Platelet function in classic migraine during attack-free periods

Migraine signaling pathways: purine metabolites that regulate migraine and predispose migraineurs to headache

Migraine is a debilitating disorder that afflicts over 1 billion people worldwide, involving attacks that result in a throbbing and pulsating headache. Migraine is thought to be a neurovascular event associated with vasoconstriction, vasodilation, and neuronal activation. Understanding signaling in migraine pathology is central to the development of therapeutics for migraine prophylaxis and for mitigation of migraine in the prodrome phase before pain sets in. The fact that both vasoactivity and neural sensitization are involved in migraine indicates that agonists which promote these phenomena may very well be involved in migraine pathology. One such group of agonists is the purines, in particular, adenosine phosphates and their metabolites. This manuscript explores what is known about the relationship between these metabolites and migraine pathology and explores the potential for such relationships through their known signaling pathways. Reported receptor involvement in vasoaction and nociception.

Alterations in metabolic flux in migraine and the translational relevance

BACKGROUND

Migraine is a highly prevalent disorder with significant economical and personal burden. Despite the development of effective therapeutics, the causes which precipitate migraine attacks remain elusive. Clinical studies have highlighted altered metabolic flux and mitochondrial function in patients. In vivo animal experiments can allude to the metabolic mechanisms which may underlie migraine susceptibility. Understanding the translational relevance of these studies are important to identifying triggers, biomarkers and therapeutic targets in migraine.

MAIN BODY

Functional imaging studies have suggested that migraineurs feature metabolic syndrome, exhibiting hallmark features including upregulated oxidative phosphorylation yet depleted available free energy. Glucose hypometabolism is also evident in migraine patients and can lead to altered neuronal hyperexcitability such as the incidence of cortical spreading depression (CSD). The association between obesity and increased risk, frequency and worse prognosis of migraine also highlights lipid dysregulation in migraine pathology. Calcitonin gene related peptide (CGRP) has demonstrated an important role in sensitisation and nociception in headache, however its role in metabolic regulation in connection with migraine has not been thoroughly explored. Whether impaired metabolic function leads to increased release of peptides such as CGRP or excessive nociception leads to altered flux is yet unknown.

CONCLUSION

Migraine susceptibility may be underpinned by impaired metabolism resulting in depleted energy stores and altered neuronal function. This review discusses both clinical and in vivo studies which provide evidence of altered metabolic flux which contribute toward pathophysiology. It also reviews the translational relevance of animal studies in identifying targets of biomarker or therapeutic development.

A meta-analysis of biomarkers related to oxidative stress and nitric oxide pathway in migraine

Background

Oxidative and nitrosative stress are considered key events in the still unclear pathophysiology of migraine.

Methods

Studies comparing the level of biomarkers related to nitric oxide (NO) pathway/oxidative stress in the blood/urine of migraineurs vs. unaffected controls were extracted from the PubMed database. Summary estimates of mean ratios (MR) were carried out whenever a minimum of three papers were available. Nineteen studies were included in the meta-analyses, accounting for more than 1000 patients and controls, and compared with existing literature.

Results

Most studies measuring superoxide dismutase (SOD) showed lower activity in cases, although the meta-analysis in erythrocytes gave null results. On the contrary, plasma levels of thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS), an aspecific biomarker of oxidative damage, showed a meta-MR of 2.20 (95% CI: 1.65–2.93). As for NOs, no significant results were found in plasma, serum and urine. However, higher levels were shown during attacks, in patients with aura, and an effect of diet was found. The analysis of glutathione precursor homocysteine and asymmetric dimethylarginine (ADMA), an NO synthase inhibitor, gave inconclusive results.

Conclusions

The role of the oxidative pathway in migraine is still uncertain. Interesting evidence emerged for TBARS and SOD, and concerning the possible role of diet in the control of NOx levels.

Migraine: possible role of shear-induced platelet aggregation with serotonin release

BACKGROUND

Migraine patients are at an increased risk for stroke, as well as other thromboembolic events. This warrants further study of the role of platelets in a proportion of migraine patients.

OBJECTIVE

To extend the "platelet hypothesis" using literature data and observations made in a rat model of shear stress-induced platelet aggregation. Such aggregation causes release of serotonin, leading to vasoconstriction during sufficiently strong aggregation and to long-lasting vasodilation when aggregation diminishes. This vasodilation also depends on nitric oxide and prostaglandin formation.

RESULTS

A role for platelet aggregation in a number of migraineurs is indicated by reports of an increased platelet activity during attacks and favorable effects of antiplatelet medication. We hypothesize that in those patients, a migraine attack with or without aura may both be caused by a rise in platelet-released plasma serotonin, albeit at different concentration. At high concentrations, serotonin may cause vasoconstriction and, consequently, the neuronal signs of aura, whereas at low concentrations, it may already stimulate perivascular pain fibers and cause vasodilation via local formation of nitric oxide, prostaglandins, and neuropeptides. Platelet aggregation may be unilaterally evoked by elevated shear stress in a stenotic cervico-cranial artery, by reversible vasoconstriction or by other cardiovascular abnormality, eg, a symptomatic patent foramen ovale. This most likely occurs when a migraine trigger has further enhanced platelet aggregability; literature shows that many triggers either stimulate platelets directly or reduce endogenous platelet antagonists like prostacyclin.

CONCLUSION

New strategies for migraine medication and risk reduction of stroke are suggested.

Evaluation of the use of sumatriptan-naproxen sodium for menstrual migraine and dysmenorrhea

Menstrual migraine (MM) is a form of headache that tends to occur with prolonged, intense and extremely disabling attacks in a short period around the menstrual cycle (usually 2 days before to 3 days after the onset of the menstrual flow). At least 50% of the female migraine population suffers from this subtype of migraine. The possible presence of other perimenstrual pain, such as dysmenorrhea, can make the attacks even more disabling. Since both of these conditions have a common pathological background consisting of a secretion of abnormally high levels of prostaglandins, it can be particularly useful to use a combination of sumatriptan, the progenitor of the triptans and the drug of choice in the treatment of migraine attack, and naproxen sodium, a potent inhibitor of prostaglandin biosynthesis. The combination of sumatriptan 85 mg and naproxen sodium 500 mg has been tested in women suffering from MM and dysmenorrhea, and this combination has been shown to achieve greater satisfaction when compared with placebo. Moreover, sumatriptan-naproxen was also better than placebo in reducing functional disability and improving productivity. The study is discussed in the context of the current state of knowledge about MM treatment.

Adenylate-cyclase activity in platelets of patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder

Although the main biological hypothesis on the pathophysiology of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is centered on the serotonin system, indications are available that other neurotransmitters, and even second messengers, particularly the cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) signaling, may be involved, though effective data are few. Therefore, the aim of the present study was to evaluate and compare the basal and isoprenaline (ISO)-stimulated velocity of adenylate-cyclase (AC) in human platelet membranes of patients with OCD and healthy control subjects. The results showed that the basal and ISO-stimulated AC activity, as well as the dose-response curves of ISO by using agonist concentrations ranging between 0.1 nM and 10 muM, were not different in the two groups. However, OCD patients showed lower EC(50) and higher E(max) values than healthy subjects. These findings suggest the presence of supersensitive beta-adrenergic receptors in platelets of OCD patients.

Genomic abnormalities in patients with migraine and chronic migraine: preliminary blood gene expression suggests platelet abnormalities

BACKGROUND

Migraine has strong genetic and environmental components and may also be a significant contributor to chronic migraine (CM). It is hypothesized that gene expression changes in peripheral blood cells can be used to detect the interaction of these influences.

OBJECTIVE

Distinct genomic expression patterns for migraine and CM will be present. These genomic profiles will help clarify the interactions of inheritance and environment. This initial study begins to examine the feasibility of peripheral blood cell genomic analysis to assist in the understanding of the pathophysiology of migraine and CM.

METHODS

Blood samples from patients were obtained either during an acute migraine or CM. Genomic expression patterns were analyzed using Affymetrix U95A microarrays.

RESULTS

Expression patterns of 7 migraine and 15 CM patients were compared to four distinct control groups (total patients, n=56) including healthy subjects. A group of platelet genes were upregulated in both migraine and CM samples. Different gene expression patterns were also seen between migraine and CM. A group of immediate early genes including c-fos and cox-2 were expressed at higher levels in migraine, whereas specific mitochondrial genes were expressed at higher levels in CM.

CONCLUSIONS

Increased expression of platelet genes in patients with migraine and CM suggests similar underlying pathophysiology. The differences seen between migraine and CM in other genes suggest an overlapping but not identical pathophysiology. Further genomic profiling studies will help define these relationships and provide further insights into headache pathogenesis.

Investigation of the low-density lipoprotein receptor gene and cholesterol as a risk factor for migraine

The Low-Density Lipoprotein Receptor (LDLR) gene is a cell surface receptor that plays an important role in cholesterol homeostasis. We investigated the (TA)n polymorphism in exon 18 of the LDLR gene on chromosome 19p13.2 performing an association analysis in 244 typical migraine-affected patients, 151 suffering from migraine with aura (MA), 96 with migraine without aura (MO) and 244 unaffected controls. The populations consisted of Caucasians only, and controls were age- and sex-matched. The results showed no significant difference between groups for allele frequency distributions of the (TA)n polymorphism even after separation of the migraine-affected individuals into subgroups of MA and MO affected patients. This is in contradiction to Mochi et al. who found a positive association of this variant with MO. Our study discusses possible differences between the two studies and extends this research by investigating circulating cholesterol levels in a migraine-affected population.

Migraine and haemostasis

Migraine is a risk factor for cerebral infarction in young women. The nature of the connection between these diseases remains however essentially unknown. Abnormalities of haemostasis leading to an increased thrombotic risk would provide a logical link. Platelets, antiphospholipid antibodies and more recently congenital thrombophilia have thus successively been implicated. The different studies concerning these topics have been reviewed. Because of the conflicting results obtained and because of the numerous methodological shortcomings of many of these studies, no definite conclusion can be reached. It is possible that these 3 factors play a role in the ischemic risk of migraine, but it is as likely or even more likely that other factors (inside or outside the hemostatic system) play a more important role. Further studies are thus deeply needed.

Oxidative stress and platelet responsiveness in migraine

The aim of this study is to investigate whether oxidative stress may represent a pivotal determinant of the altered functional features of platelets in migraineurs during the headache-free period. Twenty-three patients with migraine with aura, free of attack, and 23 healthy volunteers were enrolled for the study. The involvement of an oxidative condition appears confirmed by the statistically significant increase (p < 0.001) of plasma levels of thiobarbituric acid-reactive substances which may be considered a marker for oxidative stress and themselves strong-pro-oxidants. Such oxidative status seems to induce in platelets of migraineurs increased membrane rigidity (p < 0.001), reduced cytosolic calcium in the resting condition and after thrombin stimulation (p < 0.001), and decreased aggregatory responses to ADP and collagen. These findings indicate that the "in vitro" anomalous platelet behavior in migraineurs, observed in headache-free periods, may be considered as the transient expression of the exhausted platelets to "in vivo" stimulation and probably related to an increased vulnerability to oxidative stress.

L-arginine/nitric oxide pathway activation in platelets of migraine patients with and without aura

Nitric oxide (NO) in platelets has been proposed as a promising tool for studying NO variations in migraine. In the present research the platelet response to collagen and the basal and collagen-induced production of NO and cGMP in platelet cytosol were assessed in migraine patients (25 with aura and 35 without aura) both interictally and ictally, and compared with the same parameters in 30 age-matched control subjects. A reduced responsiveness to collagen was found in migraine patients, particularly those with aura, and this was more marked during attacks (ANOVA interictal periods: p < 0.01, attacks: p < 0.02) The basal and collagen-stimulated production of NO and cGMP in the platelet cytosol was significantly higher in migraine patients with aura assessed in interictal periods than in control subjects, and this production was further increased during attacks (interictal period: NO ANOVA: p < 0.001, ictal period: p < 0.01; cGMP: interictal period p < 0.01, ictal period: p < 0.02). The increase in platelet NO and cGMP production was also evident, though to a lesser extent, in migraine patients without aura. The present research supports the hypothesis of an activation of the L-arginine/NO pathway in migraine patients, especially those with aura, and confirms the findings of a previous study of increased levels of L-arginine in platelets of migraine patients studied in headache free-periods, and decreased collagen aggregation in whole blood.

Platelet changes in classic migraine

We investigated some ultrastructural aspects of platelet activity in patients with classic migraine during an attack-free period. We focused on the production of malondialdehyde (MDA), the intracellular concentration of Ca++ and the membrane phospholipid structure using a DPH (1,6 diphenyl-1,3,5 hexatriene) fluorescent probe. Our study comprised 20 patients with classic migraine and 5 healthy controls, from whom 10 cc samples of blood were collected in test tubes containing sodium citrate (1/9 cc). We found no significant differences in MDA production between migraineurs and controls either before or after stimulation with thrombin. The same applies to the concentration of intracellular Ca++ (Ca++i). The membrane lipid composition assessed by DPH fluorescent probe was normal both in migraineurs and in controls. Our findings suggest no intrinsic activation of platelet aggregation.

Ethanol exposure results in a transient decrease in human platelet cAMP levels: evidence for a protein kinase C mediated process

At concentrations between 2 and 32 mM, ethanol is shown to depress human platelet cAMP levels. The effect is biphasic, maximal at 30 sec, with platelet concentrations of cAMP returning to baseline values at higher ethanol concentrations and at longer incubation times. The cAMP lowering effect of ethanol can be blocked by a phosphodiesterase (PPDE) inhibitor, 3-isobutyl-1-methyl-xanthine (IBMX), at a concentration of 2 mM, suggesting that an increase in PPDE activity may be responsible for this effect. Exposure of platelets to 1-(5-isoquinolinylsulfonyl)-2-methylpiperazine (H7), a protein kinase C (PKC) inhibitor, blocks the ethanol-induced decrease in platelet cAMP, suggesting ethanol may be acting through activation of PKC.

Cerebrovascular risk factors in migraine with prolonged aura and without aura

The role of cerebrovascular risk factors such as mitral valve prolapse, platelet aggregation, platelet activation and cardiac arrythmias in migraine was investigated in a total of 44 migraineurs (32 migraineurs without aura and 12 with prolonged aura) and 32 controls. Comparing the total of migraineurs and the two subgroups with controls, mitral valve prolapse, a raised thromboxane B2 level, at least one platelet aggregation dysfunction or an abnormality in 24-h ECG was statistically seen no more often than in the control group. Neither did combinations of the variables occur more frequently. Altogether, this study showed no increased coincidence of migraine with prolonged aura and migraine without aura with the above parameters. The absence of cardiac and haematological abnormalities in migraine with prolonged aura focuses attention on the control of the cortical microcirculation.

Platelet antiaggregate activity

Calcium ions act as a second messenger to platelet agonists, with increases in intracellular calcium bringing about changes in shape, aggregation, and release reactions. Changes in platelet function have been reported previously in migraine sufferers and there is evidence that hyperaggregability occurs during a migraine attack. It was decided to assess platelet aggregation with platelet-rich plasma (PRP) from nicardipine-treated migraine sufferers because dihydropyridine derivatives are known to inhibit adenosine diphosphate (ADP)- and epinephrine-induced aggregation. Aggregation induced by 1.4 mumol/L arachidonic acid was similar in PRP from control subjects and untreated migraine sufferers, whereas 1 or 2 mumol/L ADP-induced aggregation was lower in PRP from migraine sufferers. Treatment with 20 mg of nicardipine three times daily for 2 months significantly (p less than 0.05) increased 2 mumol/L ADP-induced aggregation. It is concluded that nicardipine was acting either on migraine pathogenic mechanisms or directly on the platelets.

Platelet P1, P4-Di (adenosine-51) tetraphosphate (AP4A) in migraine patients before and during beta-adrenoceptor blockade

P1,P4-Di(adenosine-51) tetraphosphate (AP4A) is a metabolically inactive nucleotide which can be released from platelet dense granules. This study was designed firstly, to investigate whether platelet content of AP4A was decreased in patients with classical migraine and secondly, whether the content of AP4A was changed by beta-adrenoceptor blockade. No significant difference in platelet dense granule content of AP4A, was observed between 10 migraine patients and 10 normal controls. Both metoprolol, a beta 1-selective blocker and propranolol, a non-selective beta-blocker significantly decreased the migraine attack rate. However, while propranolol significantly reduced the platelet content of AP4A, metoprolol did not. Therefore, the present data suggest that platelet dense granule release, as estimated by the content of AP4A is not of major importance in migraine.

Migraine: the platelet hypothesis after 10 years

The proposal that migraine is a blood disorder and caused by a primary abnormality of platelet behaviour was first put forward in 1978. This paper outlines the basis on which the proposal was made and the way in which the platelet hypothesis can account for the many facets of the disorder. It also reports further studies of platelet composition and function which have been undertaken by a large number of independent workers during the past ten years. The results of their investigations provide strong additional support for the platelet hypothesis in migraine.