FLOW-CYTOMETRIC ANALYSES OF NUCLEAR DNA CONTENT IN FOUR FAMILIES OF NEOTROPICAL BATS

The Genome of Blue-Capped Cordon-Bleu Uncovers Hidden Diversity of LTR Retrotransposons in Zebra Finch

Avian genomes have perplexed researchers by being conservative in both size and rearrangements, while simultaneously holding the blueprints for a massive species radiation during the last 65 million years (My). Transposable elements (TEs) in bird genomes are relatively scarce but have been implicated as important hotspots for chromosomal inversions. In zebra finch (Taeniopygia guttata), long terminal repeat (LTR) retrotransposons have proliferated and are positively associated with chromosomal breakpoint regions. Here, we present the genome, karyotype and transposons of blue-capped cordon-bleu (Uraeginthus cyanocephalus), an African songbird that diverged from zebra finch at the root of estrildid finches 10 million years ago (Mya). This constitutes the third linked-read sequenced genome assembly and fourth in-depth curated TE library of any bird. Exploration of TE diversity on this brief evolutionary timescale constitutes a considerable increase in resolution for avian TE biology and allowed us to uncover 4.5 Mb more LTR retrotransposons in the zebra finch genome. In blue-capped cordon-bleu, we likewise observed a recent LTR accumulation indicating that this is a shared feature of Estrildidae. Curiously, we discovered 25 new endogenous retrovirus-like LTR retrotransposon families of which at least 21 are present in zebra finch but were previously undiscovered. This highlights the importance of studying close relatives of model organisms.

Genome Biology and the Evolution of Cell-Size Diversity

Cell size is highly variable among different species across the Tree of Life. For decades, biologists have generated hypotheses to explain this variation, in many cases, drawing on the correlations that exist among cell size, genome size, nucleus size, and various physiological and developmental parameters. In recent years, our understanding of the molecular processes that generate variation in genome size over evolutionary time, as well as the processes that maintain homeostasis in cell size over ontogenetic time, has increased dramatically. The goal of this article is to highlight how information from these fields can be integrated to generate new hypotheses to explain cell-size diversity.

The bat genome: GC-biased small chromosomes associated with reduction in genome size

Bats are distinct from other mammals in their small genome size as well as their high metabolic rate, possibly related to flight ability. Although the genome sequence has been published in two species, the data lack cytogenetic information. In this study, the size and GC content of each chromosome are measured from the flow karyotype of the mouse-eared bat, Myotis myotis (MMY). The smaller chromosomes are GC-rich compared to the larger chromosomes, and the relative proportions of homologous segments between MMY and human differ among the MMY chromosomes. The MMY genome size calculated from the sum of the chromosome sizes is 2.25 Gb, and the total GC content is 42.3%, compared to human and dog with 41.0 and 41.2%, respectively. The GC-rich small MMY genome is characterised by GC-biased smaller chromosomes resulting from preferential loss of AT-rich sequences. Although the association between GC-rich small chromosomes and small genome size has been reported only in birds so far, we show in this paper, for the first time, that the same phenomenon is observed in at least one group of mammals, implying that this may be a mechanism common to genome evolution in general.

LTR retrotransposons contribute to genomic gigantism in plethodontid salamanders

Among vertebrates, most of the largest genomes are found within the salamanders, a clade of amphibians that includes 613 species. Salamander genome sizes range from ~14 to ~120 Gb. Because genome size is correlated with nucleus and cell sizes, as well as other traits, morphological evolution in salamanders has been profoundly affected by genomic gigantism. However, the molecular mechanisms driving genomic expansion in this clade remain largely unknown. Here, we present the first comparative analysis of transposable element (TE) content in salamanders. Using high-throughput sequencing, we generated genomic shotgun data for six species from the Plethodontidae, the largest family of salamanders. We then developed a pipeline to mine TE sequences from shotgun data in taxa with limited genomic resources, such as salamanders. Our summaries of overall TE abundance and diversity for each species demonstrate that TEs make up a substantial portion of salamander genomes, and that all of the major known types of TEs are represented in salamanders. The most abundant TE superfamilies found in the genomes of our six focal species are similar, despite substantial variation in genome size. However, our results demonstrate a major difference between salamanders and other vertebrates: salamander genomes contain much larger amounts of long terminal repeat (LTR) retrotransposons, primarily Ty3/gypsy elements. Thus, the extreme increase in genome size that occurred in salamanders was likely accompanied by a shift in TE landscape. These results suggest that increased proliferation of LTR retrotransposons was a major molecular mechanism contributing to genomic expansion in salamanders.

The genome sizes of megabats (Chiroptera: Pteropodidae) are remarkably constrained

It has long been recognized that bats and birds contain less DNA in their genomes than their non-flying relatives. It has been suggested that this relates to the high metabolic demands of powered flight, a notion that is supported by the fact that pterosaurs also appear to have exhibited small genomes. Given the long-standing interest in this question, it is surprising that almost no data have been presented regarding genome size diversity among megabats (family Pteropodidae). The present study provides genome size estimates for 43 species of megabats in an effort to fill this gap and to test the hypothesis that all bats, and not just microbats, possess small genomes. Intriguingly, megabats appear to be even more constrained in terms of genome size than the members of other bat families.

Genome size and wing parameters in passerine birds

Despite their status as the most speciose group of terrestrial vertebrates, birds exhibit the smallest and least variable genome sizes among tetrapods. It has been suggested that this is because powered flight imposes metabolic constraints on cell size, and thus on genome size. This notion has been supported by analyses of genome size and cell size versus resting metabolic rate and other parameters across birds, but most previous studies suffer from one or more limitations that have left the question open. The present study provides new insights into this issue through an examination of newly measured genome sizes, nucleus and cell sizes, body masses and wing parameters for 74 species of birds in the order Passeriformes. A positive relationship was found between genome size and nucleus/cell size, as well as between genome size and wing loading index, which is interpreted as an indicator of adaptations for efficient flight. This represents the single largest dataset presented for birds to date, and is the first to analyse a distinctly flight-related parameter along with genome size using phylogenetic comparative analyses. The results lend additional support to the hypothesis that the small genomes of birds are indeed related in some manner to flight, though the mechanistic and historical bases for this association remain an interesting area of investigation.

Characterization of an EcoRI family of satellite DNA from two species of the genus Eptesicus (Vespertilionidae; Chiroptera)

We have cloned and sequenced a 321 bp band of repetitive DNA from Eptesicus fuscus and E. serotinus observed after gel electrophoresis of EcoRI digested genomic DNA in both species. Southern blot analysis of genomic DNA (from both species) digested with the same enzyme showed the existence of a ladder pattern indicating that the repetitive DNA is arrayed in tandem. The repetitive sequences have a monomer unit of 321 bp which is composed of two subunits of 160 bp, suggested by the existence of a 160 bp band in the ladder of E. fuscus and by the presence of some direct repeats found in the analysis of the consensus sequence. Analysis of the methylation status demonstrated that cytosines in CCGG sequences in this satellite DNA are methylated in E. fuscus but not in the E. serotinus. Alignment of the sequenced clones showed that several nucleotide positions are diagnostic species-specific and consequently the phylogenetic analysis grouped the monomer units from both species in two clearly separated groups.

Allometry of base pair specific-DNA contents in Tetrapoda

Cells of 82 species of Tetrapoda were stained with DNA base pair specific fluorochromes (Hoechst 33258 and olivomycin) and studied by means of flow cytometry. The genome size range was about 50-fold. The class Amphibia, which had the widest range of genome size variation (about 20-fold), exhibited linear allometry in their base pair specific DNA contents (bps-C-values), i.e., the more DNA they had, the lower the quotient of AT-pairs (C(AT) = 0.13 + 0.87 x C(GC), r = +0.998). Data for Mammalia, pooled with amphibians, fell on the same allometric line at the lower extreme end of genome size range, supporting the correlation. Reptilia-Aves (or Reptilia alone) pooled with Amphibia did not conform with this relationship. Reptilia-Aves form their own line (zone); pooled with Mammalia, this group showed no regularities in the relationship of their bps-DNA contents. Besides revealing the allometry of bps-C-values, these data indicate an integral genomic feature, localization within the same regression line, which Mammalia share with Amphibia but not with recent Reptilia (and Aves). These data also suggest that the relationship between DNA base frequencies and genome size is nonlinear (reciprocal); to obtain a linear relationship, the bps-C-values should be used. It is also concluded that caution is needed when DNA-content is measured for comparative purposes using a fluorescent dye which is known to be base-pair specific. DNA content values obtained with fluorochromes with different specificity may differ as much as by a factor of 1.8, the average discrepancy level is about 14%.

Pericentric satellite DNA sequences in Pipistrellus pipistrellus (Vespertilionidae; Chiroptera)

This paper reports the molecular and cytogenetic characterization of a HindIII family of satellite DNA in the bat species Pipistrellus pipistrellus. This satellite is organized in tandem repeats of 418 bp monomer units, and represents approximately 3% of the whole genome. The consensus sequence from five cloned monomer units has an A-T content of 62.20%. We have found differences in the ladder pattern of bands between two populations of the same species. These differences are probably because of the absence of the target sites for the HindIII enzyme in most monomer units of one population, but not in the other. Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) localized the satellite DNA in the pericentromeric regions of all autosomes and the X chromosome, but it was absent from the Y chromosome. Digestion of genomic DNAs with HpaII and its isoschizomer MspI demonstrated that these repetitive DNA sequences are not methylated. Other bat species were tested for the presence of this repetitive DNA. It was absent in five Vespertilionidae and one Rhinolophidae species, indicating that it could be a species/genus specific, repetitive DNA family.

Gradual and quantum genome size shifts in the hystricognath rodents

We assessed genome size variation by flow cytometry within and among 31 species of nine families of African and South American hystricognath rodents. Interspecific variation was extensive and genome size was relatively high among the South American radiation whereas only moderate variation and smaller estimates of genome size were observed in the African counterparts. The largest genome size, indicating tetraploidy was recorded in the South American octodontid, Tympanoctomys barrerae (16.8 pg DNA). This quantum shift in DNA content represents a novel mechanism of genome evolution in mammals. As expected in polyploid organisms, varying nucleotypic effects were observed in the dimensions of the sperm cells and lymphocytes of T. barrerae. The role of control mechanisms that influence cell dimensions in polyploid organisms is discussed.

Highly repeated DNA sequences in three species of the genus Pteropus (Megachiroptera, Mammalia)

Bat genomes are characterised by an A-T richness and by a small C-value compared with other mammalian groups. It has been suggested that the small C-value is mainly due to the lack of repetitive DNA sequences. However, little information about repetitive DNA sequences in this mammalian group is available at the molecular level. Here we describe a PstI family of repetitive DNA sequences present in three species of the genus Pteropus. These repetitive sequences are 54.97% G-C rich, organised in tandem and with a unit length of 744 bp. Methylation analysis indicates that some of the CCGG target sites present in these repetitive DNA sequences have methylated cytosines and that there are small differences in the methylation pattern between species. Several features of this family of repetitive sequences suggest that they evolved by concerted evolution.

Nucleotypic effects without nuclei: genome size and erythrocyte size in mammals

Previously reported haploid genome sizes (C-values) and erythrocyte sizes (measured as mean dry diameters) were compared for 67 species of mammals representing 31 families and 16 orders. Measurements on erythrocytes of four species of bats were also included in the study. Erythrocyte size was significantly positively correlated with genome size at each of the specific, generic, familial, and ordinal levels, with the relationship becoming much stronger following the exclusion of the order Artiodactyla, a group unique among mammals in terms of red blood cell morphology. Physiologically, these results are relevant in light of the known relationship between C-value and mass-corrected metabolic rate in homeotherms. In evolutionary terms, they provide insights into the constraints on genome expansion among mammals and are therefore of interest in attempts to solve the long-standing C-value enigma (also known as the C-value paradox).

ZOO-FISH analysis in a species of the order Chiroptera: Glossophaga soricina (Phyllostomidae)

Glossophaga soricina is a flower-visiting bat which lives in the neotropics. The diploid chromosome number is 2n = 32 with a fundamental number of autosomal arms, FN, of 60. G. soricina belongs to the Microchiroptera which have a lower diploid DNA content and a higher AT composition in their DNA compared with other mammals. By ZOO-FISH analysis with human chromosome-specific DNA probes, the human autosomes were found conserved in 41 segments. This is an arrangement similar to other mammals which have been analyzed. Several chromosomal associations already known from ZOO-FISH studies in other species were also present in G. soricina.

Base-compositional biases and the bat problem. I. DNA-hybridization melting curves based on AT- and GC-enriched tracers

We explored the interordinal relationships of mammals using DNA-DNA hybridization, with particular reference to the much-debated problem of whether the megabats and microbats are more closely related to each other than the megabats are to primates. To try to improve resolution when taxa are distantly related and the melting points of hybrids are low and difficult to distinguish, we increased the GC content of DNA by a fractionation method that used the same melting-point apparatus used in the hybridization studies. When we used GC-rich DNA as the tracer to make hybrids, the melting point of the self-hybrid shifted to a higher temperature as expected, but the behaviour of heterologous hybrids varied with the taxa being compared. When the melting point of the heterologous hybrid also shifted to a higher temperature so that the two compared taxa maintained the same or proportional distance, we called this 'following behaviour', because the heterologous hybrid made with GC-rich tracer 'followed' the GC-rich self-hybrid to higher temperatures. We also commonly saw anomalous behaviour, where the melting point of the heterologous hybrid shifted to a lower temperature when compared with an AT-rich hybrid. In these anomalous cases, the distance measured between the taxa increased markedly as a result of GC-enrichment, indicating that an underestimate of distance may have resulted from AT bias in DNA. This inference was supported by the finding that it was rare to observe a decrease in measured distance between taxa using GC-rich DNA, but very common to find an increase as would be expected from the generally higher AT contents of eutherian DNAs. Moreover, the most extreme cases, where distances changed most using GC-rich DNA, were usually those involving comparisons between taxa known to have the most extreme AT-biases among mammals, such as the megabats and rhinolophoid (including megadermatid) microbats. Our results show consistent underestimates of measured differences between eutherian taxa with extreme AT-biases.

How bats achieve a small C-value: frequency of repetitive DNA in Macrotus

Bats possess a genome approximately 50-87% the size of other eutherian mammals. We document that the events that have achieved or maintained a small genome size in the Mexican leaf-nosed bat Macrotus waterhousii have resulted in a lower copy number of interspersed and tandemly repetitive elements. These conclusions are based on examination of 1726 randomly chosen recombinant cosmids, with an average insert size of 35.7 kb and representing 2.6% of the haploid genome of M. waterhousii. Probes representative of microsatellites [(GT)n, (CT)n, (AT)n, (GC)n] and a tandem repeat (rDNA) were used to estimate frequency of repetitive elements in the M. waterhousii genome. Of the four dinucleotides, (GT)n was present in 33.5% of the clones, (CT)n was present in 31.0% of the clones, and (AT)n and (GC)n were not represented in any of the clones examined. The 28S rDNA and a repetitive element from M. californicus were found in three and four clones, respectively. The dinucleotides (GT)n and (CT)n occurred together in the same clone more frequently than expected from chance. Although our data do not allow us to empirically test which mechanisms are maintaining copy number of repetitive DNA in the bat genome, the nonrandom association of these different families of repetitive DNA may provide insight into a mechanism that proportionately reduces diverse families of repetitive DNA that are known to be amplified by very different mechanisms.

Rapidly evolving repetitive DNAs in a conservative genome: a test of factors that affect chromosomal evolution

The hypothesis that tandemly repeated DNA sequences may facilitate chromosomal rearrangements was tested by comparing a conservatively evolving karyotype of a bat species (Macrotus waterhousii) with data published for a rapidly evolving karyotype of an equid species (Equus zebra). Empirical data generated from the phylogenetic screening of rapidly evolving repetitive DNAs from approximately 0.1% of the M. waterhousii genome showed only one sequence that was repetitive in M. waterhousii but low in copy number or absent from the outgroup Artibeus jamaicensis. This compares to 34 such clones containing sequences which were repetitive in E. zebra but were low in copy number or absent from the outgroup Ceratotherium simum. The bat sequence represents a single family of repeated sequences, whereas six families of sequences were identified in E. zebra. Southern blot analysis suggested that the sequence from M. waterhousii is interspersed rather than tandemly repeated, as are the sequences in E. zebra. These data support the above hypothesis and suggest that species with conservatively evolving karyotypes have fewer numbers and families of rapidly evolving DNA sequences than do species such as the equids that possess a karyotype that is considered to have undergone rapid karyotypic evolution.

Measurement by flow cytometry of genomic AT/GC ratio and genome size

Flow cytometry with the AT-specific fluorochrome Hoechst 33258 (HO) and the GC-specific fluorochrome olivomycin (OM) was used for measurement of base pair specific DNA content in 20 species of vertebrates. The results were found to be in good correlation with the biochemical literature on base pair frequencies (r = 0.972, P < 1 x 10(-8). This correlation allows one to determine the percent of GC/AT-pairs and genome size from flow cytometric data. The genome sizes obtained were compared with the literature data on flow cytometric genome size values determined with the use of propidium iodide (PI) that is usually believed to be non-base pair specific. The results were found to be in general agreement; however, the previously reported slight GC-preference of PI is confirmed. The optimal conditions for flow cytometry of AT/GC ratio and genome size with the use of OM and HO are discussed. The approach can be useful for research in ecology, fisheries science, species conservation, and other environmental studies as a tool for rapid survey of a vast array of specimens.

Further flow cytometric studies of the effects of triethylenemelamine on somatic and testicular tissues of the rat

Exposure to the mutagen triethylenemelamine on rat bone marrow, blood, and testis was studied using flow cytometry of DAPI-stained nuclei. Increased coefficients of variation (CVs) of the G1 peaks were observed in bone marrow and blood after both 1 d and 5 d exposures. After 5 d exposure and 7 d recovery both tissues had recovered, in some cases to significantly lower CVs. Increased CVs of the 1C peak of testis were observed only after 5 d exposure to the high dose with no subsequently observed recovery. Bone marrow cells also were stained with Hoechst 33258 and Propidium Iodide. No differences among dyes were observed indicating that increased CVs likely are due to DNA damage resulting from interactions with the mutagen rather than differences in how the dyes bind to DNA relative to mutagen binding. This study demonstrates that differences occur among tissues in how quickly they respond and recover from mutagen exposure. Increased CVs, cell cycle alterations, and decreased CVs after recovery are all potentially useful biomarkers of effect for laboratory and field studies in environmental toxicology.

DNA content in Eurasian sturgeon species determined by flow cytometry

The nuclear DNA content in 10 species of chondrostean fishes was measured by flow cytometry. The sterlet Acipenser ruthenus blood cells were used as an internal standard. The sterlet DNA content was calculated on the basis of comparison with the Xenopus laevis blood cells, 2C = 6.30 pg. In the tetraploid A. ruthenus and A. stellatus the DNA content comprises 3.74 pg/nucleus and is practically invariant; in Huso dauricus it is almost the same, 3.74-3.81 pg; and in A. nudiventris it is a little higher, 3.88-4.04 pg. In the oldest chondrostean, Pseudoscaphirhynchus kaufmanni, the nuclear DNA content is slightly lower, 2C = 3.46-3.48 pg, and in the American paddlefish Polyodon spathula it is lower still, 3.17 pg. In two octoploid sturgeons, A. baeri and A. gueldenstaedti, the DNA content is twice as high as that of the sterlet, 8.29-8.31 and 7.86-7.88 pg, respectively; a very similar amount, 8.24-8.42 pg, was determined in the hybrid Huso huso x A. ruthenus. In the Sakhalin sturgeon, A. medirostris (= A. mikadoi), the DNA content is two times higher than in the octoploids, 13.93-14.73 pg; therefore its ploidy may be 16n and the number of chromosomes could be 500.

Flow-cytometric analysis of the effects of triethylenemelamine on somatic and testicular tissues of the rat

The effects of short-term (24 h) exposure to triethylenemelamine on cellular DNA in five tissues (bone marrow, spleen, kidney, large intestine, and testis) of the rat were studied using flow cytometry. Mean coefficients of variation of the G1 peaks were increased in both the low and high dosage groups relative to controls. Bone marrow exhibited the highest degree of effect, possibly due to the rapid rate of cell division in that tissue, and spleen was next highest. Thus, hematopoietic tissues are highly responsive to short-term, acute exposure to this mutagen. The results of the flow-cytometry assay closely paralleled a simultaneous chromosomal assay conducted on bone marrow of the same rats. These data are interpreted to be consistent with the hypothesis that the observed increase in mean coefficients of variation is due to the clastogenic effects of the mutagen and subsequent unequal distribution of DNA among the daughters of affected cells.

Genetic stock assessment of spawning arctic cisco (Coregonus autumnalis) populations by flow cytometric determination of DNA content

Intraspecific variation in cellular DNA content was measured in five Coregonus autumnalis spawning populations from the Mackenzie River drainage, Canada, using flow cytometry. The rivers assayed were the Peel, Arctic Red, Mountain, Carcajou, and Liard rivers. DNA content was determined from whole blood preparations of fish from all rivers except the Carcajou, for which kidney tissue was used. DNA content measurements of kidney and blood preparations of the same fish from the Mountain River revealed statistically indistinguishable results. Mosaicism was found in blood preparations from the Peel, Arctic Red, Mountain, and Liard rivers, but was not observed in kidney tissue preparations from the Mountain or Carcajou rivers. The Liard River sample had significantly elevated mean DNA content relative to the other four samples; all other samples were statistically indistinguishable. Significant differences in mean DNA content among spawning stocks of a single species reinforces the need for adequate sample sizes of both individuals and populations when reporting "C" values for a particular species.

Intraspecific variation in nuclear DNA content among world populations of a mosquito, Aedes albopictus (Skuse)

Aedes albopictus is commonly distributed in most parts of the Oriental region and on many islands in the Indian and the Pacific Oceans. The species was recently introduced into the United States and Brazil. Feulgen cytophotometric quantitation of haploid nuclear DNA content was carried out for 37 populations of Ae. albopictus to determine the extent of intraspecific variation in nuclear DNA content and whether the range expansion of the species has coincided with an increase in DNA content. The haploid nuclear DNA content varied nearly three-fold. The minimum DNA content was 0.62 pg in Koh Samui from Thailand, and the maximum DNA content was 1.66 pg in Houston-61 from the United States. Statistical comparisons of populations revealed significant differences in DNA contents. No geographic clustering of populations was noted with respect to DNA content. In general, populations from the United States and Brazil had higher DNA contents, but there was no indication that the range expansion had occurred hand in hand with an increase in DNA content. Each population had a specific amount of DNA that is probably imposed by the microenvironment.