Applications of diagonal chromatography for proteome-wide characterization of protein modifications and activity-based analyses

Monitoring proteolytic processing events by quantitative mass spectrometry

INTRODUCTION

Protease activity plays a key role in a wide variety of biological processes including gene expression, protein turnover and development. misregulation of these proteins has been associated with many cancer types such as prostate, breast, and skin cancer. thus, the identification of protease substrates will provide key information to understand proteolysis-related pathologies. Areas covered: Proteomics-based methods to investigate proteolysis activity, focusing on substrate identification, protease specificity and their applications in systems biology are reviewed. Their quantification strategies, challenges and pitfalls are underlined and the biological implications of protease malfunction are highlighted. Expert commentary: Dysregulated protease activity is a hallmark for some disease pathologies such as cancer. Current biochemical approaches are low throughput and some are limited by the amount of sample required to obtain reliable results. Mass spectrometry based proteomics provides a suitable platform to investigate protease activity, providing information about substrate specificity and mapping cleavage sites.

Identification of Carboxypeptidase Substrates by C-Terminal COFRADIC

We here present a detailed procedure for studying protein C-termini and their posttranslational modifications by C-terminal COFRADIC. In fact, this procedure can enrich for both C-terminal and N-terminal peptides through a combination of a strong cation exchange fractionation step at low pH, which removes the majority of nonterminal peptides in whole-proteome digests, while the actual COFRADIC step segregates C-terminal peptides from N-terminal peptides. When used in a differential mode, C-terminal COFRADIC allows for the identification of neo-C-termini generated by the action of proteases, which in turn leads to the identification of protease substrates. More specifically, this technology can be applied to determine the natural substrate repertoire of carboxypeptidases on a proteome-wide scale.

A COFRADIC protocol to study protein ubiquitination

Here, we apply the COmbined FRActional DIagonal Chromatography (COFRADIC) technology to enrich for ubiquitinated peptides and to identify sites of ubiquitination by mass spectrometry. Our technology bypasses the need to overexpress tagged variants of ubiquitin and the use of sequence-biased antibodies recognizing ubiquitin remnants. In brief, all protein primary amino groups are blocked by chemical acetylation, after which ubiquitin chains are proteolytically and specifically removed by the catalytic core domain of the USP2 deubiquitinase (USP2cc). Because USP2cc cleaves the isopeptidyl bond between the ubiquitin C-terminus and the ε-amino group of the ubiquitinated lysine, this enzyme reintroduces primary ε-amino groups in proteins. These amino groups are then chemically modified with a handle that allows specific isolation of ubiquitinated peptides during subsequent COFRADIC chromatographic runs. This method led to the identification of over 7500 endogenous ubiquitination sites in more than 3300 different proteins in a native human Jurkat cell lysate.

Complementary methods for the identification of substrates of proteolysis

Proteolysis describes the cleavage of proteins into smaller components, which in vivo occurs typically to either activate or impair the functionality of cellular proteins. Proteolysis can occur during cellular homeostasis or can be induced due to external stress stimuli such as heat, biological or chemical insult, and is mediated by the activity of cellular enzymes, namely, proteases. Proteolytic cleavage of proteins can influence protein activation by exposing an active site or disrupting inhibitor binding. Conversely, proteolytic cleavage of many proteins has also been shown to lead to protein degradation resulting in inactivation of the substrate. Thousands of proteolytic events are known to take place in regulated cellular processes such as apoptosis and pyroptosis, however, their individual contribution to these processes remains poorly understood. Additionally, many cellular homeostatic processes are regulated by proteolytic events, however, in some cases, few proteolytic substrates have been identified. To gain further insight into the mechanism of action of these cellular processes, and to characterize biomarkers of cell death and other pathological indications, it is imperative to utilize a complete arsenal of tools for studying proteolysis events in vivo and in vitro. In this chapter, we focus on alternative methodologies to N-terminomics for profiling substrates of proteolysis and describe an additional suite of tools including orthogonal biophysical separation techniques such as COFRADIC or GASSP, and affinity capture tools that can enrich for newly formed C-termini (C-terminomics) generated as a result of caspase-mediated proteolysis.

Using proteomics to uncover extracellular matrix interactions during cardiac remodeling

The left ventricle (LV) responds to a myocardial infarction with an orchestrated sequence of events that result in fundamental changes to both the structure and function of the myocardium. This collection of responses is termed as LV remodeling. Myocardial ischemia resulting in necrosis is the initiating event that culminates in the formation of an extracellular matrix (ECM) rich infarct scar that replaces necrotic myocytes. While the cardiomyocyte is the major cell type that responds to ischemia, infiltrating leukocytes and cardiac fibroblasts coordinate the subsequent wound healing response. The matrix metalloproteinase family of enzymes regulates the inflammatory and ECM responses that modulate scar formation. Matridomics is the proteomic evaluation focused on ECM, while degradomics is the proteomic evaluation of proteases as well as their inhibitors and substrates. This review will summarize the use of proteomics to better understand matrix metalloproteinase roles in post myocardial infarction LV remodeling.

Proteome-derived peptide libraries to study the substrate specificity profiles of carboxypeptidases

Through processing peptide and protein C termini, carboxypeptidases participate in the regulation of various biological processes. Few tools are however available to study the substrate specificity profiles of these enzymes. We developed a proteome-derived peptide library approach to study the substrate preferences of carboxypeptidases. Our COFRADIC-based approach takes advantage of the distinct chromatographic behavior of intact peptides and the proteolytic products generated by the action of carboxypeptidases, to enrich the latter and facilitate its MS-based identification. Two different peptide libraries, generated either by chymotrypsin or by metalloendopeptidase Lys-N, were used to determine the substrate preferences of human metallocarboxypeptidases A1 (hCPA1), A2 (hCPA2), and A4 (hCPA4). In addition, our approach allowed us to delineate the substrate specificity profile of mouse mast cell carboxypeptidase (MC-CPA or mCPA3), a carboxypeptidase suggested to function in innate immune responses regulation and mast cell granule homeostasis, but which thus far lacked a detailed analysis of its substrate preferences. mCPA3 was here shown to preferentially remove bulky aromatic amino acids, similar to hCPA2. This was also shown by a hierarchical cluster analysis, grouping hCPA1 close to hCPA4 in terms of its P1 primed substrate specificity, whereas hCPA2 and mCPA3 cluster separately. The specificity profile of mCPA3 may further aid to elucidate the function of this mast cell carboxypeptidase and its biological substrate repertoire. Finally, we used this approach to evaluate the substrate preferences of prolylcarboxypeptidase, a serine carboxypeptidase shown to cleave C-terminal amino acids linked to proline and alanine.

Deep proteome coverage based on ribosome profiling aids mass spectrometry-based protein and peptide discovery and provides evidence of alternative translation products and near-cognate translation initiation events

An increasing number of studies involve integrative analysis of gene and protein expression data, taking advantage of new technologies such as next-generation transcriptome sequencing and highly sensitive mass spectrometry (MS) instrumentation. Recently, a strategy, termed ribosome profiling (or RIBO-seq), based on deep sequencing of ribosome-protected mRNA fragments, indirectly monitoring protein synthesis, has been described. We devised a proteogenomic approach constructing a custom protein sequence search space, built from both Swiss-Prot- and RIBO-seq-derived translation products, applicable for MS/MS spectrum identification. To record the impact of using the constructed deep proteome database, we performed two alternative MS-based proteomic strategies as follows: (i) a regular shotgun proteomic and (ii) an N-terminal combined fractional diagonal chromatography (COFRADIC) approach. Although the former technique gives an overall assessment on the protein and peptide level, the latter technique, specifically enabling the isolation of N-terminal peptides, is very appropriate in validating the RIBO-seq-derived (alternative) translation initiation site profile. We demonstrate that this proteogenomic approach increases the overall protein identification rate 2.5% (e.g. new protein products, new protein splice variants, single nucleotide polymorphism variant proteins, and N-terminally extended forms of known proteins) as compared with only searching UniProtKB-SwissProt. Furthermore, using this custom database, identification of N-terminal COFRADIC data resulted in detection of 16 alternative start sites giving rise to N-terminally extended protein variants besides the identification of four translated upstream ORFs. Notably, the characterization of these new translation products revealed the use of multiple near-cognate (non-AUG) start codons. As deep sequencing techniques are becoming more standard, less expensive, and widespread, we anticipate that mRNA sequencing and especially custom-tailored RIBO-seq will become indispensable in the MS-based protein or peptide identification process. The underlying mass spectrometry proteomics data have been deposited to the ProteomeXchange Consortium with the dataset identifier PXD000124.

Applications of reversible covalent chemistry in analytical sample preparation

Reversible covalent chemistry (RCC) adds another dimension to commonly used sample preparation techniques like solid-phase extraction (SPE), solid-phase microextraction (SPME), molecular imprinted polymers (MIPs) or immuno-affinity cleanup (IAC): chemical selectivity. By selecting analytes according to their covalent reactivity, sample complexity can be reduced significantly, resulting in enhanced analytical performance for low-abundance target analytes. This review gives a comprehensive overview of the applications of RCC in analytical sample preparation. The major reactions covered include reversible boronic ester formation, thiol-disulfide exchange and reversible hydrazone formation, targeting analyte groups like diols (sugars, glycoproteins and glycopeptides, catechols), thiols (cysteinyl-proteins and cysteinyl-peptides) and carbonyls (carbonylated proteins, mycotoxins). Their applications range from low abundance proteomics to reversible protein/peptide labelling to antibody chromatography to quantitative and qualitative food analysis. In discussing the potential of RCC, a special focus is on the conditions and restrictions of the utilized reaction chemistry.

Plastid proteome assembly without Toc159: photosynthetic protein import and accumulation of N-acetylated plastid precursor proteins

Import of nuclear-encoded precursor proteins from the cytosol is an essential step in chloroplast biogenesis that is mediated by protein translocon complexes at the inner and outer envelope membrane (TOC). Toc159 is thought to be the main receptor for photosynthetic proteins, but lacking a large-scale systems approach, this hypothesis has only been tested for a handful of photosynthetic and nonphotosynthetic proteins. To assess Toc159 precursor specificity, we quantitatively analyzed the accumulation of plastid proteins in two mutant lines deficient in this receptor. Parallel genome-wide transcript profiling allowed us to discern the consequences of impaired protein import from systemic transcriptional responses that contribute to the loss of photosynthetic capacity. On this basis, we defined putative Toc159-independent and Toc159-dependent precursor proteins. Many photosynthetic proteins accumulate in Toc159-deficient plastids, and, surprisingly, several distinct metabolic pathways are negatively affected by Toc159 depletion. Lack of Toc159 furthermore affects several proteins that accumulate as unprocessed N-acetylated precursor proteins outside of plastids. Together, our data show an unexpected client protein promiscuity of Toc159 that requires a far more differentiated view of Toc159 receptor function and regulation of plastid protein import, in which cytosolic Met removal followed by N-terminal acetylation of precursors emerges as an additional regulatory step.

Regulatory perspective on translating proteomic biomarkers to clinical diagnostics

Issues associated with the translation of complex proteomic biomarkers from discovery to clinical diagnostics have been widely discussed among academic researchers, government agencies, as well as assay and instrumentation manufacturers. Here, we provide an overview of the regulatory framework and type of information that is typically required in order to evaluate in vitro diagnostic tests regulated by the Office of In Vitro Diagnostic Device Evaluation and Safety (OIVD) at the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), with the focus on some of the issues specific to protein-based complex tests. Technological points pertaining to mass spectrometry platforms and assessment of potential concerns important for assurance of safety and effectiveness of this type of assays when introduced into clinical diagnostic use, as well as general approaches for evaluating the performance of these devices, are discussed.

Post-translation modification of proteins; methodologies and applications in plant sciences

Proteins have the potential to undergo a variety of post-translational modifications and the different methods available to study these cellular processes has advanced rapidly with the continuing development of proteomic technologies. In this review we aim to detail five major post-translational modifications (phosphorylation, glycosylaion, lipid modification, ubiquitination and redox-related modifications), elaborate on the techniques that have been developed for their analysis and briefly discuss the study of these modifications in selected areas of plant science.

Updated biological roles for matrix metalloproteinases and new "intracellular" substrates revealed by degradomics

Shotgun proteomics techniques are conceptually unbiased, but data interpretation and follow-up experiments are often constrained by dogma, established beliefs that are accepted without question, that can dilute the power of proteomics and hinder scientific progress. Proteomics and degradomics, the characterization of all proteases, inhibitors, and protease substrates by genomic and proteomic techniques, have exponentially expanded the known substrate repertoire of the matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs), even to include intracellular proteins with newly recognized extracellular functions. Thus, the dogma that MMPs are dowdy degraders of extracellular matrix has been resolutely overturned, and the metamorphosis of MMPs into modulators of multiple signaling pathways has been facilitated. Here we review progress made in the field of degradomics and present a current view of the MMP degradome.

Structural and kinetic determinants of protease substrates

Two fundamental questions with regard to proteolytic networks and pathways concern the structural repertoire and kinetic threshold that distinguish legitimate signaling substrates. We used N-terminal proteomics to address these issues by identifying cleavage sites within the Escherichia coli proteome that are driven by the apoptotic signaling protease caspase-3 and the bacterial protease glutamyl endopeptidase (GluC). Defying the dogma that proteases cleave primarily in natively unstructured loops, we found that both caspase-3 and GluC cleave in alpha-helices nearly as frequently as in extended loops. Notably, biochemical and kinetic characterization revealed that E. coli caspase-3 substrates are greatly inferior to natural substrates, suggesting protease and substrate coevolution. Engineering an E. coli substrate to match natural catalytic rates defined a kinetic threshold that depicts a signaling event. This unique combination of proteomics, biochemistry, kinetics and substrate engineering reveals new insights into the structure-function relationship of protease targets and their validation from large-scale approaches.

Post-translational modification of proteins during intermittent hypoxia

Post-translational modification (PTM) is one of the mechanisms by which protein function is regulated by chronic hypoxia. This article presents an overview of recent findings on PTM of proteins induced by chronic intermittent hypoxia (CIH) which is experienced by humans with sleep disordered breathing resulting in autonomic abnormalities. The analysis of PTM of proteins involves electrophoretic separation of tissue or cellular proteins followed by immunolabeling using antibodies specific to native and post-translationally modified forms. Recent results demonstrate that CIH, depending on the pattern, duration and severity of hypoxia, alters the state of phosphorylation of a subset of proteins associated with transcriptional factor activation, signaling pathways and neurotransmitter synthesis via activation of appropriate enzymatic machinery that catalyzes specific phosphorylation reactions. Investigation pertaining to PTMs associated with CIH is at its infant stage and future application of high throughput proteomics techniques are necessary to unravel other important PTMs associated with various critical metabolic and signaling pathways that are activated by intermittent hypoxia.

Stable isotopic labeling in proteomics

Labeling of proteins and peptides with stable heavy isotopes (deuterium, carbon-13, nitrogen-15, and oxygen-18) is widely used in quantitative proteomics. These are either incorporated metabolically in cells and small organisms, or postmetabolically in proteins and peptides by chemical or enzymatic reactions. Only upon measurement with mass spectrometers holding sufficient resolution, light, and heavy labeled peptide ions or reporter peptide fragment ions segregate and their intensity values are subsequently used for quantification. Targeted use of these labels or mass tags further leads to specific monitoring of diverse aspects of dynamic proteomes. In this review article, commonly used isotope labeling strategies are described, both for quantitative differential protein profiling and for targeted analysis of protein modifications.

Reverse-phase diagonal chromatography for phosphoproteome research

We present a gel-free proteomics procedure for the specific isolation of phosphorylated peptides from whole proteome digests. Central is the use of diagonal, reverse-phase chromatography which consists of two consecutive reverse-phase peptide separations with a modification step in between. The latter alters the column retention of affected peptides, thereby allowing their specific isolation from the bulk of nonaffected peptides. To isolate phosphopeptides from complex mixtures, this modification step is a dephosphorylation reaction using a cocktail of broad-spectrum phosphatases. Upon dephosphorylation, peptides undergo a hydrophobic shift and are thereby sorted from in vivo nonphosphorylated peptides. To increase the overall yield of phosphopeptides, a pre-enrichment step was found necessary and to further distinguish true ex-phosphorylated peptides from nonphosphorylated peptides sorted artificially, differential isotope labeling was introduced. The complete COFRADIC sorting procedure is described here.

Discovery, identification, and characterization of candidate pharmacodynamic markers of methionine aminopeptidase-2 inhibition

The catalytic activity of methionine aminopeptidase-2 (MetAP2) has been pharmacologically linked to cell growth, angiogenesis, and tumor progression, making this an attractive target for cancer therapy. An assay for monitoring specific protein changes in response to MetAP2 inhibition, allowing pharmacokinetic (PK)/pharmacodynamic (PD) models to be established, could dramatically improve clinical decision-making. Candidate MetAP2-specific protein substrates were discovered from undigested cell culture-derived proteomes by MALDI-/SELDI-MS profiling and a biochemical method using (35)S-Met labeled protein lysates. Substrates were identified either as intact proteins by FT-ICR-MS or applying in-gel protease digestions followed by LC-MS/MS. The combination of these approaches led to the discovery of novel MetAP2-specific substrates including thioredoxin-1 (Trx-1), SH3 binding glutamic acid rich-like protein (SH3BGRL), and eukaryotic elongation factor-2 (eEF2). These studies also confirmed glyceraldehye 3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) and cyclophillin A (CypA) as MetAP2 substrates. Additional data in support of these proteins as MetAP2-specific substrates were provided by in vitro MetAP1/MetAP2 enzyme assays with the corresponding N-terminal derived peptides and 1D/2D Western analyses of cellular and tissue lysates. FT-ICR-MS characterization of all intact species of the 18 kDa substrate, CypA, enabled a SELDI-MS cell-based assay to be developed for correlating N-terminal processing and inhibition of proliferation. The MetAP2-specific protein substrates discovered in this study have diverse properties that should facilitate the development of reagents for testing in preclinical and clinical environments.