A Comparison of the Efficacy of Newly Developed Reversible Inhibitors of Acetylcholinesterase with Commonly Used Pyridostigmine as Pharmacological Pre-Treatment of Soman-Poisoned Mice

Combination of acetylcholinesterase inhibitors and NMDA receptor antagonists increases survival rate in soman-poisoned mice

Organophosphorus nerve agents pose a global threat to both military personnel and civilian population, because of their high acute toxicity and insufficient medical countermeasures. Commonly used drugs could ameliorate the intoxication and overall medical outcomes. In this study, we tested the drugs able to alleviate the symptoms of Alzheimer's disease (donepezil, huperzine A, memantine) or Parkinson's disease (procyclidine). They were administered to mice before soman intoxication in terms of their: i) protection potential against soman toxicity and ii) influence on post-exposure therapy consisting of atropine and asoxime (also known as oxime HI-6). Their pretreatment effect was not significant, when administered alone, but in combination (acetylcholinesterase inhibitor such as denepezil or huperzine A with NMDA antagonist such as memantine or procyclidine) they lowered the soman toxicity more than twice. These combinations also positively influenced the efficacy of post-exposure treatment in a similar fashion; the combinations increased the therapeutic effectiveness of antidotal treatment. In conclusion, the most effective combination - huperzine A and procyclidine - lowered the toxicity three times and improved the post-exposure therapy efficacy more than six times. These results are unprecedented in the published literature.

Memantine and Its Combination with Acetylcholinesterase Inhibitors in Pharmacological Pretreatment of Soman Poisoning in Mice

Nerve agents pose a real threat to both the military and civil populations, but the current treatment of the poisoning is unsatisfactory. Thus, we studied the efficacy of prophylactic use of memantine alone or in combination with clinically used reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitors (pyridostigmine, donepezil, rivastigmine) against soman. In addition, we tested their influence on post-exposure therapy consisting of atropine and asoxime. Pyridostigmine alone failed to decrease the acute toxicity of soman. But all clinically used acetylcholinesterase inhibitors administered alone reduced the acute toxicity, with donepezil showing the best efficacy. The combination of memantine with reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitors attenuated soman acute toxicity significantly. The pretreatment administered alone or in combinations influenced the efficacy of post-exposure treatment in a similar fashion: (i) pyridostigmine or memantine alone did not affect the antidotal treatment, (ii) centrally acting reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitors alone increased the antidotal treatment slightly, (iii) combination of memantine with reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitors increased the antidotal treatment more markedly. In conclusion, memantine alone failed to decrease the acute toxicity of soman or increase post-exposure antidotal treatment efficacy. The combination of memantine with donepezil significantly increased post-exposure effectiveness (together 5.12, pretreatment alone 1.72). Both drugs, when applied together, mitigate soman toxicity and boost post-exposure treatment.

Some Possibilities to Study New Prophylactics against Nerve Agents

Nerve agents belong to the most dangerous chemical warfare agents and can be/were misused by terrorists. Effective prophylaxis and treatment is necessary to diminish their effect. General principles of prophylaxis are summarized (protection against acetylcholinesterase inhibition, detoxification, treatment "in advance" and use of different drugs). They are based on the knowledge of mechanism of action of nerve agents. Among different examinations, it is necessary to test prophylactic effectivity in vivo and compare the results with protection in vitro. Chemical and biological approaches to the development of new prophylactics would be applied simultaneously during this research. Though the number of possible prophylactics is relatively high, the only four drugs were introduced into military medical practice. At present, pyridostigmine seems to be common prophylactic antidote; prophylactics panpal (tablets with pyridostigmine, trihexyphenidyl and benactyzine), transant (transdermal patch containing HI-6) are other means introduced into different armies as prophylactics. Scavenger commercionally available is Protexia®. Future development will be focused on scavengers, and on other drugs either reversible cholinesterase inhibitors (e.g., huperzine A, gallantamine, physostigmine, acridine derivatives) or other compounds.

Development of small bisquaternary cholinesterase inhibitors as drugs for pre-treatment of nerve agent poisonings

Background

Intoxication by nerve agents could be prevented by using small acetylcholinesterase inhibitors (eg, pyridostigmine) for potentially exposed personnel. However, the serious side effects of currently used drugs led to research of novel potent molecules for prophylaxis of organophosphorus intoxication.

Methods

The molecular design, molecular docking, chemical synthesis, in vitro methods (enzyme inhibition, cytotoxicity, and nicotinic receptors modulation), and in vivo methods (acute toxicity and prophylactic effect) were used to study bispyridinium, bisquinolinium, bisisoquinolinium, and pyridinium-quinolinium/isoquinolinium molecules presented in this study.

Results

The studied molecules showed non-competitive inhibitory ability towards human acetylcholinesterase in vitro that was further confirmed by molecular modelling studies. Several compounds were selected for further studies. First, their cytotoxicity, nicotinic receptors modulation, and acute toxicity (lethal dose for 50% of laboratory animals [LD₅₀]; mice and rats) were tested to evaluate their safety with promising results. Furthermore, their blood levels were measured to select the appropriate time for prophylactic administration. Finally, the protective ratio of selected compounds against soman-induced toxicity was determined when selected compounds were found similarly potent or only slightly better to standard pyridostigmine.

Conclusion

The presented small bisquaternary molecules did not show overall benefit in prophylaxis of soman-induced in vivo toxicity.

The Evaluation of Benefit of Newly Prepared Reversible Inhibitors of Acetylcholinesterase and Commonly Used Pyridostigmine as Pharmacological Pretreatment of Soman-Poisoned Mice

AIM

The ability of four newly prepared reversible inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase (6-chlorotacrine, 7-phenoxytacrine, compounds 1 and 2) and currently used carbamate pyridostigmine to increase the resistance of mice against soman and the efficacy of antidotal treatment of soman-poisoned mice was evaluated.

METHODS

The evaluation of the effect of pharmacological pretreatment is based on the identification of changes of soman-induced toxicity that was evaluated by the assessment of its LD50 value and its 95% confidence limit using probitlogarithmical analysis of death occurring within 24 h after administration of soman.

RESULTS

6-chlorotacrine was only able to markedly protect mice against acute toxicity of soman. In addition, the pharmacological pretreatment with 6-chlorotacrine or compound 2 was able to increase the efficacy of antidotal treatment (the oxime HI-6 in combination with atropine) of soman-poisoned mice. The other newly prepared reversible inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase (7-phenoxytacrine, compound 1) as well as commonly used pyridostigmine did not influence the efficacy of antidotal treatment.

CONCLUSION

These findings demonstrate that pharmacological pretreatment of somanpoisoned mice can be promising and useful in the case of administration of 6-chlorotacrine and partly compound 2.

Dose Dependent Prophylactic Efficacy of 6-Chlorotacrine in Soman-Poisoned Mice

AIM

The influence of the dose on the ability of promising newly prepared reversible inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase (6-chlorotacrine) to increase the resistance of mice against soman and the efficacy of antidotal treatment of soman-poisoned mice was evaluated.

METHODS

The evaluation of the effect of pharmacological pretreatment is based on the identification of changes of soman-induced toxicity that was evaluated by the assessment of its LD50 value and its 95% confidence limit using probit-logarithmical analysis of death occurring within 24 hrs after administration of soman.

RESULTS

The dose of 6-chlorotacrine significantly influences the prophylactic efficacy of 6-chlorotacrine. Its highest dose was only able to significantly protect mice against acute toxicity of soman and increase the efficacy of antidotal treatment (atropine in combination with the oxime HI-6) of soman-poisoned mice. In addition, the highest dose of 6-chlorotacrine was significantly more effective to protect mice from soman poisoning than its lowest dose.

CONCLUSION

These findings demonstrate the important influence of the dose of 6-chlorotacine on its prophylactic efficacy in the case of pharmacological pretreatment of soman poisoning in mice.

Novel cholinesterase modulators and their ability to interact with DNA

In the present work, an interaction of four cholinesterase modulators (1-4) with calf thymus DNA was studied via spectroscopic techniques (UV-Vis, fluorescent spectroscopy and circular dichroism). From UV-Vis spectroscopic analysis, the binding constants for DNA-pyridinium oximes complexes were calculated (K=3.5×10(4) to 1.4×10(5)M(-1)). All these measurements indicated that the compounds behave as effective DNA-interacting agents. Electrophoretic techniques proved that ligand 2 inhibited topoisomerase I at a concentration 5μM.