The temperature influence on the spontaneous mutation rate. I. Literature review

Challenges and opportunities for plant viruses under a climate change scenario

There is an increasing societal awareness on the enormous threat that climate change may pose for human, animal and plant welfare. Although direct effects due to exposure to heat, drought or elevated greenhouse gasses seem to be progressively more obvious, indirect effects remain debatable. A relevant aspect to be clarified relates to the relationship between altered environmental conditions and pathogen-induced diseases. In the particular case of plant viruses, it is still unclear whether climate change will primarily represent an opportunity for the emergence of new infections in previously uncolonized areas and hosts, or if it will mostly be a strong constrain reducing the impact of plant virus diseases and challenging the pathogen's adaptive capacity. This review focuses on current knowledge on the relationship between climate change and the outcome plant-virus interactions. We summarize work done on how this relationship modulates plant virus pathogenicity, between-host transmission (which include the triple interaction plant-virus-vector), ecology, evolution and management of the epidemics they cause. Considering these studies, we propose avenues for future research on this subject.

Investigations concerning the impact of consumption of hot beverages on acute cytotoxic and genotoxic effects in oral mucosa cells

Consumption of very hot beverages and foods increases the incidence of oral and esophageal cancer but the mechanisms are not known and the critical temperature is not well defined. We realized a study with exfoliated cells from the oral cavity of individuals (n = 73) that live in an area in Iran which has the highest incidence of EC worldwide. Consumption of beverages at very high temperatures is a characteristic feature of this population. We analyzed biomarkers which are (i) indicative for genetic instability (micronuclei that are formed as a consequence of chromosomal damage, nuclear buds which are a consequence of gene amplifications and binucleated cells which reflect mitotic disturbances), (ii) markers that reflect cytotoxic effects (condensed chromatin, karyorrhectic, karyolitic and pyknotic cells), (iii) furthermore, we determined the number of basal cells which is indicative for the regenerative capacity of the buccal mucosa. The impact of the drinking temperature on the frequencies of these parameters was monitored with thermometers. We found no evidence for induction of genetic damage but an increase of the cytotoxic effects with the temperature was evident. This effect was paralleled by an increase of the cell division rate of the mucosa which was observed when the temperature exceeded 60 °C. Our findings indicate that cancer in the upper digestive tract in drinkers of very hot beverages is not caused by damage of the genetic material but by an increase of the cell division rate as a consequence of cytotoxic effects which take place at temperatures over 60 °C. It is known from earlier experiments with rodents that increased cell divisions lead to tumor promotion in the esophagus. Our findings provide a mechanistic explanation and indicate that increased cancer risks can be expected when the drinking temperature of beverages exceeds 60 °C.

Temperature affects the repeatability of evolution in the microbial eukaryote Tetrahymena thermophila

Evolutionary biologists have long sought to understand what factors affect the repeatability of adaptive outcomes. To better understand the role of temperature in determining the repeatability of adaptive trajectories, we evolved populations of different genotypes of the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila at low and high temperatures and followed changes in growth rate over 6,500 generations. As expected, growth rate increased with a decelerating rate for all populations; however, there were differences in the patterns of evolution at the two temperatures. The growth rates of the different genotypes tended to converge as evolution proceeded at both temperatures, but this convergence was quicker and more pronounced at the higher temperature. Additionally, over the first 4,000 generations we found greater repeatability of evolution, in terms of change in growth rate, among replicates of the same genotype at the higher temperature. Finally, we found limited evidence of trade-offs in fitness between temperatures, and an asymmetry in the correlated responses, whereby evolution in a high temperature increases growth rate at the lower temperature significantly more than the reverse. These results demonstrate the importance of temperature in determining the repeatability of evolutionary trajectories for the eukaryotic microbe Tetrahymena thermophila and may provide clues to how temperature affects evolution more generally.

Temperature dependence of spontaneous mutation rates

Mutation is the source of genetic variation and the fundament of evolution. Temperature has long been suggested to have a direct impact on realized spontaneous mutation rates. If mutation rates vary in response to environmental conditions, such as the variation of the ambient temperature through space and time, they should no longer be described as species-specific constants. By combining mutation accumulation with whole-genome sequencing in a multicellular organism, we provide empirical support to reject the null hypothesis of a constant, temperature-independent mutation rate. Instead, mutation rates depended on temperature in a U-shaped manner with increasing rates toward both temperature extremes. This relation has important implications for mutation-dependent processes in molecular evolution, processes shaping the evolution of mutation rates, and even the evolution of biodiversity as such.

Estimation of the Genome-Wide Mutation Rate and Spectrum in the Archaeal Species Haloferax volcanii

Organisms adapted to life in extreme habitats (extremophiles) can further our understanding of the mechanisms of genetic stability, particularly replication and repair. Despite the harsh environmental conditions they endure, these extremophiles represent a great deal of the Earth's biodiversity. Here, for the first time in a member of the archaeal domain, we report a genome-wide assay of spontaneous mutations in the halophilic species Haloferax volcanii using a direct and unbiased method: mutation accumulation experiments combined with deep whole-genome sequencing. H. volcanii is a key model organism not only for the study of halophilicity, but also for archaeal biology in general. Our methods measure the genome-wide rate, spectrum, and spatial distribution of spontaneous mutations. The estimated base substitution rate of 3.15 × 10^-10 per site per generation, or 0.0012 per genome per generation, is similar to the value found in mesophilic prokaryotes (optimal growth at ∼20-45°). This study contributes to a comprehensive phylogenetic view of how evolutionary forces and molecular mechanisms shape the rate and molecular spectrum of mutations across the tree of life.

Stability of the Salmonella Typhimurium rcsC11 mutant under different stress conditions

The virulence genes of Salmonella are modulated during infection by several regulatory systems, and the RcsCDB system is one of the most important of these. The S. Typhimurium EG14873 (rcsC11) strain harbours the rcsC11 point mutation, displaying a constitutive activation of this system, which is characterized by mucoid colonies and attenuated virulence phenotypes. In this work, the stability of the rcsC11 mutation was analysed under stress conditions. Under acid and anaerobic stresses, we observed the appearance of small and non-mucoid colonies of the rcsC11 strain. The sequencing of the rcsC gene from these colonies showed that the mutation is conserved. Moreover, we found that small colonies were also generated when the wild-type strain grew in acid and anaerobic conditions. It is worth noting that the transition from normal to atypical colonies of both strains only took place after several days of incubation and was not observed during eukaryotic cell infection. Therefore, the appearance of these atypical colonies is a characteristic feature of S. Typhimurium strains under stressful situations and does not involve a reversion of the rcsC11 allele and nor does it imply any risk to mammalian cells. Therefore, we propose that the S. Typhimurium rcsC11 strain is a good candidate for the development of attenuated vaccines.

Temperature responses of mutation rate and mutational spectrum in an Escherichia coli strain and the correlation with metabolic rate

Background

Temperature is a major determinant of spontaneous mutation, but the precise mode, and the underlying mechanisms, of the temperature influences remain less clear. Here we used a mutation accumulation approach combined with whole-genome sequencing to investigate the temperature dependence of spontaneous mutation in an Escherichia coli strain. Experiments were performed under aerobic conditions at 25, 28 and 37 °C, three temperatures that were non-stressful for the bacterium but caused significantly different bacterial growth rates.

Results

Mutation rate did not differ between 25 and 28 °C, but was higher at 37 °C. Detailed analyses of the molecular spectrum of mutations were performed; and a particularly interesting finding is that higher temperature led to a bias of mutation to coding, relative to noncoding, DNA. Furthermore, the temperature response of mutation rate was extremely similar to that of metabolic rate, consistent with an idea that metabolic rate predicts mutation rate.

Conclusions

Temperature affects mutation rate and the types of mutation supply, both being crucial for the opportunity of natural selection. Our results help understand how temperature drives evolutionary speed of organisms and thus the global patterns of biodiversity. This study also lend support to the metabolic theory of ecology for linking metabolic rate and molecular evolution rate.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12862-018-1252-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Human Germline Mutation and the Erratic Evolutionary Clock

Our understanding of the chronology of human evolution relies on the “molecular clock” provided by the steady accumulation of substitutions on an evolutionary lineage. Recent analyses of human pedigrees have called this understanding into question by revealing unexpectedly low germline mutation rates, which imply that substitutions accrue more slowly than previously believed. Translating mutation rates estimated from pedigrees into substitution rates is not as straightforward as it may seem, however. We dissect the steps involved, emphasizing that dating evolutionary events requires not “a mutation rate” but a precise characterization of how mutations accumulate in development in males and females—knowledge that remains elusive.

How many tautomerization pathways connect Watson-Crick-like G*·T DNA base mispair and wobble mismatches?

In this study, we have theoretically demonstrated the intrinsic ability of the wobble G·T(w)/G*·T*(w)/G·T(w1)/G·T(w2) and Watson-Crick-like G*·T(WC) DNA base mispairs to interconvert into each other via the DPT tautomerization. We have established that among all these transitions, only one single G·T(w) ↔ G*·T(WC) pathway is eligible from a biological perspective. It involves short-lived intermediate - the G·T*(WC) base mispair - and is governed by the planar, highly stable, and zwitterionic [Formula: see text] transition state stabilized by the participation of the unique pattern of the five intermolecular O6(+)H⋯O4(-), O6(+)H⋯N3(-), N1(+)H⋯N3(-), N1(+)H⋯O2(-), and N2(+)H⋯O2(-) H-bonds. This non-dissociative G·T(w) ↔ G*·T(WC) tautomerization occurs without opening of the pair: Bases within mispair remain connected by 14 different patterns of the specific intermolecular interactions that successively change each other along the IRC. Novel kinetically controlled mechanism of the thermodynamically non-equilibrium spontaneous point GT/TG incorporation errors has been suggested. The mutagenic effect of the analogues of the nucleotide bases, in particular 5-bromouracil, can be attributed to the decreasing of the barrier of the acquisition by the wobble pair containing these compounds of the enzymatically competent Watson-Crick's geometry via the intrapair mutagenic tautomerization directly in the essentially hydrophobic recognition pocket of the replication DNA-polymerase machinery. Proposed approaches are able to explain experimental data, namely growth of the rate of the spontaneous point incorporation errors during DNA biosynthesis with increasing temperature.

On genetic information uncertainty and the mutator phenotype in cancer

Recent evidence supports the existence of a mutator phenotype in cancer cells, although the mechanistic basis remains unknown. In this paper, it is shown that this enhanced genetic instability is generated by an amplified measurement uncertainty on genetic information during DNA replication. At baseline, an inherent measurement uncertainty implies an imprecision of the recognition, replication and transfer genetic information, and forms the basis for an intrinsic genetic instability in all biological cells. Genetic information is contained in the sequence of DNA bases, each existing due to proton tunnelling, as a coherent superposition of quantum states composed of both the canonical and rare tautomeric forms until decoherence by interaction with DNA polymerase. The result of such a quantum measurement process may be interpreted classically as akin to a Bernoulli trial, whose outcome X is random and can be either of two possibilities, depending on whether the proton is tunnelled (X=1) or not (X=0). This inherent quantum uncertainty is represented by a binary entropy function and quantified in terms of Shannon information entropy H(X)=-P(X=1)log(2)P(X=1)-P(X=0)log(2)P(X=0). Enhanced genetic instability may either be directly derived from amplified uncertainty induced by increases in quantum and thermodynamic fluctuation, or indirectly arise from the loss of natural uncertainty reduction mechanisms.

Efficient transposition of IS204-derived plasmids in Streptomyces coelicolor

In order to study functional gene expression in Streptomyces coelicolor, a mini-transposon encoding the apramycin resistance gene aac(3)IV within its inverted repeat (IR) boundaries was constructed based on IS204, which was previously identified in the genome of Nocardia asteroides YP21. The mini-transposon and IS204 transposase gene were then put on a kanamycin-resistant conjugative plasmid pDZY101 that can only replicate in Escherichia coli. After mating with S. coelicolor A3(2) M145, resistant colonies arose efficiently on both apramycin and kanamycin plates. Plasmid rescue indicated that entire plasmids were inserted into the M145 genome with cleavage at an inverted repeat junction formed by the right inverted repeat (IRR) and the last 18bp of the transposase gene, while the left inverted repeat (IRL) was untouched. Southern blot analysis of the mutants using an aac(3)IV gene probe showed that transposition of plasmid pDZY101 was genetically stable, with a single-copy insertion within the S. coelicolor M145 genome. Several mutagenesis libraries of S. coelicolor M145 were constructed using plasmid pDZY101 derivatives and the transposon insertion site was determined. The correlation between novel mutant phenotypes and previously uncharacterized genes was established and these transposon locations were widely scattered around the genome.

Direct determination of the influence of extreme temperature on transposition and structural mutation rates of Drosophila melanogaster mobile elements

Two sets of mutation accumulation lines, one reared at 28 degrees C and the other at 24 degrees C, were compared for their transposition and rearrangement rates of eleven transposable element families. The changes affecting mobile elements were analysed by the Southern technique and in situ hybridization. No differences were found between treated and control lines. The role of the host genotype in transposition control and the significance of structural mutations in transposable element dynamics are discussed.

Influence of climatic conditions on the mutations in pollen mother cells of Tradescantia clone 4430 and implications for the Trad-MCN bioassay protocol

The present was study aimed at investigating the influence of relative humidity and temperature on spontaneous and pollution-induced mutation rates during exposure and recovery periods in the Trad-MCN test. Cuttings of Tradescantia clone 4430 were exposed to a negative control, to 4 mM maleic hydrazide (MH), and to a polluted water sample under varying conditions of air temperature and humidity in climatic chamber experiments. The relative humidity did not affect the spontaneous mutation rate in the clone investigated, but was negatively correlated with the frequency of pollution-induced mutations. Low temperature caused an increase in the number of micronuclei in the negative control, but no comparable response in polluted samples. At an extremely high temperature, signs of strong physiological damage and/or of a meiotic delay of pollen maturation were detected. When the temperature increased gradually and the extreme value was maintained only for short time, such detrimental effects were not observed. Subsequent treatment with high and low temperatures, by contrast, resulted in the highest MCN rates of all experiments. Our studies point to the possibility of producing irregular results of the Trad-MCN test if the influence of climatic factors has not sufficiently been considered.

The mutagenic potential of hyperthermia and fever in mice

The cytogenetic effects of hyperthermia resulting from climatic influences as well as from infections were studied. Whole-body exposure of NMRI mice to an elevated environmental temperature induced a high frequency of micronucleated polychromatic erythrocytes in bone marrow. Hyperthermia at high relative humidity was more effective in increasing body temperature and cytogenetic damage than at low RH. A sex-related difference in response to heat stress was observed. Hyperthermia on pregnant mice induced a significant increase in the incidence of micronucleated PEs in fetal blood cells. Parenteral administration of bacterial endotoxin, lipopolysaccharides, induced either hypothermia or hyperthermia. However, LPS-induced hypothermia as well as fever does not so far appear to produce cytogenetic damage.

Effect of temperature on mutation in cultured human skin fibroblasts

Because clothing enhances the gonadal temperature in the human male and because as a consequence of that the spontaneous mutation rate might be increased, a study was undertaken to determine the effect of temperature on mutation towards HPRT deficiency in human diploid skin fibroblasts. Culturing of the cells in HAT medium containing azaserine, to remove pre-existing mutants, was highly mutagenic. Some results suggested that azaserine acts as an indirect mutagen. The mutational process in the presence of azaserine was influenced by temperature, a rise in temperature from 33 to 37 degrees C leading to a more than 10-fold increase in mutation rate per cell generation. This temperature dependence, taken as a starting point for the estimation of the consequences of the rise in gonadal temperature, could be responsible for an increase of 135% in the incidence of a sex-linked lethal (Lesch-Nyhan) in the human population. Epidemiological data on the frequency of Lesch-Nyhan disease and on the ratio of paternal and maternal mutations leading to Lesch-Nyhan disease do not contradict the findings in the cultured cells.

The genetic effects of elevated temperature in the yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The growth of yeast cultures at supra-optimal temperatures up to 39 degrees C and exposure in non-nutrient solution up to 52 degrees C has been examined for the induction of genetic change. Both sets of conditions lead to the induction of mutation to antibiotic resistance, mitotic gene conversion, crossing-over and mitotic chromosomal non-disjunction.