The effects of hormone resuscitation on cardiac function and hemodynamics in a porcine brain-dead organ donor model

Hemodynamic Effects of High-dose Levothyroxine and Methylprednisolone in Brain-dead Potential Organ Donors

BACKGROUND

Hormonal replacement therapy is administered to many brain-dead organ donors to improve hemodynamic stability. Previous clinical studies present conflicting results with several randomized studies reporting no benefit.

METHODS

Consecutive adult donors (N = 199) were randomized to receive high-dose levothyroxine, high-dose methylprednisolone, both (Combo), or no hormonal therapy (Control). Vasopressor requirements using the vasoactive-inotropic score (VIS) were assessed at baseline, 4 h, and at procurement. Crossover to the Combo group was sufficient to require separate intention-to-treat and per-protocol analyses.

RESULTS

In the intention-to-treat analysis, the mean (±SD) reduction in VIS from baseline to procurement was 1.6 ± 2.6, 14.9 ± 2.6, 10.9 ± 2.6, and 7.1 ± 2.6 for the levothyroxine, methylprednisolone, Combo, and Control groups, respectively. While controlling for the baseline score, the reduction in VIS was significantly greater in the methylprednisolone and Combo groups and significantly less in the levothyroxine group compared with controls. Results were similar in the per-protocol analysis.

CONCLUSION

High-dose methylprednisolone alone or in combination with levothyroxine allowed for significant reduction in vasopressor support in organ donors. Levothyroxine alone offered no advantage in reducing vasopressor support. Organ yield, transplantation rates, and recipient outcomes were not adversely affected.

Prolonged (≥24 Hours) Normothermic (≥32 °C) Ex Vivo Organ Perfusion: Lessons From the Literature

For 2 centuries, researchers have studied ex vivo perfusion intending to preserve the physiologic function of isolated organs. If it were indeed possible to maintain ex vivo organ viability for days, transplantation could become an elective operation with clinicians methodically surveilling and reconditioning allografts before surgery. To this day, experimental reports of successfully prolonged (≥24 hours) organ perfusion are rare and have not translated into clinical practice. To identify the crucial factors necessary for successful perfusion, this review summarizes the history of prolonged normothermic ex vivo organ perfusion. By examining successful techniques and protocols used, this review outlines the essential elements of successful perfusion, limitations of current perfusion systems, and areas where further research in preservation science is required.

Peritransplant Cardiometabolic and Mitochondrial Function: The Missing Piece in Donor Heart Dysfunction and Graft Failure

Primary graft dysfunction is an important cause of morbidity and mortality after cardiac transplantation. Donor brain stem death (BSD) is a significant contributor to donor heart dysfunction and primary graft dysfunction. There remain substantial gaps in the mechanistic understanding of peritransplant cardiac dysfunction. One of these gaps is cardiac metabolism and metabolic function. The healthy heart is an "omnivore," capable of utilizing multiple sources of nutrients to fuel its enormous energetic demand. When this fails, metabolic inflexibility leads to myocardial dysfunction. Data have hinted at metabolic disturbance in the BSD donor and subsequent heart transplantation; however, there is limited evidence demonstrating specific metabolic or mitochondrial dysfunction. This review will examine the literature surrounding cardiometabolic and mitochondrial function in the BSD donor, organ preservation, and subsequent cardiac transplantation. A more comprehensive understanding of this subject may then help to identify important cardioprotective strategies to improve the number and quality of donor hearts.

Heart Transplantation From Brain Dead Donors: A Systematic Review of Animal Models

Despite advances in mechanical circulatory devices and pharmacologic therapies, heart transplantation (HTx) is the definitive and most effective therapy for an important proportion of qualifying patients with end-stage heart failure. However, the demand for donor hearts significantly outweighs the supply. Hearts are sourced from donors following brain death, which exposes donor hearts to substantial pathophysiological perturbations that can influence heart transplant success and recipient survival. Although significant advances in recipient selection, donor and HTx recipient management, immunosuppression, and pretransplant mechanical circulatory support have been achieved, primary graft dysfunction after cardiac transplantation continues to be an important cause of morbidity and mortality. Animal models, when appropriate, can guide/inform medical practice, and fill gaps in knowledge that are unattainable in clinical settings. Consequently, we performed a systematic review of existing animal models that incorporate donor brain death and subsequent HTx and assessed studies for scientific rigor and clinical relevance. Following literature screening via the U.S National Library of Medicine bibliographic database (MEDLINE) and Embase, 29 studies were assessed. Analysis of included studies identified marked heterogeneity in animal models of donor brain death coupled to HTx, with few research groups worldwide identified as utilizing these models. General reporting of important determinants of heart transplant success was mixed, and assessment of posttransplant cardiac function was limited to an invasive technique (pressure-volume analysis), which is limitedly applied in clinical settings. This review highlights translational challenges between available animal models and clinical heart transplant settings that are potentially hindering advancement of this field of investigation.

Normothermic Ex Vivo Heart Perfusion: Effects of Live Animal Blood and Plasma Cross Circulation

Prolonged normothermic ex vivo heart perfusion could transform cardiac transplantation. To help identify perfusate components that might enable long-term perfusion, we evaluated the effects of cross-circulated whole blood and cross-circulated plasma from a live paracorporeal animal on donor porcine hearts preserved via normothermic ex vivo heart perfusion. Standard perfusion (SP; n = 40) utilized red blood cell/plasma perfusate and Langendorff technique for a goal of 12 hours. Cross-circulation groups used a similar circuit with the addition of cross-circulated venous whole blood (XC-blood; n = 6) or cross-circulated filtered plasma (XC-plasma; n = 7) between a live paracorporeal pig under anesthesia and the perfusate reservoir. Data included oxygen metabolism, vascular resistance, lactate production, left ventricular function, myocardial electrical impedance, and histopathologic injury score. All cross-circulation hearts were successfully perfused for 12 hours, compared with 22 of 40 SP hearts (55%; p = 0.002). Both cross-circulation groups demonstrated higher oxygen consumption and vascular resistance than standard hearts from hours 3-12. No significant differences were seen between XC-blood and XC-plasma hearts in any variable, including left ventricular dP/dT after 12 hours (1478 ± 700 mm Hg/s vs. 872 ± 500; p = 0.17). We conclude that cross circulation of whole blood or plasma from a live animal improves preservation of function of perfused hearts, and cross-circulated plasma performs similarly to cross-circulated whole blood.

Achieving 12 Hour Normothermic Ex Situ Heart Perfusion: An Experience of 40 Porcine Hearts

Although total body perfusion with extracorporeal life support (ECLS) can be maintained for weeks, individual organ perfusion beyond 12 hours has yet to be achieved clinically. Normothermic ex situ heart perfusion (ESHP) offers the potential for prolonged cardiac preservation. We developed an ESHP system to study the effect of perfusate variables on organ preservation, with the ultimate goal of extending organ perfusion for ≥24 hours. Forty porcine hearts were perfused for a target of 12 hours. Hearts that maintained electromechanical activity and had a <3× increase in vascular resistance were considered successful preservations. Perfusion variables, metabolic byproducts, and histopathology were monitored and sampled to identify factors associated with preservation failure. Twenty-two of 40 hearts were successfully preserved at 12 hours. Successful 12 hour experiments demonstrated lower potassium (4.3 ± 0.8 vs. 5.0 ± 1.2 mmol/L; p = 0.018) and lactate (3.5 ± 2.8 vs. 4.5 ± 2.9 mmol/L; p = 0.139) levels, and histopathology revealed less tissue damage (p = 0.003) and less weight gain (p = 0.072). Results of these early experiments suggest prolonged ESHP is feasible, and that elevated lactate and potassium levels are associated with organ failure. Further studies are necessary to identify the ideal perfusate for normothermic ESHP.

Establishing a brain-death donor model in pigs

INTRODUCTION

An animal model that imitates human conditions might be useful not only to monitor pathomechanisms of brain death and biochemical cascades but also to investigate novel strategies to ameliorate organ quality and functionality after multiorgan donation.

METHODS

Brain death was induced in 15 pigs by inserting a catheter into the intracranial space after trephination of the skull and augmenting intracranial pressure until brain stem herniation. Intracranial pressure was monitored continuously; after 60 minutes, brain death diagnostics were performed by a neurologist including electroencephalogram (EEG) and clinical examinations. Clinical examinations included testing of brain stem reflexes as well as apnoe testing; then intensive donor care was performed according to standard guidelines until 24 hours after confirmation of brain death. Intensive donor care was performed according to standard guidelines for 24 hours after brain death.

RESULTS

Sixty minutes after brain-death induction, neurological examination and EEG examination confirmed brain death. Intracranial pressure increased continuously, remaining stable after the occurrence of brain death. All 15 animals showed typical signs of brain death such as diabetes insipidus, hypertensive and hypotensive periods, as well as tachycardia. All symptoms were treated with standard medications. After 24 hours of brain death we performed successful multiorgan retrieval.

DISCUSSION

Brain death can be induced in a pig model by inserting a catheter after trephination of the skull. According to standard guidelines the brain-death diagnosis was established by a flat-line EEG, which occurred in all animals at 60 minutes after induction.

The effect of total spinal anesthesia on cardiac function in a large animal model of brain death

Brain death (BD) causes cardiac dysfunction in organ donors, attributable to the catecholamine storm that occurs with raised intracerebral pressure (ICP). However the direct contribution of the spinal sympathetics has not been well described. We examined the effect of total spinal anesthesia (TSA) on cardiac function in a large animal model of BD. Eighteen pigs were allocated to 3 experimental groups: Group 1, the saline-treated control group; Group 2, TSA administered prior to BD; and Group 3, TSA administered 30 min after BD. Inflation of an intracerebral balloon-tipped catheter was used to induce BD. Ventricular function was assessed using a pressure–volume loop catheter and magnetic resonance imaging. Serum catecholamine levels were assessed with high performance liquid chromatography. Inflation of the intracerebral balloon-tipped catheter was associated with a dramatic rise in heart rate and blood pressure, along with increased concentrations of serum epinephrine and norepinephrine. This phenomenon was not observed in Group 2. In Group 1, there was a significant decline in contractility, whereas groups 2 and 3 saw no change. Group 2 had greater contractile reserve than groups 1 and 3. Our data demonstrate the central role of spinal sympathetics in the hemodynamic response to raised ICP. Further work is required to determine the utility of TSA in reversing cardiac dysfunction in BD donors.

Inflammatory immune responses in a reproducible mouse brain death model

BACKGROUND

Brain death impairs donor organ quality and accelerates immune responses after transplantation. Detailed aspects of immune activation following brain death remain unclear. We have established a mouse model and investigated the immediate consequences of brain death and anesthesia on immune responses.

METHODS

C57JBl/6 mice (n=6/group) were anesthetized with isoflurane (ISF) or ketamine/xylazine (KX); subsequently, animals underwent brain death induction and were followed for 3h under continuous ventilation. Blood pressure was monitored continuously and animals were resuscitated with normal saline to achieve normotension. Immune activation in brain dead animals was analyzed by IFNγ-ELispot, MLR, and flow-cytometry. Sham-operated and naïve animals served as controls.

RESULTS

Blood pressure remained stable in both BD/KX and BD/ISF animals during the 3h observation time. Brain death was linked to systemic immune activation: IFNγ-expression of splenocytes and lymphocyte proliferation rates was significantly elevated subsequent to brain death (p<0.02, <0.01); T-cell activation markers CD28 and CD69 had increased in brain dead animals (p<0.03, <0.02). Isoflurane treatment in sham controls throughout the observation period (3.5h) revealed anesthesia associated IFNγ-expression and lymphocyte activation which were not observed when animals were treated with ketamine/xylazine (p<0.04, <0.009).

CONCLUSIONS

This study reports on a reproducible and hemodynamically stable brain death mouse model. Hemodynamic stability was not impacted through either isoflurane or ketamine/xylazine induction. Of clinical relevance, prolonged anesthesia with isoflurane had been linked to pro-inflammatory cytokine activation. Brain death caused systemic immune activation in organ donors.

Endocrine changes in brain death and transplantation

Following brain death (BD) many hormonal changes occur. These include an increase and then a fall in the levels of circulating catecholamines, reduced levels of anti-diuretic hormone and cortisol as well as alterations in the hypothalamic-pituitary thyroid axis consistent with the non-thyroidal illness syndrome. In an era when the numbers of potential recipients listed for transplantation are greater than the number of donors, with an increasing donor age, a detailed knowledge of the endocrine changes and pathophysiological consequences of these is essential to optimise the management of the brain-stem dead organ donor. There still remains significant debate as to whether hormone replacement therapy to correct the observed changes is beneficial.

Primary graft failure after heart transplantation

Primary graft failure (PGF) is a devastating complication that occurs in the immediate postoperative period following heart transplantation. It manifests as severe ventricular dysfunction of the donor graft and carries significant mortality and morbidity. In the last decade, advances in pharmacological treatment and mechanical circulatory support have improved the outlook for heart transplant recipients who develop this complication. Despite these advances in treatment, PGF is still the leading cause of death in the first 30 days after transplantation. In today's climate of significant organ shortages and growing waiting lists, transplant units worldwide have increasingly utilised "marginal donors" to try and bridge the gap between "supply and demand." One of the costs of this strategy has been an increased incidence of PGF. As the threat of PGF increases, the challenges of predicting and preventing its occurrence, as well as the identification of more effective treatment modalities, are vital areas of active research and development.

Contribution of large pig for renal ischemia-reperfusion and transplantation studies: the preclinical model

Animal experimentation is necessary to characterize human diseases and design adequate therapeutic interventions. In renal transplantation research, the limited number of in vitro models involves a crucial role for in vivo models and particularly for the porcine model. Pig and human kidneys are anatomically similar (characterized by multilobular structure in contrast to rodent and dog kidneys unilobular). The human proximity of porcine physiology and immune systems provides a basic knowledge of graft recovery and inflammatory physiopathology through in vivo studies. In addition, pig large body size allows surgical procedures similar to humans, repeated collections of peripheral blood or renal biopsies making pigs ideal for medical training and for the assessment of preclinical technologies. However, its size is also its main drawback implying expensive housing. Nevertheless, pig models are relevant alternatives to primate models, offering promising perspectives with developments of transgenic modulation and marginal donor models facilitating data extrapolation to human conditions.

Contribution of Toll-like receptor activation to lung damage after donor brain death

INTRODUCTION

Donor brain death is the first injurious event that can produce inflammatory dysfunction after pulmonary transplantation. This study was designed to determine whether stimulation of the toll-like receptor (TLR) system contributes to the changes produced by brain death.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Rats were repeatedly treated with specific agonists for TLR4 or TLR2/6 to desensitize these receptors. Brain death was then induced by inflation of a balloon catheter within the extradural space. Mean arterial pressure changes and inflammatory markers were measured serially by protein and mRNA analysis.

RESULTS

Both desensitizing pretreatments prevented the neurogenic hypotension (P<0.001) and metabolic acidosis (P<0.001) observed in control animals after brain death. These treatments also reduced the levels of tumor necrosis factor-α and CXCL1 in serum and bronchoalveolar lavage fluid, although desensitization of TLR4 produced a greater inhibition than desensitization of TLR2. Desensitization of TLR4 also reduced (P<0.05) expression of the adhesive integrin CD11b on blood neutrophils after brain death. Examination of mRNA levels in lung tissue 5 hr after brain death showed that desensitization of TLR4 limited the expression of interferon (IFN)-γ, IFNβ, and CXCL10, whereas desensitization of TLR2/6 reduced only the expression of IFNγ.

CONCLUSION

These results indicate that activation of TLR signaling pathways can contribute to the lung damage produced by brain death; this may increase subsequent graft injury after transplantation.

The effects of acute triiodothyronine therapy on myocardial gene expression in brain stem dead cardiac donors

CONTEXT

After brain stem death (BSD), a low T(3) state is common, and T(3) supplementation has been advocated to improve heart function and yield for transplantation.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of the study was to assess the effects of T(3) on expression of mRNAs encoding T(3)-responsive genes in the post-BSD human heart.

DESIGN

Within a prospective double-blind trial, potential BSD cardiac donors undergoing hemodynamic optimization were randomized to T(3) (0.8 microg . kg(-1) bolus; infusion 0.113 microg . kg(-1) . h(-1)) or placebo (5% dextrose) for up to 6 h. Left ventricular biopsies were obtained at end-assessment from 30 donors (T(3); n=16). TaqMan real-time PCR was performed to investigate mRNA expression of the voltage-gated potassium channel Kv1.5, beta-1 adrenergic receptor (ADRB1), sarcoplasmic reticulum calcium ATPase type 2a (SERCA2a), and phospholamban (PLB).

RESULTS

Time between diagnosis of BSD and donor management was 13.2 h (range, 9.7-16.8 h). T(3) donors were managed for 7.6 (6.9-8.3) h. Median serum free T(3) (fT3) at baseline was 2.9 (2.3-3.8) pmol . liter(-1) (reference range, 3.3-7.5 pmol . liter(-1)). At baseline, 19 of 30 (56.7%) had low serum fT3, and T(3) treatment increased fT3 to supraphysiological levels (P < 0.001). Expression of mRNAs encoding Kv1.5 and SERCA2a was increased 1.99-fold and 1.51-fold (P = 0.015 and 0.043). There was no significant change in the expression of mRNAs encoding ADRB1 and PLB. Treatment with T(3) did not improve hemodynamic function compared with placebo.

CONCLUSIONS

Acute administration of T(3) in the BSD cardiac donor reverses the low T(3) state and increases expression of the mRNAs encoding Kv1.5 and SERCA2a, but not ADRB1 or PLB and is not associated with any improvement in hemodynamic performance.

Combining cariporide with glyceryl trinitrate optimizes cardiac preservation during porcine heart transplantation

Sodium-hydrogen exchange inhibitors, such as cariporide, are potent cardioprotective agents, however, safety concerns have been raised about intravenously (i.v.) administered cariporide in humans. The aim of this study was to develop a preservation strategy that maintained cariporide's cardioprotective efficacy during heart transplantation while minimizing recipient exposure. We utilized a porcine model of orthotopic heart transplantation that incorporated donor brain death and 14 h static heart storage. Five groups were studied: control (CON), hearts stored in Celsior; CAR1, hearts stored in Celsior with donors and recipients receiving cariporide (2 mg/kg i.v.) prior to explantation and reperfusion, respectively; CAR2, hearts stored in Celsior supplemented with cariporide (10 mumol/L); GTN, hearts stored in Celsior supplemented with glyceryl trinitrate (GTN) (100 mg/L); and COMB, hearts stored in Celsior supplemented with cariporide (10 mumol/L) plus GTN (100 mg/L). A total of 5/5 CAR1 and 5/6 COMB recipients were weaned from cardiopulmonary bypass compared with 1/5 CON, 1/5 CAR2 and 0/5 GTN animals (p = 0.001). Hearts from the CAR1 and COMB groups demonstrated similar cardiac function and troponin release after transplantation. Supplementation of Celsior with cariporide plus GTN provided superior donor heart preservation to supplementation with either agent alone and equivalent preservation to that observed with systemic administration of cariporide to the donor and recipient.

Systemic inflammation in the brain-dead organ donor

Brain death itself impairs organ function in the potential donor, thereby limiting the number of suitable organs for transplantation. In addition, graft survival of kidneys obtained from brain-dead (BD) donors is inferior to that of kidneys obtained from living donors. Experimental studies confirm an inferior graft survival for the heart, liver and lungs from BD compared with living donors. The mechanism underlying the deteriorating effect of brain death on the organs has not yet been fully established. We know that brain death triggers massive circulatory, hormonal and metabolic changes. Moreover, the past 10 years have produced evidence that brain death is associated with a systemic inflammatory response. However, it remains uncertain whether the inflammation is induced by brain death itself or by events before and after becoming BD. The purpose of this study is to discuss the risk factors associated with brain death in general and the inflammatory response in the organs in particular. Special attention will be paid to the heart, lung, liver and kidney and evidence will be presented from clinical and experimental studies.

Hemodynamic resuscitation with arginine vasopressin reduces lung injury after brain death in the transplant donor

BACKGROUND

The autonomic storm accompanying brain death leads to neurogenic pulmonary edema and triggers development of systemic and pulmonary inflammatory responses. Neurogenic vasoplegia exacerbates the pulmonary injury caused by brain death and primes the lung for ischemia reperfusion injury and primary graft dysfunction in the recipient. Donor resuscitation with norepinephrine ameliorates the inflammatory response to brain death, however norepinephrine has deleterious effects, particularly on the heart. We tested the hypothesis that arginine vasopressin is a suitable alternative to norepinephrine in managing the hypotensive brain dead donor.

METHODS

Brain death was induced in Wistar rats by intracranial balloon inflation. Pulmonary capillary leak was estimated using radioiodinated albumin. Development of pulmonary edema was assessed by measurement of wet and dry lung weights. Cell surface expression of CD11b/CD18 by neutrophils was determined using flow cytometry. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays were used to measure the levels of TNFalpha, IL-1beta, CINC-1, and CINC-3 in serum and bronchoalveolar lavage. Quantitative reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to determine the expression of cytokine mRNA (IL-1beta, CINC-1 and CINC-3) in lung tissue.

RESULTS

There was a significant increase in pulmonary capillary permeability, wet/dry lung weight ratios, neutrophil integrin expression and pro-inflammatory cytokines in serum (TNFalpha, IL-1beta, CINC-1 and CINC-3), bronchoalveolar lavage (TNFalpha and IL-1beta) and lung tissue (IL-1beta and CINC-1) in braindead animals compared to controls. Correction of neurogenic hypotension with either arginine vasopressin or norepinephrine limits edema, reduces pulmonary capillary leak, and modulates systemic and pulmonary inflammatory responses to brain death.

CONCLUSIONS

Arginine vasopressin and norepinephrine are equally effective in treating the hypotensive pulmonary donor in this rodent model.