Pathogenesis and mechanisms of graft rejection in concordant xenotransplantation with special reference to hamster-to-rat cardiac transplantation

Singlet oxygen energy illumination during moderate cold ischemia prolongs the survival of concordant hamster xeno-heart transplants

INTRODUCTION

Singlet oxygen energy (SOE) is a potent inhibitor of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in vitro and in vivo in certain dose ranges and can improve the levels of high-energy phosphates (HEP) in concordant hamster xeno-heart transplants. Some data indicate that a certain degree of cold ischemia (CI) might be beneficial to xenotransplants. We investigated if SOE illumination of hamster xeno-hearts during moderate cold ischemia (CI) improved graft survival.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eighteen hearts from Golden Syrian hamsters (70 to 80 g) were subjected to 8 hours of CI in cold (+4 degrees C) saline solution (NaCL, 0.9%) before heterotopic cervical transplantation to Lewis rats (220 g). Among the treatment group (n = 8), SOE was produced by illuminating the hearts for 10 minutes every 30 minutes with photons at lambda 634 nm with the Oxylight equipment. Graft function was evaluated every 6 hours after transplantation with digital exam until cessation of heart beats.

RESULTS

The graft survival of SOE-illuminated ischemic hamster xenografts was 2.34 +/- 0.56 versus 1.15 +/- 0.37 days in the control group (P < .05). All hearts displayed immediate graft function versus 70% in the controls (NS).

CONCLUSIONS

SOE illumination at lambda 634 nm during moderate cold ischemia (+4 degrees C) can improve the survival of concordant hamster xeno-heart transplants. The exact mechanism(s) are currently unknown, but the effect might in part be exerted by a combination of reduced production of ROS and increased oxidative phosphorylation.

Early onset of rejection in concordant hamster xeno hearts display signs of necrosis, but not apoptosis, correlating to the phosphocreatine concentration

BACKGROUND

The importance of apoptosis contra necrosis for ischemia/reperfusion (RP) and acute rejection in concordant rodent xenotransplantation is largely unknown. We explored this question by comparing rodent allo and concordant xenotransplants with different morphological methods to detect apoptosis and biochemical data on the levels of high-energy phosphates obtained with in vitro 31Phosphorous Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (31P MRS). More specifically, we applied a hitherto unused method in transplantation research, apoptosis specific biotin labeled oligonucleotides designed with a 10 base pair stem region and a 20 nucleotides large loop that form a hairpin like shape. The results obtained with this method were compared to results obtained with the more widely used in situ 3'-end labeling of DNA (TUNEL) assay and extraction and gel electrophoresis of labeled DNA (DNA laddering).

METHODS

Cervical heart transplantations were performed between inbred Lewis (L) (RT1l) to L, L to DA (RT1a) rats, hamster (H) to H and H to L (X) (n=5 for all groups except for X, n=9). All hearts were subjected to 30 min of cold ischemia (+4 degrees C) and 6 h of RP before explantation. In vitro 31P MRS was used to determine the phosphocreatine (PCr), beta-adenosine triphosphate (beta-ATP) concentrations and the PCr/beta-ATP ratio of the transplants. We correlated the biochemical data to haematoxylin and eosin (H & E) stained tissue slides scored for rejection, infiltration of antibodies and complement depositions, DNA extraction and gel electrophoresis of labeled DNA (DNA laddering), in situ 3'-end labeling of DNA (TUNEL) and the apoptosis specific hairpin probe assays scoring.

RESULTS

The rejection score of the xeno grafts differed significantly compared to their syngeneic hamster to hamster controls (2.40 +/- 0.25 vs. 1.20 +/- 0.20; P=0.005) and they had a significantly higher TUNEL score, 228 +/- 15 vs. 2.44 +/- 0.32 (P=0.009), that correlated to changes in PCr concentration (P<0.001) and to the PCr/beta-ATP ratio (P=0.01). The uptake was mainly (90-95%) located to 1-2 microm large extra cellular 'granule'. A picture resembling early necrosis was seen on the H & E stainings and reflected in the Billingham rejection score above.

CONCLUSIONS

After 6 h of RP the onset of acute rejection in the concordant hamster xeno hearts displayed features of early, possibly mitochondrial, necrosis, but not apoptosis, which correlated to changes in the PCr concentration and the PCr/beta-ATP ratio. The mechanism for the early rejection observed is unclear and might be caused by other factors in the sera apart from cellular components, antibodies and complement factors. Identification of the underlying mechanisms could enable us to design rational therapies that prevent activation of the recipient's innate immune response.

Anti-major histocompatibility complex class II treatment prevents graft rejection in the hamster-to-rat cardiac xenograft

BACKGROUND

Several groups have achieved graft acceptance in the concordant hamster to rat model by using a combination of anti-proliferative drugs and conventional immunosuppressive therapy. However, such aggressive treatment often leads to the recipient dying with a functional xenograft, as a result of opportunistic infections. This study aimed to investigate the effects of a short course of therapy with an anti-MHC class II monoclonal antibody treatment (chimeric OX6 [cOX6]) in combination with cyclosporin A (CyA) in a concordant hamster-to-rat xenograft model.

METHODS

Rats receiving hamster cardiac xenografts were given CyA or cOX6 alone or in combination and were monitored daily to assess the effect of treatment on graft survival. Additional studies monitored the effect of treatment on the production of cytolytic anti-hamster antibodies by the recipient and the deposition of immunoglobulin (Ig)M and complement factors within the xenograft.

RESULTS

Treatment with CyA only had no effect on graft survival, whereas treatment with cOX6 increased graft survival time by 2 days. The median graft survival time for cOX6+CyA was 76 days. cOX6 treatment of rats having undergone transplants inhibited the rise in cytotoxic anti-hamster antibodies in peripheral blood until day 5, whereas combination therapy completely inhibited anti-hamster antibody formation. Fluorescence-activated cell sorter analysis showed treatment with cOX6 significantly reduced circulating B cell numbers until day 5. Anti-MHC class II treatment also markedly reduced the deposition of both IgM and C3. Anti-MHC class II treatment with CyA gives long term survival in concordant xenografts without severe side effects.

CONCLUSIONS

The mechanism of action of this combination is complex and could be caused by an initial inhibition of B cell function by the anti-MHC class II treatment and the subsequent inhibition of T cell dependent pathways by CyA.

FK506 treatment in combination with leflunomide in hamster-to-rat heart and liver xenograft transplantation

BACKGROUND

In the experiment described here, we investigated the effects of the immunosuppressants FK506 and leflunomide (Lef) on the survival of hamster hearts and liver xenografts in Lewis rats.

METHODS

Lewis rats were used as recipients of hamster heart or liver grafts using different regimens of FK506 and Lef. Donor-matched heart grafts were transplanted into long-term surviving Lewis rat recipients of hamster xenografts to test donor-specific prolongation of xenograft survival. Hyperimmune, late xenograft rejection, and naive sera were transferred into long-term surviving Lewis rat recipients of hamster heart xenografts to determine whether these sera could inhibit the efficacy of donor-specific long-term survival. Anti-donor-specific antibodies were analyzed by flow cytometry.

RESULTS

After a short induction with FK506 plus Lef, maintenance treatment with FK506 alone was sufficient to prolong survival of hamster xenografts. All hamster heart and four of six hamster liver xenografts survived for more than 3 months. Second hamster hearts were permanently accepted by Lewis rats bearing long-term surviving hamster heart xenografts when rats were treated with FK506 monotherapy (mean survival time >60 days, n=4). Long-term surviving hamster heart grafts were rejected after transfer of hyperimmune serum but not late xenograft rejection serum or naive serum. Lef and FK506 significantly reduced the production of anti-donor-specific antibodies in Lewis rats transplanted with hamster liver and heart xenografts.

CONCLUSION

Long-term survival of hamster liver and heart xenografts in Lewis rats could be induced by a regimen of short-term FK506 in combination with Lef followed by FK506 monotherapy. The acquired sensitivity of late xenoreactivity to FK506 reflects primarily a modification in the host immune response to the hamster graft.