Assessing the allozyme variation in cultivars and Swedish landraces of rye (Secale cereale L.)

Investigation of obsolete diversity of rye (Secale cereale L.) using multiplexed SSR fingerprinting and evaluation of agronomic traits

Common rye (Secale cereale L.) is one of the most important cereals in Europe. Nevertheless, its germplasm collections are among the least numerous compared with cereals. There are only about 27,000 Secale accessions in 70 gene banks around the world. Despite extensive research on the molecular characterization of genetic resources, only a fraction of this collection has been described. The main objective of the presented study was to perform genotypic and phenotypic characterization of an obsolete gene pool represented by 100 accessions originated from 28 countries around the world and preserved in the gene bank of the Polish Academy of Sciences Botanical Garden - Center for Biological Diversity Conservation in Powsin. Genetic analysis using simple sequence repeat markers showed that the obsolete gene pool is relatively large. This indicates that different sources of variability were used in breeding programs. However, the genetic variation is in no way related to the place of origin. Despite the great differences in the genetic make-up, the collection showed a broadly common phenotype. This could result in a low level of interest among breeders in the stored germplasm, undervalued as a source of important but not easily observable traits, e.g., high disease resistance, which was found in some accessions.

Phylogeny and genetic structure in the genus Secale

Secale L. is a small but important genus that includes cultivated rye. Although genetic diversity of cultivated rye is high, patterns of genetic diversity in the whole genus, and potential factors affecting the distribution of genetic diversity remain elusive. The population structure and distribution of genetic variation within Secale, and its correlation with taxonomic delimitation, cultivation status or spatial distribution in relation to geography and climate zones were analyzed in this study. A collection of 726 individual plants derived from 139 different accessions representing Secale cereale, S. vavilovii, S. strictum, and S. sylvestre were investigated using SSR analysis and sequence diversity analysis of a nuclear EST region. Our results indicated that perennial S. strictum subspecies are genetically divergent from annual forms of the genus. Existence of two distinct clusters within the annual taxa was observed, one corresponding to samples from Asia, and a second to those outside of Asia. No clear genetic structure was observed between different annual species/subspecies, indicating introgression between these taxa. The analysis of cultivated rye revealed that landrace populations from the Middle East have the highest genetic diversity, supporting the idea of the area being the center of origin for cultivated rye. Considering high adaptive potential of those populations, Middle Eastern landraces should be regarded as genetic resources reservoirs for new niches and future breeding programs.

Geographical distribution of genetic diversity in Secale landrace and wild accessions

BACKGROUND

Rye, Secale cereale L., has historically been a crop of major importance and is still a key cereal in many parts of Europe. Single populations of cultivated rye have been shown to capture a large proportion of the genetic diversity present in the species, but the distribution of genetic diversity in subspecies and across geographical areas is largely unknown. Here we explore the structure of genetic diversity in landrace rye and relate it to that of wild and feral relatives.

RESULTS

A total of 567 SNPs were analysed in 434 individuals from 76 accessions of wild, feral and cultivated rye. Genetic diversity was highest in cultivated rye, slightly lower in feral rye taxa and significantly lower in the wild S. strictum Presl. and S. africanum Stapf. Evaluation of effects from ascertainment bias suggests underestimation of diversity primarily in S. strictum and S. africanum. Levels of ascertainment bias, STRUCTURE and principal component analyses all supported the proposed classification of S. africanum and S. strictum as a separate species from S. cereale. S. afghanicum (Vav.) Roshev, S. ancestrale Zhuk., S. dighoricum (Vav.) Roshev, S. segetale (Zhuk.) Roshev and S. vavilovii Grossh. seemed, in contrast, to share the same gene pool as S. cereale and their genetic clustering was more dependent on geographical origin than taxonomic classification. S. vavilovii was found to be the most likely wild ancestor of cultivated rye. Among cultivated rye landraces from Europe, Asia and North Africa five geographically discrete genetic clusters were identified. These had only limited overlap with major agro-climatic zones. Slash-and-burn rye from the Finnmark area in Scandinavia formed a distinct cluster with little similarity to other landrace ryes. Regional studies of Northern and South-West Europe demonstrate different genetic distribution patterns as a result of varying cultivation intensity.

CONCLUSIONS

With the exception of S. strictum and S. africanum different rye taxa share the majority of the genetic variation. Due to the vast sharing of genetic diversity within the S. cereale clade, ascertainment bias seems to be a lesser problem in rye than in predominantly selfing species. By exploiting within accession diversity geographic structure can be shown on a much finer scale than previously reported.

Genetic Distinctiveness of Rye In situ Accessions from Portugal Unveils a New Hotspot of Unexplored Genetic Resources

Rye (Secale cereale L.) is a cereal crop of major importance in many parts of Europe and rye breeders are presently very concerned with the restrict pool of rye genetic resources available. Such narrowing of rye genetic diversity results from the presence of "Petkus" pool in most modern rye varieties as well as "Petkus" × "Carsten" heterotic pool in hybrid rye breeding programs. Previous studies on rye's genetic diversity revealed moreover a common genetic background on landraces (ex situ) and cultivars, regardless of breeding level or geographical origin. Thus evaluation of in situ populations is of utmost importance to unveil "on farm" diversity, which is largely undervalued. Here, we perform the first comprehensive assessment of rye's genetic diversity and population structuring using cultivars, ex situ landraces along a comprehensive sampling of in situ accessions from Portugal, through a molecular-directed analysis using SSRs markers. Rye genetic diversity and population structure analysis does not present any geographical trend but disclosed marked differences between genetic backgrounds of in situ accessions and those of cultivars/ex situ collections. Such genetic distinctiveness of in situ accessions highlights their unexplored potential as new genetic resources, which can be used to boost rye breeding strategies and the production of new varieties. Overall, our study successfully demonstrates the high prospective impact of comparing genetic diversity and structure of cultivars, ex situ, and in situ samples in ascertaining the status of plant genetic resources (PGR).

Assessment of Genetic Diversity in Secale cereale Based on SSR Markers

The primary aim of this study was to estimate genetic diversity among Secale cereale L. accessions using 22 previously published simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers. The plant material included 367 rye accessions comprising historical and contemporary cultivars, cultivated materials, landraces, and breeding strains from the Polish breeding company Danko. The studied accessions represented a wide geographical diversity. Several methods were employed to analyze genetic diversity among the Secale cereale L. accessions and to determine population structure: principal coordinate analysis (PCoA), neighbor-joining (NJ), and Bayesian clustering. We also defined a core collection of 25 rye accessions representing over 93 % of SSR alleles. The results of these analyses showed that accessions from the rye gene bank are clearly divergent in comparison with materials received directly from European breeding companies. Our findings suggest also that the genetic pool of current rye cultivars is becoming narrower during breeding processes. The selected panel of SSR markers performed well in detection of genetic diversity patterns and can be recommended for future germplasm characterization studies in rye.

Genetic diversity amongst landraces of rye (Secale cereale L.) from northern Europe

Genetic variation and diversity were estimated for three improved varieties and 18 landraces of Secale cereale, originating from the northern Europe. This material was compared with eight improved varieties and 16 landraces from Sweden, which were analysed before. The analysis used starch gel electrophoresis with the enzymes ACO, GPI, MDH, PGD and PGM and resulted in one fixed locus and seven polymorphic loci. Most of the genetic diversity was found within the accessions and it was very small between accessions. The results show that the landraces from Germany and Norway have a low genetic variation compared to the other landraces in this study. This can possibly be explained with a small original sample size of some accessions. However, in the dendrogram these accessions are well separated. The landraces from Sweden and Finland showed a high genetic variation, which is almost the same for all these accessions. In the dendrogram all of the Finnish landraces and 11 of the Swedish ones were grouped together with a very small diversity index; they can almost be considered as part of the same accession. This is probably due to the fact that a high number of Finnish immigrants arrived in Sweden during the 17th century bringing their own rye material. The early Finnish rye landraces may have the same original source. The data also show that landraces as well as improved varieties have a high heterozygosity but they are separated in the dendrogram into different clusters. The currently used varieties show a large genetic distance variation, different from that in the landraces.

Geographic and altitudinal allozyme variation in sorghum (Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench) landraces from Ethiopia and Eritrea

The amount and distribution of genetic variation was investigated in 48 sorghum landrace accessions, representing 13 regions of origin and three adaptation zones (lowland, intermediate and highland elevation) in Ethiopia and Eritrea. Assaying 11 enzymes systems, 23 putative loci were scored for a total of 27 alleles. Nineteen loci were monomorphic and fixed for the same allele, while the remaining 4 loci, each with 2 alleles, were polymorphic across the 48 accessions. The results show significant differences in allele frequencies among the accessions, regions of origin and the adaptation zones. However, all measures of genetic variation used show that the accessions maintained much lower levels of variation than the corresponding mean values for self-pollinating crop plants, confirming previous conclusions that sorghum is depauperated in allozymic variation. The total gene diversity was 0.25, which partitioned 59% within and 41% among accessions. The latter was largely due to variation among accessions within the adaptation zones (38%), while only 3% was due to variation among accessions between the adaptation zones. Similarly, most of the total gene diversity was found within the regions of origin (80%) and within the adaptation zones (97%). Both the dendrogram constructed from NEI's unbiased genetic distance and the plot of the first two principal components distinguished three groups of regions. The level of gene flow was low among accessions, regions of origin and among accessions within adaptation zones, but high among adaptation zones. The results are discussed with emphasis on genetic resources conservation and utilization.

Extent and patterns of RAPD variation in landraces and cultivars of rye (Secale cereale L.) from northern Europe

Little is known about the extent and patterns of distribution of RAPD diversity in outcrossing species. This study is the first step in using RAPD markers to quantify the amount and distribution of genetic variation within and between accessions of 9 landraces and 3 cultivars of cultivated rye from Northern Europe. A high level of RAPD variation was detected, demonstrating the utility of RAPDs for genetic characterisation in rye. The results show that: (1) landraces and improved cultivars maintain roughly the same high levels of RAPD variation, (2) landraces from Norway, Germany and Finland showed the lowest level of variation, probably because of a small amount of seeds from the original samples, (3) most of the RAPD variation was found within rather than between the accessions, which is consistent with the pattern expected for a cross pollinated crop. Both the cluster and the principal coordinates analyses displayed the same pattern of genetic relationship among the accessions studied.

Phylogenetic relationships among Portuguese rye based on isozyme, RAPD and ISSR markers

The phylogenetic relationships of 10 rye landraces and cultivars from the north of Portugal and from Brazil were analysed using 20 isozyme loci, and a total of 511 PCR markers (342 ISSRs and 169 RAPDs). The isozymes were analysed in at least 100 plants of each population/cultivar and, therefore, we have data about intra and inter population/cultivar genetic variability. However, the analyses with ISSRs and RAPDs were obtained using a mix of 25 plants of each population. Therefore, each population/cultivar was reduced to one tube and we have no data about intra genetic variability. As expected in a cross pollinated crop we found genetic diversity and a larger variation within than among the populations using isozymes. Somewhat unexpectedly, however, we found that the breeding cultivars have the same level of heterozygosity as the landraces. The phylogenetic relationships obtained using isozymes among the landraces, synthetic cultivar and the cultivars from breeding programs do not reflect their origin. Moreover, the cultivar from Brazil is not separated from the remaining populations/cultivars studied. However, the data observed using RAPDs and ISSRs are in agreement with their known origin. The populations maintained by the farmers in the north of Portugal are grouped in a cluster in the phenogram and the C902591 (from Brazil), the Alvão (synthetic variety) and Larouco (a hybrid between Montalegre and Brazil) are in a different cluster. The ISSRs and RAPDs provide a rapid method for the production of polymorphic markers, which appear to correspond to known pedigree information.

Genetic diversity of allozymes in turnip (Brassica rapa L. var. rapa) from the Nordic area

Genetic diversity and relationships based on isozymes were studied in 31 accessions of turnip (Brassica rapa L. var. rapa). The material included varieties, elite stocks, landraces and older turnip of slash-and-burn type from the Nordic area. A total of 9 isozyme loci and 26 alleles were studied. The isozyme systems were ACO, DIA, GPI, GOT, PGM, PGD and SKD. The level of heterozygosity was reduced in the landraces, but it was high for the variety group 'Ostersundom'. Turnip has a higher genetic variation than other crops within B. rapa and than in other species with the same breeding system. The genetic diversity showed that 18.7% of the genetic variation was within the accessions, and the total H tau value was 0.358. Gpi-I and Pgd-I showed the lowest variation compared with the other loci. The cluster analysis revealed five clusters, with one main cluster including 25 of the 31 accessions. The dendrogram indicated that the variety group 'Ostersundom' clustered together whereas the variety group 'Bortfelder' was associated with country of origin. The landraces were spread in different clusters. The 'slash-and-burn' type of turnip belonged to two groups.

Patterns and levels of genetic differentiation in North American populations of the Alaskan wheatgrass complex

Levels and distribution of genetic variation were assessed using six allozymes in 27 populations of Alaskan wheatgrass (Elymus alaskanus) from different locations in Canada, USA, Greenland and Russia to obtain information on the genetic structure of these populations. The enzyme systems were ACO, DIA, GPI, MDH, PGM and SKD. Allozyme variation at the species level was high, with 64.3% (Ps) of the loci being polymorphic, an average number of alleles per locus of 1.9 (As), and an average genetic diversity of 0.17 (Hes). Differentiation was found in the populations studied, with the following findings: (1) statistically significant differences were found in allele frequencies among populations for every polymorphic locus (P < 0.001); (2) 63% of the total allozyme variation at polymorphic loci was partitioned among populations (GST = 0.63); (3) relatively low mean genetic distances between the populations were obtained (mean D = 0.029); (4) the genetic structure of Russian populations are clearly distinct from the other populations, the cluster and principal component analyses revealed the same genetic patterns of relationships among populations. This study also indicates that E. alaskanus contains different levels of allozyme variation in its populations. Furthermore, some banding patterns at the loci Aco-1, Aco-2, Gpi-2, Mdh-1, Skd-1, Skd-2 can be used as markers to identify individual populations.