Comparison of fiberendoscopy and Watson capsule for small intestinal biopsy in infants and children

A prospective study to evaluate the role of duodenal bulb biopsy in the diagnosis of celiac disease

BACKGROUND

Celiac disease (CeD) requires a biopsy from the small intestine to confirm the diagnosis. Conventionally, duodenal bulb (D1) was avoided as a biopsy site due to histological confounding factors at this site. However, sometimes, the bulb mucosa is the only affected site. The aim of the present study was to assess changes in duodenal bulb histology and compare it to distal duodenal histology and to analyze whether the addition of duodenal bulb biopsy increases the diagnostic yield of the CeD.

METHODS

It was a prospective study comprising of 98 patients of CeD who were symptomatic clinically and had positive anti tissue transglutaminase (tTG) antibody. Endoscopically four mucosal biopsies were taken, two each from the bulb and distal duodenum, and morphology was graded as per modified Marsh grade.

RESULTS

Iron deficiency anemia (40%) was a most common clinical presentation followed by chronic diarrhea (30%). Sixty patients showed same Marsh grade and 38 showed different Marsh grade at both sites. Patients who were showing the difference in the Marsh grade at the two biopsy sites, in place of; descending duodenum showed higher grade in 24 patients while higher mucosal atrophy was documented in the bulb in 14 patients. No patient of CeD had isolated D1 involvement. In eight patients, the correct diagnosis of CeD could be made only because of bulb biopsy.

CONCLUSION

Majority of the patients had no classical symptoms. Different Marsh grade at the two biopsy sites was documented demonstrating the patchy distribution of CeD. Combining biopsy from both bulb and descending duodenum maximizes the diagnostic yield of the CeD.

The frequency of histologic lesion variability of the duodenal mucosa in children with celiac disease

BACKGROUND

Celiac disease (CD) may cause changes throughout the gastrointestinal tract. Patchy distribution of duodenal mucosal lesions has been described in adults as well as in children. This study aimed to verify the concept and to evaluate the frequency of histologic lesion variability of the duodenal mucosa in Indian children with CD.

METHODS

We enrolled 67 children prospectively who underwent upper gastrointestinal endoscopy because of positive tissue transglutaminase antibodies and biopsy as the final evaluation for suspected CD. Four biopsies were taken from the descending duodenum distal to the papilla, and duodenal bulb. The histologic lesions were classified according to the Oberhuber classification with modification proposed by our group.

RESULTS

Forty-three CD children (64.2%) had a "mixed" type 3 lesion characterized by a different degree of villous atrophy at different biopsy sites. Eight children (11.9%) showed two different types of histologic lesions in the same patient at different biopsy sites. The overall variability of histologic lesion (variability in the grade of villous atrophy [type 3a, 3b, or 3c], and coexistence of villous atrophy and type 2 lesion) was seen in 51 (76.1%) of the CD patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Children with CD show a high frequency of variability of histologic lesions. Therefore, multiple endoscopic biopsy specimens should be obtained not only from the distal duodenum but also from the bulb.

Optical coherence tomography in pediatric patients: a feasible technique for diagnosing celiac disease in children with villous atrophy

BACKGROUND AND AIM

Celiac disease is a common condition with many atypical manifestations, where histology serves as the "gold standard" for diagnosis. A useful new technique, optical coherence tomography, can depict villous morphology in detail, using light waves. This study examined the correlation between the sensitivity and specificity of optical coherence tomography in pediatric patients undergoing esophago-gastro-duodenoscopy for the diagnosis of celiac disease.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 134 children were prospectively enrolled, 67 with a serological suspicion of celiac disease (group 1) and 67 with negative histology for celiac disease (group 2). During a diagnostic esophago-gastro-duodenoscopy we acquired multiple images and films in the four quadrants of the second part of the duodenum, and biopsies were taken in the area where optical coherence tomography had been done. Three patterns of villous morphology were considered: pattern 1=no atrophy (types 0, 1 or 2 of the Marsh classification); pattern 2=mild atrophy (type 3a or 3b); pattern 3=marked atrophy (type 3c).

RESULTS

The diagnosis of celiac disease was histologically confirmed in all 67 children with positive antiendomysium and/or antitransglutaminase antibodies. Optical coherence tomography correlated with pattern 1 histology in 11/11 cases, pattern 2 in 30/32 (93.8%) and pattern 3 in 22/24 (91.6%). Sensitivity and specificity were 82% and 100%. In the control group there was 100% concordance between optical coherence tomography and histology. The overall concordance between optical coherence tomography and histology in determining patchy lesions was 75%.

CONCLUSION

Optical coherence tomography could be a helpful diagnostic tool in children with mild or marked villous atrophy for diagnosing celiac disease during upper gastrointestinal (GI) endoscopy, avoiding biopsies. However, duodenal biopsies are mandatory if the optical coherence tomography shows normal villous morphology in patients with positive antibodies.

Assessment of the diagnostic value of duodenal bulb histology in patients with celiac disease, using multiple biopsy sites

BACKGROUND

Multiple endoscopic biopsies from the descending duodenum are usually recognized as the standardized method for the evaluation of mucosal changes in celiac disease (CD). Generally, the duodenal bulb is not considered a useful site for biopsies, owing to some difficulties in histologic evaluation.

GOAL

We wanted to verify if duodenal bulb histology establish a correct diagnosis of CD.

STUDY

Fifty-two consecutive children with suspicion of CD and positive antitissue transglutaminase antibodies were enrolled in a prospective fashion. During upper gastrointestinal endoscopy, 2 to 4 biopsies each were taken from descending duodenum distal to the papilla of Vater (D2) and duodenal bulb (B). The histologic lesions were classified according to the modified Oberhuber classification by single pathologist who was blinded to the site of biopsy.

RESULTS

A total of 52 children had a final diagnosis of CD. The main presenting symptoms were diarrhea 43/52 (82.7%), anemia 40/52 (76.9%), and failure to thrive 32/52 (61.5%). All had type 3 lesion-(a) mild, (b) moderate, or (c) severe-in at least 1 site. There was 45/52 (86.5%) CD patients with lesions of identical type (type 2 or 3) in both biopsy sites. The number of intraepithelial lymphocytes was not significantly different in the descending part of the duodenum as compared with duodenal bulb.

CONCLUSIONS

The biopsies from the duodenal bulb and second part of the duodenum in CD can be equally representative of the underlying disease. The diagnosis of CD can reliably be made even if biopsies are taken from the duodenal bulb rather than distal duodenum or jejunum.

Duodenal bulb biopsies in celiac disease: a multicenter study

OBJECTIVES

Celiac disease (CD)-related lesions have been reported in duodenal bulb biopsies, sometimes the bulb mucosa being the only one affected. The aim was to verify in a significant series whether histological lesions are always present in the bulb of celiac patients, what is the prevalence of lesions when isolated to the bulb, and if similar lesions are present in nonceliac subjects.

METHODS

We studied 665 children with CD (241 males, range 9 months-15 years, 8 months), at diagnosis on a gluten-containing diet, and 348 age- and sex-matched gastroenterological controls submitted to upper endoscopy for gastroenterological complaints. During endoscopy, multiple biopsies (1 bulb and 4 distal duodenum samples) were taken. Anti-endomysium antibodies were evaluated by immunofluorescence method, anti-human tissue-transglutaminase antibodies by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay or radioimmunoassay. Human leukocyte antigen-DRB1, -DQA1, and -DQB1 genes were typed by polymerase chain reaction sequence-specific primers repeat method.

RESULTS

In all of the patients with CD, histological lesions were present in the bulb sample; in 16 of them, the lesions were present only in the bulb. Patchy villous atrophy was found in 20 children. All of the patients with CD were anti-endomysium and/or antitransglutaminase positive. The controls showed neither autoantibody positivity nor mucosal changes compatible with CD.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrated that CD-related histological lesions are always present in the bulb; sometimes this specific site is the only one affected. Therefore, we suggest taking 2 biopsies from the bulb and 2 from the distal duodenum for CD diagnosis.

Variability of histologic lesions in relation to biopsy site in gluten-sensitive enteropathy

OBJECTIVES

It is generally believed that in gluten-sensitive enteropathy or celiac disease (CD), mucosal lesions may have a patchy distribution. We wanted to verify this concept and establish whether one or more biopsy samples are needed in order to make a correct diagnosis of CD.

METHODS

One hundred and twelve consecutive children with positive antiendomysium (EMA) or antitissue transglutaminase (tTGA) antibodies, referred to us for suspected CD, were enrolled in a prospective fashion. During upper GI endoscopy four to five biopsies were taken from Treitz and/or distal duodenum (D3), intermediate duodenum (D2), proximal duodenum (D1), and duodenal bulb (B). Histologic lesions were classified according to Marsh criteria modified by Oberhuber.

RESULTS

A total of 110 patients, all HLA-DQ2 or DQ8 positive, had a final diagnosis of CD (59 classic, 28 atypical, and 23 silent): 102/110 (92.7%) had type 3 lesion-(a) mild, (b) moderate, or (c) severe-in at least one site and 94/110 (85.4%) had villous atrophy (VA) of some degree in all sites. VA of identical degree was present in all biopsy sites in 55/110 (50%) patients. Total VA (type 3c) was present in at least one site in 85/110 (75%), in all sites in 50/110 (45.4%), and significantly increased in aborad direction ((chi(2) > 26.22 with (= 0.01 and d.f. (degrees of freedom) = 12). Eight out of 110 (7.2%) CD patients had exclusively type 1 or 2 lesions, no patient had lesion variability >1 degree and none had normal biopsies. There was no correlation between type or distribution of histologic lesions and clinical presentation of CD.

CONCLUSIONS

Mucosal atrophy is present in 85% of patients with CD and total VA is significantly more frequent in distal duodenum or proximal jejunum. Fifty percent of patients have identical VA throughout the duodenum and no duodenal areas are histologically normal. In genetically susceptible children with positive serology, a diagnosis of CD can reliably be made even if biopsies are not taken from the distal duodenum or jejunum.

Patchy villous atrophy of the duodenum in childhood celiac disease

OBJECTIVES

Patchy villous atrophy of the duodenal mucosa has been described in adults with untreated celiac disease (CD) but not in children. The authors evaluated the presence and the distribution of villous atrophy in children with celiac disease to see whether this histologic pattern exists in children.

METHODS

We studied 95 children at diagnosis (Group 1) and seven during gluten challenge (Group 2). We measured anti-endomysium antibodies (EMA) by immunofluorescence on monkey esophagus, antihuman-tissue transglutaminase autoantibodies (anti-tTG Abs) by radioimmunoprecipitation, and HLA-DQ2/DQ8 heterodimers by polymerase chain reaction using specific primers. During upper intestinal endoscopy, at least five duodenal biopsy samples were obtained, one from the duodenal bulb and four from the distal duodenum.

RESULTS

Thirteen of 95 (13.7%) patients in Group 1 and in 3 of 7 (42.9%) in Group 2 had patchy villous atrophy of the duodenum. In all 16 patients, villous atrophy of the bulb was present. In four children from Group 1, villous atrophy was observed only in the bulb samples. EMA, anti-tTG Abs, and HLA-DQ2/DQ8 heterodimers were present in all patients. Fourteen of 16 had symptomatic CD, and two were silent, detected during screening in subjects at risk for CD.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study demonstrating that children with CD may have patchy villous atrophy of the duodenum. The bulb mucosa may be the only duodenal area involved, both at diagnosis and after gluten challenge. Therefore, multiple endoscopic biopsies should always be performed, not only in the distal duodenum, but also in the bulb.

Are endoscopic biopsies of small bowel as good as suction biopsies for diagnosis of enteropathy?

BACKGROUND

Endoscopy is increasingly used in paediatric practice for diagnosis of enteropathy, although the quality of grasp forceps-obtained biopsy specimens required for reliable diagnosis has been questioned in comparison with suction capsule biopsy specimens. This study prospectively compared the diagnostic suitability of grasp forceps biopsy versus suction biopsy in the same patient during the same procedure.

METHODS

A double-port paediatric suction biopsy capsule was front-loaded onto an endoscope and directed to the fourth part duodenum-proximal jejunum for biopsy sampling. Subsequently, three grasp biopsy specimens were taken from the same region. All biopsies were coded, photographed, and measured for area, using computed morphometry. A single blinded histopathologist assessed sample adequacy for diagnosis. Twenty-nine patients were enrolled (age range, 8-185 months).

RESULTS

On three occasions the suction capsule failed to fire, and on four occasions only one sample was obtained. Three grasp biopsy specimens were obtained on each occasion by endoscopy, and the first two were used for comparison with suction biopsy samples. Median total area of individual biopsy samples obtained by the two procedures was not different (21.3 vs. 22.5 mm2; P = 0.027). Muscularis mucosae was obtained more commonly with grasp biopsies (P<0.001), and no difference was observed for the presence of three or more villus-crypt units, degree of haemorrhage, or optimal orientation. Two suction biopsy procedures and one grasp biopsy procedure were inadequate for diagnosis.

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic grasp biopsies are perfectly adequate for the assessment of small intestinal histology. In addition, endoscopy affords advantage in diagnosis of other upper gastrointestinal disease with avoidance of radiologic screening involved with the suction capsule technique.

A comparison of endoscopic and capsule small intestinal biopsy techniques in children with upper gastrointestinal disorders

OBJECTIVE

To compare the adequacy for histological diagnosis and morphometric analysis of small intestinal biopsies obtained by either endoscopic forceps or a capsule technique.

METHODOLOGY

Small intestinal biopsies from 176 children were reviewed, 92 obtained by endoscopy and 84 by capsule.

RESULTS

The adequacy for making a histological diagnosis was 96 and 81% for endoscopic and capsule biopsies, respectively, and for morphometric analysis it was 86 and 71%. There were more tissue specimens from children who had endoscopic compared with capsule biopsies (2.3 vs 1.8 specimens per patient).

CONCLUSIONS

Endoscopic biopsies provide better specimens for histological diagnosis and endoscopy has the advantage of allowing macroscopic assessment of the upper gastrointestinal tract which can be of value in recognizing unexpected pathology and in identifying patchy mucosal changes.