patients (mean age 82; 54 men and 66 women) were enrolled (60 in each study arm). The cumulative proportion of cases surviving at 6 months was 0.65 in the GHHS group and 0.60 in GMW group (log-rank test P=.53). Functional and neurological parameters were significantly improved in both GHHS and GMW patients, without significant differences between the two groups. Depression score was significantly better in home-treated patients (P<.001), who were more likely to remain at home at 6 months than hospital-treated patients and had a lower rate of select medical complications.

CONCLUSION

Home-treated elderly patients with ischemic stroke have better depressive scores and lower rates of admission to nursing homes. These results should prompt further studies to evaluate home hospitalization for elderly stroke patients.

Needs for physician housecalls--views from health and social service providers

This article examines how the role of a physician housecall program is perceived by health and social service providers that refer their clients to the program in a Midwest suburban community. Focus groups and semi-structured interviews with those providers revealed various housecall service needs of their homebound clients. In particular, the fact that home health agencies were the largest referral source suggests that the housecall program fills the needs that are not met by the current mainstream home health services. Our findings reinforce the argument for the increased physician involvement in home care and physician housecalls.

The future history of home care and physician house calls in the United States

Over the last 20 years, home care has experienced significant change. The home care industry developed into big business and a number of innovative models of home care were developed and evaluated. Although physicians perform many fewer house calls than a half-century ago, there has been a recent revival in house-call training, education, and practice. In addition, telemedicine and other technologies hold great promise for the future of home care. However, the future history of home care will depend mostly on the ability of various stakeholders in the health care system to recognize the value of home care and develop and implement the appropriate incentives to encourage its proper place in the U.S. health care system.

Trend data on medical encounters: tracking a moving target

The National Health Care Survey (NHCS), conducted by the National Center for Health Statistics, consists of separate data collection activities that can be used to track the number and content of health care encounters in the United States. Tracking even something as simple as the number of encounters, however, is complicated by the fact that the content of these encounters changes over time. Results from the NHCS indicate that the U.S. population has been receiving more drugs, more cardiac procedures, more ambulatory surgery, more therapies in nursing homes, and more home health care over time. Policymakers and researchers who examine health care trends should be wary about judging whether the number of length of encounters is positive or negative without also examining the content of these encounters.

The doctor-patient relationship in the home

The rapid growth of the geriatric sector of the population has, in part, led to the explosion of the home care industry and the rebirth of the house call. Understanding the population being served is always the first step in providing excellent care. Older people who are frail and homebound have physical, social, and emotional needs that require careful assessment and team intervention in the home. To provide care, the practitioner must establish trust with the patient and the caregivers. Often, the agenda of the patient, family, and physician differ. A multidisciplinary team can offer help to meet the needs of each party. Allowing the patient to be an active participant in the care plan is paramount. Changes should be made slowly with careful explanation and education at each step, and the right of an individual to refuse treatment should be respected. Support for the caregiver and accessibility for consultation and advice can make a difference in the quality of care an older individual receives.

House calls to the elderly--a vanishing practice among physicians

BACKGROUND

Despite the growth in other home health care services, the number of house calls by physicians has declined dramatically during this century. We determined the frequency of house calls made by physicians to elderly U.S. patients in 1993 and analyzed the characteristics of the physicians and patients involved.

METHODS

We analyzed a 5 percent random sample of the 1993 Medicare Part B claims data for beneficiaries over the age of 65 who were not enrolled in health maintenance organizations (HMOs). With supplemental information from the Area Resource File and the American Medical Association's Physician Masterfile, we determined how many house calls were made, their cost, and a number of specific characteristics of the physicians and the patients.

RESULTS

In our 1993 sample, 36,350 house calls were made to 11,917 of the 1,357,262 patients. When extrapolated to all Medicare beneficiaries over age 65 and not enrolled in HMOs, these figures correspond to 727,000 house calls to 238,340 patients nationwide. We estimated the cost of these house calls to be $63 million. The patients who received house calls from physicians were older than those who did not, were more likely to die within the calendar year, had higher rates of hospitalization, and were more likely to receive care from other home health providers, hospice programs, and skilled-nursing facilities. Patients residing in rural areas and those in areas with high physician-to-population ratios had an increased likelihood of receiving a house call. The physicians who made house calls were more likely than others to be generalists, osteopaths, older, male, board-certified, practicing in the Northeast, and in solo practice.

CONCLUSIONS

A very small percentage (0.88 percent) of elderly Medicare patients, mainly those who are very sick and near the end of life, receive house calls from physicians.

The last 3 months of life of cancer patients: medical aspects and role of home-care services in southern Switzerland

The clinical data on terminal cancer patients who have died since the establishment of a program of collaboration between community services and the cancer center of Canton of Ticino, southern Switzerland, were retrospectively analyzed to describe the characteristics of patients seen and the effect on them of a home-care program coordinated by the cancer center. The home-care program is based on five geographically grouped community-based domiciliary services, with the addition of one nurse responsible for coordination and one physician from the oncology center. Selection criteria for participation in the home-care program are defined. The main outcome measures were: number of hospitalizations and median hospital stay during the last 3 months of life; reasons for and median length of last hospitalization; place of death of patients who had home care and those who did not. In the group of 993 patients analyzed, the median contact time with the cancer center was 9.5 months (10th percentile: 1 month, 90th percentile: 71 months); the most frequent neoplasm was lung cancer (22%) with the briefest contact time (7.5 months; 10th percentile: 1 month; 90th percentile: 21 months); 13.5% of patients were never hospitalized; half of the patients had a total hospital stay of 24 days or longer and 23% died at home. The sociodemographic and medical characteristics of home-care users were similar to those of the home-care non-users and to those of the overall group. In the group of home-care users (32% of the total) 22% were never hospitalized, half of the patients had a total hospital stay of 17 days or longer, and 43.5% of them died at home. These values were significantly different (P > 0.001) from those reported in the group of home-care non-users. Palliative care, provided at home through community-based domiciliary services, is associated with less frequent and shorter hospitalizations in the last 3 months of life. Medical oncology and palliative treatments should be mutually complementary to improve patients care. Cancer centers should be involved in the planning and coordination of supportive-care domiciliary services.

The home care practice and attitudes of Minnesota family physicians

OBJECTIVE

Assess home care practice and attitudes of Minnesota family physicians (FPs).

DESIGN

Mailed survey.

SETTING

State of Minnesota.

PARTICIPANTS

Members of the Minnesota Academy of Family Physicians, 80% of the FPs practicing in the state.

INTERVENTION

A 55-item mailed, self-complete questionnaire regarding general practice and personal physician characteristics (18 questions), specific questions regarding geriatric and home care practice and related attitudes (37 questions); up to four reminder or follow-up surveys were sent.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Descriptive summary of FP home care practice and attitudes.

RESULTS

Eighty percent of surveys were completed, 76% of responding physicians made at least one home visit in the previous year, and 92% of home visits were to geriatric patients. Discriminant function analysis identified six significant (P less than 0.001) variables that explained 52% of the variance (r2 = 0.52, Wilks Lambda = 0.48) in home visiting behavior between frequent home visiting FPs (greater than 24 visits/year) and non-visiting FPs. FPs most likely to do home visiting were older and tended to have small group or solo practices in rural settings.

CONCLUSION

The survey documented continued decline (from previously published surveys) of physician home visiting behavior and widespread dissatisfaction with reimbursement. However, attitudes regarding home care provided by other professionals were highly positive.

Factors associated with the frequency of house calls by primary care physicians

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate factors associated with the frequency of house calls by primary care physicians.

DESIGN

A cross-sectional design with a self-administered mailed survey. SITTING/PARTICIPANTS: 751 primary care physicians who care for Medicaid patients in Virginia.

RESULTS

Among 389 physician respondents (52%), regular house callers (n = 216) were compared with occasional house callers (n = 162). Among physician characteristics, specialty and practice duration were associated with house call frequency. Regular house callers also more often cited chronic illness (67% vs. 20%, p less than 0.01) and terminal illness (67% vs. 40%, p less than 0.01) as indications for house calls, compared with occasional house callers. Use of visiting nurses to substitute for physician house calls was less often considered appropriate by frequent house callers (7% vs. 24%, p less than 0.01), and regular house callers were less likely to report being "too busy" to make house calls (71% vs. 29%, p less than 0.01). Multivariate analysis confirmed the association of these attitudes with house call frequency.

CONCLUSION

These data suggest that specific attitudes among primary care physicians are associated with house call frequency.