The postpolio syndrome--a critical comment to the diagnosis

Myotonic dystrophy mimicking postpolio syndrome in a polio survivor

We describe a 38-yr-old polio survivor with newly developed weakness from myotonic dystrophy. He suffered muscle atrophy and weakness in his legs as a result of poliomyelitis at the age of 3 yrs. After a stable interval of about 30 yrs, he felt new weakness and fatigue in his legs. Electromyography revealed generalized myotonic discharges, early recruitment, and findings of chronic denervation in his left leg. Genetic testing was consistent with myotonic dystrophy type 1. A biopsy from the right gastrocnemius revealed findings of both myotonic dystrophy and chronic denervation. This case report shows the importance of considering other uncommon conditions in the differential diagnoses of postpolio syndrome.

Postpolio syndrome: a challenge to the health-care system

The practical eradication of poliomyelitis in industrialized countries marks one of the most important achievements of world health policy. Yet, disability induced by polio not only continues to exist among survivors with paralytic sequelae, but may also be further accentuated in a considerable number of affected subjects by the development of postpolio syndrome (PPS). PPS aggravates the motor sequelae already present in such subjects and reduces their functional capacity to the point where it affects their activities of daily living and worsens their quality of life. Inasmuch as development of PPS questions the concept of poliomyelitis as a static disease it poses a challenge not only to health professionals but also to policy-makers tasked with providing the necessary health-care measures and appropriate resources. This study sought to review research on this syndrome and to draw up some recommendations that might prove useful to the health authorities for decision-making purposes.

Perceived health and physical functioning in postpoliomyelitis syndrome: a 6-year prospective follow-up study

OBJECTIVES

To study prospectively the health status, and especially the physical functioning, of polio survivors with and without postpoliomyelitis syndrome (PPS), and to identify prognostic determinants of change in physical functioning.

DESIGN

Prospective cohort study; measurements at baseline and after 1, 2, and 6 years.

SETTING

University hospital in the Netherlands.

PARTICIPANTS

Seventy-six subjects with PPS and 27 without PPS.

INTERVENTIONS

Not applicable.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

The Nottingham Health Profile (NHP) physical mobility category.

RESULTS

Subjects with PPS had significantly poorer health status than subjects without PPS. No significant differences in mean NHP physical mobility scores between baseline and 6 years were found; both groups had improved after 1 year, after which there was a slow decline over the next 5 years. During the first 2 years, strength measurements showed little decline that was not related to changes in NHP physical mobility score. A physical performance test revealed no mean change in the first 2 years, but the subgroup with a decline above the 75th percentile eventually deteriorated 10.5+/-16.3 points on the NHP physical mobility category (P=.01) at 6 years from baseline. This subgroup had more extensive paresis than the other subjects, although it was not significant (P=.07). The extent of paresis at baseline was the only prognostic determinant for an increase in NHP physical mobility problems after 6 years.

CONCLUSIONS

Subjects with and without PPS did not differ with regard to changes in health status in a 6-year period. The fact that the extent of paresis was a prognostic factor for a decline in physical functioning is in accord with a (slow) decline in muscle mass, as a late effect of polio, that may lead to a decline in physical functioning as the reduced muscle capacity becomes less able to meet the demands of daily physical activities.

Post-polio syndrome and total health status in a prospective hospital study

New loss of function among patients with previous polio is frequently reported and has several causes. All patients referred to the Department of Neurology, Haukeland University Hospital, Bergen, for 13 months during 2000-2001 with diagnosis late effects of polio were examined prospectively to identify their symptoms and loss of function. Eighty-five patients aged 47-91 years with mean of 61 years were included. The most common complaints were pain (44%), muscular weakness (27%), and fatigue (16%). Muscular weakness occurred in lower limbs in 75%, in respiratory muscles in only 5%. Walking in stairs was impaired in 72% and outdoor walking in 65%. Seventeen patients (19%) reported no loss of function. Post-polio syndrome was diagnosed in 26% of the patients. Polio-related loss of function including cervical and lumbosacral radiculopathies, mononeuropathies and degenerative joint disease were found in an additional 53%. Eleven patients (13%) had distinct non-polio-related disorders that caused new loss of function. The remaining 8% had a stable condition. In conclusion, the majority of polio patients who seek hospital, experience a new loss of function because of polio-related disorders. A careful neurological examination is necessary to identify the correct diagnosis and treatment.

Perceived health in a population based sample of victims of the 1956 polio epidemic in the Netherlands

OBJECTIVE

To investigate perceived health and its relation to residual paresis from polio, late onset neuromuscular symptoms following poliomyelitis (LSP), and sex, in a population based sample of polio survivors.

METHODS

350 subjects traced from the notification records of the Dutch 1956 polio epidemic received a mailed questionnaire on residual polio paresis and new neuromuscular symptoms. Perceived health was measured using the Nottingham health profile. Respondents with new muscle weakness and new neuromuscular symptoms were considered as cases with LSP.

RESULTS

Health problems were perceived by 151 of the 260 respondents. Respondents with residual paresis had significantly more health problems than clinically recovered respondents for the Nottingham health profile category of physical mobility. The perceived health of respondents with LSP (45.5%) was significantly worse than that of respondents without LSP for all the health profile categories. Among the respondents with LSP, health status did not differ between those with residual paresis and those who had recovered, except for physical mobility. Female respondents with LSP reported worse health status than male respondents with regard to physical mobility and social isolation.

CONCLUSIONS

In this population based sample, health problems were frequently reported. They were mainly related to late onset neuromuscular symptoms following poliomyelitis, which were perceived by a substantial proportion of all polio survivors-not only subjects with polio residuals but also individuals who (subjectively) had recovered from polio.

Education, occupation, and perception of health amongst previous polio patients compared to their siblings

Patients with previous polio represent a challenge for neurological rehabilitation. We examined 168 previous polio patients and 239 of their siblings, the patients either from the 1950-1954 epidemic cohort, or from a cohort of hospital-admitted rehabilitation patients. Ninety-four paralytic patients and 74 non-paralytic patients were included. All patients and siblings answered the same questionnaires for socioeconomic and health factors and chi-square comparisons were performed. Previous polio did not affect the level of education. Both patients and siblings rated their educational options to have been good. Significantly less patients were full-time employed at the age of 40 years compared to their siblings (P=0.015). This was the result of a lower full-time employment rate amongst the paralytic patients, only 52% of this group being employed full-time. Male patients and paralytic patients reported to have experienced reduced professional options. More patients were living alone compared to their siblings (P=0.035). The perception of general health was lower amongst patients than siblings, as was assessment of total life situation and patients reported more frequently symptoms like pain and tiredness. In conclusion, previous polio had not lowered the polio patients' educational status, but fewer patients were employed full-time at the age of 40 years.

Assessment of pain and health-related quality of life in slowly progressive neuromuscular disease

Few studies have examined the effect of pain on the quality of life of individuals with slowly progressive neuromuscular disease (NMD). The purpose of this study was to determine the frequency and extent to which subjects with slowly progressive NMD report pain and the association between pain and health-related quality of life in persons with NMD. The study design was a descriptive, nonexperimental survey. Of a total of 1,432 subjects with slowly progressive NMDs recruited from a university-based NMD clinic and the membership rosters of worldwide NMD support organizations, 859 agreed to participate. The primary measurement tool used was the Medical Outcomes Study SF-36 health survey. Our results indicated that, with the exception of adult spinal muscular atrophy (SMA), the frequency and severity of pain reported in slowly progressive NMDs was significantly greater than levels of pain reported by the general US population and was comparable to pain reported by subjects with osteoarthritis and chronic low back pain. There was a significant correlation between increased pain and lower levels of general health, vitality, social function, and physical role. Pain was moderately associated with increased fatigue, inability to cope adequately with stress, and sleep disturbance. In conclusion, with the exception of adult SMA, the frequency and severity of pain reported in slowly progressive NMDs was significant.

Submaximal exercise capacity and maximal power output in polio subjects

OBJECTIVES

To compare the submaximal exercise capacity of polio subjects with postpoliomyelitis syndrome (PPS) and without (non-PPS) with that of healthy control subjects, to investigate the relationship of this capacity with maximal short-term power and quadriceps strength, and to evaluate movement economy.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional survey.

SETTING

University hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Forty-three polio subjects (25 PPS, 18 non-PPS) and 12 control subjects.

INTERVENTIONS

Not applicable.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Power output, oxygen uptake, and heart rate were measured in an incremental submaximal cycle ergometry test. Maximal short-term power was measured in 5-second all-out efforts. Knee extensor strength was measured on a chair dynamometer.

RESULTS

The mean submaximal power +/- standard deviation at 80% of heart rate reserve of 83.8 +/- 29.9 watts in the polio subjects was significantly less than the mean submaximal power of 142.1 +/- 30.4 watts in the control group. However, expressed as a percentage of the maximal short-term power, submaximal power did not differ between the groups. Strength and maximal short-term power correlated significantly (p < .005) with submaximal power (r = .64 and .76, respectively). The oxygen uptake was higher than theoretically expected for the given submaximal power output in polio subjects, and appeared to increase with increasing asymmetry in strength and power between legs. No differences were found between PPS and non-PPS subjects.

CONCLUSION

The submaximal work capacity of polio subjects was severely reduced, mainly in association with the reduced muscle capacity. And, because of a reduced movement economy, their energy cost was elevated. Although muscle loads in activities such as walking and climbing stairs differ from cycling, they also may require elevated relative levels of effort, predisposing subjects to premature fatigue in sustained activity.