Study of dose-response relationship in contact sensitivity using an in vitro assay

Dose-response studies of contact allergens using 3 guinea pigs models

A multi-dose-response induction protocol for the guinea pig maximization test (GPMT), including a statistical computer program, has earlier been developed to improve the power of predictive tests for identification of contact allergens. This dose-response protocol, with 2 modifications (i.e., increased number of animals in each group and increased number of challenge concentrations) was evaluated in the GPMT, the cumulative contact enhancement test (CCET) and the Freund's complete adjuvant test (FCAT), using potassium dichromate and hydroxycitronellal as model contact allergens. Application of the dose-response protocol on the CCET and the FCAT resulted in either monotone or non-monotone curves with significant dose-response. However, application of the dose-response protocol on the GPMT gave curves with no significant dose-response. The protocol makes it possible to obtain an EC50 value, thus improving the possibility of ranking contact allergens, which is of substantial use for risk assessments. The dose-response protocol could benefit from a few adjustments: a wider span in the induction doses; change to simultaneous increase in intradermal and topical induction doses to obtain a proper dose-response for the GPMT; the addition of further challenge concentrations. In addition the computer program should allow calculation of threshold concentration for sensitization and EC50 value for a non-monotone curve.

Contact allergens and sodium lauryl sulphate upregulate vascular endothelial growth factor in normal keratinocytes

In allergic and irritant contact dermatitis, keratinocytes are major target cells that can be activated to take part in local reactions by secreting soluble mediators. Among the growth factors produced by keratinocytes, vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) is a powerful inducer of permeability of endothelial cells, and is involved in inflammation. We determined whether different contact allergens, dinitrosulphobenzene (DNSB), para-phenylenediamine (pPD) and the metals nickel and chromium, as distinct from cobalt, which has been shown to mimic the effects of hypoxia, can modify the basal level of VEGF in normal human keratinocytes when tested at various, non-toxic concentrations. The effects of an irritant, sodium lauryl sulphate (SLS), and of hydrocortisone were also tested. Our results showed an intense dose-dependent upregulation of VEGF release by keratinocytes after treatments by metals, pPD and SLS. DNSB induced only a moderate increase of VEGF. Hydrocortisone reduced the basal level as well as the nickel-induced upregulation of VEGF. These findings suggest that contact allergens and irritants probably upregulate VEGF in keratinocytes by different mechanisms and may contribute directly to the microvascular hyperpermeability which characterizes both contact and irritant dermatitis.

Suboptimal non-inflammatory concentrations of haptens may elicit a contact sensitivity reaction when used as a mix

Contact dermatitis is a cutaneous inflammatory reaction mediated by hapten-specific T cells. We used a murine model to investigate the contact sensitivity reaction elicited by different concentrations (optimal and suboptimal) of the haptens DNFB and oxazolone applied singly or in combination. The simultaneous application of DNFB and oxazolone at optimal concentrations (0.2% and 0.4% respectively) did not significantly increase the ear swelling response induced by each of the allergens when applied singly. No contact sensitivity response was observed when the haptens were tested individually at subthreshold concentrations (0.05% and 0.1% respectively). However, mixing the 2 molecules at the same concentrations gave rise to a clinical contact sensitivity reaction. The simultaneous application of the haptens at a 2 x higher, but still suboptimal concentrations (0.1% and 0.2% respectively), elicited an inflammatory response that was significantly greater than the responses elicited by either of the haptens when applied separately. These results suggest that a "false-positive" reaction to a mix may reveal a genuine sensitization to the constituents.

Optimization of the mouse ear swelling test for in vivo and in vitro studies of weak contact sensitizers

Murine models for the assessment of the contact sensitizing properties of chemicals rely on mouse ear swelling tests (Mest), which are not sensitive enough to detect weak sensitizers. The aim of the present study was to develop in mice an adjuvant-free Mest appropriate for in vivo detection of any type of sensitizer (weak to strong), and useful for in vitro assessment of contact sensitivity (CS). 3 haptens were tested: dinitrochlorobenzene (DNCB), para-phenylenediamine (pPD) and isoeugenol. We compared various protocols for induction of the CS reaction, differing by the site of induction, the number of applications and the concentrations of the 3 haptens. Comparison of the induction site for optimal CS reaction showed that, in Balb/c mice, the back was a better site of induction than the abdomen. Detection of the sensitizing properties of weak sensitizers (pPD, isoeugenol) was possible using an adjuvant-free protocol, provided that the induction phase comprised hapten applications on 3 consecutive days on the backs of animals. For DNCB, one application was sufficient to obtain optimal CS reaction. For all 3 haptens, a secondary response in vitro was obtained using semi-purified lymph node T cells from animals sensitized 5 days before with the optimized Mest. These results demonstrate that the Mest could be a useful experimental model for the study of all types of contact sensitizers.