Nuclear death in living Tetrahymena: the case of the haploid nuclei

Colchicine-induced degeneration of the micronucleus during conjugation in Tetrahymena

One of the most dramatic examples of nuclear morphogenesis occurs during conjugation in Tetrahymena when the micronucleus elongates to a size longer than the cell itself. After contraction to a spherical shape, the nucleus moves directly to chromosome separation in the first meiotic division. Here we investigate the consequences of interrupting the elongation process. Colchicine, a microtubule inhibitor, caused retraction of elongated structures. With time, cells began to lose their micronuclei, and by five hours more than half of the paired cells had at least one cell missing a micronucleus. After reversing the colchicine block, existing micronuclei did not undergo elongation again, nor did meiosis occur. These observations indicate that micronuclear elongation is critical to subsequent meiotic division. Further, nuclear elimination occurs, which could be due to meiotic failure or possibly a problem downstream from meiosis. An analysis of the process of colchicine-induced micronuclear degeneration indicated that it was regulated by a caspase-dependent mechanism, characteristic of apoptosis, and then resorbed by a lysosome-dependent autophagic mechanism. Amicronucleate cells failed to grow when returned to nutrient medium, likely because of a lesion in the post-conjugation reconstruction of a functioning oral apparatus. The ease by which a large number of nuclei are induced to "self-destruct" may make this system useful in investigating the link between colchicine treatment and nuclear death in Tetrahymena, and in investigating how nuclear death could be regulated in living cells more generally. Finally, we note that this phenomenon might relate to the evolution of amicronucleate species of Tetrahymena.

Morphological apoptotic characteristics of the post-meiotic micronuclei in Paramecium caudatum

In a previous study, the apoptotic degeneration of meiotic products outside the paroral region of Paramecium caudatum was indirectly demonstrated by means of "apofluor" staining. In this experiment, conjugating pairs and exconjugants of P. caudatum were stained with either "apofluor" or carbol fuchsin or both to find some direct evidence to demonstrate the apoptotic characteristics of this process. As a result, asynchronous meiotic nuclear degeneration was observed. Furthermore, a number of additional meiotic nuclei were found. Disintegrating/dividing meiotic nuclei outside the paroral region were observed, which might be the origin of these additional meiotic nuclei. Condensed chromatin and disintegrated chromatin attached to the nuclear membrane were also observed in degenerating nuclei, which are the typical morphological characteristics of apoptosis. Comparison of the cells stained by the above two methods indicated that "apofluor"-stained meiotic nuclei could not be detected by carbol fuchsin in some cells, which suggests a time lag between meiotic nuclear DNA degradation and their eventual disappearance. In this study, some direct evidence was found to show that the meiotic nuclear degeneration in P. caudatum is of apoptotic nature, which further confirmed our previous study (Yang et al. 2007) and indicated that morphological apoptotic characteristics discovered in multicellular organisms do exist in unicellular eukaryotic ciliate protozoa.

Selection of the germinal micronucleus in Paramecium caudatum: nuclear division and nuclear death

Each cell of Paramecium caudatum has a germinal micronucleus. When a bi-micronucleate state was created artificially by micronuclear transplantation, both micronuclei divided for at least 2 cell cycles after nuclear transplantation. However, this bi-micronucleate state was unstable and reduced to a uni-micronucleate state after several fissions. Although the number of micronuclei was usually 1 during the vegetative phase, 4 presumptive micronuclei differentiated after conjugation. At the first post-conjugational fission, only 1 of the 4 micronuclei divided, indicating that there is tight regulation of micronuclear number in exconjugants. Micronuclei that did not divide at the first post-conjugational fission may persist through the first and second post-conjugational cell cycles. The decision to divide appears to be separate from the decision to degenerate, as evidenced by division of a remaining micronucleus upon removal of the dividing micronucleus at the first division. Degeneration of micronuclei in exconjugants differs from that of haploid nuclei after meiosis. Nutritional state affected micronuclear degeneration. Under well-fed conditions, the micronuclei destined to degenerate lost the ability to divide earlier than after starvation treatment, suggesting that micronuclear degeneration is an "apoptotic" phenomenon, probably under the control of the new macronuclei (macronuclear anlagen).

Unusual distribution of mitochondrial large subunit rRNA in the cytosol during conjugation in Tetrahymena thermophila

The distribution of mitochondria during conjugation of the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena thermophila was surveyed using a mitochondrial stain and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). When the mitochondria-specific stain, Mito-Tracker, was used, the majority of mitochondria were detected in the cortex; their distribution was not changed during conjugation. On the other hand, FISH using mitochondrial large subunit (LSU) rRNA as a probe showed an unusual distribution of signals during conjugation. Unexpectedly, the signals were detected throughout the cytoplasm of conjugating cells. These signals were not observed in pre-mating cells and in exconjugants. The cytosolic localization of mitochondrial rRNA was supported by northern blot analysis using post-mitochondrial RNA fraction at the later stages of conjugation. These observations suggest selective mitochondrial breakdown or transport of LSU rRNA into cytosol. The biological significance of the conjugation-specific appearance of the cytosolic mitochondrial rRNA is discussed.

Caspase-like Activity is Required for Programmed Nuclear Elimination during Conjugation in Tetrahymena

During conjugation in the binucleate ciliate, Tetrahymena thermophila, the old macronucleus is eliminated as new macronuclei and micronuclei are ontogenetically derived from the zygote nucleus. The mechanism of programmed nuclear elimination in ciliates may be related to the mechanism of apoptosis in higher organisms since its chromatin undergoes major condensation, its DNA is digested into nucleosome-sized fragments, and it stains positively for TUNEL. The present study explores whether caspases are involved in programmed macronuclear degradation in Tetrahymena. We show here that caspase-like activity is detectable using two specific colorimetric substrates, and that the activity is reduced with specific caspase inhibitors. In addition, using the fluorigenic substrate PhiPhiLux, active caspase-like activity is detected in living cells, localized to cytoplasmic vesicles; activity is not detected in pre- or post-condensed macronuclei. Finally, three different inhibitors of caspase activity cause a block to macronuclear chromatin condensation and elimination. Therefore, a caspase-like enzyme activity is necessary for regulating macronuclear elimination in Tetrahymena. These data support the possibility that macronuclear elimination is related, evolutionarily, to regulated cell death in multicellular organisms.

Development in electrofused conjugants of tetrahymena thermophila

Electric shock can create parabiotic fusions of living Tetrahymena cells. In this study, cells were mated and successful pairs were electrofused with either vegetatively growing cells or other mating pairs. In particular, we electrofused pairs from normal [diploid x diploid] matings with vegetatively dividing cells in G- or M-phase of the cell cycle. We also fused [diploid x diploid] conjugants with mating pairs involving an aneuploid partner [diploid x "star"], which typically undergo an abortive conjugal pathway termed genomic exclusion. Using such parabiotic fusions we identified and characterized two developmentally critical landmarks: 1) the "abort" signal, which is initiated in pairs with nuclear defects (this first becomes evident soon after the completion of Meiosis I or the beginning of Meiosis II); and 2) the "terminal commitment point", a developmental stage in normal [diploid x diploid] pairs after which conjugation no longer responds to a parabiotically transmitted abort signal (this correlates with the onset of the second postzygotic nuclear division). Finally we demonstrate that a conjugal-arrest-activity varies with the vegetative cell cycle, reaching its highest level of activity during M-phase and dropping just after cytokinesis.

Lysosomal enzymes in the macronucleus of Tetrahymena during its apoptosis-like degradation

A key characteristic of apoptosis is its regulated nuclear degradation. Apoptosis-like nuclear degradation also occurs in the ciliated unicellular organism, Tetrahymena thermophila. Chromatin of the macronucleus undergoes massive condensation, a process that can be blocked by caspase inhibitors. The nucleus becomes TUNEL-positive, and its DNA is cleaved into nucleosome-sized fragments. In a matter of hours the macronucleus is completely degraded, and disappears. The condensed nucleus sequesters acridine orange, which means that it might become an acidic compartment. We therefore asked whether lysosomal bodies fuse with the condensed macronucleus to form an autophagosome. We monitored acid phosphatase (AP) activity, which is associated with lysosomal bodies but is not found in normal nuclei. We find that after the macronucleus condenses AP activity is localized in cap-like structures at its cortex. Later, after the degrading macronucleus loses much of its DNA, acid phosphatase deposits appear deeper within the nucleus. We conclude that although macronuclear elimination is initiated by an apoptosis-like mechanism, its final degradation may be achieved through autophagosomy.