[Adhesion of dental cements to zirconia restorations. Part 2]

The information about methods of surface preparation for dentures made from ceramic based on zirconium dioxide for better adhesive fixation is presented in the first part of this article. Micromechanical methods of preparation for cementation of the surface of a zirconia dental prosthesis are discussed in the first part of this article. The second part of the article provides an overview of scientific research on chemical methods for preparing a surface made of zirconia and the problem of the bond strength of polymer cement with a prepared surface made of zirconia.

Effects of laser treatments on surface roughness of zirconium oxide ceramics

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to analyze the surface roughness of yttrium stabilized tetragonal polycrystalline zirconia (Y-TZP) ceramics after different laser treatments (CO_2, ER: YAG).

METHODS

5x5x2 mm rectangular prisms of forty eight Y-TZP (Zirkonzahn) ceramic specimens were prepared. In order to standardize surfaces, 600-, 1200- grid silicon carbide papers were used to gradually ground wet on 300 rpm grinding machine for 10 s. Eight groups (n = 6) were randomly formed from the specimens of each ceramic as control (GroupC), sandblasted (GroupS), two different CO₂ laser treatments (Group3W: 3 W and 382 w/cal, Group4W: 4 W and 509w/cal) and four different Er: YAG laser treatments (Group150SP: 150 mJ and 10-Hz with 100μS; Group150SSP: 150 mJ and 10-Hz with 300μS; Group300SP: 300 mJ and 10-Hz with 100μS; Group300SSP: 300 mJ and 10-Hz with 300μS). A profilometer was used to conduct surface roughness measurements (Ra). Surface morphologies of the specimens were evaluated under SEM after laser treatment.

RESULTS

To analyze the data one-way ANOVA and to compare the mean values Tukey HSD tests (α = .05) were used. One - way ANOVA results showed that Group S had the highest Ra value and Group150 SP had the lowest. After sandblasting group the highest value was seen in Group4W. There were no statistically significant differences among Group C, Group3W, Group150SSP, Group300SP, and Group300SSP.

CONCLUSIONS

The study showed that surface roughness of zirconium oxide ceramics was increased with CO2 laser.

Evaluation of the Effect of Glow Discharge Plasma Surface Treatment on Bonding Cements to Zirconia

Background:

The major difference in the chemical composition of Y-TZP ceramics, as compared with conventional porcelain, led researchers to develop alternative solutions for achieving durable and long term bonding with the zirconia surface.

Objective:

The study aims to evaluate the effects of glow discharge treatment on the bonding between cement and zirconia.

Methods:

The zirconia rings and rods were prepared with the Zirconia Y-TZP powder and TZ-3YSB-E (Tosoh-Zirconia) through auto-mix to investigate the glow discharge and thermo-cycling. An orientation Teflon mold was used to centralize each rod into the zirconia ring, and aided as a cementation jig during the cementation procedure.

Results:

Cohesive failure (2/3 or more of luting agent remained on the zirconia surface) has been majorly observed with RelyX Ultimate, while adhesion failure (less than 1/3 of the luting agent remained on the zirconia surface) has been primarily observed in Ketac-Cem. Mixed failure was observed among the three specimen including Rely X Unicem 2, Multilink Auto-mix and Ceramir.

Conclusion:

The glow discharge surface treatment procedure had a major impact on bond strength to zirconia.

Effect of different treatments on the flexural strength of fully versus partially stabilized monolithic zirconia

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Recent monolithic zirconia materials used for indirect restorations are predominantly fully stabilized zirconia with claims of enhanced optical properties. These restorations may behave differently from the conventional partially stabilized zirconia restorations, which may negatively affect some of the core properties required for restoration success.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this in vitro study was to evaluate and compare the effects of staining, airborne-particle abrasion, and artificial aging on the flexural strength of fully and partially stabilized zirconia material.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Each partially stabilized monolithic zirconia (PSZ) and fully stabilized zirconia (FSZ) material and a zirconia core material (control) were prepared as bar-shaped specimens (2×2×25 mm) and divided into 6 groups (n=8/subgroup): regular sintering, vacuum sintering, stained, airborne-particle abrasion, artificially aged regular sintering, and artificially aged vacuum sintering. Critical load to fracture was determined for all groups by using monotonic uniaxial loading in accordance with International Organization for Standardization standard 6872. Data were analyzed using univariate analysis of variance, followed by the Tukey honest significant difference post hoc test (α=.05).

RESULTS

The control and PSZ (1034 and 1008 MPa) displayed a significantly higher (P<.05) flexural strength than FSZ (582 MPa). Airborne-particle abrasion significantly (P<.05) enhanced the strength of the control and PSZ (1413 and 1227 MPa) but significantly (P<.05) reduced the flexural strength of the FSZ (442 MPa). Staining, artificial aging, and vacuum sintering had no significant effects on any of the groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Fully stabilized zirconia may behave differently from conventional PSZ, especially with regard to airborne-particle abrasion, which may weaken the FSZ. The strength of PSZ is approximately double the strength of FSZ. Both of the zirconia materials showed resistance to artificial aging.

Degree of conversion of dual-polymerizing cements light polymerized through monolithic zirconia of different thicknesses and types

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Monolithic zirconia restorations are increasingly common. Dual-polymerizing cements have been advocated for cementation. The opacious nature of zirconia restoration can attenuate light, compromising optimal resin polymerization and eventually restoration debonding.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this in vitro study was to evaluate the influence of material thickness on light irradiance, radiant exposure, and the degree of monomer conversion (DC) of 2 dual-polymerizing resin cements light-polymerized through different brands of monolithic zirconia.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Dual-polymerizing resin cements (RelyX Ultimate; 3M-ESPE, and Variolink II; Ivoclar, Vivadent) were mixed according to the manufacturers' instructions with a film thickness of 40 μm, placed under a 10 × 10 mm specimen of monolithic zirconia (Prettau Anterior by Zirkonzahn, Katana by Noritake, BruxZir by Glidewell, and Zenostar by Wieland) and a zirconia core control (ICE zirkon by Zirkonzahn) at various thicknesses (0.50, 1.00, 1.50, and 2.00 mm, n = 5 of each thickness). Each specimen was irradiated for 20 seconds (RelyX Ultimate) and 40 seconds (Variolink II) with Elipar S10 (3M-ESPE, 1200 mW/cm(2)). The amount of irradiance and radiant exposure was quantified for each specimen. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy was used to measure the DC from the bottom surface of the resin. Statistical analysis was performed with 2-way ANOVA and post hoc Tukey honest significant difference (HSD) tests (α = .05).

RESULTS

Light irradiance and radiant exposure decreased as the thickness of the specimen increased (P < .05) regardless of the brand. The ranking from least to highest was BruxZir < ICE zircon = Wieland < Katana = Prettau Anterior. The zirconia brand, thickness, and cement type had a significant effect on the DC (P < .001). The DC decreased significantly as the thickness of the zirconia increased (P < .001). Katana and Prettau Anterior showed the highest DC and BruxZir showed the lowest.

CONCLUSION

The thickness of zirconia affects the DC of resin-based cements. The DC of the resin cements differed significantly between cements and among zirconia brands. More polymerizing time may be needed to deliver sufficient energy through some brands of zirconia.